This HuffPost Canada page is maintained as part of an online archive.

It Seems Density Doesn't Exactly Equal Affordability In Vancouver

Many people are thinking: Vancouver embraced density, so where's the affordability? If last year's speech was controversial for being blunt about how we need to change our housing expectations to live in the city, this year's speech was surprising for another reason -- Bob Rennie insinuated that Vancouver was inevitably going to get too expensive for middle-class people.
|
This post was published on the now-closed HuffPost Contributor platform. Contributors control their own work and posted freely to our site. If you need to flag this entry as abusive, send us an email.
Open Image Modal
Brian Stablyk via Getty Images
One of the Worlds most Densely Populated Areas, Vancouver-Canada

Written by Stephanie MacDonald

For such a smart, friendly, funny person, Bob Rennie has experienced more than his share of being vilified by the public. He's often seen as the face of the development industry (despite not being a developer) in a city with a very limited amount of land, and a reputation as one of the most desirable, and expensive, places in the world to live.

Rennie has been a vocal cheerleader for the city, writing open letters to the newspaper in favour of the 2010 Olympics, and was instrumental in creating the global demand for land and condominiums we're seeing today. He's one of the most phenomenally successful and visible businesspeople the city has ever seen.

But in this year's highly anticipated speech for the Urban Development Institute he made one thing clear -- he's pretty much over talking about real estate. In fact, he announced that this would be his last speech; despite the over 1,000 enthusiastic listeners gathered at the Hotel Vancouver to hear what he had to say. Last year at the 2015 UDI luncheon, Rennie spoke extensively about the issue of affordability in the city and the 19 factors he believes contribute to the crisis of affordability we're experiencing.

He bravely said what everyone else was thinking: without an adequate supply of housing types, prices will continue to go up, and in order to create this supply we will have to sacrifice single-family neighbourhoods. Rennie himself lives in a condo, preferring to spend his considerable wealth on philanthropic causes and his contemporary art gallery, so he is walking the walk when he's talking about the benefits of densification.

But now many people are thinking: Vancouver embraced density, so where's the affordability?

If last year's speech was controversial for being blunt about how we need to change our housing expectations to live in the city, this year's speech was surprising for another reason -- Rennie insinuated that Vancouver was inevitably going to get too expensive for middle-class people and they should just be resigned to moving out into the suburbs.

The prices are so high that the middle-class consumer cannot even afford the multi-family units created.

It seems a bit defeatist compared to his statements only a year ago, though it was good news for the many companies creating housing in the Fraser Valley. He mentioned the millennials' increasing penchant for working from home, the acceptance of densification around suburban transit centres, and the fact that in cities like New York, the population doubles every work day with commuters from the 'burbs.

It did seem a bit odd that in one year we're supposed to go from "densification is the answer" to "urban sprawl is inevitable, so we better get used to it."

He seems visibly weary of talking about the huge market demand for condos which he helped to create. He also passed on really discussing the issue of foreign ownership, saying that it only affects the single-family home market. But if single-family homes need to go by the wayside to make room for more density, all the foreign speculation is just driving up the prices so that developers cannot even afford to assemble the land, and if they can, the prices are so high that the middle-class consumer cannot even afford the multi-family units created (see the Cambie Corridor).

Being the "condo king" (a title he hates) is clearly not where Rennie's heart is anymore -- and it has been several years since he has really been at the helm of Rennie Marketing Systems. What he does obviously feel passion about is the Rennie Gallery, where his collection of contemporary art is considered one of the most carefully curated in North America.

He's also on the acquisitions board of the Tate London and various other galleries. His focus is on art that explores difference, race, exploitation and social justice issues -- issues that are often the result of the financial inequity we're experiencing right now in the world and, ironically, in our housing market. Certainly his considerable talent and energy will enliven the important conversations around these topics, and the contemporary art world in general, in the future.

Read the original story at YPNextHome.ca.

