LOADINGERROR LOADING
Former President Donald Trump’s criminal trial has wrapped up its second week.
Trump, the first former president to be tried on criminal charges, is facing 34 counts connected to his alleged attempts to hide $130,000 in hush money payments made in 2016 to conceal claims of an extramarital affair with adult film actor Stormy Daniels.
The presumptive Republican presidential nominee is represented by Todd Blanche and Susan Necheles. The prosecution is led by Susan Hoffinger and Joshua Steinglass, who were selected by Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg to argue the case. Judge Juan Merchan is presiding.
Advertisement
Also present during opening statements was Matthew Colangelo, a lawyer from Bragg’s office, who detailed a “catch and kill” scheme allegedly greenlighted by Trump. In one such scheme, he said, Trump attempted to cover up an alleged affair with Playboy Playmate Karen McDougal.
“When it came time to pay Michael Cohen back for the catch and kill deal, you’ll see he didn’t negotiate it down. He doubled it,” Colangelo said.
Trump’s former attorney, Michael Cohen — who served a jail sentence over his role in facilitating the payments — is expected to testify, as is Daniels.
Follow along with live updates below:
Pinned
Week 2 Has Wrapped Up. Here’s What Happened.
- The trial isn't convening on Monday, April 29, due to the Passover holiday. It will resume Tuesday.
- Defense attorneys did their best to poke holes in the testimony of National Enquirer publisher David Pecker, who was released after more than 10 hours on the stand.
- Trump lawyer Emil Bove tried to undermine Pecker’s credibility by focusing on efforts to sell the National Enquirer amid the ongoing legal trouble. In Bove’s telling, Pecker may have been so eager to end the investigations he would do anything law enforcement asked.
- In redirect, Pecker confirmed under oath that his agreement with McDougal was principally about helping Trump’s campaign by suppressing damaging stories.
- Pecker also told the prosecution he would have never signed the contract with McDougal if Michael Cohen (on behalf of the Trump organization) hadn’t agreed to reimburse him the $125,000.
- The prosecution called its second witness, longtime former Trump assistant Rhona Graff, who offered brief testimony under subpoena.
- A third witness, bank executive Gary Farro, also began testifying. Farro allegedly helped Cohen secure the home equity loan he used to pay Stormy Daniels — though Cohen said it was for real estate.
Trump Waited 15 Minutes After Court To Declare Biden A 'No-Show' To The Fake Debate Invite He Made Up At Lunch
Trump used his lunch break today to challenge President Joe Biden to a debate at the courthouse after court adjourned.
To no one’s surprise, Biden was unable to make it. Trump nevertheless triumphantly declared Biden a “no show” on social media 15 minutes after court got out today.
“I’ve been waiting for Crooked Joe at the Courthouse, the Fake News Media was there also — HE DIDN’T SHOW! ANY WHERE, ANY TIME, ANY PLACE!” Trump wrote on Truth Social.
The missive was a response to Biden’s own statement Friday morning that he’d be “happy” to debate Trump, who didn’t participate in any of the 2024 GOP primary debates.
To no one’s surprise, Biden was unable to make it. Trump nevertheless triumphantly declared Biden a “no show” on social media 15 minutes after court got out today.
“I’ve been waiting for Crooked Joe at the Courthouse, the Fake News Media was there also — HE DIDN’T SHOW! ANY WHERE, ANY TIME, ANY PLACE!” Trump wrote on Truth Social.
The missive was a response to Biden’s own statement Friday morning that he’d be “happy” to debate Trump, who didn’t participate in any of the 2024 GOP primary debates.
Judge Merchan Calls It A Day
Merchan has concluded the trial is at a natural stopping point for the week, and dismissed the jurors with all the typical instructions (don’t talk about the case, don’t do your own research, etc.).
Gary Farro: Michael Cohen Used A Second Account For The Stormy Daniels Payment
For reasons that are unclear, Cohen never funded the first account and instead opened a second account with the bank that he ultimately used for the Stormy Daniels payoff.
"He stated he was changing course and no longer wanted to open Resolution Consultants, and wanted to open a new account," Gary Farro told Mangold. The new LLC was called “Essential Consultants, LLC.”
"Every time Michael Cohen spoke to me he gave a sense of urgency,” he recalled, “and this was one of those times."
The second account, like the first, was purportedly for a real estate consulting company. On a form that asked if the entity is “associated with political fundraising/Political Action Committee (PAC),” Cohen checked “No.”
"He stated he was changing course and no longer wanted to open Resolution Consultants, and wanted to open a new account," Gary Farro told Mangold. The new LLC was called “Essential Consultants, LLC.”
"Every time Michael Cohen spoke to me he gave a sense of urgency,” he recalled, “and this was one of those times."
The second account, like the first, was purportedly for a real estate consulting company. On a form that asked if the entity is “associated with political fundraising/Political Action Committee (PAC),” Cohen checked “No.”
Next Witness Up Is Gary Farro, Former First Republic Bank Employee
Farro allegedly helped structure the home equity loan Cohen used to pay off Stormy Daniels. Assistant DA Rebecca Mangold is leading the questioning.
Farro told Mangold that Cohen had several accounts at the bank.
Bank executives assigned him to handle Cohen because he knew the ins and outs of bank regulation, and also because he was known to capably handle “challenging” clients.
Mangold produced a series of emails up from October 2016 for Farro to review. They’re conversations between Farro and his assistant.
"Michael Cohen just called for you, I let him know you were out of the office,” reads one from Oct. 11. “Need an account opened for Mike Cohen immediately,” reads another sent four days later. “He wants no address on the checks.”
“He said it was an account for real estate,” Farro said.
Farro told Mangold that Cohen had several accounts at the bank.
Bank executives assigned him to handle Cohen because he knew the ins and outs of bank regulation, and also because he was known to capably handle “challenging” clients.
Mangold produced a series of emails up from October 2016 for Farro to review. They’re conversations between Farro and his assistant.
"Michael Cohen just called for you, I let him know you were out of the office,” reads one from Oct. 11. “Need an account opened for Mike Cohen immediately,” reads another sent four days later. “He wants no address on the checks.”
“He said it was an account for real estate,” Farro said.
And Graff Is Done
Short and sweet, Graff's main contribution appears to be that she could link Trump to McDougal and Daniels. As she departed, Trump stood and touched her hand, according to Trumpologist Maggie Haberman.
Hoffinger Has Wrapped Up. Trump Attorney Susan Necheles Is Now Questioning Graff.
Graff described her former boss in complementary terms under cross-examination from Trump’s defense attorney, as Trump looked on, smiling.
"It was a very stimulating, exciting, fascinating place to be,” she said. "I think that [Trump] was fair, and, what’s the word I’m looking for, respectful boss to me."
Graff told Necheles she did see Stormy Daniels at Trump Tower on occasion and “assumed” she was being considered for a spot on The Apprentice.
"It was a very stimulating, exciting, fascinating place to be,” she said. "I think that [Trump] was fair, and, what’s the word I’m looking for, respectful boss to me."
Graff told Necheles she did see Stormy Daniels at Trump Tower on occasion and “assumed” she was being considered for a spot on The Apprentice.
Rhona Graff Has A Long History With Trump: ‘If She’s Called … That Will Be The End Of Trump’
Who is Rhona Graff? The one who knows where the metaphorical bodies are buried, apparently. In early 2019, as Democrats wielded their new dominance in the House by launching a wide-ranging investigation into then-President Trump, former “Apprentice” star Omarosa Manigault Newman told MSNBC whose testimony she believed Trump most feared.
“One name: Rhona Graff,” Manigault Newman said. “She knows everyone. She knows the role they play. She knows who said what and when. She set up the meetings. If she’s called to testify, that will be the end of Donald Trump.”
Graff was the former president’s longtime executive assistant, responsible for arranging his travel plans and his schedule. People who wanted to meet with Trump went through her. She was also subpoenaed by New York Attorney General Leticia James’ office in 2022 to help with the civil fraud investigation that led to a half-billion-dollar judgment against Trump. While she stayed in New York City when Trump went to Washington, she maintained her connection with him, according to a 2017 profile in The New York Times, which referred to her as Trump's "gatekeeper."
“One name: Rhona Graff,” Manigault Newman said. “She knows everyone. She knows the role they play. She knows who said what and when. She set up the meetings. If she’s called to testify, that will be the end of Donald Trump.”
Graff was the former president’s longtime executive assistant, responsible for arranging his travel plans and his schedule. People who wanted to meet with Trump went through her. She was also subpoenaed by New York Attorney General Leticia James’ office in 2022 to help with the civil fraud investigation that led to a half-billion-dollar judgment against Trump. While she stayed in New York City when Trump went to Washington, she maintained her connection with him, according to a 2017 profile in The New York Times, which referred to her as Trump's "gatekeeper."
Prosecutor Susan Hoffinger Asks Graff About Her Time In The Trump Org
The 34-year Trump employee is testifying under a subpoena and is being represented by two lawyers paid for by the Trump Organization.
Graff says she sat outside Trump’s office on the 26th floor of Trump Tower. She maintained Trump’s calendar and various contact lists, she said, including information for Karen McDougal and Stormy Daniels, who was listed in the system as “Stormy” alongside her cell phone number.
She says she never recalled Trump using email.
Graff says she sat outside Trump’s office on the 26th floor of Trump Tower. She maintained Trump’s calendar and various contact lists, she said, including information for Karen McDougal and Stormy Daniels, who was listed in the system as “Stormy” alongside her cell phone number.
She says she never recalled Trump using email.
Pecker Ends His Testimony And The Next Witness Takes The Stand
After more than 10 hours on the stand, former National Enquirer publisher David Pecker is done. The prosecution has called its next witness, longtime former Trump assistant Rhona Graff.
Trump praised Graff’s loyalty in his 1997 book, “The Art of the Comeback.” Per CNN, Graff didn’t appear to make eye contact with Trump as she walked to the witness stand, though Trump looked at her.
Trump praised Graff’s loyalty in his 1997 book, “The Art of the Comeback.” Per CNN, Graff didn’t appear to make eye contact with Trump as she walked to the witness stand, though Trump looked at her.
Trump Would 'Love To Be With Melania On Her Birthday,' If Not For Court
Over the lunch break, Trump's campaign sent a text to supporters lamenting that Trump couldn't spend time with his wife on her birthday because of his criminal trial.
"I'D LOVE TO BE WITH MELANIA ON HER BIRTHDAY, BUT INSTEAD I'M STUCK IN COURT!" the all-caps text reads.
Last year, Trump appeared to forget it was Melania Trump's birthday, but had time to post more than a dozen times on Truth Social.
And in 2018, Trump admitted he was "too busy" to get his wife a present for her birthday.
Melania, meanwhile, hasn't shown up for any of Trump's criminal trial appearances.
"I'D LOVE TO BE WITH MELANIA ON HER BIRTHDAY, BUT INSTEAD I'M STUCK IN COURT!" the all-caps text reads.
Last year, Trump appeared to forget it was Melania Trump's birthday, but had time to post more than a dozen times on Truth Social.
And in 2018, Trump admitted he was "too busy" to get his wife a present for her birthday.
Melania, meanwhile, hasn't shown up for any of Trump's criminal trial appearances.
Trump Responds To Biden’s Debate Challenge
Joe Biden told Howard Stern during a live interview Friday that he’d be “happy” to debate Trump, who didn’t participate in the 2024 GOP primary debates.
Trump responded on social media during the lunch break by inviting Biden to debate him at the courthouse.
Read more from HuffPost's Igor Bobic:
Trump responded on social media during the lunch break by inviting Biden to debate him at the courthouse.
Read more from HuffPost's Igor Bobic:
We’re Back
Trump is back in the courtroom and court has resumed. David Pecker is expected to conclude his testimony this afternoon. Prosecutors say they have around 30 minutes of questioning left, and afterward, the defense has the opportunity to question Pecker once more.
Lunch Break
Court is on hiatus for lunch. We'll return this afternoon with the rest of the testimony from National Enquirer publisher David Pecker.
Pecker Agrees Story Was Suppressed To Prevent Influence On Election
During redirect questioning, Pecker agreed with prosecutors that the "principal purpose" of suppressing the story about Trump and McDougal was to prevent it from having an influence on the presidential election.
"AMI's principal purpose into entering into the agreement was to suppress the model's story so as to prevent it from influencing the election," Steinglass said.
Pecker said he agreed with that characterization.
"AMI's principal purpose into entering into the agreement was to suppress the model's story so as to prevent it from influencing the election," Steinglass said.
Pecker said he agreed with that characterization.
And With That, Cross-Examination Of Pecker Concludes
The former National Enquirer publisher will likely now sit for another round of questions from the prosecution.
Bove Tries To Bait Pecker Into Discrediting Cohen
Recalling yesterday’s testimony, Bove brought up the Federal Election Commission letter that Pecker said left him “very worried” he might be charged with campaign finance violations.
Cohen told him not to worry, because “Jeff Sessions is the Attorney General, and Donald Trump has him in his pocket.”
“Based on your experience Michael Cohen was prone to exaggeration?" Bove asked. When Pecker agreed, Bove went further: “Could not trust anything he said?”
The question prompted an objection from the prosecution, which Judge Merchan sustained.
Cohen told him not to worry, because “Jeff Sessions is the Attorney General, and Donald Trump has him in his pocket.”
“Based on your experience Michael Cohen was prone to exaggeration?" Bove asked. When Pecker agreed, Bove went further: “Could not trust anything he said?”
The question prompted an objection from the prosecution, which Judge Merchan sustained.
Bove Zeroes In On Efforts To Sell The National Enquirer Amid Legal Troubles
Bove asked Pecker about attempts to sell the tabloid along with two others to Hudson News Group, and how the ongoing investigations have complicated the transaction.
Pecker confirmed a deal in the neighborhood of $100 million was hashed out, but that the investigations had to be cleared up before the deal could go through.
"If AMI had been indicted that would have affected the value of its assets?” Bove asked.
Pecker answered affirmatively.
"To Hudson News, the federal investigation was going to reduce the earnings of those magazines," he said.
Pecker confirmed a deal in the neighborhood of $100 million was hashed out, but that the investigations had to be cleared up before the deal could go through.
"If AMI had been indicted that would have affected the value of its assets?” Bove asked.
Pecker answered affirmatively.
"To Hudson News, the federal investigation was going to reduce the earnings of those magazines," he said.
Cohen Asked Pecker To Send Paparazzi To His Meeting With Another Billionaire
An interesting aside from earlier this morning: Pecker said Michael Cohen once asked him to send paparazzi to a meeting Cohen had with Mark Cuban.
Cohen apparently believed the resulting photos would impress Trump and "put pressure" on him to respect Cohen more.
Cohen apparently believed the resulting photos would impress Trump and "put pressure" on him to respect Cohen more.
After A Brief Recess, We're Back
Trump attorney Emil Bove told Merchan prior to the morning break that he has less than an hour left for cross examination. After that, prosecutors can question Pecker again in what's known as a redirect.
Trump Lawyers Keep Calling Him 'President' — And Prosecutors Keep Objecting
Trump’s defense has referred to their client as “President Trump” throughout the trial, even during time periods he wasn’t actually president.
Prosecutor Joshua Steinglass has objected repeatedly. "He wasn't President Trump," Steinglass said this morning.
Merchan has sustained the objections.
