Justin Trudeau Vows To Scrap First Nations Financial Transparency Act | HuffPost

This HuffPost Canada page is maintained as part of an online archive.

Trudeau Vows To Scrap First Nations Disclosure Bill

The Huffington Post Canada

|

CP

Justin Trudeau has promised to scrap a controversial law forcing First Nations leaders to disclose salaries and band financial statements online and replace it with something more "respectful" if he becomes prime minister in 2015.

Trudeau told The Vancouver Sun the First Nations Financial Transparency Act, passed in 2013 amid complaints from many aboriginal leaders, has been used as a "weapon" against critics of the Stephen Harper government.

"I wouldn't keep the legislation in place," Trudeau told the newspaper. "I would work with First Nations to make sure that a proper accountability act that would have disclosed any excesses we see, but is done in a way that is respectful of the First Nation communities."

The law requires First Nations bands post audited financial statements — including remunerations of chiefs and councillors — on their websites within 120 days of the end of the financial year. Smaller bands without websites can post them to the sites of larger First Nations groups or a site hosted by the Department of Aboriginal Affairs.

The department is publishing the documents online as they are received from more than 600 First Nations bands. As of Monday afternoon, documents from less than 250 bands were posted, despite a deadline to submit the information by July 29.

After the rules came into effect two weeks ago, it was revealed Kwikwetlem First Nation Chief Ron Giesbrecht received nearly $1 million in remuneration last year for serving as leader and economic development officer of his B.C. band.

Tory MP Mark Strahl, parliamentary secretary to the minister of Aboriginal Affairs, was quick to throw a dig at both the Liberals and NDP after the jaw-dropping disclosure.

The Canadian Taxpayers Federation, which has long advocated for the legislation, urged Trudeau to rethink his position Monday.

"We have heard some very heartbreaking tales from people on reserves who have been bullied, harassed and assaulted for daring to ask questions about where public funds are going in their communities," said Colin Craig, CTF Prairie director, in a statement.

"The new First Nations Financial Transparency Act allows them to go on the Internet and view their community's financial statements anonymously, without fear of reprisal."

The group also advised the Liberal leader not to try to use the issue to score political points on Conservatives.

But some aboriginal leaders deeply resent the legislation. As pointed out by CBC News, First Nations groups already produce financial statements to the federal government and some believe posting them online is about little more than sowing divisions.

In fact, one of Trudeau's star candidates for the next federal election has expressed such concerns.

Jody Wilson-Raybould, the B.C. regional chief of the Assembly of First Nations who was acclaimed to run for the Liberals in the new riding of Vancouver-Granville, suggested before a Commons committee in 2012 the act was an attempt to interfere in how First Nations govern themselves.

"Chiefs were clear in their assertion that these proposed measures… are both heavy-handed and unnecessary, and they suggest that First Nations governments are corrupt and our leaders are not transparent and consequently need to be regulated by Ottawa," she said.

"It is not surprising that many of our chiefs have resented this approach and are turning the lens back on Canada, suggesting that it is Canada that needs to develop more stringent accountability frameworks for their governing bodies, that it is Canada that needs to be held more accountable for the treatment of First Nations."

An Ontario chief recently accused Wilson-Raybould of a "gross conflict" for refusing to give up her AFN job while standing as a candidate for the Liberals.

Last week, Aboriginal Affairs Minister Bernard Valcourt said bands that don't post their statements online by the end of November could risk having government funding withheld.

Some First Nations leaders have already threatened to fight back with blockades and court battles.

On Monday, Valcourt released a statement accusing Trudeau of taking the side of chiefs like Wilson-Raybould who he said wish to keep "basical financial information" hidden from the Canadian taxpayers and their communities.

"We put this legislation in place to empower community members and ensure that they are informed of their community’s financial situation," he said in the statement. "The fact that Justin Trudeau would give opponents of transparency and accountability an easy way out is an affront to the community members and taxpayers this act is intended to serve."

