The Full Story Behind Michael Caine's Controversial Oscar Comments

The actor said, "You can't vote for an actor because he's black," but that wasn't all.
CLEMENS BILAN via Getty Images

To paraphrase Alfred in "The Dark Knight," some men just want to watch the Internet burn. That must be the case with the recent comments from Michael Caine on the Oscars.

In a recent interview about his movie "Youth" the "Dark Knight" actor said, "You can't vote for an actor because he's black." He goes on to say, "You can’t just say, 'I’m going to vote for him. He’s not very good, but he’s black. I’ll vote for him.'"

Now those comments are causing more chaos online than The Joker, Bane or Ra's al Ghul did in Gotham combined. But that's not the full quote. Caine says actors should be selected based on their performances and points out a black actor he thought should've been in the running for an Academy Award.

Caine says, "The one I -- I don’t know whether Idris [Elba] got [nominated] because I saw Idris [in 'Beasts of No Nation'], and I thought he was wonderful. I thought he would get [nominated]. Did he not get nominated?”

It seems like Caine is unaware of the controversy he was asked to speak about. Did Idris get nominated? Uh, no. He did not get nominated. No black actor got nominated. That's why this is such a big issue.

Given that he's probably unaware of why this is a problem, it's understandable -- not excusable, but understandable -- to give an answer like, "Actors should be nominated based on their performances."

The fact he's unaware of the controversy is a problem, though.

Of more than 2,900 Oscars awarded, only 31 have reportedly gone to black winners. This year, no black actors have been nominated in individual actor categories. No, Mr. Caine, not even Idris Elba. (We're there with you. He was great.) And though much of the Oscars discussion has been centered around the lack of black acting nominees, it's worth pointing out that Asian, Latino and Native American actors have been notoriously underrepresented as well.

Unfortunately, those paltry numbers make it seem like actors aren't solely being selected based on their performances. And it doesn't sound like anybody is voting for an actor "because he's black." If anything, it's the opposite.

Also on HuffPost:

Idris Elba
Netflix
Best Actor, "Beasts of No Nation"
Jason Mitchell
Universal
Best Supporting Actor, "Straight Outta Compton"
Tessa Thompson
Warner Bros. Pictures
Best Supporting Actress, "Creed"
Will Smith
Columbia Pictures
Best Actor, "Concussion"
Benicio Del Toro
Lionsgate
Best Supporting Actor, "Sicario"
Michael B. Jordan
Warner Bros. Pictures
Best Actor, "Creed"
Oscar Isaac
Universal Studios
Best Supporting Actor, "Ex Machina"
Shameik Moore
Open Road Films
Best Supporting Actor, "Dope"
Samuel L. Jackson
The Weinstein Company
Best Actor, "The Hateful Eight"

Popular in the Community