Prosecutor Joshua Steinglass has objected repeatedly. "He wasn't President Trump," Steinglass said this morning.
Merchan has sustained the objections.
Trump Gets A (Small) Break On Gag Order Hearing
Merchan scheduled a hearing for Wednesday afternoon to discuss all the gag order violations Trump has allegedly made. The trial is generally off on Wednesdays, however, and Trump had rallies scheduled in both Michigan and Wisconsin. This morning, the judge moved the hearing to Thursday at 9:30 a.m.
It’s Cold In Court And Trump Is Grumpy About It
On the way into court Friday, the former president revisited a long-running gripe: It’s cold in the courtroom. He believes it’s on purpose.
“So we have another day of court in a freezing courthouse,” Trump told reporters. “It’s very cold in there … on purpose I believe. They don’t seem to be able to get the temperature up. It shouldn’t be that complicated. We have a freezing courthouse and that’s fine.”
(HuffPost’s Sara Boboltz, who’s in the courtroom, confirms it’s “a bit chilly.”)
“So we have another day of court in a freezing courthouse,” Trump told reporters. “It’s very cold in there … on purpose I believe. They don’t seem to be able to get the temperature up. It shouldn’t be that complicated. We have a freezing courthouse and that’s fine.”
(HuffPost’s Sara Boboltz, who’s in the courtroom, confirms it’s “a bit chilly.”)
Trump Attorney Hints That McDougal Deal Was Simply Good Business
Going over the terms of AMI’s agreement with Pecker, Bove established that McDougal published over 65 articles across AMI’s various titles. He is emphasizing how McDougal wanted to give her career a boost rather than tell her story about her alleged affair with Trump, seemingly trying to undercut the prosecution’s argument that AMI’s deal with her was a catch-and-kill operation.
Biden Does Radio Interview As Trump Sits In Court
President Joe Biden, who is in New York City following a campaign event last night, is doing a live interview with Howard Stern on Sirius XM this morning as Trump sits in court.
Bove Suggests Everyone Knew The National Enquirer Was Backing Trump
Trump’s attorney led Pecker to acknowledge a line in a November 2016 Wall Street Journal piece about Trump and McDougal that read, “Since last year, the Enquirer has supported Mr. Trump’s presidential bid, endorsing him and publishing negative articles about some of his opponents.” A key aspect to the prosecution's case was an August 2015 meeting in which Trump, Pecker and Cohen agreed to use Pecker's magazines to help Trump.
“People picked up on it, right?” Bove asked.
“Yes,” Pecker responded.
“People picked up on it, right?” Bove asked.
“Yes,” Pecker responded.
Coverage Against Ben Carson, Marco Rubio Was Recycled From Other Outlets
Bove is establishing that the National Enquirer did not originate some of the claims that were critical of Trump’s political enemies such as Ben Carson and Marco Rubio. A Guardian piece published in May 2015, for example, outlined the multiple malpractice suits against Carson.
Asked to confirm that it was "cost-efficient and made business sense" to run the pieces, Pecker said yes.
Asked to confirm that it was "cost-efficient and made business sense" to run the pieces, Pecker said yes.
Jeenah Moon/Pool via Associated Press
Trump Captured Sitting In Court For Day 8 Of His Trial
Trump was photographed after taking his seat inside the courtroom for day 8 of his criminal trial.
Pecker Affirms Trump Tower Pact Was Good For Business
Agreeing to publish content that favored Trump and disfavored his political opponents, like Bill and Hillary Clinton, was ultimately good for the National Enquirer’s business, Pecker confirmed.
McConnell Says He Doesn't Think Presidents Should Have Absolute Immunity
Meanwhile, Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell said he doesn't think presidents should be immune from prosecution as the Supreme Court heard arguments yesterday in Trump's case on the issue.
Former National Enquirer Publisher Is Back For Fourth Day
Trump attorney Emil Bove has resumed his cross-examination of Pecker, attempting to punch holes in his prior testimony.
Biden’s Reelection Campaign Calls Trump ‘Paranoid’
The rapid response account of Biden's reelection campaign blasted Trump over his remarks on the temperature of the courtroom prior to the resumption of his trial this morning, calling him "paranoid and feeble."
Trump Says Trial Is 'Presided Over By A Conflicted Pawn' Of Democratic Party
Trump once again complained about tight security at the courthouse, falsely claiming the purpose is to block his supporters from showing up, in a post on his Truth Social platform ahead of the trial's start.
He also attacked Judge Merchan, calling him a "highly conflicted pawn of the Democrat Party."
"Security is that of Fort Knox, all so that MAGA will not be able to attend this trial, presided over by a highly conflicted pawn of the Democrat Party. It is a sight to behold!" Trump said.
He also attacked Judge Merchan, calling him a "highly conflicted pawn of the Democrat Party."
"Security is that of Fort Knox, all so that MAGA will not be able to attend this trial, presided over by a highly conflicted pawn of the Democrat Party. It is a sight to behold!" Trump said.
Trump Arrives
The former president has taken his seat in the courthouse. He entered with a thick stack of documents in a large binder clip.
Trump Wishes Former First Lady Happy Birthday
Trump stopped to speak to reporters on the way in to his trial and started by wishing his wife Melania a happy birthday. He said he wished he could be with her on her birthday but she hasn't been attending any of his trial proceedings.
Latest Trump Effort To Avoid $83 Million Payout To E. Jean Carroll Fails
While conservative justices at the Supreme Court seemed prepared to give Trump what he most wants in his presidential immunity case, U.S. District Judge Lewis Kaplan rejected an effort by the former president to appeal or reduce the judgment against him in a defamation case.
“Mr. Trump’s argument is entirely without merit both as a matter of law and as a
matter of fact for all of the reasons articulated in Ms. Carroll’s memorandum of law in opposition to his motion,” Kaplan wrote.
“Mr. Trump’s argument is entirely without merit both as a matter of law and as a
matter of fact for all of the reasons articulated in Ms. Carroll’s memorandum of law in opposition to his motion,” Kaplan wrote.
Merchan Reschedules Gag Order Hearing
Judge Juan Merchan moved a hearing on the prosecution's motion to have Trump held in contempt and sanctioned for his gag order violations to May 2.
The proceeding was originally scheduled to take place on May 1, and the reason for the schedule change is unknown, CNN reported.
Prosecutors yesterday said Trump has committed four more violations since they originally filed the motion, bring the total to 14.
The proceeding was originally scheduled to take place on May 1, and the reason for the schedule change is unknown, CNN reported.
Prosecutors yesterday said Trump has committed four more violations since they originally filed the motion, bring the total to 14.
Trump Is En Route To Courthouse
Trump's motorcade is on the way to the Manhattan courthouse, CNN reports.
Amateur Traders Cash In On Trump Woes
There's at least one group of people who want to see Trump go out of business: the amateur investors who are making money betting against the stock price of Trump's social media company Truth Social.
“This company makes no money. ... It makes no sense,” said one investor, who estimates she's made $1,300 betting against Trump Media & Technology stock.
Not all of them are doing it for political reasons. But the ones who are say that if they can get the stock down to zero, that's one less source of cash he can tap into to pay his legal bills.
Read more here.
“This company makes no money. ... It makes no sense,” said one investor, who estimates she's made $1,300 betting against Trump Media & Technology stock.
Not all of them are doing it for political reasons. But the ones who are say that if they can get the stock down to zero, that's one less source of cash he can tap into to pay his legal bills.
Read more here.
Pecker Returns To Witness Stand Again Today
Defense attorneys today will continue their cross-examination of former National Enquirer publisher David Pecker. They will likely press him on details like times and dates in his recollection of events.
Pecker so far has described how the tabloid would help bury embarrassing stories that Trump feared would hurt his presidential campaign.
Pecker so far has described how the tabloid would help bury embarrassing stories that Trump feared would hurt his presidential campaign.
Trump Complains About Prosecutors In Newsmax Interview
Trump joined "Greg Kelly Reports" on the right-wing network Newsmax on Thursday evening to discuss the various cases against him.
He said he thought he had a "very good session" at the Supreme Court as his lawyers argued that a president should have immunity from all crimes.
"You need presidential immunity to do the right thing. And sometimes you may do the wrong thing. I mean, that's possible, too," he said.
"And I heard the lawyers did a great job. I heard the justices were on their game, as the expression goes."
On the business fraud trial in New York, he ventured into familiar grievances about the people involved. He is currently under a gag order prohibiting him from attacking witnesses or jurors in the case.
"You have crime all over the place [in New York], violent crime," Trump said. "And they've got 20 prosecutors and people from that office sitting there, it's a disgrace."
"We don't want to get you in trouble with that silly gag order!" Kelly said.
He said he thought he had a "very good session" at the Supreme Court as his lawyers argued that a president should have immunity from all crimes.
"You need presidential immunity to do the right thing. And sometimes you may do the wrong thing. I mean, that's possible, too," he said.
"And I heard the lawyers did a great job. I heard the justices were on their game, as the expression goes."
On the business fraud trial in New York, he ventured into familiar grievances about the people involved. He is currently under a gag order prohibiting him from attacking witnesses or jurors in the case.
"You have crime all over the place [in New York], violent crime," Trump said. "And they've got 20 prosecutors and people from that office sitting there, it's a disgrace."
"We don't want to get you in trouble with that silly gag order!" Kelly said.
Key Moment
We're Entering Day 8 Of Trump’s First Criminal Trial. Here’s What Happened Yesterday.
- The prosecution wrapped up its questioning of former National Enquirer publisher David Pecker, who is now being cross-examined by defense attorney Emil Bove.
- Trump's lawyers will continue the cross-examination of Pecker today.
- Prosecutors yesterday had Pecker discuss the inner workings of the hush money deals he offered both Karen McDougal and Stormy Daniels, and how both came at the behest of Donald Trump ahead of the 2016 presidential election.
- Pecker, who’s testifying under a plea agreement, acknowledged that the deals violated campaign finance laws and were made for the sole purpose of helping Trump win the election.
- At the time the payments were made, the publisher squabbled with Trump’s former personal lawyer Michael Cohen over how Trump would reimburse him, and how to hide the atypically large money transfers from the National Enquirer’s accountants.
Judge Rebukes Trump Lawyer Before Trump's Exit
With the jury out of the room, lawyers resumed their debate over Bove’s line of questioning on Pecker’s memory at a volume everyone can hear. Prosecutors accused Trump’s attorney of misleading the jury by suggesting Pecker omitted the fact of Hope Hicks’ presence in the Trump Tower meeting, asking him whether he remembered doing that, then handing him a document that did not actually contain relevant information.
“If there wasn’t anything in that document, it’s misleading,” Merchan said. “I’m going to ask you to be very careful with that.”
Bove appeared to justify himself, prompting Merchan to interject: “Mr. Bove, are you missing my point?”
Trump has now filed out of the courtroom.
“If there wasn’t anything in that document, it’s misleading,” Merchan said. “I’m going to ask you to be very careful with that.”
Bove appeared to justify himself, prompting Merchan to interject: “Mr. Bove, are you missing my point?”
Trump has now filed out of the courtroom.
Jurors Adjourned For The Day
The jury has been let go, with the usual instructions not to discuss the case with anyone or seek out information about it. We are expected to wrap up Pecker's testimony tomorrow.
Objection To Trump Attorney’s Memory Questioning
The judge sustained an objection to Bove's line of questioning on what Pecker told federal investigators in July 2018 about the August 2015 Trump Tower meeting.
His question, meant to point out that Pecker initially omitted Hope Hicks' presence in the meeting, prompted a sidebar. When questioning resumed, Bove came at the issue a slightly different way.
His question, meant to point out that Pecker initially omitted Hope Hicks' presence in the meeting, prompted a sidebar. When questioning resumed, Bove came at the issue a slightly different way.
Remembering The Long Line Of Failed Trump Magazines
Bove had Pecker recall the ill-fated lifestyle magazine centered around Trump’s empire, Trump Style, that was launched in the late 1990s.
Trump Style became Trump World, which later morphed into Trump Magazine before ultimately folding in 2009, all of them having lost millions of dollars. Amusingly, a website affiliated with the publication Trumpthemag.com, now redirects to BernieSanders.com.
In 2018, Eric Trump revived Trump Magazine, proudly tweeting about it with the tagline, “Live Luxury, Never Settle.” But it appears to have met the same fate as its predecessors.
Trump Style became Trump World, which later morphed into Trump Magazine before ultimately folding in 2009, all of them having lost millions of dollars. Amusingly, a website affiliated with the publication Trumpthemag.com, now redirects to BernieSanders.com.
In 2018, Eric Trump revived Trump Magazine, proudly tweeting about it with the tagline, “Live Luxury, Never Settle.” But it appears to have met the same fate as its predecessors.
Trump Attorney Presses Pecker On Memory
Bove is trying to catch Pecker up with regard to precisely when the infamous Trump Tower meeting took place.
During grand jury proceedings last year, Pecker said that the incident took place the first week of August 2015. He said he received information later, suggesting it actually took place in the middle of August 2015. Bove is using this to show how it’s hard to remember things that took place almost a decade ago.
During grand jury proceedings last year, Pecker said that the incident took place the first week of August 2015. He said he received information later, suggesting it actually took place in the middle of August 2015. Bove is using this to show how it’s hard to remember things that took place almost a decade ago.
National Enquirer Publisher 'Caught' Stories For Other Celebs
Bove established through his questioning that Pecker helped celebrities Tiger Woods, Mark Wahlberg, Ron Perlman and Arnold Schwarzenegger shut down unflattering stories in the past. The Schwarzenegger stories landed Pecker in hot water in California, due to his candidacy for governor, although nothing came of it except that AMI implemented a new policy to be more careful.
In Woods’ case, Pecker affirmed that he used the rights to an unflattering story to get the golf star to appear on the cover of Men’s Fitness magazine and provide an interview. Regarding Wahlberg, Pecker said he told the actor's attorneys where to go to purchase rights to a story about a fight he had with his wife.
Pecker also confirmed that he and Trump exchanged useful information over their 40-year relationship, with Trump giving Pecker behind-the-scenes “Apprentice” stories.
In Woods’ case, Pecker affirmed that he used the rights to an unflattering story to get the golf star to appear on the cover of Men’s Fitness magazine and provide an interview. Regarding Wahlberg, Pecker said he told the actor's attorneys where to go to purchase rights to a story about a fight he had with his wife.
Pecker also confirmed that he and Trump exchanged useful information over their 40-year relationship, with Trump giving Pecker behind-the-scenes “Apprentice” stories.
Trump Attorney Begins Cross-Examination
Emil Bove is handling cross-examination for Trump’s team. He is having Pecker confirm that it was “standard operating procedure” for AMI to enter into contracts with its sources. Only around half the stories that AMI purchased were published under Pecker’s watch, he confirmed.
Pecker also confirmed there were instances where AMI would purchase a story in order to hold it over the celebrity’s head, using it to convince them to provide other content for its outlets.
“The point was to use it against the celebrity?” Bove asked.
“Yes,” Pecker said.
Pecker also confirmed there were instances where AMI would purchase a story in order to hold it over the celebrity’s head, using it to convince them to provide other content for its outlets.
“The point was to use it against the celebrity?” Bove asked.
“Yes,” Pecker said.
National Enquirer Publisher: ‘Donald Trump Was My Mentor’
Pecker testified that he has not spoken directly to Trump since January or February of 2019, although friends who visited Trump at Mar-a-Lago have passed on his regards.
