Oscars Ballot Counters: We Blew It, Warren Beatty Given Wrong Envelope

The screw-up became one of the most memorable moments in Academy Awards history.

The accounting firm of PricewaterhouseCoopers has a message about last night’s shocking Oscars ending: We’re sorry.

The 89th annual Academy Awards was mere minutes from wrapping a somewhat boring broadcast when backstage staffers started running to the microphone to interrupt the final acceptance speeches.

Presenters Warren Beatty and Faye Dunaway had just awarded the Oscar for Best Picture to “La La Land.” The only problem was they were supposed to give “Moonlight” that honor, and there had been a terrible mix-up behind the scenes.

Here’s the entire moment as it played out on live TV:

The veteran actors took to the stage to present the final award of the night. As Beatty read the card in the envelope, he looked visibly confused. He checked the envelope more than once, paused, looked to Dunaway, started to announce the winner, and then passed the envelope to his co-presenter, who promptly said, “La La Land.”

According to Jeffrey Fleishman, senior writer on film, art and culture at the Los Angeles Times, the ceremony’s backstage crew immediately began to panic:

“As the ‘La La Land’ cast was taking the stage to celebrate, a stagehand in the wings said, ‘Oh ... Oh my god, he got the wrong envelope.’ They walked back and forth repeating it.”

Only two humans on the planet know the Oscar winners in advance, and that’s PricewaterhouseCoopers’ Brian Cullinan and Martha Ruiz. After stuffing the envelopes and locking them in a briefcase, they memorize the list of winners. Just last week, the duo blogged on The Huffington Post about the process, and described a meticulous system for ensuring there were no mistakes:

“We hand each envelope directly to the presenter in each category. We are positioned on either side of the stage, so we can hand envelopes from stage right or stage left, depending on where the presenter is entering. We don’t leave for the entire show ― not even for a bathroom break! We’re so focused on doing our jobs that we don’t mind the hours of standing.”

In the photo below, Cullinan appears to be checking envelopes with a stagehand as “La La Land” producer Fred Berger thanked his family.

Commotion broke out as "La La Land" producers accept the award for Best Picture.
Commotion broke out as "La La Land" producers accept the award for Best Picture.
Kevin Winter via Getty Images

“La La Land” cast and crew quickly learned they were erroneously awarded the Best Picture honor.

“There’s a mistake,” “La La Land” producer Jordan Horowitz said. “’Moonlight,’ you guys won best picture. This is not a joke.”

“This is not a joke. I’m afraid they read the wrong thing,” “La La Land” producer Marc Platt added.

Los Angeles Times film writer Amy Kaufman described the atmosphere at the Dolby Theater.

The producers and cast of “Moonlight” were invited to the stage as the stunned crowd applauded and host Jimmy Kimmel joked about the blunder. Beatty took to the microphone to explain what went wrong:

“I want to tell you what happened. I opened the envelope and it said Emma Stone, ‘La La Land.’ That’s why I took such a long look at Faye and at you. I wasn’t trying to be funny.”

Kimmel elaborated on Beatty’s confusion in an interview with ABC.

“I know that the envelope Warren Beatty was handed said ‘Outstanding Female Actor’ on it,” Kimmel said. “This was confusing, obviously. We thought he was being coy and cute and milking it to make everybody suffer, but in reality, he was perplexed by why her name was on it.”

Soon after the show ended, photos started circulating on Twitter of Beatty appearing to hold an envelope that read “actress in a leading role.”

Emma Stone was also confused by the mix-up, as she told reporters backstage that she was holding her winning envelope when Dunaway announced the Best Picture winner, suggesting that she didn’t understand how Beatty’s card could have been the same.

But as Cullinan and Ruiz confirmed last week, there were two copies of each envelope.

A few hours after the awards show, the accounting firm released a statement to The Hollywood Reporter confirming Beatty was given the wrong envelope:

The accounting firm vowed to investigate how the mistake occurred. Meanwhile, the cast and crew of “Moonlight” celebrated their surreal win.

“It’s very hard to feel joy in a moment like that,” Mahershala Ali, who won Best Supporting Actor for his work in “Moonlight,” told the Hollywood Reporter. “But I feel very fortunate for all of us to have walked away with the best picture award. It’s pretty remarkable.”

The card for Best Picture shows "Moonlight" as the winner.
The card for Best Picture shows "Moonlight" as the winner.
Kevin Winter via Getty Images
Producer Adele Romanski, writer/director Barry Jenkins and producer Jeremy Kleiner accept the Best Picture Oscar for "Moonlight."
Producer Adele Romanski, writer/director Barry Jenkins and producer Jeremy Kleiner accept the Best Picture Oscar for "Moonlight."
Kevin Winter via Getty Images
What a win.
What a win.
Jeff Kravitz via Getty Images

CORRECTION: A previous version of this article incorrectly identified “La La Land” producer Jordan Horowitz as Jason Horowitz.