Progressives Still Don't Like The Puerto Rico Bill

Time is running out for the beleaguered island.
Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.) speaks at a campaign rally in San Juan, Puerto Rico on May 16, 2016. Sanders has come out strongly against the House bill to aid the island.
Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.) speaks at a campaign rally in San Juan, Puerto Rico on May 16, 2016. Sanders has come out strongly against the House bill to aid the island.
David Gasser/LatinContent/Getty Images

WASHINGTON -- The House is set to move on Republican-crafted legislation next week that would give Puerto Rico powers to restructure its crippling debt. After one failed markup and three drafts, the hard part should be over.

Or not. While Democratic leaders appear ready to support the revised bill, a number of progressives and unions representing workers on the island are concerned about the new text.

Namely, some lawmakers are wary of the bill because it creates a seven-person financial oversight board authorized to help the commonwealth restructure its $70 billion in unpayable debt and draft an economic recovery plan.

Democratic presidential candidate Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.) issued the strongest rebuke of any politician, calling the board a move in the 鈥渨rong direction.鈥

鈥淭his undemocratic board would have the power to slash pensions, cut education and health care, and increase taxes on working families in Puerto Rico,鈥 Sanders said in a statement issued by his Senate office. 鈥淭hat is unacceptable.鈥

Sanders argued that the oversight board will be structured in a way that favors Republican policies.

鈥淢ajority Leader [Mitch] McConnell (R-Ky.) and Speaker [Paul] Ryan (R-Wis.) would be in charge of handpicking a majority of the control board鈥檚 members, while the people of Puerto Rico would be in charge of choosing none,鈥 he said.

Sanders has opposed the Puerto Rico bill since its first draft emerged in late March. He has framed the island鈥檚 debt crisis as part of the Wall Street-versus-Main Street battle that has been a fundamental theme of his campaign -- a message he took to Puerto Rico on Monday, where he was campaigning ahead of the island鈥檚 Democratic primary on June 5.

Hillary Clinton, who is leading Sanders in the race for the Democratic presidential nomination, offered qualified support for the House legislation in a statement released by her campaign.

Meanwhile, House Democrats like Rep. Xavier Becerra (D-Calif.), chair of the House Democratic Caucus, and Rep. Luis Gutierrez (D-Ill.) are withholding their support for the bill until they review more of the text.

"My hope is to support a bill that helps the people of Puerto Rico, that protects them from the vulture capitalist hedge funds that want to cash-in on the Island's misery,鈥 Gutierrez said in a statement after the bill鈥檚 release.

The oversight board raised some red flags for Gutierrez, he said, but he wants to get to a 鈥測es.鈥 That's precisely the predicament Democrats and the Obama administration are facing: This isn鈥檛 the bill they would have written, but they're running out of time as the commonwealth stares down the barrel of a $2 billion default on July 1.

It also appears to be the only kind of legislation that can pass an obscenely gridlocked Congress.

鈥淭his undemocratic board would have the power to slash pensions, cut education and health care, and increase taxes on working families in Puerto Rico.鈥

- Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.)

Still, the AFL-CIO labor federation and several individual unions representing some 50,000 Puerto Rican workers oppose the bill -- including the American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees, the Service Employees International Union, and the International Association of Machinists and Aerospace Workers.

In a letter to Congress, the unions say the bill fails to 鈥減rotect the accrued pension benefits of Puerto Rican workers and retirees, retain worker protections that apply to all working people in the U.S. including minimum wage and overtime protections, and preserve the democratic rights of the people of Puerto Rico.鈥

Roberto Pagan, president of SEIU鈥檚 29,000-worker-strong Puerto Rico chapter, said he was concerned that five out of seven board members must vote to approve a court-supervised debt restructuring process in which a federal judge could force write-downs on creditors. (Other budgetary changes would only need four votes.)

Pagan said court-supervised restructuring would be unlikely if four people on the board are selected by congressional Republicans. (The remaining 3 seats on the board will be nominated by Democrats, and President Barack Obama will have the final say on all choices.)

Eric LeCompte, executive director of Jubilee USA, a religious anti-poverty group and proponent of restructuring Puerto Rico's debt, endorsed the bill while acknowledging it is not 鈥減erfect.鈥

LeCompte argued that even the threat of court-supervised restructuring would create an incentive for parties to reach a voluntary agreement to put Puerto Rico鈥檚 debt on a sustainable path.

The bill contains other provisions that give Puerto Rico鈥檚 government more leverage over creditors, LeCompte said. He described an 鈥渋nnovative鈥 clause that would require all creditors in a given bond pool to proceed with a voluntary restructuring deal if the lenders holding two-thirds of that pool's bonds agreed to it. This would prevent a small number of holdouts from blocking a resolution, he said -- something that was a problem in Argentina and other countries plagued by sovereign debt crises.

鈥淪peaker Ryan (R-Wis.), Chairman Bishop (R-Utah) and Rep. Duffy (R-Wis.) have really strongly stood against the special interests,鈥 LeCompte said. 鈥淚t is really pretty amazing that they put the people of Puerto Rico first and a small group of creditors second.鈥

鈥淚t is better to have nothing than this law, because it does not give any protection to the pensions of the retirees, or provide an economic growth plan.鈥

- Roberto Pagan, SEIU Puerto Rico

It's not entirely clear what viable alternatives are available to Puerto Rico if this legislation fails.

Some progressive detractors do not even see the need for them.

鈥淚t is better to have nothing than this law, because it does not give any protection to the pensions of the retirees, or provide an economic growth plan,鈥 Pagan said.

But the labor leader and other critics of the bill suggested a number of unconventional, end-run tactics that they could use to force bondholders to agree to more favorable restructuring terms.

Pagan said a Puerto Rican government-sponsored commission to audit the island鈥檚 debt should be allowed to complete its investigation.

If the commission finds -- as Pagan and others expect -- that a significant percentage of Puerto Rico鈥檚 debt was issued illegally, the island鈥檚 government could choose to nullify that portion entirely.

Manuel Natal, a member of Puerto Rico鈥檚 House of Representatives who serves on the commission and was one of the driving forces behind its creation, believes the island would be on strong legal footing to refuse payment of illegal debt. But he argues that it would likely not be necessary.

鈥淚t is more of a negotiating strategy,鈥 he said.

Puerto Rico may also receive relief from the Supreme Court. The high court is expected to decide in late June whether to uphold a local Puerto Rican bankruptcy law that would allow Puerto Rico to seek court-mandated restructuring on $20 billion in debt owed by its municipalities and public corporations.

That would presumably mean it could dispense with a sizable portion of its $70-billion debt burden without the need for new legislation.

Sanders, for his part, called on the Federal Reserve to use 鈥渋ts emergency authority to facilitate an orderly restructuring of Puerto Rico鈥檚 debt.鈥

鈥淚f congressional legislation fails, we could see something like that,鈥 LeCompte ventured.

Experts on the Federal Reserve, however, say that the central bank does not have the legal authority to effectively bail out Puerto Rico.

In the end, it comes down to timing. Without fast action ahead of the July 1 debt payment deadline, Puerto Rico's financial situation will crumble further, hurting its already-squeezed economy, health care and education systems.

鈥淚t is critical that Congress pass this as there are very significant bond payments due in July,鈥 Treasury Secretary Jack Lew said on the sidelines of the G7 meetings in Japan on Friday morning. 鈥淚t is always significant when you reach bipartisan agreement on a difficult area, but this is one where time is of the essence.鈥

Puerto Ricans Are Americans

Puerto Rico's Debt Crisis

Popular in the Community