Wendy Mogel, author of The Blessing of a Skinned Knee and The Blessing of a B Minus -- and a parenting genius, in my opinion -- says that kids need to have jobs in high school.
I get that. When I was in high school in the '80s, I had three jobs: I worked the counter at a pharmacy, was the hostess at a diner and waitressed at the local catering hall.
A job was a good thing for several reasons. Besides offering me a chance to make some money for college (in those days, my college ended up costing about $15,000 a year, so having $3,000 saved up from working actually did make a difference), working also taught me life lessons, including how to make change at a cash register. (Calculus honors student that I was, I tried to subtract in my head, which wasn't easy. Instead, my dad taught me to "count up." So if something cost $3.84, and the customer gave me a ten dollar bill, I added a penny to make 85 cents, a dime and nickel to get to four dollars, and then six more dollars to get to ten. A true life lesson!)
I also have a strong memory of my oldest brother telling us that one of his coworkers, another high school kid, was skimming a bit of money out of the cash register each week. That was a totally shocking real world lesson for us -- and one that led to important family talks about ethics and character that I won't ever forget.
So, even though kids are busier these days -- taking more tests and doing more extracurricular activities to get into much more competitive colleges -- a part-time job during the school year in high school should be a no-brainer, right?
I say, wrong. The more I dug into this question, and analyzed the trade-offs, I truly think that the answer for many kids is that school is their job.
Time Well Spent: Homework vs. Job
For starters, having a job in high school could drop your kid's grades significantly -- from an A- to a C-, for instance. At least, that's what a working paper from the Bureau of Labor Statistics suggests.
The study found that kids who held a job while they were in high school spent 49 minutes less on homework on the days they worked.
The study explains that other research has found that increasing time spent on homework by just 30 minutes per night improves math grades, for example, by two full grade levels -- so it's clear that an after-school job can hurt academic performance.
If scooping ice cream can get you kicked off the honor roll, it could also, in theory, increase the amount of student debt you are forced to take on.
Work Now, Pay Later?
Here's my thinking: Lower grades usually make it harder to get into top colleges -- particularly those that might have more money to dole out.
Though the Ivy League schools, considered among the most competitive, tend not to offer scholarship money for academic achievement, if you get in and qualify for financial aid, several have the most generous aid packages around.
Some Ivies have replaced loans with grants in all of their financial aid packages, and even eliminated the amount parents have to contribute if their incomes are below a stipulated income. (At Yale, it's $65,000; at Harvard, it's $60,000.)
What's more, there are many highly-rated private colleges that do pay a big chunk of the costs for kids with terrific academic records. And some of the best teaching can be had at public colleges, which often have special discounted scholar programs for great academic performers.
Real World Experience
Not all kids are academic superstars, of course. And I certainly understand the gestalt of Mogel's philosophy: A B- is a blessing, since it means a kid isn't so narrowly focused on often unattainable goals like perfect 800s on SATs.
This is sound and healthy, for sure. I also agree that kids should be more engaged in the real world, and focus on what really matters outside of their narrow interests and desires.
And, of course, I appreciate the fact that some kids have to work to help support themselves or their families. (Wendy wisely recommends that they try to keep the hours worked under 15 a week.)
However, in the end, I come down on the side of no job during the school year. And though it may be "academically incorrect" to point out, the prestige bestowed by an Ivy League diploma does pay off for many kids.
Economist Alan Krueger's work shows that students who are black or Hispanic, or whose own parents did not go to college, experience an income boost by attending such tony institutions.
Krueger speculates that these very top academic institutions offer kids from less advantaged backgrounds a key into a world of professional contacts that they would not have had otherwise.
Now, I'm all for real jobs in the summer. And I'm an advocate of helping at the local homeless shelter over social action programs in far-off places that cost parents thousands of dollars.
(I am not saying that these programs aren't worthwhile, but I am saying that they aren't jobs.)
I am curious to hear what other people think. Is it wise to make a high school student juggle academics plus a real job?
Beth Kobliner is a personal finance commentator and journalist, the author of the New York Times bestseller Get a Financial Life: Personal Finance in Your Twenties and Thirties, and a member of the President's Advisory Council on Financial Capability. Visit her at bethkobliner.com, follow her on Twitter, and like her on Facebook.
This post was originally published on Mint.com.