Counterfeit Heinz Ketchup Operation Discovered In New Jersey

Heinz officials are investigating what they're calling an abandoned Heinz Tomato Ketchup counterfeiting operation, conducted in a warehouse in Dover, New Jersey. They were tipped to it by warehouse tenants when flies began appearing -- the bottles had exploded.

The running theory is that would-be profiteers purchased traditional Heinz Ketchup in large quantities and transferred it into fraudulent plastic bottles labeled "Simply Heinz," a premium Heinz brand made with sugar in place of high fructose corn syrup.

Once abandoned, the unwatched bottles of ketchup fermented. Pressure built up inside the bottles until they exploded in a giant, ketchup-y mess.

counterfeit ketchup operation
Photo credit: Dover Police

When Simply Heinz was introduced in 2010, Heinz announced that 32-ounce bottles would cost the same as 36-ounce bottles of regular ketchup. In effect, Simply Heinz is slightly more expensive per ounce than the company's regular ketchup -- perhaps providing motivation to counterfeit it.

It's unclear how long the operation was running, but Heinz told the Star-Ledger that it didn't think things got too far:

"The site of this operation was abandoned and had produced only a small quantity of bottles, much of which was still on site," said Michael Mullen, vice president of corporate & government affairs in an e-mail.

But Heinz can't say if the bottles were ever purchased, or it they were contaminated in any way. Dover police aren't involved, but Heinz is working with the U.S. Food and Drug Administration’s Office of Criminal Investigation.

There have several high-profile instances in recent years of counterfeit food. In 2011, some experts estimated that about a third of all honey in the U.S., imported from China, was tainted with illegal antibiotics and heavy metals. Tainted olive oil is also a noted problem, as recounted in the 2011 book "Extra Virginity" by Tom Mueller.

The Best Ketchup: Our Surprising Taste Test Results