Food & Drink

What Is A Sandwich? HuffPost Editors Wage An Intense Debate

HuffPost editors debate over sushi and even bread bowls.
02/13/2015 09:08am ET | Updated February 13, 2015

What is a sandwich? The answer seems obvious, until you actually start to think about it, and the lines start blurring. There are foods you pick up with your hands to eat, myriad types of bread and bread-like encasings, and endless other kinks in a sandwich's definition. It's a cruel world out there for sandwich purists.

February 3 marked the commencement of an important debate among some editors at The Huffington Post over what defines a sandwich. It all began when Associate Special Projects Editor Amanda Gutterman told Tech Editor Alexis Kleinman that she had a revelation: sushi is just another kind of sandwich. Needless to say, a heated discussion ensued in the arena best-suited for these kinds of deep, philosophical questions: Twitter.

Indeed, as Kleinman rightly asked, "What is NOT a sandwich?"

After talk of pizza...

... the conversation naturally turned to open-faced sandwiches.

And if a consensus started brewing that sandwiches required bread enveloping something else, someone asked about bread bowls. Sandwich or not?

Then the debaters entertained the following as possible sandwiches: wraps, Hot Pockets, pizza bagels stuck together, calzones and dumplings. Gutterman stands by her original statement, per the following reasoning: "A carb 'holder' for any meat and/or veggie 'filling' fulfills the platonic requirements for sandwich-ness."

The editors at HuffPost Taste obviously have strong opinions. Executive Food Editor Kristen Aiken insists a sandwich must have two layers of carbs surrounding a layer of fillings. Food Editor Julie Thomson believes, "a wrap will never, ever be a sandwich," while Healthy Living and Taste Editor Kate Bratskeir points out that "a wrap could loosely be considered a sandwich. If a friend said to you, 'I'm gonna grab a sandwich,' and returned with a wrap, you'd not think twice." Staff Writer Joe Satran negates the bread bowl as as a possible sandwich because not only do you eat bread bowls with a spoon, you don't get the filling and the container in the same bite. He wonders, however: If sandwiches require bread, where do falafel and hummus pitas stand? "The bread isn't sliced!" Satran says.

It's a universal debate, of course -- one that has existed as long as sandwiches, whatever they are, have been around. Our friends at The Meat Hook in Brooklyn were outraged at the thought that a wrap could be considered a sandwich. Sandwich master Ashley Berman argues that wraps and sandwiches appear in different categories on menus everywhere. Same goes for burritos.

Sausage Maestro and co-owner of The Meat Hook, Ben Turley, puts it this way: "I guess sandwiches are like pizza. A calzone is like a pizza, but it's not a pizza. That's why it's called something different. Similar to the sandwich/wrap conundrum. But sandwiches, like pizza, are endlessly versatile (toppings, breads, sauces, etc.) so it blurs the lines between what it is, what it can be, and what it can't be ever."

Luckily for those of us who live in New York, the New York State Department of Taxation has clarified the matter, as Gothamist reported this summer. For the record, they include wraps. They also include items as specific as "simple as a buttered bagel or roll, or as elaborate as a six-foot, toasted submarine sandwich," Gothamist notes.

So what do you think? Is a dumpling a sandwich? Help us out and tell us what you think, 'cuz right now we're kind of stuck:

Oh. And this:

Please weigh in for the sake of sandwich eaters everywhere.

Want to read more from HuffPost Taste? Follow us on Twitter, Facebook, Pinterest and Tumblr.

