This HuffPost Canada page is maintained as part of an online archive.

Nickelback Has The Smartest Lyrics In Rock Music, Study Suggests

Well this sure is "Too Bad."
|
Open Image Modal
AP
Singer Chad Kroeger and drummer Daniel Adair of Nickelback perform at the Juno Awards on Sunday, April 1, 2012, in Ottawa, Ontario. (AP Photo/Arthur Mola)

Look at this graph. It definitely makes us laugh.

Data visualization blog Seatsmart has found that Hanna, Alta.'s own Nickelback are responsible for the smartest lyrics in rock music, putting them above acts such as Linkin Park and the Foo Fighters.

It suggests that lyrics like these...

"Look at this photograph

Every time I do, it makes me laugh

How did our eyes get so red?

And what the hell is on Joey's head?"

- From Nickelback's "Photograph"

Are smarter than ones like these.

"Run and tell all of the angels

This could take all night

Think I need a devil to help me

Get things right."

- From Foo Fighters' "Learn to Fly"

OK, bear with us now.

Seatsmart analyst Andrew Powell-Morse isn't necessarily saying that Nickelback's lyrics are objectively smarter than any other rock band's.

His finding came as part of a study that looked at whether pop music lyrics as a whole had become dumber over the course of a decade. And they have.

Powell-Moore arrived at his conclusions using "Readability Score," a metric that uses tools such as the Flesch-Kincaid grade index to determine a text's average U.S. reading level.

He looked at 225 songs that had spent more than three weeks on the Billboard charts for genres such as rock, country, pop and R&B/hip hop.

Powell-Moore's analysis took account of song lyrics and word count, but did not examine a track's meaning or metaphor — you know, two things that really make a song great.

With all this in mind, Nickelback's lyrics came out with an average grade level of 3.3, beating Linkin Park (3.2), Seether (2.78) and, yes, the Foo Fighters (2.62).

Powell-Moore found that word length played a role in a lyric's intelligence. In this sense, country came out as the smartest genre with an average reading level of 3.3, followed by pop and rock (both 2.9) and R&B/hip hop (2.6).

The reason for this was that country songs don't usually have words such as "'oh' or 'yeah' repeated 20 times in a row," he wrote.

He concluded that songs with words such as "hillbilly," "tacklebox," "cigarettes" and "Cincinnati" gave the genre a leg up on its counterparts.

R&B/hip hop and pop singers, meanwhile, often vocalize about places such as New York or L.A., and have titles such as "Buy U a Drank." So clearly there was a relationship there.

Few, for example, could accuse Kanye West of writing songs that lack substance. But he ranked fifth out of the top seven R&B/hip hop artists from the last ten years, behind Eminem, Nicki Minaj, Macklemore and Drake (Beyonce was seventh).

We just don't buy that Queen Bey belongs anywhere but first place.

Powell-Moore's analysis is right about one thing, however.

When you strip things like metaphor, meaning and substance out of your evaluation of a song, Nickelback probably could be considered the best at what they do.

Open Image Modal
Open Image Modal

Follow Us On Twitter

ALSO ON HUFFPOST:

