Immigration, Ambition, Identity Shape Film <em>Miss India America</em>

It should come as no surprise to anyone familiar with the culture of South Asian immigrants that both ambition and identity do a similar dance, often with greater intensity, and is among the latest variations on a familiar American story.
This post was published on the now-closed HuffPost Contributor platform. Contributors control their own work and posted freely to our site. If you need to flag this entry as abusive, send us an email.

Immigration, ambition and identity tend to be perceived as intertwined strands of the American DNA, and it always renews itself. It should come as no surprise to anyone familiar with the culture of South Asian immigrants that both ambition and identity do a similar dance, often with greater intensity, and is among the latest variations on a familiar American story.

Actress Hannah Simone, left, and Tiya Sircar in a scene from Miss India America.
Photo: Miss India America Pictures.

In Dallas recently for the second annual DFW South Asian Film Festival (DFWSAFF), where thirteen ground-breaking, sold-out screenings of shorts, documentaries and feature films during its three-day festival (Feb. 19 to the 21) at the Perot Museum in downtown Dallas and the Angelika Film Center in Plano, I was delighted to view the comedy feature film Miss India America on Opening Night.


The leadership of the DFWSAFF. From L To R: Ambica Dev, Reema Rasool, Nancy Williams, Sashena Hassamal, Jitin Hingorani, Ami Doshi, Dev Shapiro, Tanveer, Sejal Desai, Patrick O'Hara, Nikita Vyas Hattangady, Krista Weinstein, Ritu Krishna, Patric Alva, Anjali Desai and Meeta Manglani. Not pictured are Viveck Vaswani, Preeta Monga and Allyson Williams. Photo: Selig Polyscope Company.

More than 350 people attended the opening night film, red carpet and festivities at the Perot, followed by another 1200 cinephiles at the Angelika on Saturday and Sunday. Every film was either a Texas or U.S. premiere, and the festival's closing night film, Hansal Mehta's powerful Aligarh, was the North American premiere.

Glamour on the Red Carpet in Texas. Photo: Selig Polyscope Company.

Categories included education programming, arts programming, youth programming, women's programming, men's programming, family programming and LGBT programming. The topics explored varied in scope from slave brides in Rajasthan to the effects of depression and mental illness on the South Asian community to the plight of the LGBTQ community in India.


DFWSAFF Opening Night at the Perot Museum in downtown Dallas.
Photo: Selig Polyscope Company.

Miss India America stars Tiya Sircar (The Internship, Star Wars: Rebels) and Hannah Simone (Fox's "New Girl," Oldboy), who also serves as an Executive Producer. It was directed by Ravi Kapoor and co-written by him, alongside his wife Meera Simhan. Meera is a Creative Producer on the film, and one of its stars. It was produced by Megha Kadakia and Saurabh Kikani.

Tiya Sircar and Kosha Patel in Miss India America.
Photo: Miss India America Pictures.

Miss India America is less a film about Indian identity, and more a story about the limits of American ambition, which explores how the drive to succeed at all costs reveals the best and the worst of who we are. It's a journey that most immigrant communities to the U.S. embark upon, and South Asians are among the most recent to wrestle with these issues. Miss India America explores these ideas through a comedic lens, combining beauty pageants, overachievers, and a vibrant California-based South Asian community.

Lead Actress Tiya Sircar of Miss India America. Photo: Selig Polyscope Company.

The striving for greater success is not unique to South Asian immigrant groups, but the raised public profile of this community has put them in a brighter spotlight in recent years. With statistics stating that Indian-Americans have become the most affluent group in America, and with high-profile leaders across multiple industries, from medicine and the tech industry, to political offices and the arts, it is timely that a film such as Miss India America arrives, and explores the theme of what success really means and why we are driven to achieve it, particularly within the context of the Indian-American community.

1200 cinephiles at the Angelika in Plano on Saturday and Sunday.
Photo: Selig Polyscope Company.

The film focuses on Lily Prasad, a high school valedictorian with ambitions of being a Harvard-educated brain surgeon, who has always won at everything. She suddenly finds herself in the shocking position of having lost her boyfriend to a reigning beauty pageant queen. Not one to be beat, she decides she must now join the pageant competition, and win at all costs.

Photo: Miss India America Pictures.

In a telling scene from the film, Lily has a heart-to-heart with her father, who reminds her that he rose up from poverty in India, to become a successful physician in Orange County, CA. The American Dream writ large. It is in scenes like this that the film touches upon the subtext of ambitious drive for immigrants and their children.


Jaswant Lalwani and Aroon Shivdasani were among the many New Yorkers
in town for the Festival. Photo: Selig Polyscope Company.

Discussing these themes, Saurabh Kikani, one of the film's producers, and a son of Indian immigrant parents, told me:

I think that one of the factors driving all immigrants and their kids is this sense of making the sacrifice worth it. Whether the circumstances in your home country were good or bad, you are leaving behind an entire reality and sense of history which makes up your identity - from language, to food, to cultural norms.

