Former Miss America: Pageant Contestants Today Are Too Skinny (VIDEO)

Former Miss America: Pageant Contestants Today Are Too Skinny

The Miss USA 2013 pageant stirred up chatter this week because of Miss Utah's infamously flubbed answer in the Q+A portion. But others took notice of another troubling happening on the pageant stage: the contestants' shrinking bodies.

Several former Miss USA and Miss America competitors are sounding off on how thin many of the Miss USA contestants appeared on Sunday night. Whether or not you've been tracking the changes over the years, it's plain to see that these Miss USA finalists tended to fit a standard physical shape not unlike that of a runway model: lean, toned and very slender.

"The girls, I thought, were much too thin," said Miss America 2008 Kirsten Haglund, speaking with other former pageant queens on HuffPost Live. "I agree that if you would have tested their BMIs that they probably would have been much too thin. And that's the standard in the modeling industry and the fashion industry as well."

Miss USA 2003 Susie Castillo agreed. "I was a little shocked too, sitting in the audience and seeing ribcages showing, protruding from these girls' skins. I was like, 'Wow, these girls...'" The Miss USA 2011 competition invited similar reactions several years back.

It wasn't always this way. "I realize that 10 years ago, when I was Miss USA, I was a lot thinner too, only because I was younger and active. I was an athlete. I wasn't that thin. And I agree that it's going in a way where girls are just super thin," Castillo noted.

Former pageant competitors aren't the only ones who've noticed a pattern. In 2009, Australia's representative to the Miss Universe pageant, Stephanie Naumoska, was deemed too unhealthy to compete in the international event. At around 5 feet 11 inches tall and and just 108 punds, Naumoska's BMI was about 15, well below the "normal weight" standards. At the time, the Australian Medical Association commented, "Other young women may view this as normal when clearly it is not."

And it's that unspoken example that today's pageant alumni are concerned about. "I personally don't love the swimsuit competition -- I think it could go," said Haglund. As it stands, the Miss America and Miss USA contestants are presented as ideal women, role models to emulate in every way -- and that will inevitably include body shape.

Do you think today's pageant competitors are setting an unrealistic, unhealthy example when it comes to body image? Watch clips from the conversation in the video above and check out the full segment on HuffPost Live.

Miss USA 2013 contestants:

former miss america

former miss america

former miss america

former miss america

former miss america

What pageant queens used to look like:

Miss America Through The Years

Want more? Be sure to check out HuffPost Style on Twitter, Facebook, Tumblr, Pinterest and Instagram at @HuffPostStyle.

Support HuffPost

Do you have info to share with HuffPost reporters? Here’s how.

Go to Homepage

Popular in the Community


Gift Guides