10 Acts You Hate As Much As Nickelback
Creed(01 of10)
Open Image Modal
The Good: Over 40 million records sold. Creed almost single-handedly kept grunge-rock alive in the mainstream at the turn of the millennium when rave was rising and hip-hop was taking over the world.The Bad: The whole we're-not-a-religious-band thing was kind of irritating, especially after videos full of, y'know, religious imagery. But worst was probably lead singer Scott Stapp's various vices and addictions getting so bad that fans actually sued (link) the band because their shows in 2003 were so bad. (Non-fans, of course, simply blamed the music.)The Disparaging Words: "I want to dedicate this next song to the lead singer of Creed... That guy is an egomaniac. He's a f---ing punk, and he's backstage right now acting like f---ing Michael Jackson. F--- that motherf---er, and f--- you, too," said Limp Bizkit's Fred Durst, onstage at a music festival in 2000. (credit:Getty)
Coldplay(02 of10)
Open Image Modal
The Good: Over 50 million records sold, a legion of copycats like Snow Patrol, Travis, Doves and Pilot Speed, and the undeniable earworm brought on by the word 'Yellow.' (Ed. Note: Don't tell anyone but we totally dig 'Clocks.')The Bad: Coldplay have mastered a genre some quarters refer to as "secretary rock," or, as 'Family Guy' patriarch Peter Griffin calls it, "whiny bullcrap." Worse, though, is the knowledge that if you heart a Coldplay fan, you probably ain't gettin' any as a recent study (link) revealed they're the least likely to have sex on the first date.The Disparaging Words:"Coldplay are the dictionary definition of corporate rock. The singer is about as weird as Phil Collins. They are career rock personified. EMI should've signed Otis the Aardvark instead. At least he only sucks his thumb rather than corporate c---," said Alan McGee, founder of Creation Records. (credit:YouTube)
The Eagles(03 of10)
Open Image Modal
The Good: Over 120 million records sold, six Grammy Awards and the campfire singalong classic, 'Hotel California.'The Bad: Many bands are capable of doing it, but few are so brazenly capitalist as to charge "what the market will bear" for tickets. Not the Eagles, who have charged fans over 1,000 British pounds to sing along to 'Hotel California' with the band. Then there is the fact that The Dude hates them. And he abides a lot.The Disparaging Words: "Don Henley's a fool, a pompous, bloated twit who oughta be castrated so he can't reproduce," said Mojo Nixon. (credit:Getty)
Insane Clown Posse(04 of10)
Open Image Modal
The Good: The 6.5 million records sold by rappers Shaggy 2 Dope and Violent J are rather modest compared to most of the other bands on this list, but ICP have created something bigger -- their own society. The band's face-painted clown army known as "juggalos" conduct an annual pilgrimage to something called the Gathering of the Juggalos. It's basically the equivalent of the Muslim Hajj to Mecca, except this pilgrimage is usually to a mid-western U.S. campsite to take drugs, listen to murder-rap and watch pro wrestling.The bad: For the average ICP fan, wondering how magnets work is a legit existential crisis.The Disparaging Words: "I was put here to put fear/In people who spray Faygo root beer/And call themselves clowns cuz they look gay/Faggy 2 Dope and Silent Gay Claiming Detroit, when y'all live 20 miles away," rapped Eminem, homophobically, on his ICP diss-track 'Marshall Mathers.' (credit:AP)
Kanye West(05 of10)
Open Image Modal
The Good: If it was rap music made post-2000, and it was good, there was a pretty solid chance Kanye West was involved. Jay-Z, Common, Kid Cudi and John Legend have all experienced 'Ye's golden touch. Better though are Yeezy's own hits. He's sold over 25 million digital singles of tracks like 'Gold Digger,' 'Heartless' and 'Power' and millions more in albums.The Bad: Kanye's mouth often gets him in trouble, whether it's bullying praying mantis-like country music star Taylor Swift at the VMAs or saying that President George W. Bush "doesn't care about black people."The Disparaging Words: "Jackass," said President Barack Obama, after the VMA incident. (credit:Getty)
Limp Bizkit(06 of10)
Open Image Modal
The Good: Not many bands can say they popularized a new musical genre like Limp Bizkit did rap-metal. From 1997 to 2004, lead singer Fred Durst and his backwards red baseball cap rode a wave of anger to over 50 million records sold.The Bad: Limp Bizkit's set at Woodstock '99 was considered the catalyst for what would eventually deteriorate into a bacchanal of rapes, assaults, fires and general chaos as wasted rioters battled state troopers amidst a festival in flames.The Disparaging Words: "Fred Durst is one pathetic midget," said morning radio DJ Mancow Muller. (credit:Getty)
Maroon 5(07 of10)
Open Image Modal
The Good: Some 15 million records later, Maroon 5's soul-pop has become nearly ubiquitous on the radio. Of course, what people can see is almost as important as what they hear, which is why lead singer Adam Levine rarely has a shirt on.The Bad: If you've walked through a shopping mall you've definitely heard M5's latest hit 'Moves Like Jagger.' But such Jagger appreciation is an awkward thing. There are two distinct periods in the history of The Rolling Stones, the early dangerous period (circa Altamont) and the later leotard period (circa disco). Maroon 5 prefer the leotard period.The Disparaging Words: "People hated Creed. They don't hate us. At worst, they just don't really like us. Creed were easy to hate and we're just, you know, easy to disregard," said a sorta self-aware Adam Levine. (credit:AP)
Metallica(08 of10)
Open Image Modal
The good: These godfathers of thrash metal have sold over 100 million albums and provided the soundtrack to just as many bush parties, drag races and witch hunts.The bad: As awesome as albums like 'Master of Puppets' were, it's been a commitment to stay loyal to Metallica. They've gone after Napster and made us watch Dave Mustaine weep in their therapy doc 'Some Kind of Monster.' Even worse, the band got together with aged art-zombie Lou Reed for the 'Lulu' album and attempted to tell us it was "awesome." (link)The Disparaging Words: "You can tell the other guys in [Metallica] are cool and used to just be serious heshers who were probably whacked out on meth and would've kicked your ass in the '80s. On the other hand, you have Lars, who is just this swishy Mary who grew his hair long, put on a denim jacket and infiltrated this cool gang. The only time I met him, he was wearing a golf pantsuit and everybody was wondering who this fat golfer dude was acting like an ass---- in our backstage area," said Eagles of Death Metal's Jesse Hughes on Metallica drummer Lars Ulrich. (credit:AP)
Morrissey(09 of10)
Open Image Modal
The Good: Smiths lead singer Morrissey probably did more to make poetry cool than anyone since the Doors' Jim Morrison. Meanwhile, the song 'Meat Is Murder' has probably helped convert more people to vegetarianism than any work of art short of Robert Newton Peck's book 'A Day No Pigs Would Die.'The Bad: Morrissey's such an angry curmudgeon that not only are writers inspired to piss on (link) his records but other bands write songs about how much they hate him (link).The Disparaging Words: "If Morrissey says not to eat meat, then I'll eat meat; that's how much I hate Morrissey," said Robert Smith of the Cure. (credit:PA)
Spin Doctors(10 of10)
Open Image Modal
The Good: Spin Doctors' six million records sold is a relatively modest number, but 1991's 'Pocket Full of Kryptonite' and its hits 'Little Miss Can't Be Wrong' and 'Two Princes' have inspired generations of jam bands to follow in the band's funky footsteps.The Bad: Give the kids with beards and hacky sacks an anthem and you give everyone else something to hate. And sure enough, by the time the new millennium came around, former supporters like VH1 were declaring 'Two Princes' among the 50 Most Awesomely Bad Songs Ever. (VH1 List).The Disparaging Words: "Those are the videos that I f---ing hate," said Noel Gallagher, discussing having to watch Spin Doctors on VH1. (credit:Getty)
-- This HuffPost Canada page is maintained as part of an online archive. If you have questions or concerns, please check our FAQ or contact support@huffpost.com.