Like Us On Facebook

Also on HuffPost

11 Things We Won't Forget About The Spring Sitting Of Parliament

11 Things We Won't Forget About The Spring Sitting Of Parliament(01 of48)

HuffPost Canada's Ottawa bureau chief Althia Raj looks back at the highlights and lowlights of the spring session of Parliament. (credit:The Canadian Press)

1. Board of Internal Economy/NDP mailings(02 of48)

The secretive board broke a tradition of working by consensus after it found that 23 NDP MPs had broken rules governing large volume mail. The board said the electoral letters should have been paid for by the party. It also said MPs owed a combined $36,309 to the House for envelopes and toner and $1.13 million to Canada Post for franking privileges.The board is also pursuing a study of NDP satellite offices, despite the objection of the two NDP MPs on the committee. New Democrats say they will not pay the money and vow a legal challenge, calling the board's action a "ridiculous witch-hunt" by a kangaroo court.The board is also looking into the use of per diems and secondary — housing allowances — those expenses that got senators such as Mike Duffy into trouble. Commons staff are reviewing each MP’s usage and warning party whips of what they find. The rules may be revamped. (credit:The Canadian Press)

2. Harper’s battle with the Supreme Court(03 of48)

After the Supreme Court of Canada ruled against the federal government’s desired go-it-alone Senate reform plans, softened two tough-on-crime measures the Conservatives introduced and said Justice Marc Nadon was ineligible to sit on the top court, Conservatives fought back. Prime Minister Stephen Harper insinuated that the Chief Justice Beverley McLachlin had inappropriately tried to contact him to discuss Nadon’s candidacy. Weeks later, however, Canadians learned that McLachlin never attempted to influence either Harper or Justice Minister Peter MacKay on Nadon’s appointment. Instead, it appears that she tried to warn them of potential constitutional problems with appointing four of the nominees on the government’s short list. (credit:The Canadian Press)

3. Jim Flaherty's death(04 of48)

The former finance minister’s death stunned parliamentarians on April 10. The 64-year-old died of an apparent heart attack, a few weeks after announcing his retirement from politics. He resigned his finance portfolio but kept his seat after a public spat with the Prime Minister and Employment Minister Jason Kenney over the government’s desire to implement income splitting – a costly the promise the Tories ran on in 2011 but one that Flaherty believed would benefit too few Canadians. Flaherty, who was well loved by opposition MPs, united the Hill in a brief moment of collegiality and genuine grief. (credit:The Canadian Press)

4. The Fair Elections Act(05 of48)

In a rare scene, political critics, civil society and even some of its own MPs united against the government’s proposed changes to the Canada Elections Act. The Tories tried to stack the deck in their favour by revamping fundraising rules and severely limiting some Canadians’ ability to vote. After the outcry, Democratic Reform Minister Pierre Poilievre agreed to scrap several of the bill’s most contentious provisions, such as big fundraising loophole and the elimination of vouching. (credit:The Canadian Press)

5. Robocalls(06 of48)

It looks like Canadians will never know exactly what happened during the last federal election when thousands of voters received illegal calls misinforming them their polling station had moved. The Commissioner of Elections Canada issued a summary report in April finding that, despite not having the cooperation of a key witness or being able to listen or track most of the calls, it believed there had been no wide conspiracy to suppress the vote.In June, the trial of former Conservative staffer Michael Sona, the only person charged over the misleading calls in Guelph, provided few answers. The Crown’s key witness, Andrew Prescott, a colleague of Sona’s during the local campaign, suggested that campaign manager Ken Morgan was also involved. It remains unclear whether anyone in the Conservatives’ national campaign knew what was going on or, even less clear, whether anyone up top orchestrated it. The verdict in Sona’s trial is expected in August. (credit:The Canadian Press)

6. Veterans(07 of48)

The Conservative government prides itself on being a strong defender of Canada’s armed forces, but it dropped the ball on veterans issue this year. Veterans Affairs Minister Julian Fantino cut funds to nine regional veterans affairs offices as part of a plan to move services to a centralized Service Canada counter. When upset vets flew to Ottawa to meet with him, he initially cancelled a meeting but then reluctantly met with them with the cameras rolling. Later in May, Fantino was caught on tape evading the spouse of a veteran with post-traumatic stress disorder. His office been under the gun for spending $4 million on advertising programs for veterans rather than investing the money in services. Meanwhile, the government organized a big show on Parliament Hill to praise Afghan vets. (credit:The Canadian Press)

7. Abortion(08 of48)

Liberal Leader Justin Trudeau’s policy of imposing a pro-choice position on all new candidates while grandfathering MPs with anti-abortion views drew criticisms from all sides. One of his MPs dubbed it a “bozo eruption” and questioned the advice Trudeau was getting, while Roman Catholic leaders condemned his policy. Meanwhile, the NDP attacked him for keeping longtime anti-abortion MPs within the party fold. Trudeau had difficulty explaining his position at first, but after two months of clarifying the Liberal policy, it now seems that everyone has got the message. (credit:The Canadian Press)

