Elizabeth Warren Hits Wall Street To Defend Obama Retirement Rule

The senator is fighting back against special perks that can encourage financial advisers to push clients into bad investments.
Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.) supports the Obama administration's efforts to stop retirement advisers from pushing investme
Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.) supports the Obama administration's efforts to stop retirement advisers from pushing investments that might not be in their clients' best interests.

Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.) took a swipe at Wall Street Tuesday, detailing a host of vacations, cruises and other perks that retirement professionals commonly receive for steering clients into particular investments. The rewards provide investment experts with plush incentives to shortchange retirees for their own personal benefit.

Warren's description of the perks, outlined in a report issued by her office, serves as a fresh defense of a retirement security rule proposed by the Obama administration, which would prohibit such activity. Americans collectively lose about $17 billion dollars a year to conflicted retirement account advice, according to the administration.

To solve that problem, the Department of Labor would impose a "fiduciary duty" on fund managers, requiring them to make investment decisions in the best interests of their clients and making it illegal for investment professionals to push clients into under-performing investments in order to score vacations or other benefits. Wall Street has aggressively lobbied against the rule, which is opposed by Republicans and many conservative Democrats with close ties to the financial industry.

"The most frequently cited inducements involve paid trips to resorts and vacation destinations – often touted as annual sales meetings or conventions 'with an educational component,'" the Warren report reads. "One company noted the ubiquity and importance of these trips, describing them as a 'long standing practice' and 'an important tool … to incent sales.'"

Warren's report details a host of rewards that annuities agents receive for high sales volumes. While the perks -- which the report describes as "kickbacks" -- do not compensate investment experts for specific sales of individual products, they do provide them with incentives to sell particular products to their overall client base, without regard to whether such products are appropriate for their financial profile.

American Equity offered a trip to San Francisco in October 2015 for "top performing" sales agents ("and their guests") with sales of over $3 million in annuities and life insurance. The company brochure for this trip notes that the "event [is] in one of the country’s most picturesque and storied cities … at one of the world’s most luxurious hotels."


Lincoln Financial offered agents a trip to South Africa in 2015, followed by an offer in 2016 for "an extraordinary getaway to the newest resort destination in the Bahamas, Baha Mar. … Days will be spent unwinding on the sun-drenched sands of Cable Beach, exploring the sparkling turquoise waters of the Atlantic, immersing yourself in the Bahamian culture at a bustling market or enjoying cool ocean breezes from the fairways."


Fidelity Guarantee and Life offered agents the opportunity to attend the company’s 2015 Power Producer Conference at the Four Seasons Resort in Punta Mita, Mexico. Mutual Trust invited sales agents to its annual Vanguard Conference in Laguna Beach, California, offering "star treatment" to its top agents; American National offered a five-day, four-night stay at the Cove Atlantis on Paradise Island in the Bahamas for top-selling agents and their guests.

Warren said that such lavish travel arrangements are only described in "the broadest and most vague terms" in official investment disclosures -- terms that conceal their vacation-oriented nature.

While most rank-and-file Democrats have been quiet (or at times, even hostile) to the Obama administration's retirement security rule, Warren has emerged as its staunchest proponent in Washington -- a marked shift from the summer, when Warren and Obama publicly feuded over trade policy.

Zach Carter is The Huffington Post's senior political economy reporter and a co-host of the HuffPost Politics podcast, "So That Happened." Listen to the latest episode here: