Texas Education Commissioner Michael Williams Considers School Rating System Using Minority Progress

Michael Williams, with the Texas Railroad Commission, talks to the media at the entrance to the blast site Tuesday, June 8, 2
Michael Williams, with the Texas Railroad Commission, talks to the media at the entrance to the blast site Tuesday, June 8, 2010. About a half dozen people were injured and taken to hospitals on Monday, June 7, after a natural gas line exploded in Johnson County, Texas. A digging machine struck a gas line. (Photo by Paul Moseley/Fort Worth Star-Telegram/MCT via Getty Images)

Texas’ new education commissioner Michael Williams is considering a new system for rating school success that would take into account how well districts are closing the achievement gap that exists among poor and minority students.

According to the Associated Press, schools and districts are currently rated and ranked based almost exclusively on student performance on state-mandated standardized tests.

The Houston Chronicle reports the formula for the new rankings, which were mandated by the Legislature in 2009 to accompany the new State of Texas Assessments of Academic Readiness, will also incorporate test scores, student gains and a post-high school readiness measure, though Williams says he wants the achievement gap measure to weigh more heavily than the other three indicators.

"In a state that is 60 percent economically disadvantaged and 60 percent black and brown, we've got to be concerned about closing that racial achievement gap because indeed our demographics are changing," Williams told the State Board of Education on Thursday.

According to Texas Education Agency data, 92 percent of white students graduated on time in 2011, compared to 82 percent of Latino students and 81 percent of black students, reports the AP. Only 84 percent of economically disadvantaged children graduated.

Schools will receive the initial ratings in August, one year after Gov. Rick Perry tapped Williams to be the next state education commissioner.

The Houston Chronicle reports that Wiliams would not specify whether schools will be given number scores, letter grades or new titles, but the current categories of “exemplary,” “recognized,” “acceptable” or “unacceptable” will be done away with.

Houston Independent School District board member Harvin Moore told the paper he hopes the new rating system is more challenging. In 2011, about 88 percent of the state’s districts were rated as “recognized” or “acceptable.”

"It was getting to where too many schools were rated at the top level and it becomes fairly meaningless," he said.

Democratic Rep. Lawrence Allen, Jr., one of two black members on the State Board of Education, told the Houston Chronicle in August that Williams’ appointment would encourage minority students.

“As we look at Barack Obama as the first black president, we see all the energy and enthusiasm among minority students in terms of high aspirations,” Allen said. “[Williams] has an excellent story to tell, and he has some excellent things in his background that will give him balance.”



5 Hidden Costs of Public High School