Asked whether he had any “bad feelings or ill will” toward Trump, Pecker responded, “On the contrary. … I felt that Donald Trump was my mentor. He helped me a lot throughout my career.”
Pecker recalled the 2001 incident where anthrax was sent to his newly renovated offices in Boca Raton, Florida.
“One of the editors opened up one of the envelopes, inhaled weaponized anthrax, and ended up dying,” Pecker said. “And the first person to call me … was Donald Trump.”
“Even though we haven’t spoken, I still consider him a friend,” he said.
Asked whether he had any “bad feelings or ill will” toward Trump, Pecker responded, “On the contrary. … I felt that Donald Trump was my mentor. He helped me a lot throughout my career.”
Pecker recalled the 2001 incident where anthrax was sent to his newly renovated offices in Boca Raton, Florida.
“One of the editors opened up one of the envelopes, inhaled weaponized anthrax, and ended up dying,” Pecker said. “And the first person to call me … was Donald Trump.”
“Even though we haven’t spoken, I still consider him a friend,” he said.
Key Line From Federal Non-Prosecution Agreement
National Enquirer publisher David Pecker read the following line aloud:
“At all relevant times, AMI knew that corporations such as AMI are subject to federal campaign finance laws and that expenditures by corporations, made for purposes of influencing an election and in coordination with or at the request of a candidate or campaign, are unlawful.”
Pecker also reached a non-prosecution agreement with the Manhattan District Attorney’s office on Oct. 25, 2019, which was displayed in court. At the time, the office was run by Cy Vance.
“At all relevant times, AMI knew that corporations such as AMI are subject to federal campaign finance laws and that expenditures by corporations, made for purposes of influencing an election and in coordination with or at the request of a candidate or campaign, are unlawful.”
Pecker also reached a non-prosecution agreement with the Manhattan District Attorney’s office on Oct. 25, 2019, which was displayed in court. At the time, the office was run by Cy Vance.
Pecker: Trump Was Furious After Stormy Daniels Interview, Demanded $24 Million
Four days after Anderson interviewed McDougal, Stormy Daniels sat for a similar interview, again with Anderson Cooper.
National Enquirer publisher David Pecker says Trump called him again, this time claiming Daniels owed him $24 million for breaching the terms of their agreement by talking about him in the interview.
National Enquirer publisher David Pecker says Trump called him again, this time claiming Daniels owed him $24 million for breaching the terms of their agreement by talking about him in the interview.
Cohen Bragged That Trump Had U.S. Attorney General ‘In His Pocket’
David Pecker, the National Enquirer publisher, recalled getting a letter from the Federal Election Commission that worried him.
He said that Cohen told him not to be worried, saying, “Jeff Sessions is the Attorney General, and Donald Trump has him in his pocket.”
“I said, ‘I’m very worried,’” Pecker said. The non-prosecution agreement AMI reached with federal prosecutors regarding campaign finance violations was then shown to the jury.
He said that Cohen told him not to be worried, saying, “Jeff Sessions is the Attorney General, and Donald Trump has him in his pocket.”
“I said, ‘I’m very worried,’” Pecker said. The non-prosecution agreement AMI reached with federal prosecutors regarding campaign finance violations was then shown to the jury.
‘Very Upset’ Trump Lashes Out After McDougal Interview
McDougal, who had secured permission from Pecker to speak about the articles being written about her, eventually gave an interview to CNN’s Anderson Cooper. Pecker said he got a call afterward from Trump, who thought McDougal was breaking the terms of her agreement with AMI.
“Mr. Trump got very aggravated when he heard that I amended [McDougal’s agreement] and couldn’t understand why,” Pecker testified. “So he was very upset, couldn’t understand why I did it.”
“Mr. Trump got very aggravated when he heard that I amended [McDougal’s agreement] and couldn’t understand why,” Pecker testified. “So he was very upset, couldn’t understand why I did it.”
Lunch With McDougal
Pecker described a lunch with McDougal in which the former model spoke about her frustrations with the ghostwriters assigned to help her write articles and about her general lack of media training.
Biden Campaign Calls Out Trump For Golfing On His Off Day
Donald Trump went golfing yesterday instead of campaigning, and the Biden camp wants everyone to know about it. Trump has complained frequently about how his mandatory attendance during the trial keeps him from campaigning.
“We found out where Trump was. He was golfing. Not campaigning. Golfing," Biden campaign spokesperson Ammar Moussa said in a statement. "But, when your entire campaign is about enacting revenge and retribution for yourself and doing nothing to make Americans’ lives better, it makes sense you wouldn’t feel the need to actually speak to voters.”
“We found out where Trump was. He was golfing. Not campaigning. Golfing," Biden campaign spokesperson Ammar Moussa said in a statement. "But, when your entire campaign is about enacting revenge and retribution for yourself and doing nothing to make Americans’ lives better, it makes sense you wouldn’t feel the need to actually speak to voters.”
National Enquirer Publisher: My Dinner With Donald
In early 2017, after his inauguration, Pecker said that Trump called him with an invitation to the White House for a “thank you” dinner. Pecker’s wife did not want to travel to Washington, so he brought his deputy, Dylan Howard. Trump asked about McDougal.
“I said, ‘She’s doing well, she’s quiet, everything’s going good,’” Pecker said.
The following day, Howard sent a message: "Surreal last night."
“I said, ‘She’s doing well, she’s quiet, everything’s going good,’” Pecker said.
The following day, Howard sent a message: "Surreal last night."
Court Is Back In Session
We're back after a roughly hour-long lunch break. National Enquirer publisher David Pecker is expected to resume his testimony this afternoon.
Lunch Time
A stern-looking Donald Trump has left the courtroom for lunch.
Pecker Suggests Trump Didn't Care About Affair Claims For Family's Sake
Asked whether he felt Trump was concerned what Melania Trump and Ivanka Trump — his wife and daughter — would think about the affair allegations, Pecker replied in the negative. He said he thought Trump had been most concerned about his campaign.
National Enquirer Publisher Spoke To Trump About Cohen's Bonus
Pecker recalled two more Trump Tower conversations. In one of them, Cohen had asked Pecker to say something to Trump about his compensation.
“I said to him that Michael Cohen is very concerned about his bonus for this year and I want you to know that he’s very loyal, and he’s been working very hard from my perspective,” Pecker recalled telling Trump, adding that he thought Cohen would “throw himself in front of a bus” for him. Trump said he did not know what Pecker was talking about, pointing to Cohen’s taxi medallion business and the apartments he had in Trump Tower.
Then in early 2017, Pecker said walked into Trump’s office to find him receiving updates as the president-elect on the Ft. Lauderdale airport shooting from James Comey, Reince Preibus, Mike Pompeo and others. Trump introduced Pecker by quipping that he knew more than anyone in the room, but they apparently did not get the joke. The men left, and Trump asked Pecker for an update on McDougal. Pecker said she was “quiet,” as arranged.
“I said to him that Michael Cohen is very concerned about his bonus for this year and I want you to know that he’s very loyal, and he’s been working very hard from my perspective,” Pecker recalled telling Trump, adding that he thought Cohen would “throw himself in front of a bus” for him. Trump said he did not know what Pecker was talking about, pointing to Cohen’s taxi medallion business and the apartments he had in Trump Tower.
Then in early 2017, Pecker said walked into Trump’s office to find him receiving updates as the president-elect on the Ft. Lauderdale airport shooting from James Comey, Reince Preibus, Mike Pompeo and others. Trump introduced Pecker by quipping that he knew more than anyone in the room, but they apparently did not get the joke. The men left, and Trump asked Pecker for an update on McDougal. Pecker said she was “quiet,” as arranged.
National Enquirer Publisher Admits He Lied To WSJ About Trump Arrangement
After the Wall Street Journal published its story about the National Enquirer buying McDougal’s silence, publisher David Pecker authorized a public statement denying his company was helping Trump bury harmful content.
Pecker now acknowledges that was a lie.
"I wanted to protect my company, I wanted to protect myself, and I wanted also to protect Donald Trump,” he said.
Pecker now acknowledges that was a lie.
"I wanted to protect my company, I wanted to protect myself, and I wanted also to protect Donald Trump,” he said.
McDougal Had Confidentiality Agreement Amended
After the Wall Street Journal article sparked a wave of press attention, McDougal’s attorney reached out to ask if her confidentiality agreement with AMI could be amended to give her a chance to speak out.
“I wanted to try to keep some form of control around the story,” Pecker said when asked why he agreed to the request in December 2016. The election had already been called for Trump.
“I wanted to try to keep some form of control around the story,” Pecker said when asked why he agreed to the request in December 2016. The election had already been called for Trump.
Trump Was Upset About Aired Dirty Laundry
Three days before Election Day 2016, National Enquirer Publisher David Pecker said that he spoke to an upset Trump about a Wall Street Journal article.
Titled “National Enquirer Shielded Donald Trump From Playboy Model’s Affair Allegations,” the story referred to McDougal and the deal made with AMI.
On the phone with Trump, Pecker said no one on his side would have leaked that information, and it must have come from McDougal’s side. “He didn’t say goodbye, it was very unusual,” Pecker said of Trump.
Titled “National Enquirer Shielded Donald Trump From Playboy Model’s Affair Allegations,” the story referred to McDougal and the deal made with AMI.
On the phone with Trump, Pecker said no one on his side would have leaked that information, and it must have come from McDougal’s side. “He didn’t say goodbye, it was very unusual,” Pecker said of Trump.
Infighting Over Who Should Pay Stormy Daniels
Howard did not stay out of the issue like Pecker wanted him to. When an arrangement he facilitated for Cohen to wire a payment for Daniels did not happen, Howard asked Pecker to get Cohen on the phone. Cohen then suggested that Pecker pay for the story. He refused, saying that he never wanted to be involved with Daniels.
Pecker recalled Cohen telling him: “If you don’t, and this gets out, I believe the boss is going to be very angry with you.”
Pecker recalled Cohen telling him: “If you don’t, and this gets out, I believe the boss is going to be very angry with you.”
Pecker's Deputy On Stormy Daniels: ‘This Story Is True’
Pecker recalled how he learned that Stephanie Clifford, aka Stormy Daniels, was shopping a story about her alleged affair with Trump while he was enjoying dinner with his wife in early October 2016. His texts with AMI chief content officer Dylan Howard were shown to jurors. In the first, Howard said Daniels wanted $120,000 and would take a lie detector test.
“I know the denials were made in the past, but this story is true,” Howard’s text read. But Pecker had a couple problems: He did not want to pay the hefty sum, and he did not want the National Enquirer “to be associated with a porn star,” given that its largest distributor was Walmart. He believed it would be a “very bad” look for the magazine.
Howard later texted that he spoke to Cohen about the story, writing to Pecker, “all sorted, no fingerprints.”
“There was no paper trial,” Pecker said. “I said to him, great work.”
“I know the denials were made in the past, but this story is true,” Howard’s text read. But Pecker had a couple problems: He did not want to pay the hefty sum, and he did not want the National Enquirer “to be associated with a porn star,” given that its largest distributor was Walmart. He believed it would be a “very bad” look for the magazine.
Howard later texted that he spoke to Cohen about the story, writing to Pecker, “all sorted, no fingerprints.”
“There was no paper trial,” Pecker said. “I said to him, great work.”
‘At Least If He Wins I Will Be Pardoned For Electoral Fraud’
Howard sent quite the text to an unnamed relative on election night 2016, seemingly acknowledging that AMI’s payment scheme ran afoul of campaign law.
“He’s just been named President-elect,” Howard wrote, adding, “At least if he wins I will be pardoned for electoral fraud.”
Trump lawyer Emil Bove disputed the exhibit on the grounds that it was a personal communication and not related to business records.
“It can’t possibly be in furtherance of the conspiracy between Mr. Howard and the relative,” he said.
Merchan seems inclined to agree and, for now, has excluded it from evidence.
“He’s just been named President-elect,” Howard wrote, adding, “At least if he wins I will be pardoned for electoral fraud.”
Trump lawyer Emil Bove disputed the exhibit on the grounds that it was a personal communication and not related to business records.
“It can’t possibly be in furtherance of the conspiracy between Mr. Howard and the relative,” he said.
Merchan seems inclined to agree and, for now, has excluded it from evidence.
Pecker On ‘Access Hollywood’ Tape: ‘Very Embarrassing’
Asked to recall the impact of the infamous “Access Hollywood” tape in which Trump made ugly comments about women, Pecker said: “It was very embarrassing, very damaging for the campaign.”
He said that he spoke to Cohen shortly afterward.
“The feedback was very, very damaging to the campaign and everybody was very concerned … about what impact it would have,” Pecker said.
Cohen was also upset about a post to Radar Online — an AMI outlet — that referenced the tape. AMI’s chief content officer at the time, Dylan Howard, took it down.
He said that he spoke to Cohen shortly afterward.
“The feedback was very, very damaging to the campaign and everybody was very concerned … about what impact it would have,” Pecker said.
Cohen was also upset about a post to Radar Online — an AMI outlet — that referenced the tape. AMI’s chief content officer at the time, Dylan Howard, took it down.
In A Separate Court Proceeding Today, Tump Is Arguing For Presidential Immunity
Read more from HuffPost's Igor Bobic:
Pecker Details Failed Reimbursement Scheme
Pecker explained how Cohen attempted to pay him $125,000 in exchange for the lifetime rights to McDougal’s story, which would be transferred to a shell company created by Cohen.
Trump was apparently worried about the story eventually getting out if anyone else owned the rights. (Pecker said he valued the content McDougal agreed to create for his publications as part of their deal at $25,000.)
But the arrangement ultimately fell through when Pecker decided he no longer wanted to be reimbursed.
“It’s a bad idea,” Pecker said he told Cohen. “He was very, very angry, very upset, screaming basically at me. … Michael Cohen said, ‘The boss is going to be very angry with you.’ And I said, 'I’m sorry. The deal is off.’”
He recalled saying on the phone: “I am very concerned, and I am not going forward, period.”
Without revealing privileged conversations between himself and his legal counsel, Pecker implied that he was concerned about legal exposure if he were to be reimbursed.
Trump was apparently worried about the story eventually getting out if anyone else owned the rights. (Pecker said he valued the content McDougal agreed to create for his publications as part of their deal at $25,000.)
But the arrangement ultimately fell through when Pecker decided he no longer wanted to be reimbursed.
“It’s a bad idea,” Pecker said he told Cohen. “He was very, very angry, very upset, screaming basically at me. … Michael Cohen said, ‘The boss is going to be very angry with you.’ And I said, 'I’m sorry. The deal is off.’”
He recalled saying on the phone: “I am very concerned, and I am not going forward, period.”
Without revealing privileged conversations between himself and his legal counsel, Pecker implied that he was concerned about legal exposure if he were to be reimbursed.
Pecker: Sole Purpose Of Paying McDougal Was To Help Trump Win Election
Getting to the core of the prosecution’s argument, Steinglass asked Pecker if the “principal purpose to suppress her story” was to help Trump win the election.
“Yes, it was,” Pecker replied.
Asked if he knew that “expenditures by corporations made for the purpose of influencing an election” are unlawful, Pecker again replied in the affirmative.
“We purchased the story so it wouldn’t be published by any other organization,” Pecker said.
“Yes, it was,” Pecker replied.
