PlayStation 4 And Xbox One Are Energy Hogs

Your Shiny New Game System Is An Energy Disaster

For all their graphical improvements and multimedia functionality, there's one place where Microsoft's Xbox One and Sony's PlayStation 4 are sorely lacking: energy efficiency.

This is according to a report released on Thursday from the Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC), which found that both the Xbox One and the PlayStation 4 consume two to three times more electricity than the previous generation of consoles. The Nintendo Wii U is the only next-gen console that consumes less energy than the Wii that came before it, the NRDC found.

According to the NRDC's estimation, the current generation of gaming systems will eat up the same amount of energy each year as all the homes in Houston, Texas, while costing consumers nearly $1 billion annually to operate. The Xbox One's consumption is largely thanks to Kinect, an accessory that senses motions and voices and came with every Xbox One until Microsoft announced earlier this week that it would start shipping systems without it.

Because the Kinect is always on -- saying "Xbox on" will activate the system -- it serves as a huge energy suck, one which the NRDC estimates will cost upwards of $400 million every year in electricity bills. The Kinect's "always on" functionality has drawn other criticisms as well, with some charing it's an invasion of privacy and others saying it's a tool for advertisers to target Xbox owners.

For the Playstation 4, the excess energy use comes from the USB ports on the system, which are powered even when the system is on standby mode and nothing is plugged into them.

By comparison, Nintendo's Wii U uses anywhere from half to a third of the energy of the Xbox One or the Playstation 4 when turned on, and it uses no power when the system is off, the NRDC found.

In order to help curb the energy waste, the NRDC suggested that Microsoft offer an opt-out option for the "always on" Kinect and that Sony attempt to bring down the power draw of the USB ports when they're not charging a device. In addition, the two systems could more efficiently power their multimedia options, the NDRC said, as it found that both the Xbox One and Playstation 4 use 30 to 45 times more power to stream video than an Apple TV or a Google Chromecast.

Microsoft and Sony didn't immediately respond to requests for comment on Sunday.

CORRECTION: A previous headline and sentence in this story said the gaming consoles studied used energy when they were "off," while the accurate description is "on standby mode." One sentence has been adjusted and the headline changed to reflect this.

Popular in the Community


What's Hot