The moment my baby came out of my body, the most natural instinct to parent him in certain ways flooded my mind, body and soul. I refused to let him sleep in the hospital nursery, opting instead to let him sleep on my chest. Once we got home and started our lives together, I chose to co-sleep, breast feed on demand, and I often "wore" him in a sarong-type carrier popular in African countries. And guess what? I was criticized almost every day of his childhood.
Fears of fostering dependence, of spoiling my child, of creating a monster rained down on me like confetti at a New Year's Eve celebration. It was as if there was some collective responsibility to raise my child, and if I failed, I would be letting down the world (incidentally, my son is a junior at a university about four states away, having the time of his life).
I'd hoped my experiences were a thing of the past; that in the last 21 years we, as a society, had evolved beyond expressing unsolicited opinions about "controversial parenting" decisions that have long been put to rest by child development experts. New parents need support, they need our trust, they need others to remind them every single day that their instincts to love and nurture their babies are good and necessary.
The impact unsolicited advice has on new parents, particularly new moms (the most common targets of parenting criticism) can be devastating. One new mom I spoke with recently said it best:
Unsolicited advice [about my parenting] makes me feel worthless. Like I'm not good enough or I don't know what I'm doing. Like I am a bad mother for doing what feels natural to me.
Criticizing new moms is almost a cultural rite-of-passage in the United States, and most of the criticism is focused on the very same concern: the fear of fostering dependence in our children. These concerns are not based on research, but on cultural traditions rooted in Western values of rugged individualism and symbols of higher socio-economic status.
I'd like to confront these so-called controversial parenting issues once and for all, by sharing my experiences as well as the consensus of experts (real experts, not well-meaning mothers, fathers, sisters, brothers, in-laws, neighbors, store clerks, people sitting on planes, strangers walking their dogs, etc.):
- Co-sleeping: My son slept with me when he was young. Not every night, but to be honest, most nights. It was a necessary arrangement for us because I worked full-time and was in graduate school and my obedient son by day, was a terror by night. He hated going to sleep. And I simply didn't have three hours for a bedtime ritual, nor did I want one. Besides, I loved sleeping with him. It was a wonderful time of bonding. But, you would have thought my choice to co-sleep with my son was tantamount to tossing back a shot of tequila before nursing, or smoking a pack of cigarettes and blowing the smoke in his face. Parents and babies have been sleeping together for centuries. It's normal. It's natural. Guess where co-sleeping is stigmatized the most? Yep, the United States, where we tend to over-sexualize natural processes, value individualism over nurturing, and link children having their own rooms with socio-economic status. Research is clear. Co-sleeping is good for everyone. It doesn't cause overdependence, SIDS, or divorce. If co-sleeping works for your family, do it. If it doesn't, don't.
So now that we have all the facts, I'd like to promote a cultural change -- a revolution if you will, with these five recommendations:
- If new parents don't ask for your advice, don't give it to them, period.
And to all the new moms (and dads) out there: If you've elected to co-sleep, chest-nap, feed-on-demand and wear your baby, then rest assured, you're doing a great job. If on the other hand, you've elected to have your baby sleep in a crib, feed on a schedule, and tool around town in a stroller rather than a sling, then rest assured, you're doing a great job.