How The Democrats, And Traditional Republicans, Won In Alabama

How The Democrats, And Traditional Republicans, Won In Alabama
This post was published on the now-closed HuffPost Contributor platform. Contributors control their own work and posted freely to our site. If you need to flag this entry as abusive, send us an email.
Alabama Democrat Rally

Alabama Democrat Rally

John A. Tures

In Birmingham, Alabama, the Doug Jones campaign is celebrating its win in the Senate Special Election of 2017. Senate Republicans are probably celebrating Roy Moore’s defeat as well. Here’s why.

We discovered that U.S. Attorney Doug Jones was not just a good prosecutor, most famous for taking down those responsible for the Birmingham Church Bombing calamity of 1963 that killed four African-American girls. He refused to be just the “anti-Trump,” the way Hillary Clinton did. He ran a biracial message in the Barack Obama tradition, just like Virginia Lt. Governor Ralph Northam. Both Jones and Northam, and even Obama, were criticized by some on the left for running a “color-blind” campaign that did not call for overt direct appeals exclusively tailored to African-Americans.

“Ah, the colorblind message. How well has that been reporting for Democrats in recent years?” writes Michael Arceneaux with Essence. His critique of Jones notes that the Alabama Democrat focused “instead on the more universal messages of job creation and health care.”

Sean Sullivan with the Washington Post wrote in late November “African American voters not energized by Alabama’s Senate race.” The amazing turnout by African Americans made this headline pretty much “fake news.”

From this Virginia election, and Alabama race, we learned is that a biracial message appeals to whites and blacks. It provides the blueprint for blue, purple and red states among Democrats. It provides a rejection of specific tribalism, whether it’s white-only or black-only. I expect him to occupy the middle ground of the Senate, and perhaps serve as one of those politicians who can be a bridge between both parties.

On the other side, conservatives have to be in shock. This was Doug Jones’ first election, while Roy Moore has run more times for statewide office than anyone in Alabama not named Wallace or Folsom, and may even top those two names. But they shouldn’t take the loss too hard. That’s because Roy Moore’s defeat gave a huge opportunity for the Republican Party to save itself.

First of all, Republicans had a good Senator in Luther Strange. If Senator Strange isn’t knocked out in the primary, he likely wins, barring some unforeseen gaffe. But ultra-conservative gadfly Steve Bannon had to enter the race, push Roy Moore and the politics of hate, and trashed Strange, who was a good Attorney General and U.S. Senator who would not embarrass Alabama. He also attacked a number of Republican Senators in his scorched earth campaign that upended the Alabama GOP.

Second of all, there was one outcome far worse than Moore’s defeat for the GOP. And that was Moore’s victory. For all the talk about an investigation and an expulsion of Senator Moore, we didn’t see anything like that with Democratic Senator Roland Burris of Illinois, who should have been expelled in 2009 in the wake of the Governor Rod Blagojevich scandal. It’s hard to expel a sitting Senator, as Senators obviously don’t want to make it easy to get rid of a Senator.

As I had noted before, a Senator Moore would have a millstone around the neck of every GOP candidate for 2018, 2020, and for as long as he served in Washington, DC. Republican politicians don’t have to explain the actions of one of their member.

A number of Republican Senators running in 2018, and several House members, are about to face challengers that are backed by Steve Bannon, and his supporters. Moore’s defeat is a wake-up call for the GOP. While President Trump and Ronna Romney McDaniel’s Republican National Committee (RNC) caved in to back Moore, the National Republican Senatorial Committee (NRSC) stayed firm in their principles, refusing to support Moore. The NRSC and GOP Senators are the ones who should be listened to, for any American who calls himself or herself a Republican, instead of blaming Republican Senators for the loss in Alabama.

John A. Tures is a professor of political science at LaGrange College in LaGrange, Georgia. He can be reached at His Twitter account is JohnTures2.

Popular in the Community


What's Hot