"Can You Be More Natural?" Asked My Non-Black Boyfriend

Here’s the thing: I was already the most natural I’d ever been in my entire life.
 “Can you be more natural?” asked my non-black boyfriend.
“Can you be more natural?” asked my non-black boyfriend.

“Can you be more natural?”

“What do you mean?” I asked my boyfriend of fewer than six months. I tried to conceal my thoughts with a Stepford Wives meets Serial Mom smile.

Here’s the thing: I was already the most natural I’d ever been in my entire life. Yes, my hair was straight, but it was only a temporary effect created with my flat iron and blow dryer. I didn’t wear hair extensions, fake nails, or makeup. I’d never had plastic surgery!

From my crazy eyes, he could tell that my inner monologue switched from “quirky brown girl” to “angry black woman.” Cue: hand clapping, finger pointing, and neck rolls. See, interracial dating was new for me. I anxiously searched for signs of being tokenized. I was secure in my blackness and was not here for men looking to cure their Jungle Fever or feed their low key melanin fetish.

It's Monday. Time to #freetheafro and slay some pages #amwriting

A photo posted by Onicia Muller (@oniciamuller) on

“Can you be more natural?” his words rang in my mind as I soaked in the tub. Should I? I removed my shower cap. Reaching for the nearest towel, I dried my hands and then touched my roots and the tightly coiled top bun. Sigh. Without thinking, I released my hair. I lowered my torso and head allowing the water to penetrate my follicles. I can’t lie, yuh gyal was feeling like Janet Jackson in her “Everytime” music video.

Hopping out the tub to check my hair out. I was all praise hands emoji because my curls were popping. Team No Heat Damage! Next was the moment of truth: Would I use products or give this “be more natural” thing a chance. Insert the longest sigh of your life. I skipped the products, wrapped my head in a scarf, and went to bed.

Yo, the next day my hair was stuck in a Sideshow Bob confection! It was up, hard, and looking like Don King. I was late for church, so I had to walk the street with this hard ashy afro.

The bed hair was too epic not to share. Good morning! 😘 #freetheafro

A photo posted by Onicia Muller (@oniciamuller) on

Later that night, my face is all pushed up ready to rip him a new one for convincing me to turn my hair into stone. Boo, I am not mixed. I know exactly what’s growing out of my head.

“You’re beautiful. What’s wrong?”

That’s how I learned to not trust silky-haired friends to give hair advice. That night I spent six hours detangling and “un-crisping” my hair. Never again. Meh say, never again!

Lies, I would do it again. No, not being product-free. Never again. Meh said, never again! Natural. I would be more natural again. His request played in my mind and I realized that the “natural” look I was rocking was always with the intention of looking mixed or striving the meet the ‘good hair’ standards. Because of that, I never felt free. My afro never was free.

I’d been relaxer free for over five years when we met. I didn’t have a fussy hair regimen. Or at least it wasn’t fussy compared to many of my friends and YouTube hair gurus. I wasn’t a product junkie. Subconsciously, and thankfully without having to go through another “big chop,” a new hair journey started. I stopped doing my nightly pineapple. Weekly washing and styling turned into almost monthly washing and styling. As I experienced my hair in a new way, I began taking “bed hair” selfies. #FreeTheAfro became my aesthetic. Sometimes I share them on my Instagram.

Can you be more natural?

It looks tangled but all it needs is a bit of conditioner. #freetheafro

A photo posted by Onicia Muller (@oniciamuller) on

Created on St Maarten. Based in Chicago. Onicia writes, says funny things, and enjoys hanging with creative minds. You can read her weekly column, Just Being Funny in The Daily Herald's Weekender or on her blog. She pays her bills as a creative project manager. Find her online at OniciaMuller.com or as @OniciaMuller.