Florida Lawmaker Invokes Hitler In Meltdown Over Her Proposed Kratom Ban

State Rep. Kristin Jacobs (D) said the herb is a “scourge on society,” a claim that has very little factual backing.
Florida state Rep. Kristin Jacobs (D) says the kratom lobby is like Hitler.
Florida state Rep. Kristin Jacobs (D) says the kratom lobby is like Hitler.

The drug warrior mindset is alive and well in the Florida state legislature.

State Rep. Kristin Jacobs (D), in an interview with FloridaPolitics.com this week, defended her bill to crack down on the herb kratom as a matter of life and death for drug users, who she said were being coddled by a kratom lobby that has resorted to the tactics of Adolf Hitler.

“They have a story,” Jacobs said of kratom supporters. “Just like Hitler believed if you tell a lie over and over again, it becomes the truth.”

Kratom is an herb made from the leaves of Mitragyna speciosa, a Southeast Asian tree related to coffee. It contains alkaloids that appear to activate opioid receptors in the brain and reduce pain. Although most opioids have sedative qualities, low to moderate doses of kratom serve as a mild stimulant. Kratom supporters tout these characteristics in claims that the herb can treat anxiety, depression and opioid addiction. Initial studies on kratom suggest it has low potential for acute harm and possible therapeutic applications. Users acknowledge that kratom can lead to withdrawal or dependence after regular use, though they say these side effects pale in comparison to those associated with prescription opioids or heroin.

The science on kratom isn’t settled, however. And, as a largely unregulated dietary supplement, it hasn’t been subject to rigorous clinical tests that would define medicinal properties or risks.

Last year, the U.S. Drug Enforcement Administration, citing concerns over the lack of regulation and isolated reports of harm to users, announced plans to make kratom a Schedule I controlled substance ― a category of drugs with the highest potential for abuse and no accepted medical purpose. The agency later backed down, and awaits Food and Drug Administration guidance in determining how to proceed.

Jacobs did not respond to a request for comment. It appears, however, that her mind is already made up. Her bill, introduced last week, would add kratom to Florida’s list of Schedule I controlled substances, and would make selling, delivering, manufacturing or importing the herb or its active alkaloids a first-degree misdemeanor.

Jacobs, who has unsuccessfully introduced similar legislation in years past, told FloridaPolitics.com that kratom is a “scourge on society” that has led to deaths in the state. There don’t appear to be records of any deaths solely attributable to kratom in Florida ― or anywhere, for that matter. A 2016 report from the Florida Department of Law Enforcement found that kratom “does not currently constitute a significant risk to the safety and welfare of Florida residents.”

Jacobs also lashed out at kratom advocates, calling them “addicts with glassy eyes and shaky hands.” She suggested they were only lobbying in order to protect profits from sales of the herb.

Susan Ash, founder of the American Kratom Association, a nonprofit that works with consumers, said she was taken aback by Jacobs’ remarks.

“I’ve never been more offended by a comment made about our efforts in my two years of doing this,” Ash told The Huffington Post. “It was such an outrageous and inappropriate comment and it shows a level of desperation.”

Ash said her work, beyond lobbying against attempts to ban kratom and for regulatory efforts like age restrictions or packaging standards, revolves around making sure kratom users have safe access to the herb they use to treat a variety of conditions.

“We’re not profiting off of anyone, and if anything, we’re helping addicts,” Ash said. “I’m a recovering addict myself.”

Like many kratom users, Ash was once addicted to opioids, which she’d been prescribed for pain stemming from Lyme disease and its complications. She now uses kratom regularly, and said it gives her energy and pain relief, without the side effects of narcotic painkillers. Read more about her story here.

Ash said the American Kratom Association has more members from Florida than from any other state. Many of them, she said, have contacted Jacobs to complain about her offensive rhetoric and to seek to give their views about her legislation. So far, they haven’t gotten a response. 

“She’s turning a deaf ear to thousands of people who are trying to reach her office who she represents,” said Ash. “When we’re able to get in and talk to people who are honestly willing to listen to us, we’re usually able to get people to see that there are areas where we can compromise.”