Asked if he knew that “expenditures by corporations made for the purpose of influencing an election” are unlawful, Pecker again replied in the affirmative.
“We purchased the story so it wouldn’t be published by any other organization,” Pecker said.
Pecker Says He Knowingly Violated Campaign Finance Laws
Pecker reiterated that he never intended to publish McDougal's story, rather, he was motivated by a desire to prevent the story from getting out and influence the 2016 presidential election.
He also agreed with Steinglass that he had an obligation to comply with campaign finance laws, yet did not report the $150,000 to the FEC as he knew he should. (Pecker has an immunity deal with the government to avoid criminal charges regarding what could be considered an illegal campaign contribution in exchange for his cooperation.)
“We didn’t want the story to embarrass Mr. Trump, or embarrass or hurt the campaign,” he testified.
He also agreed with Steinglass that he had an obligation to comply with campaign finance laws, yet did not report the $150,000 to the FEC as he knew he should. (Pecker has an immunity deal with the government to avoid criminal charges regarding what could be considered an illegal campaign contribution in exchange for his cooperation.)
“We didn’t want the story to embarrass Mr. Trump, or embarrass or hurt the campaign,” he testified.
Pecker: Cohen Wasn’t Authorized To Spend Trump Corp. Money Without Trump’s Approval
Pecker tells Steinglass he understood Trump would ultimately reimburse him for buying McDougal’s story, because Cohen was never authorized "to buy or acquire or spend any money … without Mr. Trump’s approval.”
"Every time we even went out for lunch, I always paid," Pecker said.
"Every time we even went out for lunch, I always paid," Pecker said.
Pecker Explains Legal Concerns With Buying McDougal’s Story
Pecker confirmed that he had concerns about AMI squashing a story about a presidential candidate based on a past experience around 2002 acquiring stories about then-gubernatorial candidate Arnold Schwarzenegger.
After Schwarzenegger announced his candidacy, Pecker said, “A number of women called up the National Enquirer about stories that they had to sell on different relationships or contacts and sexual harassment that they felt Arnold Schwarzenegger did.” One of the stories he bought for Schwarzenegger got out, leading Pecker to discover a potential conflict with campaign election law.
“Based on what happened 14 years ago, I wanted to be comfortable that the agreement we were going to prepare for Karen McDougal met all the obligations with respect to a campaign contribution,” he said, noting that his company consulted an election law attorney on the matter while drawing up the terms of a contract with McDougal.
After Schwarzenegger announced his candidacy, Pecker said, “A number of women called up the National Enquirer about stories that they had to sell on different relationships or contacts and sexual harassment that they felt Arnold Schwarzenegger did.” One of the stories he bought for Schwarzenegger got out, leading Pecker to discover a potential conflict with campaign election law.
“Based on what happened 14 years ago, I wanted to be comfortable that the agreement we were going to prepare for Karen McDougal met all the obligations with respect to a campaign contribution,” he said, noting that his company consulted an election law attorney on the matter while drawing up the terms of a contract with McDougal.
McDougal Wanted To Use Pecker’s Magazines To ‘Restart Her Career’
Listing off some of the terms McDougal had in addition to requiring a cash payment for her story, Pecker said she wanted to write for some of his health and fitness titles and anchor red carpet events for Radar magazine. Then came the question of who would cough up the cash.
“I said, Why would I pay? I just paid $30,000 for the doorman’s story. Now you’re asking me to pay $150,000 for Karen’s story, plus all of these other additional items that she wants to do,” Pecker testified. “I don’t have a problem doing everything else that she requested … [but] who is going to reimburse me for this? And he [Cohen] said, ‘Don’t worry about it. I’m your friend. The boss will take care of it.’”
"The boss" meant Trump, Pecker said.
“I said, Why would I pay? I just paid $30,000 for the doorman’s story. Now you’re asking me to pay $150,000 for Karen’s story, plus all of these other additional items that she wants to do,” Pecker testified. “I don’t have a problem doing everything else that she requested … [but] who is going to reimburse me for this? And he [Cohen] said, ‘Don’t worry about it. I’m your friend. The boss will take care of it.’”
"The boss" meant Trump, Pecker said.
Oral Arguments Are Underway In Trump's Presidential Immunity Case
Oral arguments are underway in Trump’s presidential immunity case before the Supreme Court. Trump's attorney John Sauer is currently answering questions from the nine justices. You can listen in to the proceeding here.
Trump Allegedly Called McDougal ‘A Nice Girl’
Pecker described a phone call with Trump regarding McDougal's story.
“Karen is a nice girl. What do you think I should do?” Pecker recalled Trump saying. (Trump has repeatedly denied having an affair with her.) Pecker said he recommended that Trump buy the story, and offered Dylan Howard to negotiate the terms of the agreement.
“And then I said, Who’s going to pay for it? And he [Cohen] said to me, don’t worry, I’m your friend, the boss will take care of it,” Pecker said.
“Karen is a nice girl. What do you think I should do?” Pecker recalled Trump saying. (Trump has repeatedly denied having an affair with her.) Pecker said he recommended that Trump buy the story, and offered Dylan Howard to negotiate the terms of the agreement.
“And then I said, Who’s going to pay for it? And he [Cohen] said to me, don’t worry, I’m your friend, the boss will take care of it,” Pecker said.
Pecker Resumes Testimony
Prosecuting attorney Joshua Steinglass resumed his questioning of Pecker, picking up where he left off in the story of how AMI vetted Karen McDougal’s claim that she had an affair with Trump. She declined an offer of $10,000 for her story.
Pecker said he convened Cohen and Dylan Howard on a conference call to discuss purchasing the rights to it.
“Cohen said ‘It’s not true,’ which is something he always said,” Pecker testified. “Dylan [Howard] mentioned that ABC was interested in acquiring the story … he also mentioned that a Mexican group made an offer for the story for $1 million. We didn’t believe there was a Mexican group that was going to buy the story,” Pecker said. “The ABC offer was interesting because they were offering Karen a slot on ‘Dancing with the Stars.’ I knew from my experience that ABC didn’t pay for stories.”
Pecker and Howard believed they had a very good shot at snapping up McDougal's story, however, because they thought she did not actually want it made public.
“She said she didn’t want to be the next Monica Lewinsky. She said she wanted to restart her career,” Pecker said of McDougal, recounting Howard’s talks with her. “He felt she would be more interested in having American Media buy the story than anyone else.”
Pecker said he convened Cohen and Dylan Howard on a conference call to discuss purchasing the rights to it.
“Cohen said ‘It’s not true,’ which is something he always said,” Pecker testified. “Dylan [Howard] mentioned that ABC was interested in acquiring the story … he also mentioned that a Mexican group made an offer for the story for $1 million. We didn’t believe there was a Mexican group that was going to buy the story,” Pecker said. “The ABC offer was interesting because they were offering Karen a slot on ‘Dancing with the Stars.’ I knew from my experience that ABC didn’t pay for stories.”
Pecker and Howard believed they had a very good shot at snapping up McDougal's story, however, because they thought she did not actually want it made public.
“She said she didn’t want to be the next Monica Lewinsky. She said she wanted to restart her career,” Pecker said of McDougal, recounting Howard’s talks with her. “He felt she would be more interested in having American Media buy the story than anyone else.”
Trump Addresses Economy News Ahead Of Trial Start
Before entering the courtroom, Trump addressed the news of U.S. economic growth falling in the January-March quarter.
“Gasoline is going way up,” he said. “Energy costs are going way up and the stock market is in a sense crashing. The numbers are very bad. This is Bidenomics.”
Among many other topics he addressed, Trump also predicted he has a “good chance” of winning New York in November and suggested his campaign would hold a rally in Madison Square Garden in the near future.
“Gasoline is going way up,” he said. “Energy costs are going way up and the stock market is in a sense crashing. The numbers are very bad. This is Bidenomics.”
Among many other topics he addressed, Trump also predicted he has a “good chance” of winning New York in November and suggested his campaign would hold a rally in Madison Square Garden in the near future.
Prosecutors Add 4 Alleged Gag Order Violations
Prosecuting attorney Christopher Conroy told Merchan the government was tacking on another four alleged gag order violations to their motion to hold Trump in contempt of court. There were “four violations in the last three days,” Conroy said. That brings the total to 14.
In one comment, Trump said he had an explicit message for Pecker: “Be nice.” Merchan has yet to rule on the issue.
In one comment, Trump said he had an explicit message for Pecker: “Be nice.” Merchan has yet to rule on the issue.
Trump Enters Courtroom
Trump walked silently into the courtroom with his team of attorneys shortly before 9:30 a.m.
Trump Claims Presidency Will Lose Prestige If Supreme Court Rules Against Him
Trump took to Truth Social, sharing three back-to-back posts claiming that presidents should be immune from prosecution as the Supreme Court is set to hear oral arguments in his case.
“Without Presidential Immunity, the Presidency will lose its power and prestige, and under some Leaders, have no power at all," he wrote. "The Presidency will be consumed by the other Branches of Government. THAT IS NOT WHAT OUR FOUNDERS WANTED!"
“Without Presidential Immunity, the Presidency will lose its power and prestige, and under some Leaders, have no power at all," he wrote. "The Presidency will be consumed by the other Branches of Government. THAT IS NOT WHAT OUR FOUNDERS WANTED!"
Trump Forced To Skip Presidential Immunity SCOTUS Hearing
Last week, Merchan denied the former president’s request to attend a Supreme Court hearing on his “presidential immunity” defense that will be held this morning. Trump has argued that special prosecutor Jack Smith should not have charged him with interfering with the 2020 presidential election results because he was acting in his capacity as president at the time, and presidents should have broad immunity from prosecution in order to feel free to do their job.
Instead, he will hear David Pecker talk about Trump's sordid past.
Instead, he will hear David Pecker talk about Trump's sordid past.
Michael Cohen Says He'll Stop Posting About Trump Until He Testifies
Michael Cohen, Trump's former personal fixer who facilitated a hush money payment to porn star Stormy Daniels ahead of the 2016 election, said he will stop sharing posts about Trump on his X account until he takes the stand at Trump's trial.
Cassidy Hutchinson Describes What Happens To Trump's Loyal Aides
Former White House aide Cassidy Hutchinson spoke to CNN last night after news broke that Mark Meadows, Trump's former chief of staff, was one of the people indicted by an Arizona grand jury over his role in an alleged scheme to undo the 2020 election result.
Trump “takes out everybody who is loyal to him because it’s all about his personal gain and what he can gain from those people,” she said.
Trump “takes out everybody who is loyal to him because it’s all about his personal gain and what he can gain from those people,” she said.
Trump Is On His Way To The Courthouse
Trump's motorcade is leaving Trump Tower now en route to the Manhattan courthouse, where his trial is expected to resume at 9:30 a.m. ET, according to CNN's live coverage.
Yuki Iwamura via Associated Press
Trump Addresses Reporters At Campaign Stop
Trump was photographed speaking to reporters at a campaign stop in New York City before he returns to the Manhattan courthouse for another day of proceedings in his criminal trial.
Trump Lawyer Makes Gloomy Prediction About Trial
Alina Habba, a lawyer for the former president, made a gloomy prediction regarding the outcome of his hush money trial.
Read more on her comments here.
Read more on her comments here.
Trump Makes Campaign Stop Ahead Of Court Appearance
The former president stopped by a construction site near Trump Tower around 6:45 a.m. ET, where he was greeted by supporters chanting, "We love Trump."
During the visit, Trump spoke to reporters about the Supreme Court hearing oral arguments in his presidential immunity case.
"A president has to have immunity," he said. "If you don't have immunity, you just have a ceremonial president."
Judge Juan Merchan, who is presiding over the hush money trial, had denied a request by Trump's team earlier this month to make a change in the trial's schedule to accommodate Trump's desire to attend the Supreme Court hearing even though his presence there was not required.
"Your client is a criminal defendant," Merchan told Trump's lawyer Todd Blanche at the time.
During his remarks this morning, Trump said David Pecker, who is due to return to the stand for a third day of testimony, has "been very nice."
During the visit, Trump spoke to reporters about the Supreme Court hearing oral arguments in his presidential immunity case.
"A president has to have immunity," he said. "If you don't have immunity, you just have a ceremonial president."
Judge Juan Merchan, who is presiding over the hush money trial, had denied a request by Trump's team earlier this month to make a change in the trial's schedule to accommodate Trump's desire to attend the Supreme Court hearing even though his presence there was not required.
"Your client is a criminal defendant," Merchan told Trump's lawyer Todd Blanche at the time.
During his remarks this morning, Trump said David Pecker, who is due to return to the stand for a third day of testimony, has "been very nice."
What To Expect From Day 7 Of Trump's Criminal Trial
- After a day off court, Trump is due back in the Manhattan courthouse this morning for day 7 of his criminal trial, which is set to kick off at 9:30 a.m. ET.
- Ahead of his court appearance Trump made a campaign stop at a construction site in New York City near Trump Tower, where he briefly spoke to reporters. Trump said David Pecker, the former publisher of the National Enquirer and the first witness the prosecution called to the stand, has "been very nice."
- Pecker is expected back in court today to answer more questions, reportedly about his role in the hush money payment to porn star Stormy Daniels ahead of the 2016 election.
- Meanwhile, the Supreme Court is due to hear oral arguments in Trump's presidential immunity case.
- The former president has continued to vent about his gag order on his Truth Social platform, calling it "totally UNCONSTITUTIONAL." Judge Merchan hasn't ruled yet on Trump's potential gag order violations.
- Trump was described as an unindicted co-conspirator in an Arizona grand jury indictment of Mark Meadows, his former chief of staff, Rudy Giuliani, his former personal lawyer, and 16 others, released yesterday.
Trump Talks Trial (Again) In Local News Interview
Trump spoke to a Philadelphia ABC affiliate for more than 10 minutes on Tuesday evening, mostly about the upcoming presidential election, but he also answered questions about his trial in potential violation of his gag order.
Calling Cohen “a convicted liar,” Trump told 6ABC, “He was my lawyer and you rely on your lawyers.”
He then vented more of his frustrations with Merchan.
“We have a very conflicted judge. The judge is highly conflicted. He should recuse himself immediately. There’s never been a judge so conflicted as this guy,” Trump said. “He should absolutely recuse himself immediately. That’s all they have — they have a good judge for them. But other than that, they have no case.”
Calling Cohen “a convicted liar,” Trump told 6ABC, “He was my lawyer and you rely on your lawyers.”
He then vented more of his frustrations with Merchan.
“We have a very conflicted judge. The judge is highly conflicted. He should recuse himself immediately. There’s never been a judge so conflicted as this guy,” Trump said. “He should absolutely recuse himself immediately. That’s all they have — they have a good judge for them. But other than that, they have no case.”
AP
Donald Trump Rants About Juan Merchan, Alvin Bragg And Maggie Haberman On Truth Social
Trump took his grievances regarding his criminal trial to Truth Social after court wrapped on Tuesday.
In his first post, the former president complained about New York Times reporter Maggie Haberman, whom he accused of “falsely” reporting Trump hasn’t been pleased with the lack of supporters gathering outside the Manhattan courthouse.
“Thousands of people were turned away from the Courthouse… It is an armed camp to keep people away,” he wrote. “Maggot Hagerman of The Failing New York Times, falsely reported that I was disappointed with the crowds. No, I’m disappointed with Maggot, and her lack of writing skill, and that some of these many police aren’t being sent to Columbia and NYU to keep the schools open and the students safe.”
