TV & Film

'Catfish' Fake? Report Says Aspects of MTV Reality Show Not Very Truthful

Certain aspects of MTV's "Catfish" are fake, according to

The show, based on the movie of the same name, is about online relationships between two strangers who may or may not be lying to each other. The film -- which followed Nev Schulman as he sparked up an online relationship, but then soon discovered that the person he thought he was talking to wasn't being truthful -- also elicited authenticity debates. On the MTV show, Schulman and Max Joseph serve as hosts/stars and travel around the country to unite the online users.

Every episode begins with Schulman reading an email from somebody who wants to meet an online love interest. According to, the catfishee (person who is sending the email) doesn't initiate contact, it's the person who is the catfisher who reached out to MTV almost always. "You know how they said that [the catfishee] had reached out to them?" a cast member from the series anonymously told "I don't know why they put that in there because it’s not even true. It was actually me that reached out to them."

Other phony allegations include the show had participants agree to meet in person prior to filming and Schulman's calls and research. Additionally, some cast members said their online relationships were never romantic and some had their timelines fudged, others weren't actually talking to their "Internet love." However, reports Schulman and Joseph really don't know who the catfisher is and do the research, despite MTV reportedly being in contact with them.

The Huffington Post's request for comment was not returned by MTV.

"Catfish: The TV Show" has been a ratings hit for MTV. The series was renewed for a second season and averaged 2.4 million viewers. MTV will air "Catfish: The Reunion Show" on Monday, Feb. 25 at 11 p.m. EST with SuChin Pak, Schulman and Joseph serving as hosts. The special will reunite various participants and catch viewers up on what they've been up to since their episodes were produced.

Click over to to read the report in full

"666 Park Avenue"

2013 Renewal Index: Canceled, Renewed & On The Bubble Shows

Popular in the Community