This HuffPost Canada page is maintained as part of an online archive.

Jagmeet Singh Says He Opposes Quebec’s Controversial Religious Neutrality Bill 62

He hopes Bill 62 is struck down by the courts.
NDP leadership candidate Jagmeet Singh poses for a picture in Brampton, Ont. on July 13, 2017.
Mark Blinch / Reuters
NDP leadership candidate Jagmeet Singh poses for a picture in Brampton, Ont. on July 13, 2017.

OTTAWA — NDP leadership contender Jagmeet Singh says he's firmly opposed to Quebec's current efforts to legislate secularism and hopes Bill 62 is struck down in the courts.

"I am opposed to Bill 62. I think it contravenes individuals freedoms and in fact it also contravenes the Quebec Charter of Human Rights and Freedoms," he told HuffPost Canada Saturday.

The legislation prevents women wearing face coverings — effectively Muslims who wear the niqab or burqa — from delivering or accessing government services. Yet, Singh wouldn't go so far as to call the bill Islamophobic.

'That is not cool'

"I think it is important to acknowledge that there is going to be a disproportional impact on people of different faiths, and, specifically, it is going to disproportionately impact Muslims. ... That is why, as an act of solidarity, I think it is important to acknowledge that the Muslim community is facing a very significant amount of hate and Islamophobia, and it is up to all of us to stand in solidarity with the community," the Ontario NDP MPP said.

"That is part of why I am opposed to it," he added. "This is disproportionately going to impact Muslims. That is not cool."

If he were prime minister, Singh said, he wouldn't be quick to take the province to court but he would stand behind other groups that sought to protect their rights.

"I'm very confident that Quebec's own Charter of Human Rights and Freedoms would be able to tackle this issue, ... There are clear protections that exist under that Charter, and I'm confident in the legal system seeing this through and protecting religious freedoms," he said. "So, I would express my opposition and then express my confidence in the legal system in ensuring that laws that contravene human rights are struck down."

"...If there is a point where another decision needs to be made, I'd look at it then," he added.

Singh said that while he strongly believes in a secular state, as in the separation of church and state, he doesn't believe the state should prevent people from exercising their personal freedoms.

He doesn't believe, for example, that individuals who dress like him — Singh wears a turban and carries a kirpan as part of his Sikh religion — should be prevented from holding positions of authority in government. Quebec's opposition parties, the Coalition Avenir Québec, Parti Québécois, and Québec Solidaire, support legislation that would prevent those wearing religious symbols from holding visible positions of provincial authority, such as a police officer or a judge.

Singh's position is at odds with fellow NDP contender and Quebec MP Guy Caron.

Earlier this week, Caron said that while he personally believes the state should not legislate on what people should or shouldn't wear, he feels that Quebec's majority consensus on secular matters — Bill 62 is supported by all four parties in the National Assembly — should be respected.

"It comes down to the principles of the Sherbrooke declaration," Caron told HuffPost.

Guy Caron speaks as Charlie Angus and Niki Ashton look on in the first debate of the federal NDP leadership race in Ottawa on March 12, 2017.
Guy Caron speaks as Charlie Angus and Niki Ashton look on in the first debate of the federal NDP leadership race in Ottawa on March 12, 2017.

"I mean if in the Sherbrooke declaration we are recognizing Quebec as a nation within Canada, those are not only words, so we need to actually implement that notion that it is a nation allowing it to make those decisions," he added.

The Sherbrooke declaration is NDP policy that recognizes Quebec's "national character" and its "right to self-determination."

Singh said Quebec should be allowed to make decisions about its nation, but that, as NDP leader, he wouldn't shy away from criticizing any laws the National Assembly passed that he felt were improper.

"I think it is important to say that I don't think this is appropriate. This contravenes human rights, and this is not something I support."

New numbers in battleground Quebec

A Léger poll published by The Globe and Mail Saturday suggested that many Quebecers — 28 per cent of respondents — would be less likely to support Singh during the next election because he wears a turban.

While the vast number of the 1,002 surveyed, 80 per cent, either said they didn't know whom they preferred to lead the NDP or declined to state a preference, Caron was the preferred candidate of 10 per cent of respondents, followed by Singh at four per cent, Ontario MP Charlie Angus at three per cent, and Manitoba MP Niki Ashton with two per cent.

In a statement to supporters, Caron's team noted that he had more than twice the support that his nearest competitor had.

"The NDP is a real contender to win in 2019 if we rebound in Quebec. Clearly Guy is the leadership contender best placed to take us to greater heights in Quebec," said a fundraising email from Caron's co-campaign director, Isaac Cockburn.

Big debate in Montreal

Singh said he isn't concerned by the numbers.

"I'm confident that when it comes down to it, the people of Quebec really care about values, and I share values that will connect with the people of Quebec," he told HuffPost. "People care about social democracy in Quebec, progressive values, and I share those values and I am committed to fighting for them.

"I also share a deep love for the French language, and I understand the importance of language, and culture and identity. And because of these unique things that I bring to the table I will be able to connect with the people of Quebec in a really profound way."

The four leadership contenders go head-to-head in a French language debate Sunday in Montreal. In 2011, the NDP obtained official Opposition status after winning 59 seats in Quebec. The party now holds 16 in the province.

This HuffPost Canada page is maintained as part of an online archive. If you have questions or concerns, please check our FAQ or contact