8. Privacy(09 of48)

The government reintroduced a new version of a bill that would give police sweeping powers to track and trace telecommunications online. The bill, C-13, “Protecting Canadians from Online Crime Act,” tackles cyberbullying by prohibiting the non-consensual distribution of intimate images. But it also overhauls the existing system of production orders and warrants. The government says the bill does nothing new and that police are already obtaining information from third parties voluntarily, without a court order. That practice, however, was put into jeopardy in June when the Supreme Court said in a 8-0 ruling that police need a search warrant to get internet service producers to turn over information on their subscribers’ identities.The Tories are also pushing ahead on another bill, S-4, “Digital Privacy Act,” that would allow internet service providers to share subscriber information with any organization that is investigating a possible breach of contract, such as a copyright violation, or illegal activity. Telecoms would be allowed to keep the sharing of data secret from the affected customers. – With files from Daniel Tencer and the Canadian Press (credit:The Canadian Press)

9. Prostitution(10 of48)

The Conservatives tabled legislation in June to respond to a Supreme Court ruling that struck down three major laws relating to prostitution last December. The constitutionality of its bill, C-36, “Protection of Communities and Exploited Persons Act,” was first questioned by experts. Then, outspoken sex-workers and those who advocate on their behalf argued that the bill would do nothing to address the top court’s concerns and would actually make their jobs less safe. Finally, even the Conservatives’ own supporters found problems with the bill, since it criminalizes prostitutes. The bill has been rushed to committee, which will hold hearings during the summer, when everyone is paying attention to other things. (credit:The Canadian Press)

10. Citizenship(11 of48)

Bill C-24, “Strengthening Canadian Citizenship Act,” contains several controversial measures that have opposition MPs worried. Among them: – It limits appeals in order to cut down on processing time and reduce the department’s large backlog; – Increases the length of time applicants need to spend in Canada before obtaining their citizenship; – Forces 14- to 16-year-olds as well as 54- to 64-year-olds to meet language requirements and pass knowledge tests; – Gives Ottawa the power to revoke the citizenship of dual citizens who are convicted with terrorism outside Canada.Critics worry that there is no distinction between someone convicted after a fair hearing or a political scapegoat convicted in a sham trial. They are also concerned that the minister retains the right to grant or revoke citizenship without public knowledge or court approval. (credit:The Canadian Press)

11. Ukraine(12 of48)

Prime Minister Stephen Harper took a strong stand against Russia, condemning President Vladimir Putin for invasion and annexation of Crimea in March. But despite tough talk, Canada and the international community have not been willing to do much to prevent Putin from expanding his sphere of influence. A team of 500 Canadian election observers, however, oversaw the country’s May 25 election. And Harper became the first world leader to meet Ukraine’s newly inaugurated President Petro Poroshenko. Poroshenko was elected after his predecessor, pro-Russian president Viktor Yanukovych, fled the country following violent protests. There are more than 1.25 million Canadians who claim Ukrainian roots, and the group is an important electoral constituency. But, NDP MP Jack Harris said, it’s unclear what the federal government has accomplished on the issue.“Is the government doing much more than shouting out rhetoric at Vladimir Putin, or are we doing more on the ground?” (credit:The Canadian Press)

(13 of48)

On April 1, 2014, members of Parliament received a 2.2 per cent pay increase, bringing the basic pay of each MP up to $163,700 from $160,200 the year prior.But while that base salary is the same for every member, certain MPs are afforded the chance to make much more.The full list of indemnities, salaries and allowances can be found here. (credit:Getty)

Member of the House of Commons(14 of48)

Tory MP Brad Butt (Mississauga-Streetsville) is an example of an MP who earns just the base salary afforded to all MPs.2014 Salary: $163,700There are currently 308 MPs. (credit:CP)

Prime Minister of Canada(15 of48)

The Right Honourable Stephen Harper, however, makes double the salary of your average MP.2014 Salary: $327,400Car Allowance: $2,000 (credit:CP)

Speaker of the House of Commons(16 of48)

Tory MP Andrew Scheer (Regina—Qu'Appelle) earns the base salary, plus $78,300 for serving as Speaker.2014 Salary: $242,000Car allowance: $1,000 (credit:CP)

Leader of the Opposition in the House of Commons(17 of48)