Reporters on the scene say there has been no indication pro-Trump protesters have been blocked from the area surrounding the courthouse.
A second missive, posted about an hour later, Trump focused his ire on Merchan and Bragg, calling the judge “ridiculously conflicted” and the district attorney “corrupt.”
“THIS FAKE CASE SHOULD BE DROPPED, IMMEDIATELY!” he wrote.
In his first post, the former president complained about New York Times reporter Maggie Haberman, whom he accused of “falsely” reporting Trump hasn’t been pleased with the lack of supporters gathering outside the Manhattan courthouse.
“Thousands of people were turned away from the Courthouse… It is an armed camp to keep people away,” he wrote. “Maggot Hagerman of The Failing New York Times, falsely reported that I was disappointed with the crowds. No, I’m disappointed with Maggot, and her lack of writing skill, and that some of these many police aren’t being sent to Columbia and NYU to keep the schools open and the students safe.”
Reporters on the scene say there has been no indication pro-Trump protesters have been blocked from the area surrounding the courthouse.
A second missive, posted about an hour later, Trump focused his ire on Merchan and Bragg, calling the judge “ridiculously conflicted” and the district attorney “corrupt.”
“THIS FAKE CASE SHOULD BE DROPPED, IMMEDIATELY!” he wrote.
AP
Trump Complains To Reporters That He Can’t Complain To Reporters
In comments after the hearing, Trump complained about the gag order that bars him from attacking witnesses.
Standing before the cameras, Trump held aloft a large stack of what he said were “very good articles” and complained he would be unable to share them on social media.
“The articles say the case is a sham,” he said. “We have a gag order which to me is totally unconstitutional … I’m not allowed to say anything.”
“I’d love to talk to you people,” he said. “I’d love to say everything that’s on my mind, but I’m restricted because I have a gag order.”
Earlier Tuesday, Judge Merchan criticized Trump attorney Todd Blanche for attempting to argue that Trump could repost anything he wanted without violating the gag order, since Trump hadn’t personally written it.
"You are losing credibility,” Merchan told Blanche. “I have to tell you right now. You're losing all credibility with the court."
Trump also complained after the hearing about the “freezing” temperature in the courtroom. HuffPost’s Sara Boboltz, who’s in the courthouse, reports it was actually warm there today.
Standing before the cameras, Trump held aloft a large stack of what he said were “very good articles” and complained he would be unable to share them on social media.
“The articles say the case is a sham,” he said. “We have a gag order which to me is totally unconstitutional … I’m not allowed to say anything.”
“I’d love to talk to you people,” he said. “I’d love to say everything that’s on my mind, but I’m restricted because I have a gag order.”
Earlier Tuesday, Judge Merchan criticized Trump attorney Todd Blanche for attempting to argue that Trump could repost anything he wanted without violating the gag order, since Trump hadn’t personally written it.
"You are losing credibility,” Merchan told Blanche. “I have to tell you right now. You're losing all credibility with the court."
Trump also complained after the hearing about the “freezing” temperature in the courtroom. HuffPost’s Sara Boboltz, who’s in the courthouse, reports it was actually warm there today.
Day 6 Of Trump’s Hush Money Trial Has Wrapped Up. Here’s What Happened.
- Court adjourned early Tuesday for Passover, and will be out Wednesday.
- Judge Merchan made no immediate ruling on Trump’s numerous potential gag order violations, but the hearing couldn’t have gone worse for Trump lawyer Todd Blanche, who Merchan warned was “losing all credibility with the court.”
- David Pecker, the prosecution’s first witness, testified about the great lengths the National Enquirer went to in 2016 to boost Trump and denigrate his opponents. That included publishing headlines essentially dictated by Trump’s personal lawyer Michael Cohen, and purchasing the rights to negative stories about Trump and then burying them, a practice referred to as "catch and kill."
Court Adjourns For The Day
Trump filed out of the courtroom around 2 p.m.
Jurors Hear About Karen McDougal Catch-And-Kill Operation
Pecker described hearing from former National Enquirer Editor-in-Chief Dylan Howard that former Playboy model Karen McDougal was shopping around a story about an alleged affair with Trump. Pecker called Cohen and told him what he’d heard. According to Pecker, Cohen said the affair didn’t happen, but told Pecker to look into it.
Cohen eventually told Pecker that they should move their conversation on McDougal from a landline to the encrypted app Signal.
“I’d never heard of it before,” the 72-year-old Pecker said of the app.
He explained that Howard had gone to interview McDougal and came to believe she did not actually want her story to be made public. When Trump called to discuss McDougal, Pecker said he told Trump to buy the story. But Trump said he doesn’t buy stories because, in his experience, the story always leaks out, Pecker testified. He added that Cohen appeared to be under a lot of pressure to handle the situation.
Cohen eventually told Pecker that they should move their conversation on McDougal from a landline to the encrypted app Signal.
“I’d never heard of it before,” the 72-year-old Pecker said of the app.
He explained that Howard had gone to interview McDougal and came to believe she did not actually want her story to be made public. When Trump called to discuss McDougal, Pecker said he told Trump to buy the story. But Trump said he doesn’t buy stories because, in his experience, the story always leaks out, Pecker testified. He added that Cohen appeared to be under a lot of pressure to handle the situation.
AMI Eventually Finds Doorman's Story To Be False
An addendum to ex-Trump Tower doorman Dino Sajudin’s agreement with AMI from late 2015 stipulated that if he went elsewhere with his story, he would owe AMI $1 million. It also said the exclusivity agreement with AMI would be extended in perpetuity. Prosecutors showed the jurors evidence in the form of a December 2015 email titled “INVOICE FOR DINO G. SAJUDIN.”
Pecker said he eventually determined the story was not true. He told Cohen that the doorman was “very difficult to deal with,” and that he thought they should release the man from the exclusivity agreement. Cohen made Pecker promise not to do so before the 2016 presidential election, Pecker testified. Sajudin was told he was being released from the agreement on Dec. 9, 2016.
Pecker said he eventually determined the story was not true. He told Cohen that the doorman was “very difficult to deal with,” and that he thought they should release the man from the exclusivity agreement. Cohen made Pecker promise not to do so before the 2016 presidential election, Pecker testified. Sajudin was told he was being released from the agreement on Dec. 9, 2016.
Checking In On The Jury Box
As we near the end of proceedings for the day, jurors are largely attentive, taking notes on their notepads. Most are looking studiously at Pecker, but some turn their gaze elsewhere. There is no lunch break today, as court will adjourn at 2 p.m. for Passover.
Pecker Describes Catch-And-Kill Plan For Trump Tower Doorman's Story
Pecker explained how he became aware of a story being peddled by a former Trump Tower doorman, Dino Sajudin, who alleged that Trump had fathered a child with a Trump Tower maid at one point. He called Cohen, who told him it was “absolutely not true,” but instructed Pecker to look into it anyway. One of the first steps was to pay the doorman $500 to take a polygraph test.
“I called Michael Cohen, and said, we have to go forward with the story,” Pecker said. Steinglass had told him not to reveal the results of the test. The doorman would need to be paid $30,000, Pecker testified.
“I said, I’ll pay for it,” Pecker. “This could be a very big story, I believe it’s important that it be removed from the market.” While he had no intention of publishing the story, at least before the election, Pecker said if he were to do so, the National Enquirer would see the biggest day of sales "since the death of Elvis Presley."
A copy of the agreement between AMI and Sajudin, dated Nov. 15, 2015, was shown to the jury.
“I called Michael Cohen, and said, we have to go forward with the story,” Pecker said. Steinglass had told him not to reveal the results of the test. The doorman would need to be paid $30,000, Pecker testified.
“I said, I’ll pay for it,” Pecker. “This could be a very big story, I believe it’s important that it be removed from the market.” While he had no intention of publishing the story, at least before the election, Pecker said if he were to do so, the National Enquirer would see the biggest day of sales "since the death of Elvis Presley."
A copy of the agreement between AMI and Sajudin, dated Nov. 15, 2015, was shown to the jury.
Trump Loved The ‘Ted Cruz JFK Assassin’ Conspiracy Concocted By National Enquirer
Trump leaned heavily into a bizarre conspiracy during the 2016 primary alleging a link between Sen. Ted Cruz’s father and the assassin of President John F. Kennedy.
“His father. I don’t know his father, I met him once,” Trump said at a speech shortly after accepting the Republican nomination. “I think he’s a lovely guy. I think he’s a lovely guy. All I did is point out the fact that on the cover of the National Enquirer there was a picture of him and crazy Lee Harvey Oswald having breakfast.”
Pecker testified Tuesday that the National Enquirer concocted the baseless claim.
“We mashed the photos and the different picture with Lee Harvard Oswald ... we mashed the two together," Pecker told the jury. "That's how that story was prepared — created, I would say."
“His father. I don’t know his father, I met him once,” Trump said at a speech shortly after accepting the Republican nomination. “I think he’s a lovely guy. I think he’s a lovely guy. All I did is point out the fact that on the cover of the National Enquirer there was a picture of him and crazy Lee Harvey Oswald having breakfast.”
Pecker testified Tuesday that the National Enquirer concocted the baseless claim.
“We mashed the photos and the different picture with Lee Harvard Oswald ... we mashed the two together," Pecker told the jury. "That's how that story was prepared — created, I would say."
Sidebar On Steve Bannon’s Alleged Influence On National Enquirer
With the jurors momentarily out of the courtroom, lawyers for both parties argued over how questions should be handled with regard to former Trump adviser Steve Bannon’s alleged influence on what the National Enquirer published during the 2016 presidential campaign. Prosecutors agreed to drop the line of questioning and move on.
Here Are Some Of The Headlines Pecker Published At Trump Camp’s Direction
Pecker testified that Cohen would essentially dictate various pro-Trump headlines for the National Enquirer, and Pecker would run embellished versions.
"After the Republican debates, and based on the success that some of the other candidates had, I would receive a call from Michael Cohen and he would direct me, and direct Dylan Howard on which candidate and which direction we should go," Pecker testified.
Here’s a sample of the headlines they published:
"After the Republican debates, and based on the success that some of the other candidates had, I would receive a call from Michael Cohen and he would direct me, and direct Dylan Howard on which candidate and which direction we should go," Pecker testified.
Here’s a sample of the headlines they published:
- DONALD TRUMP: THE MAN THE LEGEND
- TED CRUZ SHAMED BY PORN STAR
- DONALD TRUMP GETS THE DUKE'S BLESSING
- BUNGLING SURGEON BEN CARSON LEFT SPONGE IN PATIENT’S BRAIN
- JFK'S SECRET SON ENDORSES DONALD TRUMP
- DONALD DOMINATES!
- OBAMA'S HALF-BROTHER-CHEERING ON DONALD AT DEBATE
- TED CRUZ SEX SCANDAL — 5 SECRET MISTRESSES
- CRUZIN' TO VICTORY! TED ENDORSES DONALD
- DONALD TRUMP BLASTS TED CRUZ’S DAD FOR PHOTO WITH JFK ASSASSIN
- ‘FAMILY MAN’ MARCO RUBIO’S LOVE CHILD STUNNER!
‘An Agreement Among Friends’
The meeting Trump called at Trump Tower lasted only about 20 to 25 minutes, Pecker testified. He described what came out of it as “an agreement among friends,” rather than a more formal arrangement.
It was important for the deal to be kept secret, Pecker said, due to the number of people who worked at his publishing company.
“I did not want anyone else to know,” he said.
Jurors were shown a series of National Enquirer headlines praising Trump. After gazing at a series of National Enquirer headlines attacking Trump's political opponents, Pecker testified that Cohen would simply tell him what he wanted to see published about Trump's enemies, and Pecker's staff would then "embellish" the claims.
Cohen also got PDFs of the stories before they ran, in order to provide feedback.
It was important for the deal to be kept secret, Pecker said, due to the number of people who worked at his publishing company.
“I did not want anyone else to know,” he said.
Jurors were shown a series of National Enquirer headlines praising Trump. After gazing at a series of National Enquirer headlines attacking Trump's political opponents, Pecker testified that Cohen would simply tell him what he wanted to see published about Trump's enemies, and Pecker's staff would then "embellish" the claims.
Cohen also got PDFs of the stories before they ran, in order to provide feedback.
Trump ‘Pleased’ By Anti-Clinton Content
Negative stories about Hillary and Bill Clinton would provide “a mutual benefit” for both Trump and Pecker, he said.
Trump was “pleased” about the idea that AMI publications would be pushing stories about former President Bill Clinton’s “womanizing,” Pecker recalled.
Trump was “pleased” about the idea that AMI publications would be pushing stories about former President Bill Clinton’s “womanizing,” Pecker recalled.
Pecker Recalls Infamous Trump Tower Meeting, Thought 'A Lot' Of Women Would Have Trump Stories
Pecker was asked to give details of the August 2015 meeting between Trump, Cohen and Hope Hicks at Trump Tower that was organized by Trump — or “the boss,” as Cohen apparently called him then.
“At that meeting, they asked me what can I do and what my magazines can do to help the campaign,” Pecker said. “So thinking about it as I did previously, I said what I would do is I would run or publish positive stories about Mr. Trump and I would publish negative stories about his opponents. And I said … I would be your eyes and ears, because I knew that the Trump Organization had a very small staff."
Anything he heard that was "negative" about Trump or "about women selling stories,” Pecker would notify Cohen about, he said.
“I was the person who thought that a lot of women would come out to try to sell their stories, because Mr. Trump was well-known as the most eligible bachelor and dated the most beautiful women," Pecker testified. "And it was clear that, based on my past experience, that when someone is running for office like this, it is very common for these women to call up a magazine like the National Enquirer to try to sell their stories."
“At that meeting, they asked me what can I do and what my magazines can do to help the campaign,” Pecker said. “So thinking about it as I did previously, I said what I would do is I would run or publish positive stories about Mr. Trump and I would publish negative stories about his opponents. And I said … I would be your eyes and ears, because I knew that the Trump Organization had a very small staff."
Anything he heard that was "negative" about Trump or "about women selling stories,” Pecker would notify Cohen about, he said.
“I was the person who thought that a lot of women would come out to try to sell their stories, because Mr. Trump was well-known as the most eligible bachelor and dated the most beautiful women," Pecker testified. "And it was clear that, based on my past experience, that when someone is running for office like this, it is very common for these women to call up a magazine like the National Enquirer to try to sell their stories."
Cohen: 'Truth Will Prevail Over Donald'
Trump’s former lawyer and personal fixer hit back at the former president Tuesday after he repeatedly ranted about Cohen on social media, potentially in violation of a gag order.
Cohen was sentenced to three years in prison for his role in the scheme that Trump is now on trial for.
“After the Trump administration had me remanded to solitary confinement for a total of 51 days, I learned that I am much stronger than I ever imagined," Cohen told NBC in a statement.
"Strong enough to ensure that truth will prevail over Donald and his acolytes’ incessant lying and denigration of me; in the court hallways or his unTruth Social platform. Regardless. no one is above the law.”
Cohen was sentenced to three years in prison for his role in the scheme that Trump is now on trial for.
“After the Trump administration had me remanded to solitary confinement for a total of 51 days, I learned that I am much stronger than I ever imagined," Cohen told NBC in a statement.
