This week in art news, Parisians are up in arms over an 80-foot "butt plug" imagined by the art world's ultimate enfant terrible, Paul McCarthy.
Of course, the massive sculpture isn't technically a butt plug. It's a Christmas tree, simply dubbed "Tree," that's made its way to Place Vendôme in Paris. The piece is part of the International Contemporary Art Fair (FIAC), writes Citylab's Kriston Capps, and is showing in conjunction with McCarthy's first solo show in France -- "Chocolate Factory."
Yet despite all the seemingly obvious signs -- it's art, McCarthy's an artist, FIAC is an art fair -- the inflatable masterpiece is attracting attention not for its aesthetic uniqueness but for its resemblance to sex toys. In fact, France's far-right is not convinced the 24-meter high plant is an objet d'art at all.
"Anal plug or tree?" Printemps Français pondered on Twitter. "Place Vendôme is disfigured... Paris is humiliated!" On top of this, an unknown assailant allegedly attacked McCarthy during the installation of the piece, "screaming that his sculpture did not belong" in public.
Recently, the hashtag #PlugGate has appeared on social media. Hyperallergic dubbed the piece "Paul McCarthy's XXXmas Tree." Anal-related puns are running wild in headlines across the Internet. But is the hype warranted?
If you haven't heard of Paul McCarthy, here's a quick review of his work. He's created a 51-foot tall, inflatable pile of poop, he's turned the beloved fairy tale "Snow White" into a pornographic playground, he's tempted oglers with erotic takes on James Dean, and he's sculpted a nude George W. Bush with a cowboy hat that appears gigantic in proportion to his very apparent penis. In essence, he's not exactly a G-rated, plaza-friendly artist.
To those giggling at the fact the Paris Christmas tree looks like a buttplug, I suggest googling the artists work (Paul McCarthy).
— Huw Lemmey (@spitzenprodukte) October 17, 2014
"This tree is like a giant fantasy," Chiara Parisi, head of cultural programs at Monnaie de Paris, explains of "Tree" in an MSN video. "In the French tradition, it's a fantastical work. It's oversized, it can be analyzed from different angles, it needs this kind of ambiguity too. It's like a big dream that has entered the public space."
The words "fantasy" and "dream" don't exactly deter viewers from assuming "Tree" is an anal plug masquerading as a holiday decoration. But that's the point. In his own opinion, McCarthy says he originally imagined butt plugs looking like Brancusi sculptures, and when shown in green, says they resemble Christmas trees. “But it is an abstract work,” McCarthy states firmly. “People may be offended if they want to refer to [it as a] plug, but, for me, it is more of an abstraction.”
So everyone's in on the joke?
"Of course this work is controversial, it plays on the ambiguity between a Christmas tree and a plug: this is neither a surprise nor a secret," Jennifer Flay, artistic director of FIAC, explained to Le Monde. "But there is no offense against the public and enough ambiguity to not disturb the children. This work has also received all necessary approvals: the Prefecture of Police, the Mayor of Paris and the Ministry of Culture, in collaboration with the Comité Vendôme... What is art [meant to do] if not to disturb, to prompt questions, to reveal flaws in the company? "
There you have it. Let #PlugGate play on.
BEFORE YOU GO
How to vote
Vote-by-mail ballot request deadline: Varies by state
For the Nov 3 election: States are making it easier for citizens to vote absentee by mail this year due to the coronavirus. Each state has its own rules for mail-in absentee voting. Visit your state election office website to find out if you can vote by mail.Get more informationTrack ballot status
In-person early voting dates: Varies by state
Sometimes circumstances make it hard or impossible for you to vote on Election Day. But your state may let you vote during a designated early voting period. You don't need an excuse to vote early. Visit your state election office website to find out whether they offer early voting.My Election Office
General Election: Nov 3, 2020
Polling hours on Election Day: Varies by state/localityMy Polling Place