The former UCLA gymnast, who graduated in June, won the award for Best Viral Sports Moment.
The UCLA athlete said she stopped using the singer's music and doing Jackson-inspired moves after "Leaving Neverland" was released.
The viral gymnast recorded a perfect score in the floor routine for the fourth time this season.
"No word or judgmental stares will make me compromise," said the UCLA athlete, whose floor routine impressed the nation.
The comedian shared a "tribute" to the UCLA gymnast's routine on Instagram, with her husband as a special guest.
Katelyn Ohashi's jaw-dropping performance scored a perfect 10.