"Strong enough to ensure that truth will prevail over Donald and his acolytes’ incessant lying and denigration of me; in the court hallways or his unTruth Social platform. Regardless. no one is above the law.”
Pecker Spoke To Cohen 'Daily,' Calls Trump ‘Cautious’
Asked to describe Trump as a businessman, Pecker said he was “very knowledgeable” and “very detail-oriented.” He was “almost a micromanager … he looked at all the aspects of whatever the issue was.”
“His approach to money — he was very cautious and very frugal,” Pecker testified.
Pecker first met Cohen at a bar mitzvah in 2000, he said. Seven years later, Trump hired him as his personal attorney, and Pecker recalled that anything he had to tell Trump would have to go through Cohen after that point.
Before Trump announced his presidential run, Pecker said he spoke to Trump “probably, maybe, once a month.” After that point, he said he talked to him through Cohen “at a minimum of every week” if not “daily.”
“His approach to money — he was very cautious and very frugal,” Pecker testified.
Pecker first met Cohen at a bar mitzvah in 2000, he said. Seven years later, Trump hired him as his personal attorney, and Pecker recalled that anything he had to tell Trump would have to go through Cohen after that point.
Before Trump announced his presidential run, Pecker said he spoke to Trump “probably, maybe, once a month.” After that point, he said he talked to him through Cohen “at a minimum of every week” if not “daily.”
Remembering ‘The Apprentice’
“It was an instant success,” Pecker said of Trump’s NBC reality TV show.
He said that the show, and its “Celebrity Apprentice” offshoot, made Trump into a “major celebrity” and elevated his profile nationwide.
Steinglass asked Pecker to confirm that the show was a competition between contestants who were competing to be hired by Trump, pointing out that even though none of the contestants had been hired, Trump eliminated them from the show with the line, “You’re fired.”
He said that the show, and its “Celebrity Apprentice” offshoot, made Trump into a “major celebrity” and elevated his profile nationwide.
Steinglass asked Pecker to confirm that the show was a competition between contestants who were competing to be hired by Trump, pointing out that even though none of the contestants had been hired, Trump eliminated them from the show with the line, “You’re fired.”
Trump Follows Gag Order Hearing With Social Media Rant About Judge
Judge Merchan didn’t respond favorably to Blanche’s argument this morning that Trump can repost whatever content he wants without fear of violating his gag order.
After the hearing, Trump promptly went after Merchan on social media.
Writing in all caps, the former president posted:
“HIGHLY CONFLICTED, TO PUT IT MILDLY, JUDGE JUAN MERCHAN, HAS TAKEN AWAY MY CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHT TO FREE SPEECH. EVERYBODY IS ALLOWED TO TALK AND LIE ABOUT ME, BUT I AM NOT ALLOWED TO DEFEND MYSELF. THIS IS A KANGAROO COURT, AND THE JUDGE SHOULD RECUSE HIMSELF!”
After the hearing, Trump promptly went after Merchan on social media.
Writing in all caps, the former president posted:
“HIGHLY CONFLICTED, TO PUT IT MILDLY, JUDGE JUAN MERCHAN, HAS TAKEN AWAY MY CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHT TO FREE SPEECH. EVERYBODY IS ALLOWED TO TALK AND LIE ABOUT ME, BUT I AM NOT ALLOWED TO DEFEND MYSELF. THIS IS A KANGAROO COURT, AND THE JUDGE SHOULD RECUSE HIMSELF!”
Pecker Is Back On The Stand
Asked whether he was personally familiar with Trump, Pecker said yes.“How long have you known him?” prosecutor Joshua Steinglass asked.
“Since the late ‘80s,” Pecker said, adding that they met at Mar-a-Lago. “I’ve had a great relationship with Mr. Trump over the years.”
“Since the late ‘80s,” Pecker said, adding that they met at Mar-a-Lago. “I’ve had a great relationship with Mr. Trump over the years.”
Reminder: Pecker Was Granted Immunity In Exchange For His Cooperation
In 2018, the former National Enquirer publisher agreed to provide information to prosecutors only after they granted him immunity in the case.
Pecker avoided criminal charges as a result of the deal, as did chief content officer Dylan Howard.
The investigation at that time centered on Michael Cohen’s conduct in the scheme, not Trump’s. Trump’s former lawyer and personal fixer ultimately pleaded guilty to two counts of violating federal campaign finance laws and was sentenced to three years in prison, mostly spent in home confinement.
Pecker avoided criminal charges as a result of the deal, as did chief content officer Dylan Howard.
The investigation at that time centered on Michael Cohen’s conduct in the scheme, not Trump’s. Trump’s former lawyer and personal fixer ultimately pleaded guilty to two counts of violating federal campaign finance laws and was sentenced to three years in prison, mostly spent in home confinement.
Trump Confers With Lawyers
The former president is going back and forth between Blanche and Bove, whispering intently. He shook his head slightly. We are waiting for the judge and jury to enter.
After A Short Break, We’re Back
Court has resumed after a short break following the gag order hearing. Trump is now back in the courtroom, holding a thick stack of papers.
Trump ignored reporters’ questions during the break, including:
Trump ignored reporters’ questions during the break, including:
- Are you going to keep [posting on social media?]
- How are your lawyers doing?
- Does your lawyer have any credibility?
Merchan Schools Trump Lawyer
The judge schooled Trump's lawyer, telling him that he should have come into the courtroom to say that Trump’s team was not clear whether reposts violated the gag order. “But that’s not what you did,” Merchan said.
“The fact that the People did not run in here immediately when your client started reposting things … is not probative of anything,” the judge said.
He then called for a quick recess.
“The fact that the People did not run in here immediately when your client started reposting things … is not probative of anything,” the judge said.
He then called for a quick recess.
Judge To Trump's Attorney In Hush Money Trial: 'You're Losing Credibility'
As Blanche’s argument is not going well, he and Trump attorney Emil Bove briefly conferred over Bove's laptop. Blanche attempts to continue his argument but is soon interrupted by the judge.
"You are losing credibility. I have to tell you right now," Merchan told him. "You're losing all credibility with the court."
"You are losing credibility. I have to tell you right now," Merchan told him. "You're losing all credibility with the court."
Court Officers Take Man Into Custody
Earlier, court officers arrested a man who refused to follow the guidelines and take his seat inside the overflow courtroom, according to The Associated Press. The man was escorted out in handcuffs shortly after the gag order hearing got underway.
The news agency added that two journalists have been banned from covering the proceedings after they allegedly broke the rules.
You can read from AP here.
The news agency added that two journalists have been banned from covering the proceedings after they allegedly broke the rules.
You can read from AP here.
Judge Not Buying Trump Attorney's Argument On Reposts
"Reposting an article from a news site … we don’t believe are violations,” Blanche told the judge, who said he wanted to talk about that and asked Blanche to elaborate.
“Tell me what case law you have to support that," the judge said.
“I don’t have any case laws. But it’s just common sense, your honor,” Blanche replied. He tried arguing that the act of reposting something was a passive act, but the judge wasn’t buying it.
“Passive conduct would be if someone makes a post and it somehow ends up in the client’s account without anybody doing anything,” Merchan said.
“Tell me what case law you have to support that," the judge said.
“I don’t have any case laws. But it’s just common sense, your honor,” Blanche replied. He tried arguing that the act of reposting something was a passive act, but the judge wasn’t buying it.
“Passive conduct would be if someone makes a post and it somehow ends up in the client’s account without anybody doing anything,” Merchan said.
Judge Spars With Blanche
Blanche is attempting to convince Merchan that Trump is simply responding to “political attacks,” not violating the gag order.
“There were repeated, repeated attacks —“ Blanche said.
“Give me one, give me the most recent one,” Merchan interjected. But Blanche said he did not have a “specific tweet.”
An apparently frustrated Merchan later told him: “I’m asking the questions. I’m going to decide whether your client is in contempt or not, so please don’t turn it around.” He emphasized how long Blanche was taking to make his points and said he did not want to keep the jurors waiting when they arrived at 11 a.m.
“The People were allowed to speak as long as they wanted to,” Blanche said.
“The People were answering my questions,” Merchan replied.
“There were repeated, repeated attacks —“ Blanche said.
“Give me one, give me the most recent one,” Merchan interjected. But Blanche said he did not have a “specific tweet.”
An apparently frustrated Merchan later told him: “I’m asking the questions. I’m going to decide whether your client is in contempt or not, so please don’t turn it around.” He emphasized how long Blanche was taking to make his points and said he did not want to keep the jurors waiting when they arrived at 11 a.m.
“The People were allowed to speak as long as they wanted to,” Blanche said.
“The People were answering my questions,” Merchan replied.
Reposts Are Still Violations, Prosecutor Argues
Prosecuting attorney Christopher Conroy addressed Trump’s team’s claim that his social media reposts do not count as gag order violations because Trump did not create the content himself.
“What happened here is what the order is precisely there to prevent, and the defendant doesn’t care,” Conroy said, adding that Trump had demonstrated a “willfulness” to defy the court.
“Some of his most dangerous statements … are what he wants to carve out of the order by calling them reposts. That flies in the face of common sense,” Conroy said.
He gave as an example a repost that pictured a bat next to Bragg's head.
Blanche refuted this point and told Merchan, “Just to set the record very clear, President Trump absolutely knows what the gag order allows him to do and does not allow him to do.”
“What happened here is what the order is precisely there to prevent, and the defendant doesn’t care,” Conroy said, adding that Trump had demonstrated a “willfulness” to defy the court.
“Some of his most dangerous statements … are what he wants to carve out of the order by calling them reposts. That flies in the face of common sense,” Conroy said.
He gave as an example a repost that pictured a bat next to Bragg's head.
Blanche refuted this point and told Merchan, “Just to set the record very clear, President Trump absolutely knows what the gag order allows him to do and does not allow him to do.”
Trump Claim That Protesters Can’t Get To Courthouse Is ‘Just … Not True’
Trump has repeatedly claimed that nobody’s at the courthouse protesting on his behalf because the police have shut down the surrounding streets for security purposes.
The claim is easily disproved. On Tuesday morning, NBC’s Vaughn Hillyard shared a short video from outside the courthouse of a street open to traffic and one pro-Trump person standing by themselves in the designated protest zone.
The claim is easily disproved. On Tuesday morning, NBC’s Vaughn Hillyard shared a short video from outside the courthouse of a street open to traffic and one pro-Trump person standing by themselves in the designated protest zone.
Yuki Iwamura/Pool via Associated Press
Trump Captured By Photographers Ahead Of Gag Order Hearing
Trump is photographed inside the courtroom looking up as he waited for a hearing on his gag order to get underway.
Prosecutors Say Trump Violated The Gag Order Yet Another Time
“Defendant has violated this order repeatedly and hasn’t stopped,” attorney Christopher Conroy told Merchan.
He said Trump violated the order once again on Monday, during comments made to the press outside the courtroom in which he complained about Cohen and the trial generally. Trump also posted an all-caps screed on the case to Truth Social.
(Editor's note: This post has been updated to reflect Conroy was speaking, not Joshua Steinglass.)
He said Trump violated the order once again on Monday, during comments made to the press outside the courtroom in which he complained about Cohen and the trial generally. Trump also posted an all-caps screed on the case to Truth Social.
(Editor's note: This post has been updated to reflect Conroy was speaking, not Joshua Steinglass.)
Day 6 Of Trump’s Criminal Trial Is Underway
- A hearing is currently underway for Judge Juan Merchan to rule on the prosecution’s motion to have Trump held in criminal contempt and sanctioned for violating his gag order by attacking two known witnesses: his former personal fixer Michael Cohen and porn star Stormy Daniels.
- Following the conclusion of that proceeding, the jury will be called in to take their seats for the resumption of the hush money trial. David Pecker, the former publisher of the National Enquirer, will be back for a second day of questioning.
Trump’s Contempt Hearing Begins
Prosecutors allege the former president violated the terms of his gag order — preventing him, in theory, from publicly commenting on individuals involved in the case — 10 times.
They argued in court filings that Trump should be fined $1,000 for each incident, which have included a claim that “they are catching undercover Liberal Activists lying to the Judge in order to get on the Trump Jury.” Trump has dubbed the trial “Communism at its worst,” called Merchan a “HIGHLY CONFLICTED & CORRUPT JUDGE,” described the court and Bragg as “animals” and labeled Cohen a “sleaze bag” who engages in “lies and misrepresentations.”
Trump has complained endlessly about his gag order.
They argued in court filings that Trump should be fined $1,000 for each incident, which have included a claim that “they are catching undercover Liberal Activists lying to the Judge in order to get on the Trump Jury.” Trump has dubbed the trial “Communism at its worst,” called Merchan a “HIGHLY CONFLICTED & CORRUPT JUDGE,” described the court and Bragg as “animals” and labeled Cohen a “sleaze bag” who engages in “lies and misrepresentations.”
Trump has complained endlessly about his gag order.
Trump Attacks Biden Over Pro-Palestinian Protests On College Campuses
Prior to entering the courtroom, Trump addressed reporters, attacking President Joe Biden over the pro-Palestinian protests taking place at college campuses across the country.
“It’s all Biden’s fault and everybody knows it,” he said.
He then went on to call Biden "the worst president in the history of our country."
“It’s all Biden’s fault and everybody knows it,” he said.
He then went on to call Biden "the worst president in the history of our country."
Trump Arrives For Day 6
The former president is now seated in the courtroom with his attorneys.
Trump Takes Part In Local TV Interviews Ahead Of Court Appearance
Trump took part in virtual interviews with local TV stations in the battleground state of Pennsylvania ahead of his court appearance this morning, his campaign's national press secretary said in a post on X, formerly Twitter.
Voters in the state are heading to the polls today to cast their ballots in the primary elections.
Voters in the state are heading to the polls today to cast their ballots in the primary elections.
Timings For Today
Judge Merchan will hold a hearing at 9:30 a.m. this morning on the prosecution's motion to have Trump held in criminal contempt and sanctioned for allegedly violating his gag order with social media posts about Michael Cohen and Stormy Daniels.
Jurors will come back to the courtroom at 11 a.m. and the trial will continue, according to CNN.
Jurors will come back to the courtroom at 11 a.m. and the trial will continue, according to CNN.
‘She Is Watching’
Stephanie Grisham, a former aide to Melania Trump, said she expected the former first lady to closely track developments in her husband’s trial. The former first lady in particular will be watching any new information coming out of Pecker’s testimony, according to Grisham, after he previously admitted to having a private email account for things he "didn’t want my assistant to see."
In Other News, Trump's Valet Allegedly Promised Pardon
Walt Nauta, one of the former president's co-defendants in the classified documents case, was allegedly promised a presidential pardon if he was charged with lying to FBI investigators if Trump won reelection in November, court filings show.
You can read more here.
You can read more here.
Haberman Debunks Trump Gripe About Trial
CNN's Kaitlan Collins said that Trump is annoyed that there aren't more of his supporters outside the courthouse. Collins noted the high security surrounding the trial.
New York Times reporter Maggie Haberman said that Trump has tried to claim on Truth Social that his supporters are being blocked from the courthouse. "But that’s not it. It’s that people are not showing up," she said.
New York Times reporter Maggie Haberman said that Trump has tried to claim on Truth Social that his supporters are being blocked from the courthouse. "But that’s not it. It’s that people are not showing up," she said.
