
Ben & Jerry’s recently brought online ice cream shopping to their website, and that gave us a chance to really take in all the flavors this beloved ice cream company currently has in the works. (We’re talking pint flavors, not Scoop Shop flavors here.) They’ve got nearly 40 pints, and some true gems are hidden in the mix.
But you can’t love every flavor, so we’ve got some feelings about our least favorites, too.
According to representatives from Ben & Jerry’s, their five most popular ice cream flavors are (in no particular order): Chocolate Fudge Brownie, Half Baked, The Tonight Dough, Cherry Garcia and Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough. But are those the best? We don’t think so.
To set the record straight, we ranked all the Ben & Jerry’s pints available online for purchase. People seek out Ben & Jerry’s when they want a fun-filled, fixings-filled, decadent pint. Some of their flavors don’t fulfill that criteria, and others do it a little too heavy handedly.
Folks might disagree with our ranking ― especially you Cherry Garcia fans ― so feel free to let us know.
Now, the ranking, in order from “eh” to true greatness.

Red velvet cake batter ice cream with red velvet cake pieces and a cream cheese frosting swirl.

Chocolate and cheesecake ice creams with chocolate cookies and a cheesecake core.

Mocha and caramel ice creams with chocolate cookies, fudge flakes and a chocolate cookie core.

Vanilla ice cream.

Strawberry cheesecake ice cream with strawberries and a thick graham cracker swirl.

Caramel and sweet cream coconut ice creams with fudge flakes and a caramel core.

Peanut butter ice cream with crunchy peanut butter sugar bits, peanut butter cookies and a peanut butter cookie core.

Caramel ice cream with cinnamon bun dough and a cinnamon streusel swirl.

Pistachio ice cream with lightly roasted pistachio.

Chocolate and vanilla ice creams with fudge brownies and a brownie batter core.

Vanilla ice cream with chocolate cookie swirl, chocolate chip, and chocolate chocolate chip cookies.

Chocolate and caramel ice creams with fudge chips and a soft caramel core.

Vanilla ice cream with roasted pecans, fudge flakes and a salted chocolate ganache swirl.

Sweet cream ice cream with blondie brownies and a salted caramel core.

Dark caramel and vanilla ice creams with Speculoos cookies and Speculoos cookie butter core.

Peppermint ice cream with chocolate sandwich cookies.

Cherry ice cream with cherries and fudge flakes.

Cheesecake ice cream with cheesecake brownie chunks.

Chocolate and peanut butter ice creams with mini peanut butter cups and a peanut butter fudge core.

Vanilla ice cream with swirls of caramel and fudge.

Vanilla ice cream with fudge-covered toffee pieces.

A collision of chocolate and vanilla ice creams mixed with peanut butter cups, fudge-covered toffee pieces, white chocolatey chunks and fudge-covered almonds.

Caramel ice cream with a swirl of caramel and fudge-covered caramel chunks.

Banana ice cream with fudge chunks and walnuts.

Chocolate ice cream with white and dark fudge chunks, pecans, walnuts and fudge covered-almonds.

Burnt caramel ice cream with almonds, fudge flakes and bourbon caramel swirls.

Coffee ice cream with espresso bean fudge chunks.

Vanilla malt ice cream with peanutty fudge-covered pretzels with fudge and peanut buttery swirls.

Chocolate ice cream with fudge chunks, toasted marshmallow and graham cracker swirl.

Vanilla ice cream with fudge-covered waffle cone pieces and a caramel swirl.

Vanilla ice cream with gobs of chocolate chip cookie dough.

Chocolate ice cream with fudge brownies.

Buttery brown sugar ice cream with fudge flakes and oatmeal cinnamon cookie swirls.

Peanut butter ice creams with peanut butter cups.

Caramel and chocolate ice creams with chocolate cookie swirls and gobs of chocolate chip cookie dough and peanut butter cookie dough.

Chocolate and vanilla ice creams with fudge brownies and gobs of chocolate chip cookie dough.

Chocolate ice cream with gooey marshmallow swirls, caramel swirls and fudge fish.

Chocolate ice cream with chocolate cookies and swirls of chocolate pudding ice cream.

This is the pint that you won't be able to stop eating. It's a simple flavor for Ben & Jerry's standards, but it's perfectly balanced. The slightly-bitter coffee ice cream is offset by the sweet fudge-covered toffee bar pieces. Careful, you'll probably eat the whole pint in one sitting. If you've ever passed up this flavor thinking it didn't have enough going on, go remedy your mistake right now!
Coffee ice cream with fudge-covered toffee bar pieces.