You can bring these things with you, but even then they get transformed and contextualized differently. It is a real loss. So you have to make that loss mean something.

You have to better yourself and your circumstances through whatever lens matters to you, otherwise what was the sacrifice for? More importantly, who are you now, if you've left everything which defined you behind?

Miss India America director by Ravi Kapoor and his wife Meera Simhan.
Photo: Selig Polyscope Company.

On a related note of identity, the film cannot help but touch upon themes of female empowerment, as the near uniformly South Asian-American cast is also female. Each character is distinct, and avoids the stereotypical pitfalls associated with films which do not pass the Bechdel Test, which measures a fictional narrative's bona fides in providing an active presence of women.

The director of Aligarh, Hansal Mehta, Skype'd in to the festival for a Q&A.
Photo: Selig Polyscope Company.

Given the conversation regarding very real gender inequality in American society, let alone South Asian culture, Miss India America's presentation of strong, dynamic female characters is on point, and nearly subversive.

Photo: Miss India America Pictures.

Miss India America's purpose is not to delve deeply into the social psychology of immigrant communities, or gender politics, but in its telling of a young woman's struggle with ambition and identity, the DNA of this South Asian immigrant comedy is as American as can be.

The film opens in select theaters in D.C., San Jose and Chicago on March 25th, and it will be available online starting April 5th on a variety of VOD platforms.

Aroon Shivdasani of the Indo-American Arts Council and its New York
Indian Film Festival (NYIFF). Photo: Selig Polyscope Company.

I was honestly amazed at the world-class quality of the second annual DFW South Asian Film Festival, and overwhelmed with the hospitality I encountered. Perhaps the Festival de Cannes is more prestigious, and Sundance, South by Southwest, and the Venice Film Festival better known. I myself am particular of Toronto and Berlin International Film Festivals, and of course there is no place like home and the New York Film Festival. DFW South Asian Film Festival gives them all a run for their money - and the actor and producers were simply there - and the people in general just really nice.

Lining up to see the next film at the Angelika. Photo: Selig Polyscope Company.

"The responses we got from our audiences were overwhelmingly positive," said founder and festival director Jitin Hingorani. "People thanked us for bringing this revolutionary programming to North Texas, and they said they are already excited for next year's festival."

Photo: Miss India America Pictures.

The festival, produced by JINGO Media, a NYC and Dallas-based PR and events boutique firm, also presented networking events, after-parties and post-screening Q&A sessions with fourteen filmmakers and actors in attendance from all over the world.

Photo: Selig Polyscope Company.

Celebrities who walked the red carpet included my NYC neighbor Suraj Sharma (Umrika, Life of Pi, Homeland, Million Dollar Arm), Tiya Sircar (Miss India America, The Internship, Friends with Benefits, Vampire Diaries), Meera Simhan (Miss India America, Anger Management, Date Movie), Tanima Bhattacharya (Shackle), and Viveck Vaswani (Raju Ban Gaya Gentleman, Pathar Ke Phool, Rough Book).

Aroon Shivdasani and Jitin Hingorani. Photo: Selig Polyscope Company.

2016 Festival Sponsors included Wells Fargo, Etihad Airways & Jet Airways, Mercedes Benz of Plano, Civitas, Cambria Hotels & Suites, The Container Store, Shraman South Asian Museum, Parish Episcopal School, American India Foundation, and Milaap USA.

Community Partners are vital to a successful film festival and DFWSAFF counted among local supporters Selig Polyscope Company, Patrick O'Hara Salon, the U.S. India Chamber of Commerce DFW, Dallas Video Fest, Women in Film. Indian Association of North Texas, Women Entrepreneurs DFW, Forever Rakhi, and the World Affairs Council.

Opening Night panel at the Perot in Dallas. Photo: Selig Polyscope Company.

Media Partners included Asian Variety Show (AVS TV), Radio Azad, and Radio Hot Pepper 1220 AM as well as Karishma Radio, Brown Girl Magazine, Diya TV, Desiplaza TV, and TV Asia.

Each and every film was riveting, but I really moved by Hansal Mehta's Aligarh, shocked by Help Us Find Sunil Tripathi about the suspect in the Boston Bombing, moved to tears by The Backward Class, and truly tickled by I Say Bhallaji, Dhanak - and Miss India America.

The entire lineup of films, including trailers and synopses, is available on the festival's website.


See Stories by Jim Luce on:

Children | Education | Extremism | Fashion | Film | Gay & Lesbian Issues |
India & Indian-American Culture | Pakistan | Young Global Leadership

The James Jay Dudley Luce Foundation ( supporting young global leadership is affiliated with Orphans International Worldwide (OIWW), raising global citizens. If supporting youth is important to you, subscribe to J. Luce Foundation updates here.

Follow Jim Luce on Facebook, Twitter (@JimLuce), and LinkedIn.