1
Halloumi & Hummus Brioche
Borrowed Light
Get the Halloumi & Hummus Brioche recipe from Borrowed Light
2
Buffalo Falafel And Garlic Blue Cheese Fry Pitas
Half Baked Harvest
3
Buffalo Lentil 'Meatball' Sandwich
Naturally Ella
Get the Buffalo Lentil 'Meatball' Sandwich recipe from Naturally Ella
4
Crispy Tofu Sandwich With Golden Spread
Happy. Healthy. Life.
Get the Crispy Tofu Sandwich with Golden Spread recipe from Happy. Healthy. Life.
5
Blue Cheese And Smashed Avocado And Roasted Tomato Grilled Cheese
Half Baked Harvest
6
Vegan Avocado Caprese Sandwich
Happy. Healthy. Life.
Get the Vegan Avocado Caprese Sandwich recipe from Happy. Healthy. Life.
7
Classic Egg Salad Sandwich
Foodie Crush
Get the Classic Egg Salad Sandwich recipe from Foodie Crush
8
Peanut Butter And Basil Sandwich
Minimalist Baker
Get the Peanut Butter and Basil Sandwich recipe from Minimalist Baker
9
Greek Olive Pesto and Fried Zucchini Grilled Pitas With Marinated Feta And Garbanzo Beans
Half Baked Harvest
10
Margherita Pizza Grilled Cheese
BS in the Kitchen
Get the Margherita Pizza Grilled Cheese recipe from BS in the Kitchen
11
Eggplant Parm
Hector Sanchez/Food&Wine
Get the Eggplant Parm recipe from Food & Wine
12
Chickpea Salad Sandwiches
Macheesmo
Get the Chickpea Salad Sandwiches recipe from Macheesmo
13
Chipotle Honey Roasted Peanut Butter And Peach Grilled Sandwich
Half Baked Harvest
14
Spinach And Artichoke Melts
Half Baked Harvest
Get the Spinach and Artichoke Melts recipe from Half Baked Harvest
15
Avocado And Marinated Kale Salad Sandwich
fiveandspice/Food52
Get the Avocado and Marinated Kale Salad Sandwich recipe from fiveandspice via Food52
16
Cottage Cheese Sandwich
Foodie Crush
Get the Cottage Cheese Sandwich recipe from Foodie Crush
17
Roasted Red Pepper, Arugula And Mozzarella Sandwich
Two Peas and their Pod
18
Smashed Chickpea Greek Salad Sandwich
Two Peas and their Pod
Get the Smashed Chickpea Greek Salad Sandwich recipe from Two Peas and their Pod
19
Fried Mozzarella Sandwich
Half Baked Harvest
Get the Fried Mozzarella Sandwich recipe from Half Baked Harvest
20
Roasted Red Pepper Hummus, Avocado, & Feta Sandwich
Two Peas and their Pod
21
Edamame Avocado Salad Sandwich
Two Peas and their Pod
Get the Edamame Avocado Salad Sandwich recipe from Two Peas and their Pod
22
Grilled Hummus And Caramelized Onion Sandwich
Katy's Kitchen
23
Balsamic Brussels Sprouts Grilled Cheese
How Sweet It Is
24
Spicy Carrot And Hummus Sandwich
The Simple Veganista
Get the Spicy Carrot And Hummus Sandwich recipe from The Simple Veganista
25
Groovy Bagel Melts
Naturally Ella
Get the Groovy Bagel Melts recipe from Naturally Ella
26
Broccoli & Cheddar Soup Grilled Cheese
BS in the Kitchen
Get the Broccoli & Cheddar Soup Grilled Cheese recipe from BS in the Kitchen
27
Mediterranean Sandwich
Wholehearted Eats
Get the Mediterranean Sandwich recipe from Wholehearted Eats
28
Egg, Hummus And Eggplant Sandwich
fiveandspice/Food52
Get the Egg, Hummus and Eggplant Sandwich recipe from fiveandspice via Food52
29
Tomato Chutney And Brie Sandwich
Macheesmo
30
Ultimate 4-Layer Vegan Sandwich
Oh She Glows
Get the Ultimate 4-Layer Vegan Sandwich recipe from Oh She Glows
31
French Onion Grilled Cheese
Jessica Dasilva
Get the French Onion Grilled Cheese recipe from Portuguese Girl Cooks
32
Smoky Tempeh And Hummus Sandwiches
James Ransom/Food52
Get the Smoky Tempeh and Hummus Sandwiches recipe from Gena Hamshaw via Food52