Steven Buchwald is a startup lawyer and founding partner of Buchwald & Associates in New York, focusing on representing tech startups.
Steve Blank, a Silicon Valley entrepreneur-turned-professor with over two decades of experience, has over the course of his career founded or worked within eight different startups. And in that time, he's lived through every entrepreneur's worst nightmare: he had his ideas stolen. Twice.
"The first time it happened, it was no big deal," Blank recounted in a 2009 VentureBeat article."The other, it was serious."
Blank had presented an idea for a marketing automation system to a VP of Marketing at a Silicon Valley enterprise. After nine months of ignored phone calls from the originally enthusiastic VP, a partner pointed out that Blank's PowerPoint slides had been shamelessly stolen by the very same person. He had become CEO of a competing company and was presenting them as his own.
Don't Let Fears of Idea Theft Prevent You From Acting
"I am truly amazed by how afraid some inventors are," writes inventRight co-founder Stephen Key. "They fear that someone is going to steal their million-dollar idea. They assume that every company is eagerly lying in wait, ready to rip them off. That thinking is not only annoying and counterproductive but also simply untrue."
4 Steps to Protect Your Startup Idea
- Remember that most "theft" comes from within your company.
When I talk to founders who are afraid of presenting their ideas to investors, I remind them that this is the lesser of two threats. As Steve Jobs put it: "To me, ideas are worth nothing unless executed. They are just a multiplier. Execution is worth millions."
Running a PowerPoint presentation by a VP only gives away the high-level details. Blank himself never sought legal action. His company had enough insider knowledge to pull ahead of his new competitor. It's your employees and co-founders who have access to the real knowledge of the company -- to the "execution," rather than the "idea." Protecting the future of your company starts with realizing this.
2. Talk to a lawyer and get your documents in order.
Have a lawyer go over your idea to determine which aspects of it can be copyrighted, trademarked or patented.
It is especially important to get anybody who works with you under strict, carefully written non-disclosure and non-compete agreements. These ensure that your employees and co-founders can't walk away with or sell any proprietary knowledge that could give away your competitive advantages.
What many people don't realize is that, under the law, by default, people own the copyrights to anything they create. So if one of your employees creates a copyrightable piece of intellectual property, they own the copyrights. You don't. Without the right documents in place, this means that your employees could walk away with vital information or assets.
These documents are also useful to have in place to increase trust between co-founders or between founders and employees. On the superficial level, it might seem like getting a lawyer involved early on is a sign of mistrust. But in my experience, it is 100 percent about improving trust. The more time passes without the documents in place, the more mistrust you start to see. Interestingly, this mistrust increases the chances of such "theft" actually occurring. A co-founder who thinks the other co-founders are out to get him is more likely to walk away with the idea, which ultimately means that everybody is less likely to be successful.
3. Be discerning about the people you work with.
- Are there any complaints on the public record from people who have worked with them in the past?
- Any disgruntled co-founders?
- Any companies claiming the investor stole their idea?
- Any warning signs in their employment history?
If you've already spoken with a lawyer, you should be protected from a legal standpoint, but it's still important to be careful. You don't want to be involved with the kind of person who might make a legal battle necessary, even when your chances of winning are very good.
4. Invest in ideas that are difficult to copy.
On the strategic level, all the legal protection in the world isn't going to be particularly helpful if your idea is easy to reverse engineer. To be clear, pretty much anything can be reverse engineered on some level: the focus isn't on ideas that can never be copied, but on ideas that are hard to copy.
First mover advantage only exists if it takes time for your competitors to catch up. I've worked with many startups, and the ones that succeed are those that understand the strengths and weaknesses of legal protection. The winners understand that the documents exist to serve the business model and enhance growth. They aren't a panacea, and they won't help unoriginal ideas become successful.