Answer by Ryan Carlyle, BSChE, Subsea Hydraulics Engineer
The Stark Arc Reactor is most likely a Multi-Isotope Radio-Decay Cell.
Since this is a fictitious device, and it has no "official" scientific explanation in the Iron Man canon that I'm aware of, I'm going to make something up. I'm mixing real science and fake science here. Physics nerds and comic-book nerds, deal with it.
Let's look at what we know about the arc reactor from movies 1 and 2:
The full-sized arc reactor looks a lot like a toroidal "Tokomak" plasma containment system for standard "hot fusion":
Real world equivalent: fusion reactor
This type of fusion reactor exists today at research pilot scale. The reactor pictured, ITER, is under construction and is planned to be the first fusion reactor large enough to produce a net gain of energy. Basically, it mashes two isotopes of hydrogen, deuterium and tritium, together at such high energies that they combine into one atom. When they fuse, the reaction produces helium and a free neutron. Critically, helium+neutron has less mass than deuterium+tritium, and the missing mass is converted to energy. That energy can be captured as heat to run a traditional steam-driven turbine (like any other power plant).
So what does the arc reactor's torus (donut) shape tell us? It means there are charged particles moving in a circle, contained by a magnetic field. High-energy particles usually have high energy because they're moving very fast, and magnetic fields can curve the motion of charged particles. Curving the particles' motion into a circle keeps them in one place long enough to get them to collide.
You may notice that current fusion reactor designs have a lot of magnet coils on the outside of the torus, whereas the Stark Industries arc reactor has a viewing window. Plasma containment is the single biggest challenge for hot fusion, but the arc reactor makes it look effortless. From this, we can conclude that a key technology in the full-scale arc reactor is a way to contain the reaction in a self-sustaining ring. This line of reasoning is definitely backed up by the toroidal field lines drawn in the Stark Industries arc reactor blueprints:
There is also a remarkable lack of cooling loops, turbines, or anything that a traditional thermal reactor would require. Which means the arc reactor produces electricity directly, rather than by first generating heat. This observation jives with the fact that the megawatt-scale reactor in Tony's chest does not roast him alive. So it cannot be a hot-fusion reactor, or a traditional thermal-fission reactor. Back to the drawing board!
What else do we know about the miniature arc reactor?
- Contains a palladium core
- The palladium is damaged by neutrons, so the specific isotope is important
- Has electromagnetic coils in a torus
- Emits blue-white light
- Can be built in a cave with tools of moderate complexity
- Requires no exotic materials outside what you could scavenge from dismantled conventional weapons systems
- Runs low on power at inconvenient times, meaning it must have some sort of fuel or consumed charge
Palladium has been proposed as a substrate for "cold" fusion that does not require hot plasmas and containment toroids, but this concept is pretty widely discredited in the real world. Palladium does, however, have some interesting capture and decay properties. Wikipedia:
Palladium isotope Pd-103 produces Rh-103 (rhodium) via electron capture. This means an inner electron is absorbed by the nucleus, merging with a proton to produce a neutron and an energetic photon -- a gamma ray.
Another isotope, Pd-107, produces Ag-107 (silver) via beta decay, releasing an electron when a neutron turns into a proton. (This is kind of the opposite reaction as the above.) Now, in real-world physics, the electrons balance the resulting atomic nuclei -- silver and rhodium have different numbers of protons from palladium, and the produced/consumed electrons just balance out the proton count so there is no net flow of electricity.
I propose that Howard Stark found a way (using comic-book physics) to utilize the beta decay of Pd-107 ions as an electron source for the electron capture of Pd-103, thereby producing an electric circuit between two different radioactive isotopes. Pd-103 is very radioactive (17 day half-life) compared to Pd-107 (6.5 million year half-life) so there would need to be dramatically more of the heavier isotope to compensate for the disparity in decay rates.
The palladium core of the device would most likely be Pd-107, which emits high-energy electrons as it decays into silver. This is a pretty stable isotope that we would expect to be present in the normal (non-separated) palladium that Tony might salvage from a conventional weapon.
Since we know the device uses charged particles travelling within a ring of electromagnets, I surmise that a tiny amount of Pd-103 is ionized by an electric arc (thus the reactor's name, and start-up power requirement), which then allows Pd-103+ to be circulated at high velocity within the outer ring of the device. The ionization acts to delay the electron capture step until the atom encounters a free electron, and the high kinetic energy due to velocity increases the chances of electron capture occurring once an electron is encountered. In effect, the radioactive decay of Pd-103 can be started, stopped, and throttled by the device simply by controlling the ionization and circulation of the Pd-103.
