The Blog

Off-Brand Drinks That Taste Better Than the Real Thing

Does soda really taste better when it's a "brand"?
This post was published on the now-closed HuffPost Contributor platform. Contributors control their own work and posted freely to our site. If you need to flag this entry as abusive, send us an email.

Ah childhood, when nothing could ruin our day faster than running home from the school bus parched from an afternoon of four square or tetherball only to throw open the fridge and find...Dr. Thunder.

Though we whined and complained that we could taste the difference, our mothers stood firm that the too-sugary-not-sugary-enough-just-tastes-wrong feeling we were experiencing was all in our heads.

But was it? Does soda really taste better when it's a "brand"?

One German study suggests that brand name soda does taste better, but not because of a better drink recipe. Brand-name drinks actually have a physical effect on our brains. Researchers gave test subjects the same soda four different times, labeled as Coke, Pepsi, River Cola (a generic German soda), or a brand they said they were testing called T-Cola. All of the subjects expressed a preference for the cola labeled Coke or Pepsi.

Interestingly, when the scientists scanned the subjects' brains using MRI technology, drinking what they thought was name brand soda created activity in the reward center of their brains. But drinking what they thought was generic soda triggered activity in the medial orbitofrontal cortex of test subjects' brains, the part of the brain used to make value judgments.

Scientists believe that when we use "brand name" products, we already assume that they're of good quality, so the part of our brain used to assess whether something is worthy of appreciation shuts off, so we take more pleasure in the experience.

So even if we're sure that we could always taste the difference between our favorite soda and an impostor, the study proves that we probably can't. So if you want to save a buck or two, click through our slideshow to see some off brands that have proven to be just as satisfying as the more recognizable stuff, either through blind taste tests or enthusiastic fan bases. Think you could taste the difference?

Bubble Up
Bubble Up isn’t actually generic, as it’s been around since the 1920s, but people forget it in favor of 7 Up. Rachel Ray’s soda tasting panel preferred Bubble Up’s “limey and dry” elements. Photo Credit: ShutterstockClick Here to See More Off-Brand Drinks That Taste Better Than the Real Thing
Known as the “nectar of North Carolina,” locals can’t get enough of this super carbonated, cherry flavored soda. Photo Credit: Shutterstock
365 Everyday Value Cola
Participants in The Huffington Post’s blind taste test loved the sugary taste of Whole Foods brand soda even more than Coca-Cola classic. Photo Credit: Shutterstock. Click Here to See More Off-Brand Drinks That Taste Better Than the Real Thing
Nehi Soda
Like Cheerwine, Nehi is more forgotten than generic, but fans really love its over-the-top-sugary artificial fruit flavor, much more so than they like the more mainstream Fanta. Photo Credit: Shutterstock
RC Cola
Though most have forgotten about RC Cola, first produced in 1905, in favor of Coke and Pepsi, the brand has over 80,000 followers on Facebook who enjoy its mega sweetness and lower carbonation. Click Here to See More Off-Brand Drinks That Taste Better Than the Real Thing. Photo Credit: Shutterstock

-Emily Alford , The Daily Meal