Follow HuffPost Canada Blogs on Facebook

MORE ON HUFFPOST:

Canadian Islands That Cost Less Than A Vancouver Condo
American Island(01 of10)
Open Image Modal
Location: Stuart Lake, B.C.Price: $175,000American Island is 8 acres (3.24 hectares) in size, and has a kilometre of shoreline to run around on. The island is the seventh-largest in B.C., running 90 kilometres north-south, and 13 kilometres east-west. It has plenty of trees, and two bays good perfect for mooring boats.(Photo: PrivateIslandsOnline.com) (credit:PrivateIslandsOnline.com)
Sweet Island(02 of10)
Open Image Modal
Location: Stuart Lake, B.C.Price: $85,476Like American Island, Sweet Island is also in Stuart Lake — a great spot fishing rainbow trout, char, lake trout, and sturgeon.Sweet Island has a high elevation with no cliffs and boasts tons of pine and aspen trees. There's already old house for accomodation, and a half-acre clearing for a garden. The entire island is 66 kilometres long, 10 kilometres wide, and has 170 kilometres of shoreline.And if anyone ever needs a break on the mainland, the town of Fort St. James is also on Lake Stuart's shoreline with full services like lodges and motels.(Photo: Private Islands Online) (credit:PrivateIslandsOnline.com)
Big Tusket Island Parcel(03 of10)
Open Image Modal
Location: Tusket Island Chain, Yarmouth County, N.S.Price: $65,000A great place for a summer retreat, the Big Tusket Island Parcel is actually two pieces of land that total 37 acres of size.The chain, a group of granite islands located off of Nova Scotia's Southwestern coast, is primarily uninhabited. The islands offer a very natural environment and is home to a number of unique lighthouses. There's electricity on both islands, and amenities are available in Comeau's Hill — an attractive Acadian coastal town.(Photo: PrivateIslandsOnline.com) (credit:PrivateIslandsOnline.com)
Lizzies Cove Island(04 of10)
Open Image Modal
Location: Lama Passage, B.C.Price: $249,000Lizzies Cove Island is a magnificent 6.5-acre, virgin-forested island with almost two kilometres of ocean front.Cruise ships and killer whales regularly pass by one side of the island, and fishing in the area is "superb," according to its listing.The nearby town of Bella Bella offers plenty of amenities, including a hospital, post office, and liquor store.(Photo: Private Islands Online) (credit:PrivateIslandsOnline.com)
Big Tancook Island(05 of10)
Open Image Modal
Location: Mahone Bay, N.S.Price: $90,000 At 11.5 acres, Tancook Island is the largest island in Mahone Bay — an area with lots of fishing and about 125 year-round residents. (Photo: Private Islands Online) (credit:PrivateIslandsOnline.com)
Johnson Island(06 of10)
Open Image Modal
Location: Stuart Lake, B.C.Price: $431,482Johnson Island is a private, 20-acre space that has been occupied by the same family since 1947. It has about one kilometre of shoreline, and the cabin's beachfront has stunning views of the northern lights and stunning sunsets.The cabin, built in 1949, is made of reclaimed old growth timber from the island. It has a large front room divided into a kitchen, as well as a comfortable dining room. The house, which sleeps six people, also has a detached shower room and smokehouse. Access is by float plane or boat, the latter of which can be launched from the nearby village of Tachi.(Photo: Private Islands Online) (credit:PrivateIslandsOnline.com)
Little Island(07 of10)
Open Image Modal
Location: Ontario, near Manitoulin IslandPrice: $103,000Little Island, or Jenny Island, is a historically significant commercial fishing outport, where the fisherman and their families lived for the season during the 1800s and early 1900s.The land is accessible both by boat and by plane.(Photo: Private Islands Online) (credit:PrivateIslandsOnline.com)
Round Island(08 of10)
Open Image Modal
Location: Southern Gulf Islands, B.C.Price: $380,000This 7.5-acre property has been left entirely in its natural state. Located in the southern Gulf Islands, it's a completely private island with an impressive fir forest.The island isn't far from Ladysmith, and sits in the Stuart Channel.(Photo: Private Islands Online) (credit:PrivateIslandsOnline.com)
Tidmarsh Island(09 of10)
Open Image Modal
Location: Mitchell Bay, N.S.Price: $150,000Just 290 metres from the mainland, Tidmarsh Island has 24 acres of land that boats a thick forest a natural cove for mooring. Halifax is about two hours away, and the town of Sheet Harbour — with shops and amenities — is less than a half-hour trip.(Photo: Private Islands Online) (credit:PrivateIslandsOnline.com)
Echo Island(10 of10)
Open Image Modal
Location: B.C.Price: $449,000Echo Island, which is a 25-minute flight in a float plane from Williams Lake, is made up of four, one-acre lots. There's a dedicated road just for the island, a bridge crossing for ATVs, and pedestrian access from mainland to island.There's also a 15-metre dock neighbouring the two-bedroom cabin. (Photo: Private Islands Online (credit:PrivateIslandsOnline.com)
-- This HuffPost Canada page is maintained as part of an online archive. If you have questions or concerns, please check our FAQ or contact support@huffpost.com.