The Blog

Why McDonald's Should Fear Chick-fil-A

He calls the chicken chain a "serious and growing competitive threat" to the largest QSR brand.
This post was published on the now-closed HuffPost Contributor platform. Contributors control their own work and posted freely to our site. If you need to flag this entry as abusive, send us an email.

Despite the incessant chatter about "burger wars," the competitor McDonald's should be watching is neither Burger King nor Wendy's but Chick-fil-A, according to an investor brief from Janney Montgomery Scott analyst Mark Kalinowski. He calls the chicken chain a "serious and growing competitive threat" to the largest QSR brand.

2014-07-15-ChickLogo.jpgChick-fil-A won't top McDonald's in sales over the next decade, but Kalinowski argues that it will grow faster. "If Chick-fil-A can add $6.3-$9.0 billion to its systemwide sales over the next 10 years, it is entirely possible that this will be similar to--or worst-case, from McDonald's perspective--greater than the systemwide sales that McDonald's can add to its domestic business over that same time," he writes.

Privately held Chick-fil-A had U.S. sales of $5,052,589 (from 1,775 stores) in 2013, about triple its size in 2003. Publicly held McDonald's dwarfed it with domestic sales of $35,856,000 (14,278 U.S. stores) and while its 47% increase since 2003 is solid, it doesn't match Chick-fil-A's growth, and certainly not the chicken chain's 12.7 percent compound annual growth rate. Kalinowski says Chick-fil-A's growth "was achieved through a balanced mix of unit expansion (which ranged annually from +3.2 percent to +6.2 percent, depending on the year) and consistently positive same-store sales growth."

Kalinowski postulates several scenarios about future growth by both chains. Under what he calls Sensitivity Analysis #1 (positing 4.5% annualized unit growth and 4% annualized same-store sales growth), Chick-fil-A would rise to domestic sales of $11.4 billion in 2023. A second scenario--assuming 5 percent unit growth and 6 percent same-store sales growth)--grows Chick-fil-A to domestic sales of $14.3 billion in 2013.

"While Chick-fil-A remains meaningfully smaller than McDonald's U.S. today, to the extent it could be ignored as a competitive threat ten years ago, we would argue that it can no longer be ignored as a long-term competitive threat today," according to Kalinowski.

2014-07-15-mcdonaldslogo.jpgHis scenarios for McDonald's growth are far less confident. One, based on a 2.6% annual sales gain and just 0.6 percent unit growth, moves McDonald's from an estimated $36.8 billion for 2014 to $46.3 billion in 2023. A second is even more dire, based on a 0.3 percent annual gain in both sales and units. Under that scenario, McDonald's sales would grow less than 3 percent to $36.9 billion in 2023.

Chick-fil-A's rapid rise from a distant No. 2 in chicken sales to the category leader, passing KFC, "may hint that it could become a larger competitive threat to many more fast-food brands over 2014 and beyond--and not just chains traditionally defined as 'chicken' brands," Kalinowski writes. McDonald's sells a lot of chicken, he notes, and it is the largest QSR brand so it has the most to lose by the continued ascent of Chick-fil-A. Kalinowski rates McDonald's shares Neutral.