Using System 1 thinking on a System 2 problem doesn't work. In 2003, Vice-President Dick Cheney, no doubt with a mental model
While intuitive reactions aren't always very clear cut, the body never lies and there are many ways to detect subtler signals from your body. The more conscious, present, and aware you become, the easier it will be to follow your intuitive body, because consciousness works with awareness.
This is the first election that I won't be voting FOR a candidate. I will, by default, vote defensively for the most innocuous one. Frightfully, it isn't about who will be the best choice anymore, it's who will inflict the least amount of damage to our country.
I think that in order for you to find where you belong, you have to have a combination of both. I like to use the metaphor of "who's in the driver's seat? Your logical side or your emotional/intuitive side?" I think in order to make the best decisions you have to take turns letting both of them drive.