NDP Leader Thomas Mulcair earns the base MP salary, plus $78,300 for leading the Official Opposition.2014 Salary: $242,000Car Allowance: $2,000 (credit:CP)

Cabinet Minster(18 of48)

Treasury Board President Tony Clement (Parry Sound–Muskoka), like other cabinet ministers, earns $78,300 on top of the base MP salary.2014 Salary: $242,000Car Allowance: $2,000There are 39 cabinet ministers in Harper's government (including ministers of state who make slightly less). (credit:CP)

Minister of State(19 of48)

Minister of State for Democratic Reform Pierre Poilievre (Nepean-Carleton), like all other ministers of state, earns $58,700 on top of his base MP salary.But junior ministers do not received a car allowance.2014 Salary: $222,400 (credit:CP)

Leader of Other Parties(20 of48)

Liberal Leader Justin Trudeau and the leaders of the Green Party and Bloc Quebecois earn the base MP salary, plus $55,600 for serving as their party's top dog.2014 Salary: $219,300 (credit:CP)

Leader of the Government in the House of Commons(21 of48)

Tory MP Peter Van Loan (York-Simcoe) earns $78,300 on top of the base MP salary.2014 Salary: $242,000Car Allowance: $2,000 (credit:CP)

Oppostion House Leader(22 of48)

NDP MP Peter Julian (Burnaby—New Westminster) earns the base MP salary plus a $40,600 pay bump for serving as Opposition House leader.2014 Salary: $204,300Former NDP House leader Nathan Cullen recently took a $40,000 pay cut to move from that role to NDP finance critic. (credit:CP)

House Leader (Other Parties)(23 of48)

Liberal MP Dominic LeBlanc (Beauséjour), earns the base MP salary plus $16,300 for serving as House leader for his party.2014 Salary: $180,000 (credit:CP)

Chief Government Whip(24 of48)

Tory MP John Duncan (Vancouver Island North) earns the base MP salary, plus $29,400 for serving as the Harper government's whip.2014 Salary: $193,100 (credit:CP)

Chief Opposition Whip(25 of48)

NDP MP Nycole Turmel (Hull—Aylmer) also earns an additional $29,400 for serving as the Opposition's whip.2014 Salary: $193,100 (credit:CP)

Parliamentary Secretary(26 of48)

Tory MP Paul Calandra (Oak Ridges—Markham) is one of 31 parliamentary secretaries who gets a $16,300 pay bump on top of their salaries.2014 Salary: $180,000 (credit:CP)

(27 of48)

Conservative MP Pierre Poilievre rises in the House of Commons to apologize for making an obscene gesture yesterday, in Ottawa Wednesday June 14, 2006. (CP PHOTO/Tom Hanson) (credit:CP)

(28 of48)

Ottawa-area Conservative MP Pierre Poilievre smiles as he talks with reporters on Parliament Hill in Ottawa Tuesday Feb. 27, 2007. Poilievre referred to "extremist elements" in the Liberal party that want to ease anti-terror laws and shut down the Air India inquiry last week.(CP PHOTO/Tom Hanson) Canada (credit:CP)

(29 of48)

Democratic Reform Minister Peter Van Loan (right), with Conservative MP Pierre Poilievre looking on, makes an announcement on the introduction of the Accountability with Respect to Loans legislation at the Canadian Museum of Civilization in Gatineau, Quebec across the river from Ottawa, Tuesday May 8, 2007.(CP PHOTO/Fred Chartrand) CANADA , (credit:CP)

(30 of48)

Conservative MP Pierre Poilievre rises in the House of Commons to apologize for saying in a radio interview Wednesday that native people need to learn the value of hard work more than they need residential schools compensation, on Parliament Hill in Ottawa, Thursday June 12, 2008. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Tom Hanson (credit:CP)

(31 of48)

With copies of the Conservative accountabilty booklets, Conservative M.P. Pierre Poilievre waits for the start of the Commons House affairs committee looking into allegations of Tory election spending misconduct during the last election, on Monday Sept. 10, 2007 in Ottawa. (CP PHOTO/Fred Chartrand) (credit:CP)

(32 of48)

Conservative MP Pierre Poilievre speaks in the House of Commons during question period on Parliament Hill in Ottawa on Monday June 16, 2008. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Sean Kilpatrick (credit:CP)

(33 of48)