Courtroom Artist Describes Trump's Behavior
Courtroom sketch artist Elizabeth Williams said on CNN that when Merchan was explaining a ruling, Trump "had his eyes closed, his head would sort of tilt back and forth" and then "all of a sudden he would hear something, he would snap to attention, take a piece of paper, write something down and hand it to [his attorney] Todd Lynch."
Fox News Host Worries About Trump Getting Exercise
Fox News' Jesse Waters said that making Trump appear in court every day for his trial amounted to "cruel and unusual punishment."
"The guy needs exercise. He’s usually golfing, and so you’re going to put a man who’s almost 80, sitting in a room like this, on his butt for all that time?" he said.
"The guy needs exercise. He’s usually golfing, and so you’re going to put a man who’s almost 80, sitting in a room like this, on his butt for all that time?" he said.
Victor J. Blue/The Washington Post/Pool via Associated Press
Merchan To Hold Hearing On Trump's Gag Order Violations
Before the jury is seated for day six of Trump's criminal trial, Judge Juan Merchan is set to hold a hearing to rule on the prosecution's motion to have Trump held in criminal contempt and sanctioned for allegedly violating his gag order by making posts attacking two known witnesses: his former personal fixer Michael Cohen and porn star Stormy Daniels.
"Defendant is not above the law, and he cannot simply disregard judicial orders that upset him," Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg wrote in a court filing last week. "And both the public and the participants in the criminal trial deserve reassurance that the judicial system stands ready to protect them and to preserve the rule of law in the face of defendant's extreme and deliberate provocations."
In his filing, Bragg also called on Merchan to warn Trump that if he were to violate the gag order again in the future he could face jail time rather than just more fines.
The gag order was originally imposed on Trump in late March but expanded on April 1 with Merchan explicitly telling the former president that attacks on his family were off limits.
Trump has repeatedly complained about the directive, saying it is depriving him of his right to speak up, and has urged the judge to lift it.
"REMOVE THE GAG ORDER!!! WHAT DO YOU HAVE TO HIDE???" he asked in a Truth Social post Sunday.
Following the conclusion of the hearing, the trial will resume with the jury set to hear more from David Pecker, the former publisher of the National Enquirer.
"Defendant is not above the law, and he cannot simply disregard judicial orders that upset him," Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg wrote in a court filing last week. "And both the public and the participants in the criminal trial deserve reassurance that the judicial system stands ready to protect them and to preserve the rule of law in the face of defendant's extreme and deliberate provocations."
In his filing, Bragg also called on Merchan to warn Trump that if he were to violate the gag order again in the future he could face jail time rather than just more fines.
The gag order was originally imposed on Trump in late March but expanded on April 1 with Merchan explicitly telling the former president that attacks on his family were off limits.
Trump has repeatedly complained about the directive, saying it is depriving him of his right to speak up, and has urged the judge to lift it.
"REMOVE THE GAG ORDER!!! WHAT DO YOU HAVE TO HIDE???" he asked in a Truth Social post Sunday.
Following the conclusion of the hearing, the trial will resume with the jury set to hear more from David Pecker, the former publisher of the National Enquirer.
Donald Trump Rages, Says Things That ‘Cross The Line’ Should Be Protected By Presidential Immunity
Trump took to Truth Social on Monday night to demand he be protected by absolute presidential immunity for anything he did while in office, saying presidents should be afforded the right even for “events that ‘cross the line.’”
“ANY MISTAKE, EVEN IF WELL INTENDED, WOULD BE MET WITH ALMOST CERTAIN INDICTMENT BY THE OPPOSING PARTY AT TERM END,” he wrote in an all-caps missive. “EVEN EVENTS THAT ‘CROSS THE LINE’ MUST FALL UNDER TOTAL IMMUNITY, OR IT WILL BE YEARS OF TRAUMA TRYING TO DETERMINE GOOD FROM BAD.”
He went on to compare his plight to efforts to prevent police brutality, saying you can’t stop law enforcement from doing its job because you want to “guard against the seldom seen ‘rogue cop.’”
The Supreme Court is set to hear arguments on the matter on Thursday.
“ANY MISTAKE, EVEN IF WELL INTENDED, WOULD BE MET WITH ALMOST CERTAIN INDICTMENT BY THE OPPOSING PARTY AT TERM END,” he wrote in an all-caps missive. “EVEN EVENTS THAT ‘CROSS THE LINE’ MUST FALL UNDER TOTAL IMMUNITY, OR IT WILL BE YEARS OF TRAUMA TRYING TO DETERMINE GOOD FROM BAD.”
He went on to compare his plight to efforts to prevent police brutality, saying you can’t stop law enforcement from doing its job because you want to “guard against the seldom seen ‘rogue cop.’”
The Supreme Court is set to hear arguments on the matter on Thursday.
Getty Images
Michael Cohen Says Trump Attack Signals 'Desperation'
Trump's latest attack on his former personal attorney was met with name-calling on X, formerly Twitter, where Cohen said that Trump's comments "stink of desperation." Trump had claimed all of Cohen's past legal troubles had "nothing" to do with him.
"We are all hoping that you take the stand in your defense," Cohen wrote.
It is not yet known whether Trump will do so.
"We are all hoping that you take the stand in your defense," Cohen wrote.
It is not yet known whether Trump will do so.
Trump Rants About 'Very Unfair' Case Outside Court
Speaking to the press outside court, Trump complained about Cohen and the case, which he said was keeping him off the campaign trail.
"[Cohen] represented a lot of people over the years. But they take this payment and they call it illegal," Trump said. "This is taking me off the campaign trail."
He added: "I should be in Georgia now. I should be in Florida now ... and I’m sitting here. It’s very unfair.”
"[Cohen] represented a lot of people over the years. But they take this payment and they call it illegal," Trump said. "This is taking me off the campaign trail."
He added: "I should be in Georgia now. I should be in Florida now ... and I’m sitting here. It’s very unfair.”
Trump Exits
Trump remained seated for a moment as attorneys for the prosecution gathered their things. He then stood and laid a heavy hand on a low wooden fence at the front of the courtroom before exiting with his attorneys, carrying nothing.
Day 6 Of Trump’s Criminal Trial Starts Today. Here’s What Happened Yesterday.
- Both sides delivered their opening statements, with prosecutor Matthew Colangelo painting Trump as a serial liar who authorized a conspiracy to conceal business records during the 2016 election. Trump attorney Todd Blanche countered that the case is an insignificant non-story.
- Judge Merchan will allow prosecutors to bring up some of Trump’s recent legal struggles should he decide to testify. That includes the February civil fraud ruling, Trump’s losses in the two defamation cases brought by writer E. Jean Carroll, and a 2018 order dissolving the Donald J. Trump Foundation over fraud claims.
- The prosecution called its first witness, former National Enquirer publisher David Pecker. Prosecutors say Pecker bought the rights to stories that would be damaging to Donald Trump’s campaign, then didn’t publish them in what’s called a “catch and kill” scheme.
Jurors Dismissed For The Day
At about 12:25 p.m., Merchan dismissed the jury early for Passover and one juror's scheduling conflict.
Pecker On Pecking Order
Around 2015, Dylan Howard was serving as the National Enquirer’s editor in chief and as chief content officer for all of AMI. Howard reported to Pecker, he said, and his job was “to ensure we had the most exclusive and current content.
Prosecutor Joshua Steinglass asked Pecker to confirm that a health issue has prevented Howard from appearing at the trial, which he did.
Prosecutor Joshua Steinglass asked Pecker to confirm that a health issue has prevented Howard from appearing at the trial, which he did.
Pecker Dishes On 'Checkbook Journalism'
Asked whether he had final say over publishing decisions made by the National Enquirer and other publications, Pecker replied: “Yes … at least on the tabloid side.”
“We used checkbook journalism and we paid for stories,” he said. Pecker said he generally told his editors that they could not spend more than $10,000 on a story without seeking further approval.
“We used checkbook journalism and we paid for stories,” he said. Pecker said he generally told his editors that they could not spend more than $10,000 on a story without seeking further approval.
Remembering The Time Pecker Tried To Publish Jeff Bezos’ Dick Pics
Back in 2019, Pecker threatened to publish embarrassing photos of Jeff Bezos after the Amazon magnate (and owner of the Washington Post) ordered an investigation of Enquirer parent company American Media Inc.
According to Bezos, Pecker was “apoplectic” about a Washington Post investigation into his companies, particularly on links between AMI and the Saudi royal family.
Bezos called the Enquirer’s bluff in a public blog — and Pecker wilted.
“Rather than capitulate to extortion and blackmail, I’ve decided to publish exactly what they sent me, despite the personal cost and embarrassment they threaten,” Bezos wrote.
“I won’t participate in their well-known practice of blackmail, political favors, political attacks, and corruption. I prefer to stand up, roll this log over, and see what crawls out.”
Private investigators hired by Bezos “concluded with high confidence that the Saudis had access to Bezos’ phone and gained private information” and accused AMI of being “in league with a foreign nation that’s been actively trying to harm American citizens and companies.”
Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed Bin Salman in 2018 ordered the murder of Washington Post journalist Jamal Khashoggi in retaliation for negative coverage of the regime.
A separate investigator, meanwhile, said he believed sensitive information had also been leaked by the brother of Lauren Sanchez, whom Bezos is now engaged to.
AMI responded by saying it launched an investigation into Bezos’ claims, though the company denied its conduct reached the level of blackmail and believes it “acted lawfully.”
Pecker stepped down as AMI CEO In August 2020.
According to Bezos, Pecker was “apoplectic” about a Washington Post investigation into his companies, particularly on links between AMI and the Saudi royal family.
Bezos called the Enquirer’s bluff in a public blog — and Pecker wilted.
“Rather than capitulate to extortion and blackmail, I’ve decided to publish exactly what they sent me, despite the personal cost and embarrassment they threaten,” Bezos wrote.
“I won’t participate in their well-known practice of blackmail, political favors, political attacks, and corruption. I prefer to stand up, roll this log over, and see what crawls out.”
Private investigators hired by Bezos “concluded with high confidence that the Saudis had access to Bezos’ phone and gained private information” and accused AMI of being “in league with a foreign nation that’s been actively trying to harm American citizens and companies.”
Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed Bin Salman in 2018 ordered the murder of Washington Post journalist Jamal Khashoggi in retaliation for negative coverage of the regime.
A separate investigator, meanwhile, said he believed sensitive information had also been leaked by the brother of Lauren Sanchez, whom Bezos is now engaged to.
AMI responded by saying it launched an investigation into Bezos’ claims, though the company denied its conduct reached the level of blackmail and believes it “acted lawfully.”
Pecker stepped down as AMI CEO In August 2020.
Jurors Ask For Note-Taking Materials
Merchan paused Pecker’s testimony briefly to allow the jurors the chance to raise their hands if they wanted note-taking materials. Nearly all of them did so.
Government Calls David Pecker As First Witness
David Pecker, former publisher of the National Enquirer and head of AMI, is the prosecution's first witness. Pecker, dressed in a grey suit and yellow tie with grey hair combed back, has been sworn in.
Trump Silent As He Leaves Courtroom
Opening statements have now concluded. Trump did not speak to reporters as he left the courtroom, instead showing a raised fist.
Trump Attorney Paints Case As A Non-Story
Over the course of his opener, Blanche tried to color the charges as insignificant and tried to put as much distance as he could between Trump and the alleged criminal conduct.
He suggested that the “catch and kill” schemes involving the National Enquirer’s publisher were not so unusual and that the evidence involved was ancient history. The conversations at the center of the trial occurred from 2015 to 2017 — or as Blanche put it, "years and years ago."
He suggested that the “catch and kill” schemes involving the National Enquirer’s publisher were not so unusual and that the evidence involved was ancient history. The conversations at the center of the trial occurred from 2015 to 2017 — or as Blanche put it, "years and years ago."
Trump’s Family Absent From Courtroom
None of Trump’s family members appear to be in the courtroom for the day’s proceedings, NBC notes.
Melania Trump did break her silence Monday — with a sales pitch for a $245 necklace she’s hawking for Mother’s Day.
Melania Trump did break her silence Monday — with a sales pitch for a $245 necklace she’s hawking for Mother’s Day.
Trump Attorney Shifts Focus To Stormy Daniels
“She’s similarly extremely biased against President Trump,” Blanche said of Daniels. He added that he while he expects Daniel to testify, he does not believe she has "any idea” about the alleged criminal behavior at the heart of the trial.
“So her testimony, while salacious, does not matter,” he said.
“So her testimony, while salacious, does not matter,” he said.
Objections Prompt Pause
Merchan asked the parties to approach the bench after a series of objections made by the prosecution during a prolonged attack on Cohen's credibility.
“He has a goal and an obsession with getting President Trump. I submit to you that he cannot be trusted," Blanche told jurors of Trump's former personal attorney.
“He has a goal and an obsession with getting President Trump. I submit to you that he cannot be trusted," Blanche told jurors of Trump's former personal attorney.
Trump Attorney Begins Attacks On Michael Cohen
Blanche acknowledged that while Cohen was “very loyal” to Trump and his companies “for many years,” Cohen was also allegedly cheating on his taxes and lying to banks “unbeknownst to President Trump."
Blanche also claimed: “Michael Cohen wanted a job in the administration. He didn’t get one.”
In 2019, Cohen testified that he "was offered jobs" in the White House but "did not want to go to the White House." Trump's sons, Donald Trump, Jr. and Eric Trump, claimed Cohen wanted to be chief of staff.
Blanche also claimed: “Michael Cohen wanted a job in the administration. He didn’t get one.”
In 2019, Cohen testified that he "was offered jobs" in the White House but "did not want to go to the White House." Trump's sons, Donald Trump, Jr. and Eric Trump, claimed Cohen wanted to be chief of staff.
Trump Attorney Suggests ‘Influence’ Over Election Is Part Of Democracy
“I have a spoiler alert: There’s nothing wrong with trying to influence an election. It’s called democracy,” Blanche said, continuing to downplay the allegations against his client.
“Entering into a nondisclosure agreement is perfectly legal,” Blanche said. “You will learn that companies do that all the time with some regularity.”
“There’s nothing illegal about it.”
“Entering into a nondisclosure agreement is perfectly legal,” Blanche said. “You will learn that companies do that all the time with some regularity.”
“There’s nothing illegal about it.”
Trump Distanced From Allegedly Falsified Ledger
"President Trump had nothing to do with any of the 34 pieces of paper … except he signed the checks in the White House while he was running the country. That’s not a crime,” Blanche said.
Blanche Plays Down 34 Counts Against Trump
Trump's attorney told the jurors that the 34 counts correspond to the repayments Cohen received in installments of $35,000 over a series of months.
“The 34 counts … are really just 34 pieces of paper,” Blanche said. "None of this was a crime."
“The 34 counts … are really just 34 pieces of paper,” Blanche said. "None of this was a crime."
Trump Team Begins Opening Statement By Humanizing Ex-President
“President Trump is innocent. President Trump did not commit any crimes,” Trump attorney Todd Blanche said, adding that this case should never have been brought. Blanche said because Trump has “earned" the title of president, “We will call him ‘President Trump’ out of respect.”
“He’s also a man. He’s a husband. He’s a father. He’s a person just like you and just like me,” Blanche said.
“He’s also a man. He’s a husband. He’s a father. He’s a person just like you and just like me,” Blanche said.