The device's geometry and electromagnetic fields route the high-energy electrons from the Pd-107 core towards the outer ring. There, the electrons are captured by high-energy Pd-103 ions. This electron capture process emits gamma rays, which are deflected inward to catalyze the beta decay of the Pd-107 core. We have some good evidence for this gamma ray emission, because the suit's chestpiece unibeam weapon is clearly an emission of a large number of high-energy photons directly from the arc reactor. Normally, the gamma rays are directed inward to catalyze the device's operation, but they can be directed outward in a concentrated energy beam weapon:
So to summarize: electrons project outward from the inner core, and gamma rays project inward from the outer ring. Because this electron/photon counterflow creates a deficit of electrons (relative to protons) in the core, a massive electrostatic potential is developed and the palladium core attracts lower-energy electrons from the suit's wiring. The ejection of electrons from the core towards the rim of the device produces an electrical cell capable of generating enormous voltage and current.
Here's the full proposed reactor start-up process:
- Using external power, Pd-103 is ionized by an electric arc, and accelerated to high velocity in the outer ring. There may also be some externally-powered gamma ray production to jump-start the inner core.
- Pd-107 in the inner core starts to emit high-energy electrons as it decays to Ag-107. The electrons escape the core and are directed by magnetic fields into the outer ring. Lack of electrons creates a net positive charge in the core, which slows further emission (preventing run-away decay) until the electrons can be externally replenished.
- In the outer ring, the high-energy free electrons collide with high-energy Pd-103+ ions. This causes instantaneous electron capture and gamma ray emission. The gamma rays are deflected inward towards the core, thus catalyzing further electron emission and producing a self-sustaining reaction. Note that the reaction is self-sustaining, but very slow while the reactor is idle.
- The electron flow from the inner core to the outer core creates an electric potential difference. When a circuit is created through the suit's electrical loads, the outer ring has an excess of electrons and the inner core has a shortage of electrons. This creates current.
- The electrical current through an external load relieves the electrostatic charge accumulations that initially slowed the reactions. So the less power the suit draws, the slower the reactor produces radioactive decay, and the more power the suit draws, the faster the reactions are catalyzed. That way, the power output automatically throttles according to demand.
- The palladium slowly converts to Rh-103 and Ag-107, and the reactor runs out of power when the palladium is fully consumed.
Miniature Arc Reactor Concept:
I can't speak for the next-gen "new element" arc reactor, but presumably, it replaces the palladium isotopes with a hypothetical element that also undergoes gamma-ray-mediated beta decay, but in a less-toxic and higher-output fashion.
Several other lines of evidence also support this type of nuclear decay / electron flux reaction being the mechanism for the arc reactor. First, the reactor's glow:
It could be caused by the ionization arc, but I thinkis a much better explanation. This is a special type of light emission that occurs when an energetic particle (such as electron) enters a medium (like water or air) at a speed faster than the speed of light in that medium. The high-energy electron flux within the arc reactor would be a natural fit to generate this effect. This is a picture of an actual nuclear reactor producing Cherenkov radiation:
Notice the similarities? Unlike electrical arcs, the light from Cherenkov radiation is quiet, cool-blue, and fricken' awesome. This is a no-brainer -- the arc reactor's glow is definitely being produced by high-energy electron flux.
Another aspect of the original model palladium arc reactor was poisoning due to "palladium toxicity." It's very possible that palladium is simply being ejected from the device into Tony's blood by all the high-energy collisions going on, but this doesn't explain the freaky circuit-looking lines on his chest, and it doesn't explain why doctors can't help him.
I have a theory that fits the symptoms better. Remember, the proposed palladium decay reactions produce rhodium and silver. Excess internal silver is known to stain skin blue:
Rhodium compounds also stain skin, and are highly toxic. (Tony Stark didn't have simple palladium poisoning, he had "palladium decay-product" poisoning!) In fact, because most people have essentially zero exposure to rhodium, the toxicity of rhodium is very poorly-understood. This perfectly explains why Tony didn't seek help from the medical establishment for his accumulated heavy metal toxicity -- because he knew the doctors wouldn't know how to deal with rhodium poisoning.
So you see, everything fits together perfectly. The evidence all points towards the arc reactor relying on a Pd-103/Pd-107 radio-isotopic decay cell to produce electrical current. I will start working on my own arc reactor prototype and will post updates when I produce a working replica.
How to vote
Vote-by-mail ballot request deadline: Varies by state
For the Nov 3 election: States are making it easier for citizens to vote absentee by mail this year due to the coronavirus. Each state has its own rules for mail-in absentee voting. Visit your state election office website to find out if you can vote by mail.Get more information
In-person early voting dates: Varies by state
Sometimes circumstances make it hard or impossible for you to vote on Election Day. But your state may let you vote during a designated early voting period. You don't need an excuse to vote early. Visit your state election office website to find out whether they offer early voting.My Election Office
General Election: Nov 3, 2020
Polling hours on Election Day: Varies by state/localityMy Polling Place