Greg Abbott: Abortion Clinic Closures Are Manageable 'Inconvenience' For Women

Greg Abbott: Abortion Clinic Closures Are Manageable 'Inconvenience' For Women

Texas officials filed a memorandum with the U.S. Supreme Court on Thursday in defense of an anti-abortion law that has shut down 80 percent of clinics in the state, arguing that the law is merely a manageable "inconvenience" -- not an undue burden -- to Texas women.

Texas Attorney General Greg Abbott (R) and his colleagues wrote in the memo that "the vast majority of Texas residents" still live "within comfortable driving distance (150 miles)" of an abortion provider. For the women who live in the farther-flung regions of the state, such as the low-income Rio Grande Valley near the Mexico border, Abbott wrote, "abortion can be accessed by driving approximately 230-250 miles -- an inconvenience, but still a manageable one."

In 2013, there were 44 abortion clinics operating throughout Texas. But House Bill 2 and other anti-abortion legislation in Texas have forced all but eight of those clinics to close. The remaining clinics are concentrated in four cities, leaving large swaths of the state -- particularly the poorer regions -- without close access to a provider.

The Supreme Court ruled in Planned Parenthood v. Casey in 1992 that abortion restrictions cannot impose an "undue burden" on women's ability to have an abortion before her fetus is viable, around 22 to 24 weeks. The Texas law bans abortion after 20 weeks of pregnancy, requires all abortions to take place in ambulatory surgical centers, and requires all abortion providers to have admitting privileges at a local hospital, even if hospitals refuse to grant any such privileges.

In August, a federal judge blocked the portion of the law that requires abortion facilities to become surgical centers, or mini-hospitals, concluding that the law is not designed to protect women's health but to shut down clinics. A federal appeals court reversed that decision weeks later and allowed the law to go into effect, immediately forcing 13 abortion clinics to shut down throughout the state.

The Center for Reproductive Rights, a national advocacy group, filed an emergency application with the Supreme Court earlier this week appealing the decision. The Center claims that the law is unconstitutional because it will prevent women in the state from being able to access abortion.

“There can be no question that just a handful of clinics left to offer safe, legal abortion care to all women across the vast state of Texas is a dire emergency in need of an immediate response," said Nancy Northup, the group's president. “Every hour that these clinics are closed adds to the number of women, many facing urgent circumstances, who will be denied essential care and their constitutional rights."

According to a recent analysis by the reproductive health news site RH Reality Check, a woman in rural Texas will now have to pay more than a month's worth of wages and drive seven hours round trip in order to have an abortion. The Huffington Post reported earlier this year that women near the Mexico border were already feeling desperate enough to seek illegal, unsafe ways to end their pregnancies.

But Abbott's team doesn't see the sudden drop in clinics as an "undue burden." They called the Center's argument a "vague hyperbole" in their response to the Supreme Court appeal.

"The plaintiffs have produced not one iota of evidence that the remaining HB2-compliant providers are unable to handle the statewide demand for abortion," they wrote.

Go To Homepage

Before You Go

Kansas Gov. Sam Brownback (R)
Despite governing a deep red state, Brownback is vulnerable due to the steep income tax cuts he signed off on that have catalyzed dire revenue shortfalls. State House Minority Leader Paul Davis (D) has been attacking Brownback over the shortfall's impact on education spending, and the approach seems to be working, as he leads in the polls.
Maine Gov. Paul LePage (R)
Democrats are using LePage's outspoken comments to call him an embarrassment and a detriment to the state's reputation. Republicans are defending LePage by calling him "blunt, honest, one-of-a-kind" and "unique, just like Maine."However, his Democratic challenger, Rep. Mike Michaud, may be hampered by the presence of independent Eliot Cutler on the ballot. The Democrat would become the first openly gay person ever elected governor if he wins on Nov. 4.
Illinois Gov. Pat Quinn (D)
Pat Quinn, left, and Bruce Rauner (ASSOCIATED PRESS)
In Illinois, venture capitalist Bruce Rauner (R) is narrowly leading Quinn in the polls, as the Democratic governor suffers from low approval ratings. Rauner has emphasized his relatively moderate stances on abortion rights and marriage equality, while Democrats have seized on his comment that he's probably a member of the "0.01 percent" and his membership in a private wine club to characterize him as out of touch.
Pennsylvania Gov. Tom Corbett (R)
Tom Corbett, left, and Tom Wolf (ASSOCIATED PRESS)
Corbett is seriously lagging in the polls behind businessman Tom Wolf (D), who has been able to self-fund his campaign. Corbett's cuts to education spending and handling of the Penn State investigation into child sexual abuse when he served as attorney general have meant months of negative publicity. Wolf, on the other hand, has stayed up on the airwaves with sunny spots about his family business.
Colorado Gov. John Hickenlooper (D)
John Hickenlooper, left, and Bob Beauprez (ASSOCIATED PRESS)
Hickenlooper has been forced to defend his decision to indefinitely block the execution of Nathan Dunlap, the state's longest-serving death row inmate. Former Rep. Bob Beauprez (R-Colo.) has focused on the capital punishment issue, as well as gun control restrictions recently passed in the state, anti-fracking initiatives and proposed tax increases, to make the case that Hickenlooper's policies aren't as business-friendly as his own. While the governor has refused to air negative television ads, his Democratic allies have swooped in to protect him.
Wisconsin Gov. Scott Walker (R)
Walker has the edge against businesswoman Mary Burke (D) in the polls, but Democratic motivation to boot him out of office remains high. The race has largely hinged on economic issues. Chaos over a new voter identification requirement may affect this race's outcome.
Michigan Gov. Rick Snyder (R)
Snyder has been leading former Rep. Mark Schauer (D-Mich.) in the polls, but labor and environmental groups think they can narrow the gap before Election Day. The governor has been running on his management of the state's economy and has vetoed bills from the state legislature on gun rights, abortion restrictions and voter identification. Schauer drew attention to Snyder's opposition to marriage equality when he chose Oakland County Clerk Lisa Brown as his running mate. Brown had issued same-sex marriage licenses in opposition to Snyder's administration.Democrats have cast Snyder as out of touch, using his comments comparing disastrous flooding to a leak at his vacation home as ammunition.
Florida Gov. Rick Scott (R)
The close race between Scott and former Gov. Charlie Crist, who was once a Republican but is now running as a Democrat, may be the most expensive governor's race in the country. Scott has characterized Crist as a flip-flopper and emphasized his own actions to stimulate job growth, while Crist has hammered away at Scott's refusal to expand Medicaid under the Affordable Care Act, cuts to education spending and opposition to raising the minimum wage.
Connecticut Gov. Dannel Malloy (D)
This year's race is a rematch between Malloy and businessman Tom Foley (R), who narrowly lost to the governor in 2010. Malloy's poll numbers are hurting over economic issues, as voters express dissatisfaction with how he has handled the state budget and taxes. The governor has been highlighting his response to the 2012 mass school shooting at Sandy Hook Elementary School in Newtown, Connecticut, saying it demonstrates his responsiveness as a leader. In contrast, Foley has avoided giving specifics when asked which gun control measures passed by the state legislature he opposes.
Georgia Gov. Nathan Deal (R)
Deal appears vulnerable because state Sen. Jason Carter (D), former President Jimmy Carter's grandson, has capitalized on multiple ethics investigations to characterize Deal as a politician who has abused the powers of public office. The governor holds a small lead in the polls and has consistently tied Carter to national Democrats, though Carter has rejected that comparison.

Popular in the Community