Trump's Own Words Will Be Shown
Colangelo told jurors that he was confident they would conclude that “Donald Trump is guilty of falsifying business records with intent to conceal an illegal conspiracy to undermine the integrity of a presidential election.”
Cohen’s testimony will be backed up by testimony from Pecker and McDougal attorney Keith Davidson, along with “an extensive paper trial, bank records, emails, text messages, phone logs, business documents and other records that we will show you sometimes at length during this trial,” he said. Trump’s own words on tape, from social media posts, his books and video of his speeches will also be shown.
Cohen’s testimony will be backed up by testimony from Pecker and McDougal attorney Keith Davidson, along with “an extensive paper trial, bank records, emails, text messages, phone logs, business documents and other records that we will show you sometimes at length during this trial,” he said. Trump’s own words on tape, from social media posts, his books and video of his speeches will also be shown.
‘What Have We Done?’
As it became clearer and clearer that Trump might actually win the 2016 election, Karen McDougal's lawyer Keith Davidson seemed to have regrets about agreeing to the "catch and kill" scheme.
Colangelo says Davidson sent a message to National Enquirer editor Dylan Howard expressing unease: “What have we done?”
Colangelo says Davidson sent a message to National Enquirer editor Dylan Howard expressing unease: “What have we done?”
Details On Trump’s Cohen Reimbursement
The prosecution outlined the crux of the case: How Trump managed to pay Cohen back for the hush money Stormy Daniels received. They couldn’t just write “reimbursement for porn star payoff” in the memo line of the repayment checks, Colangelo quipped, so they "cooked the books." The result was 34 allegedly falsified business records for “legal services.”
“That was a double lie,” he said. “There was no retainer agreement... It was instead what they thought was a clever way to pay Cohen back without being too obvious about it.”
Trump agreed to pay Cohen a total of $420,000: They started with the $130,000 hush money payment, added $50,000 that Cohen said he was owed for campaign tech services, then agreed to double that amount to account for taxes Cohen would owe, and then added $60,000 as a year-end bonus. Colangelo noted that it was highly unusual for the Trump Organization to pay anyone double what they’re owed “for anything.” Trump's willingness to do so allegedly highlighted how important the matter was to him.
“You will see evidence at trial that Donald Trump is a very frugal businessman,” he said.
“That was a double lie,” he said. “There was no retainer agreement... It was instead what they thought was a clever way to pay Cohen back without being too obvious about it.”
Trump agreed to pay Cohen a total of $420,000: They started with the $130,000 hush money payment, added $50,000 that Cohen said he was owed for campaign tech services, then agreed to double that amount to account for taxes Cohen would owe, and then added $60,000 as a year-end bonus. Colangelo noted that it was highly unusual for the Trump Organization to pay anyone double what they’re owed “for anything.” Trump's willingness to do so allegedly highlighted how important the matter was to him.
“You will see evidence at trial that Donald Trump is a very frugal businessman,” he said.
Prosecutor Introduces Stormy Daniels Payment
After the “Access Hollywood” tape became public and elicited a huge backlash against Trump, his team had to figure out what to do about a third person who came forward with negative information about then-candidate Trump — Stormy Daniels.
Trump allegedly directed Cohen to try and delay finalizing the deal as long as possible. He also allegedly tried to get AMI to cover the payment, as they did for McDougal.
But Pecker was unhappy that he had never been paid back for the McDougal deal, Colangelo said. That’s why Cohen ended up transferring the $130,000 to Daniels.
"It was election fraud, pure and simple," Colangelo said.
Trump allegedly directed Cohen to try and delay finalizing the deal as long as possible. He also allegedly tried to get AMI to cover the payment, as they did for McDougal.
But Pecker was unhappy that he had never been paid back for the McDougal deal, Colangelo said. That’s why Cohen ended up transferring the $130,000 to Daniels.
"It was election fraud, pure and simple," Colangelo said.
Prosecutor Reads Part Of ‘Access Hollywood’ Transcript
Colangelo read part of the infamous “Access Hollywood” tape transcript to the jury, introducing the panel to the Washington Post scoop that threw the Trump campaign into turmoil.
Prosecutor Outlines 'Catch And Kill' Deals
Prosecutor Colangelo is outlining the three “catch and kill” deals that he says came out of the 2015 Trump Tower meeting.
The first came from a former Trump Tower doorman who claimed that Trump had fathered a child out of wedlock. After Pecker’s publishing company, AMI, determined the story was not true, Cohen allegedly told him to wait to release the doorman from his nondisclosure agreement until after the 2016 election, when it could no longer hurt Trump’s campaign.
The second “catch and kill” deal was the account from former Playboy playmate Karen McDougal, who says she had an affair with Trump for around a year while he was married. Cohen allegedly asked AMI to make arrangements to purchase McDougal’s story quickly and confidentially, and AMI ultimately agreed on a sum of $150,000. Trump initially intended to pay AMI back, Colangelo said, and had his attorney Cohen set up a shell company in order to facilitate that payment, but the deal fell apart.
Colangelo told jurors they will hear a recorded phone call that Cohen made between himself and Trump regarding that payment.
The first came from a former Trump Tower doorman who claimed that Trump had fathered a child out of wedlock. After Pecker’s publishing company, AMI, determined the story was not true, Cohen allegedly told him to wait to release the doorman from his nondisclosure agreement until after the 2016 election, when it could no longer hurt Trump’s campaign.
The second “catch and kill” deal was the account from former Playboy playmate Karen McDougal, who says she had an affair with Trump for around a year while he was married. Cohen allegedly asked AMI to make arrangements to purchase McDougal’s story quickly and confidentially, and AMI ultimately agreed on a sum of $150,000. Trump initially intended to pay AMI back, Colangelo said, and had his attorney Cohen set up a shell company in order to facilitate that payment, but the deal fell apart.
Colangelo told jurors they will hear a recorded phone call that Cohen made between himself and Trump regarding that payment.
Prosecutors' Opening Statement Continues
Colangelo is outlining the broad strokes of the case, beginning with an alleged 2015 Trump Tower meeting between Trump, Cohen and AMI CEO David Pecker, who was publishing the National Enquirer tabloid at the time.
"Those three men formed a conspiracy at that meeting to influence the presidential election by concealing negative information about Trump in order to help him get elected,” Colangelo said.
The meeting allegedly resulted in three decisions: that Pecker would act as the “eyes and ears” for the Trump campaign, that he would use his publications to push flattering stories about Trump, and that he would also use them to attack Trump’s political enemies.
“As the man in charge of AMI, Pecker had the ultimate say over publication decisions,” Colangelo said, noting that Trump’s team was allowed to review stories before they were published and have a say in any accompanying illustrations. He also explained the concept of "catch and kill," wherein publishers buy damaging information from a source in order to prevent its release.
"Those three men formed a conspiracy at that meeting to influence the presidential election by concealing negative information about Trump in order to help him get elected,” Colangelo said.
The meeting allegedly resulted in three decisions: that Pecker would act as the “eyes and ears” for the Trump campaign, that he would use his publications to push flattering stories about Trump, and that he would also use them to attack Trump’s political enemies.
“As the man in charge of AMI, Pecker had the ultimate say over publication decisions,” Colangelo said, noting that Trump’s team was allowed to review stories before they were published and have a say in any accompanying illustrations. He also explained the concept of "catch and kill," wherein publishers buy damaging information from a source in order to prevent its release.
Opening Statements Begin
“The defendant, Donald Trump, orchestrated a criminal scheme to disrupt the 2016 presidential election,” prosecuting attorney Matthew Colangelo told the jurors, adding that Trump then lied about it “over and over and over again.”
Jurors Can Only Tell Family, Employers That They Are On The Jury
The jurors are not permitted to discuss anything relating to the case with their family, friends, employers or others. They can only reveal the basic fact that they are on the jury. Merchan told them to report directly to him if anyone tries to influence their opinion in the case.
Lawyers Can't Comment On Witnesses' Testimony, Judge Says
Judge Merchan said lawyers won't be allowed to comment on the testimony of witnesses during the trial, according to CNN.
"That happens on TV and in the movies, that does not happen in real trials," he said.
Meanwhile, HuffPost's Sara Boboltz reports the 12 jurors are giving Merchan their full attention, with some looking somber.
"That happens on TV and in the movies, that does not happen in real trials," he said.
Meanwhile, HuffPost's Sara Boboltz reports the 12 jurors are giving Merchan their full attention, with some looking somber.
Jury Takes Their Seats
The 12 members of the jury have taken their seats ahead of the start of opening arguments. Judge Merchan is providing them with instructions around the basic tenets of the criminal justice system, including explaining that the burden of proof lies with the prosecutors.
Judge Allows Some Of Trump's Past Legal Issues To Come Up In Trial
The judge said that, if Trump testifies in the trial, the prosecution will be allowed to tell the jury about four past legal entanglements that ended poorly for Trump in order to impeach his credibility.
They will be able to bring up the February verdict finding that Trump fraudulently stated the value of his assets for economic benefit, including two instances in that case in which Trump was fined a total of $15,000 for violating a court order by attacking the judge’s law clerk.
Prosecutors can also bring up the outcome of two defamation-related cases brought by the writer E. Jean Carroll, and a 2018 order dissolving the Donald J. Trump Foundation, the former president's charitable organization, over fraud claims.
They will be able to bring up the February verdict finding that Trump fraudulently stated the value of his assets for economic benefit, including two instances in that case in which Trump was fined a total of $15,000 for violating a court order by attacking the judge’s law clerk.
Prosecutors can also bring up the outcome of two defamation-related cases brought by the writer E. Jean Carroll, and a 2018 order dissolving the Donald J. Trump Foundation, the former president's charitable organization, over fraud claims.
Yuki Iwamura/Pool via Associated Press
See Trump Seated Inside The Courtroom
Trump posed for photographers after taking his seat inside the courtroom.
Brendan McDermid/Pool/AFP via Getty Images
Trump Lashes Out At New York AG Letitia James Ahead Of Trial Start
Ahead of entering the courtroom, Trump spoke to the cameras, lashing out at New York Attorney General Letitia James, who has brought a separate civil trial against the former president. Trump deemed her responsible for what he described as business leaving the state.
"Nobody is gonna be listening or coming to New York anymore. Businesses are gonna be fleeing because people are treated so badly,” Trump said.
He continued: “It’s got to be the most unfriendly place to do business and that’s why businesses are leaving and people are leaving.”
Meanwhile, Trump ignored shouted questions from reporters on topics including his wife’s whereabouts, whether he plans to take the witness stand and whether he is stressed about the prospect of getting convicted in the case.
"Nobody is gonna be listening or coming to New York anymore. Businesses are gonna be fleeing because people are treated so badly,” Trump said.
He continued: “It’s got to be the most unfriendly place to do business and that’s why businesses are leaving and people are leaving.”
Meanwhile, Trump ignored shouted questions from reporters on topics including his wife’s whereabouts, whether he plans to take the witness stand and whether he is stressed about the prospect of getting convicted in the case.
Another Juror Voices Concerns About Media Attention
Merchan said that a juror contacted the court over the weekend to express concerns about the level of media attention the trial has elicited, echoing the concerns heard from certain prospective jurors during proceedings last week. The judge confirmed that she would continue serving.
Opening Statements Will Be Roughly 1 Hour Total
Prosecutors told Merchan they need about 40 minutes to make their opening statements. The defense said they need about 25 minutes.
Donald Trump Arrives For Opening Statements
The former president is now seated in the courtroom and chatting intermittently with his attorneys.
Stefan Jeremiah via Associated Press
Trump Claims His Supporters Aren't Allowed To Protest Outside Court
In a series of posts on his Truth Social account, the former president claimed it was "SO UNFAIR" his supporters couldn't gather outside the courthouse to protest his prosecution as students at Columbia University held pro-Palestinian protests over the weekend calling for a cease-fire in the Gaza war.
"But why aren’t Country Loving Republicans allowed to peacefully protest around the Courthouse, where I am right now. It’s like an armed camp. MAGA2024!" Trump wrote.
"But why aren’t Country Loving Republicans allowed to peacefully protest around the Courthouse, where I am right now. It’s like an armed camp. MAGA2024!" Trump wrote.
The First Witness Set To Testify In The Trial
David Pecker, the former publisher of the National Enquirer, is the first witness the prosecution is planning to call to the stand, The New York Times reported.
Pecker oversaw the purchase of several potentially damaging stories on Trump in the lead-up to the 2016 presidential election. Prosecutors will ask Pecker about conversations he had with Trump about hush money payments, according to the NYT.
Pecker oversaw the purchase of several potentially damaging stories on Trump in the lead-up to the 2016 presidential election. Prosecutors will ask Pecker about conversations he had with Trump about hush money payments, according to the NYT.
Trump Forced To Cancel Weekend Rally Due To A Storm
The former president was forced to cancel his first planned rally since the start of his criminal trial over dangerous weather conditions in North Carolina.
As Bill Barrow of The Associated Press writes, "The cancellation denied Trump a fresh chance to amplify claims that his multiple pending indictments are an establishment conspiracy to take him down — and, by extension, squelch the voters who first elected him eight years ago."
You can read more from the story here.
As Bill Barrow of The Associated Press writes, "The cancellation denied Trump a fresh chance to amplify claims that his multiple pending indictments are an establishment conspiracy to take him down — and, by extension, squelch the voters who first elected him eight years ago."
You can read more from the story here.
MSNBC Analyst Claims Trump Was Asleep In Court
Courtroom observers will surely be watching Trump this week to see if he appears to be asleep, as some reported last week.
"I was in the courtroom. I saw him falling asleep," MSNBC analyst Jonathan Alter told the network’s Ayman Mohyeldin. "This is not 'reportedly.’ This actually happened."
HuffPost's reporter noticed that Trump's eyes were closed at certain points but couldn't confirm if he was actually asleep.
"I was in the courtroom. I saw him falling asleep," MSNBC analyst Jonathan Alter told the network’s Ayman Mohyeldin. "This is not 'reportedly.’ This actually happened."
HuffPost's reporter noticed that Trump's eyes were closed at certain points but couldn't confirm if he was actually asleep.
Melania Trump Resurfaces With Sales Pitch
Former first lady Melania Trump hasn't appeared with her husband during his legal proceedings.
But she did attend a political event over the weekend, and has emerged on social media trying to sell a $245 necklace for Mother's Day that features her signature.
But she did attend a political event over the weekend, and has emerged on social media trying to sell a $245 necklace for Mother's Day that features her signature.
Trump Heads To The Courthouse
CNN showed images of Trump departing his residence at Trump Tower for the courtroom.
Trump Takes To Truth Social Ahead Of Week 2
Trump finished off his weekend by complaining about Alvin Bragg on Truth Social, calling him a "Corrupt Soros Funded District Attorney" who "has totally lost control of Violent Crime in New York."
Early Monday morning, he appeared to encourage MAGA fans to protest "at the front steps of Courthouses, all over the Country." He claimed that "Palestinian protesters, and even rioters" are allowed to "basically do whatever they want."
Early Monday morning, he appeared to encourage MAGA fans to protest "at the front steps of Courthouses, all over the Country." He claimed that "Palestinian protesters, and even rioters" are allowed to "basically do whatever they want."
Stay Tuned For Updates From Week 2
We'll be blogging Trump's trial as soon as court is underway.
Catch up on last week's proceedings here:
Catch up on last week's proceedings here:
Advertisement