CINCINNATI - An Ohio judge declared a mistrial on Saturday, finding jurors hopelessly deadlocked in the case of a white former University of Cincinnati police officer charged with murder in the shooting death of a black motorist during a traffic stop last year.
The panel of six white men, four white women and two black women began deliberating on Wednesday at the Common Pleas Court in Hamilton County on whether former officer Ray Tensing was guilty of murder or voluntary manslaughter in the fatal shooting of Samuel DuBose.
Prosecutors have until Nov. 28 to decide whether there will be a retrial. Cincinnati Mayor John Cranley said he hoped that would happen.
The 12 jurors had told Judge Megan Shanahan on Friday that they had failed to reach a unanimous verdict, but she ordered them to redouble their efforts.
She declared a mistrial after hearing how, despite “a night of sleep and two additional hours of deliberations,” the panel had still failed to agree.
Tensing, who had pleaded not guilty and was free on $1 million bond, drank from a water bottle and stared straight ahead as Shanahan spoke. None of DuBose’s relatives were present in the courtroom.
Tensing was fired from the University of Cincinnati Police Department after being indicted in July 2015.
DuBose’s killing fueled demonstrations against use of lethal force by white officers against unarmed blacks and other minorities, an issue which has been the focus of nationwide protests and a renewed national debate over racial bias in the criminal justice system.
‘THINK WE PROVED IT’
Hamilton County prosecutor Joe Deters said the jury had been leaning toward acquitting Tensing of murder and convicting him on the lesser charge of voluntary manslaughter, but that they could not agree.
“I still think it’s murder and I think we proved it,” Deters told reporters at the court.
Cranley, Cincinnati’s mayor, told a news conference he believes DuBose did not deserve to die.
“I believe a just outcome would lead to accountability for that fact,” Cranley said. “We’ve learned throughout this process how deeply Prosecutor Deters feels about this case ... so I suspect he will continue to find a way to bring justice.”
Cranley said city officials respect people’s right to be upset, and that he believes protests will continue to be peaceful. He said downtown remains safe and open for business.
Body-camera video of the July 2015 incident showed Tensing, 26, shooting DuBose, 43, in the head after pulling him over for a missing front license plate on his vehicle.
During the traffic stop, which took near the southeast edge of the University of Cincinnati’s main campus, Tensing asked DuBose to remove his seatbelt and tried to open the car door. DuBose did not comply and closed the door. The vehicle started rolling forward slowly as Tensing pulled his gun and fired once.
The defense maintained that Tensing feared for his life and only opened fire in an attempt to prevent being run over by DuBose’s car or pinned to a nearby guard rail.
In emotional testimony on Tuesday, Tensing told the court he had no intention of killing DuBose when he opened fire.
The prosecution countered by arguing that Tensing was never in danger and had falsified his account by exaggerating that he was being dragged by DuBose’s vehicle.
(Reporting by Ginny McCabe; Additional reporting by Gina Cherelus in New York and Timothy Mclaughlin in Chicago; Editing by Daniel Wallis, Leslie Adler and Chizu Nomiyama)