Mental Health America recently released their comprehensive State of Mental Health Report, where it ranked how well each state handled mental health challenges, primarily through its citizens’ access to care and the percentage of people with unmet needs.
And the results are pretty dismal.
Nevada fell last on the list, partly due to a majority of adult residents with mental illness not receiving treatment and a large shortage of care providers. Connecticut ranked No. 1, followed by Massachusetts and Vermont. The report also found that more than half of American adults with a mental health issue do not receive treatment.
The rankings were based on 15 different criteria, including the total number of adults and children with a mental illness, how many mental health care professionals were available and the number of adults who were uninsured. Researchers gathered data from 2011 to 2014, which was the most up-to-date information, to reach their conclusion.
“What these rankings come down to is access, investment and explaining to policy makers that they have a choice,” Paul Gionfriddo, chief executive officer of Mental Health America, told The Huffington Post. “They can invest now in mental health and prevention or they can invest later as it becomes a public health issue.”
The findings are disheartening to say the least. The glaring shortage of mental health professionals ― for example, Alabama has one worker per every 1,200 people ― is a prime example of how the health care system fails those with mental health issues, according to John Greden, executive director of the University of Michigan’s Depression Center.
“Getting people treatment won’t improve without access,” Greden said. “States need available experts and they need to be adequately distributed in order to provide care.”
Greden, who wasn’t associated with the State of Mental Health Report, says there needs to be a better focus on distribution of health care workers for rural states like Nevada and Alabama. While big cities, like Las Vegas or Birmingham for example, may have a high concentration of mental health professionals, rural areas likely have significantly fewer clinicians. This is where innovations like telemedicine can come into play, as well as more funding for medicaid and better insurance policies, he explained.
“These investments would pay dividends that are unimaginable,” Greden said. “It would save and improve so many lives. Increasing access and getting rid of the shortages in the mental health workforce would be some of the best things that states could do.”
Gionfriddo agrees. States with relatively limited providers need to look at additional service options for people in less-populated areas, he said.
That, of course, presents its own challenges. Mental health clinicians need to be certified in their state in order to provide holistic care for their clients, making it difficult to completely outsource via online platforms.
However, Gionfriddo says there are some workarounds. By knowing these roadblocks, government officials can properly invest in telemedicine so that they can have certified practitioners give care. Policy makers should also recognize that people with mental health conditions want to be heard by other people who are dealing with their same challenges. Low-ranking states have the opportunity to certify peer counselors in their states which can close some of the gap, he said.
“No state can sit there and say, ‘I have no strategies,’” Gionfriddo said. “Maybe 20 years ago that would have presented a problem but we have the internet now. There are ways to bring more services out to remote areas.”
The outlook isn’t just bleak for adults
Mental Health America’s analysis also highlights a growing problem when it comes to adolescent mental health. The rates of youth depression increased from 8.5 percent in 2011 to 11.1 percent in 2014. And at least 6 out of 10 children and young adults don’t receive adequate care, according to the report.
Mental health issues generally tend to develop starting around ages 15 to 24, but can show up in children even as young as six, Greden said. Early intervention can help young people recover more easily from these conditions but stigma or a lack of education about mental illness often impedes treatment. But experts say implementing more mental health support and counselors in schools and encouraging young people to talk with a professional can help resolve this.
“Letting these illnesses go only makes them worse,” Greden said. “We believe that not addressing mental health issues in children and teenagers is likely a variable in so many educational problems. Treatment can lead to success.”
Why everyone should take this analysis seriously
Gionfriddo hopes that the report opens people’s eyes to the disparities in mental health and available care for those who need it.
“I want people to be advocates,” he said. “People can engage with policy leaders to make a difference in state and local areas. There are lots of routes that lead to recovery and wellbeing.”
Ultimately, the goal should be to prioritize wellness and help those with mental health conditions live full and productive lives, Greden explained. Research shows proper support ― whether it be therapy, medication or both ― really does work. There just needs to be more availability of those resources.
“These are illnesses, yes, but they are treatable,” he said.
Head over to Mental Health America to see a bigger breakdown of their report and to find out more about how your state ranks.