Texas Attorney General: Marriage License For Same-Sex Couple Could Lead To 'Legal Chaos'

An angular view of the Italian Renaissance Revival architecture, the Texas Capitol, features the Sunset Red granite of this i
An angular view of the Italian Renaissance Revival architecture, the Texas Capitol, features the Sunset Red granite of this imposing building

(Adds statement from lawyer for the couple)

By Jon Herskovitz

AUSTIN, Texas, Feb 20 (Reuters) - The Texas attorney general asked the state's Supreme Court on Friday to revoke a marriage license issued a day earlier to two women, arguing the move violated a decade-old state ban against gay marriage and could cause legal chaos.

Travis County, where the capital Austin is located, issued a marriage license to Sarah Goodfriend and Suzanne Bryant, who have been together for about 30 years and have two daughters. It was the first license issued to a same-sex couple in Texas since the ban was put in place.

A county judge made a one-time exception to allow the license to be issued, saying Goodfriend was in poor health due to ovarian cancer and denying the couple the license violated their rights under the U.S. Constitution.

Attorney General Ken Paxton, a Republican who has pledged to fight for the sanctity of marriage between a man and woman, said in a press release, "the rogue actions of Travis County judges do not withstand the scrutiny of law." His office filed the petition with the Texas Supreme Court to have the license declared void.

"Relief from this Court is necessary to avoid the legal chaos that would follow if the trial court's ruling is mistakenly interpreted as authorization for the creation or recognition of same-sex marriages in Travis County or throughout the State," the petition said.

A U.S. district judge in Texas last year ruled the state's ban on gay marriage unconstitutional because it denied same-sex couples equal protection under the law. Enforcement of the decision is on hold pending an appeal.

Supporters of the couple have argued the license is valid and Paxton is standing on the wrong side of history by trying to deny same-sex couples the right to marry.

Chuck Herring, a lawyer for the couple, said the Paxton filing is inappropriate and out of step with the current situation in the country, where same-sex marriage is permitted in most states.

"If he wants to sue a woman who has ovarian cancer to try to take away her marriage license, so be it. His continuing meanness and lack of compassion are remarkable," Herring said. (Reporting by Jon Herskovitz; Editing by Mohammad Zargham and Eric Beech)



  • The sun will rise in the morning, not because we voted for it, but rather because of some force we have no control over!
    Getty / HuffPost Comedy
  • Plants will use that sunlight for photosynthesis and then expel oxygen. Right in public, where children can see!
    Getty / HuffPost Comedy
  • Oxygen will enter your lungs and bloodstream, and you'll have to let it happen if you want to live here!
    Getty / HuffPost Comedy
  • Your muscles will take the oxygen from your blood. Just like that. Oh, you're welcome muscles.
    Getty / HuffPost Comedy
  • Then, in return, your body is basically ordered to give up its carbon dioxide! You earned that carbon dioxide!
    Getty / HuffPost Comedy
  • You'll be up and about in the morning because you can't sleep anymore. Again, essentially against your will!
    Getty / HuffPost Comedy
  • For breakfast you'll toast a bagel and spread some imitation butter on it, which is totally unnatural!
    Getty / HuffPost Comedy
  • You'll hop into a car and drive to your job -- show us where THAT'S mentioned in the Bible!
    Getty / HuffPost Comedy
  • And then you'll return home after a long day's work and watch some TV before falling asleep on your couch. The couch isn't made for that, beds are! Just because you can fall asleep on your couch doesn't make it right!
    Getty / HuffPost Comedy