This article exists as part of the online archive for HuffPost Canada, which closed in 2021.

Trudeau's Oilsands 'Phase Out' Remark Not So Different From Harper: PMO

But Conservative politicians are bashing PM.

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau’s spokesman is suggesting his boss was echoing the sentiments of his predecessor when he said Canada would “phase out” Alberta’s oilsands.

Trudeau sparked some controversy Friday when he made clear at a town hall meeting in Peterborough, Ont. that resources wouldn’t be extracted from the oilsands indefinitely.

“We can’t shut down the oilsands tomorrow. We need to phase them out. We need to manage the transition off of our dependence on fossil fuels. That is going to take time,” Trudeau said. “And, in the meantime, we have to manage that transition.”

While the statement was pounced upon by politicians in Alberta and several Tory leadership contenders, Trudeau’s press secretary Cameron Ahmad says it isn’t a new concept.

“The prime minister, as he and previous prime ministers including Stephen Harper have been saying for a long time, was reiterating the need to move away from our dependency on fossil fuels and his commitment to growing the economy all while protecting the environment,” Ahmad said in an email.

The federal government is introducing a federal price on carbon pollution and has given the green light on two major oil pipeline expansions. Ahmad said the approvals will “ensure we can move Canada’s natural resources to international markets,” he added.

"The Prime Minister, as he and previous Prime Ministers including Stephen Harper have been saying for a long time, was reiterating the need to move away from our dependency on fossil fuels."

Though Harper was a vocal champion of Canadian energy and a fierce advocate for pipeline projects, he also joined with other G7 leaders in 2015 to commit to the full phase out of fossil fuels by the year 2100.

Harper said at the time that such a shift would require technological “transformations” in Canada’s energy sector over the long term to lower greenhouse gas emissions.

“I don’t think we should fool ourselves. Nobody’s going to start to shut down their industries or turn off the lights,” he said. “We’ve simply got to find a way to create lower-carbon emitting sources of energy, and that work is ongoing.”

However, a government official told The Globe and Mail at the time that the G7 statement was an “aspirational target.”

Watch Harper's 2015 remarks:

A few members of Harper’s former cabinet and caucus, who are now pursuing leadership roles of their own, were apparently alarmed by Trudeau’s remarks.

Ontario MP Lisa Raitt, now running to replace Harper, took to Twitter to accuse the prime minister of harbouring a “hidden agenda.”

Saskatchewan’s Andrew Scheer, also running for Tory leader, shared an edited clip of Trudeau’s remarks.

“Canada, we need to #PhaseHimOut,” Scheer wrote.

Meanwhile, Kellie Leitch blasted the PM on Facebook Friday.

“Would Justin Trudeau ever say we need to phase out manufacturing jobs? Banking jobs? Creative jobs? No, of course not,” Leitch wrote. “Why does he insist on being hostile to our energy sector?”

Justin Trudeau thinks we need to phase out our energy sector. I think we need to build it up and create more jobs....

Posted by Kellie Leitch on Saturday, 14 January 2017

Former federal minister Jason Kenney, now running for Alberta PC leader with hopes to merge with the Wildrose party, released a video targeting Trudeau.

Kenney accused the prime minister of wanting to hand “complete control of global oil markets” to countries such as Saudi Arabia and Venezuela.

“I have a message for Justin Trudeau. We will not let you do to Alberta’s oil energy what your father did to Alberta with his National Energy Program,” Kenney said.

Unite Alberta: Stand Up for the Oil Sands

Today Justin Trudeau said that he wants to "phase out" Alberta's oil sands.

Let's be clear what he's talking about. The oil sands represent trillions of dollars of future wealth for Canadian families. That's our ability to pay for pensions, healthcare, and infrastructure and education. It also represents hundreds of thousands of good paying jobs for working, middle-income families.

I have a message for Justin Trudeau: We will not let you do to Alberta's oil and gas industry, what your father did to Alberta with his National Energy Program.

Are you with me? Join here:

Posted by Jason Kenney on Friday, 13 January 2017

But conservatives weren't the only ones weighing in. Alberta’s NDP Premier Rachel Notley, seen by some as a Trudeau ally, also released a video last week.

“Alberta's oil and gas industry and the people who work in it are the best in the world. And we're not going anywhere, any time soon,” she said in the clip, which made no reference to Trudeau.

Today I was asked about the future of the oil sands – how long into the future will the world need oil? Here’s what I would like to say.

Posted by Rachel Notley on Friday, 13 January 2017

With files from The Canadian Press

Also on HuffPost

Trudeau's Cross-Country Tour 2017

Before You Go

Popular in the Community

This article exists as part of the online archive for HuffPost Canada. Certain site features have been disabled. If you have questions or concerns, please check our FAQ or contact