Pierre Poilievre, parliamentary secretary to the prime minister, leaves a news conference after speaking with the media about the gun registry in the Foyer of the House of Commons on Parliament Hill in Ottawa, Tuesday September 14, 2010. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Adrian Wyld (credit:CP)

(34 of48)

Conservative MP Pierre Poilievre listens to a question during a news conference in Ottawa, Friday October 15, 2010. THE CANADIAN PRESS IMAGES/Adrian Wyld (credit:CP)

(35 of48)

Conservative MP Pierre Poilievre poses with a bust of Sir John A. Macdonald after announcing the former Bank of Montreal building would be renamed in honour of Canada's first prime minister during a ceremony in Ottawa, Ont., Wednesday January 11, 2012. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Adrian Wyld (credit:CP)

(36 of48)

Conservative MP Pierre Poilievre rises during Question Period in the House of Commons on Parliament Hill in Ottawa, Tuesday February 28, 2012. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Adrian Wyld (credit:CP)

(37 of48)

Conservative MP Pierre Poilievre holds up copies of legislation as he responds to a question during Question Period in the House of Commons in Ottawa, Friday October 19, 2012. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Adrian Wyld (credit:CP)

(38 of48)

Pierre Poilievre is sworn in as the minister of state for democratic reform during a ceremony at Rideau Hall in Ottawa on Monday, July 15, 2013. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Adrian Wyld (credit:CP)

(39 of48)

The Honourable Pierre Poilievre, Minister of State (Democratic Reform), poses for a group photo after the swearing in of the federal cabinet at Rideau Hall in Ottawa on Monday, July 15, 2013. THE CANADIAN PRESS/ Patrick Doyle (credit:CP)

(40 of48)

Minister of State Pierre Poilievre stands in the House of Commons during Question Period, in Ottawa Friday, February 7, 2014. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Fred Chartrand (credit:CP)

(41 of48)

Minister of State (Democratic Reform) Pierre Poilievre responds to a question during question period in the House of Commons on Parliament Hill in Ottawa on Thursday, February 27, 2014. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Sean Kilpatrick (credit:CP)

(42 of48)

"The Fair Elections Act will ensure everyday citizens are in charge of democracy, by putting special interests on the sidelines and rule-breakers out of business," says Democratic Reform Minister Pierre Poilievre.Read more about the Fair Elections Act here. (credit:CP)

Crackdown On Illegal Robocalls(43 of48)

The legislation proposes a mandatory public registry for mass automated election calls, jail time for those convicted of impersonating an elections official, and "increased penalties for deceiving people out of their votes." (credit:CP)

No More 'Vouching' For Your Buddy(44 of48)

In the interest of cracking down on voter fraud, the bill would prohibit the practice whereby one Canadian vouches for another's identity at a polling station. In fact, voter information cards will no longer be accepted as proof of identity.But the government says voters will still have 39 forms of authorized ID to choose from in order to prove their identity and residence. (credit:CP)

Independence For The Elections Commissioner(45 of48)

The Commissioner of Canada Elections office, responsible for enforcing the elections law, will be moved under the mantle of the public prosecutor's office, not Elections Canada.Conservatives believe this will give the commissioner more independence as the Chief Electoral Officer will no longer be able to direct him to carry out investigations.In future, the commissioner would be appointed by the director of public prosecutions to a non-renewable, seven-year term.The legislation also bars former political candidates, political party employees, ministerial or MP staffers or employees of Elections Canada from being named commissioner.Tories believe the legislation will give the commissioner "sharper teeth" and a "longer reach" to seek out stronger penalties for offences. (credit:CP)

More Donations Welcome(46 of48)

The ceiling for individual political donations would be raised to $1,500 from $1,200 and party spending limits would be increased by five per cent. Union and corporate donations are still banned, though. (credit:Getty)

The West Won't Have To Wait(47 of48)

A long-standing ban on the premature transmission of election results will be lifted, meaning voters in Western Canada will get to know how things are shaping up out East before heading to the polls.Broadcasters can share results from Eastern Canada on election night, even if the polls aren't closed in the West. The government believes this change will uphold free speech. (credit:CP)

New Rules On Political Loans(48 of48)

The legislation would raise the amount candidates can contribute to their own campaigns to $5,000.Leadership contestants will be allowed to give their own campaign up to $25,000. (credit:CP)

Suggest a correction

-- This HuffPost Canada page is maintained as part of an online archive. If you have questions or concerns, please check our FAQ or contact support@huffpost.com.

From Our Partner