This article exists as part of the online archive for HuffPost India, which closed in 2020. Some features are no longer enabled. If you have questions or concerns about this article, please contact indiasupport@huffpost.com.
Newsbombay high courtrape

Rape Victims Are Not Beggars, Compensating Them Is Govt's Obligation: Bombay HC

"It is their right."
PTI
Open Image Modal
DNY59 via Getty Images

MUMBAI -- Rape victims are not beggars and giving compensation to women victims of crime is the state's obligation and not charity, the Bombay High Court said on Wednesday, terming the Maharashtra government's attitude as "ruthless".

A division bench of Chief Justice Manjula Chellur and Justice GS Kulkarni was hearing a petition filed by a 14-year-old rape victim, seeking Rs three lakh as compensation under the government's 'Manodhairya Yojana'.

The girl, a resident of suburban Borivali, alleged that she was raped by a man who had promised to marry her.

The HC bench was on Wednesday informed that after the girl filed the petition in October last year, a sum of ₹1 lakh was given to her by the government as compensation.

During the last hearing, the government had told the high court that it would pay only ₹2 lakh compensation to the girl, as the incident seems to be of "consensual nature".

Irked with this, the high court today said a 14-year-old cannot be expected to understand and take such mature decisions and realise the consequences.

"We don't like how the government is approaching the issue. This is a very heartless and ruthless attitude. Unless the government starts thinking and taking decisions in such matters from its heart and soul, nothing will happen," Chief Justice Chellur said.

The HC asked Mumbai Suburban Deputy Collector, who was present in the court today, as to how he would feel if something of this nature would have happened to his kith and kin.

"You (government) should think from your heart in such cases. There cannot be such an insensitive attitude. This is the government's obligation to help such victims. They (victims) are not beggars and this is not charity. It is their (victims) right," the judges noted.

"Manodhairya means self-confidence...the government should be boosting the victims' confidence, instead it is doing the opposite," they observed.

Also On HuffPost:

Oscars 2017 Red Carpet Photos
(01 of83)
Open Image Modal
Ryan Gosling (credit:Kevin Mazur via Getty Images)
(02 of83)
Open Image Modal
Brie Larson (credit:Frazer Harrison via Getty Images)
(03 of83)
Open Image Modal
Salma Hayek (credit:Frazer Harrison via Getty Images)
(04 of83)
Open Image Modal
Pauletta Washington and Denzel Washington (credit:Frazer Harrison via Getty Images)
(05 of83)
Open Image Modal
Dwayne Johnson and Lauren Hashian (credit:Frazer Harrison via Getty Images)
(06 of83)
Open Image Modal
Charlize Theron (credit:Frazer Harrison via Getty Images)
(07 of83)
Open Image Modal
Rosalind Ross and actor/director Mel Gibson (credit:Frazer Harrison via Getty Images)
(08 of83)
Open Image Modal
Naomie Harris (credit:Steve Granitz via Getty Images)
(09 of83)
Open Image Modal
Busy Philipps (credit:Kevork Djansezian via Getty Images)
(10 of83)
Open Image Modal
Jamie Dornan and Amelia Warner (credit:Jeff Kravitz via Getty Images)
(11 of83)
Open Image Modal
Emma Stone (credit:Kevin Mazur via Getty Images)
(12 of83)
Open Image Modal
Kate McKinnon (credit:Kevin Mazur via Getty Images)
(13 of83)
Open Image Modal
Priyanka Chopra (credit:Frazer Harrison via Getty Images)
(14 of83)
Open Image Modal
Jeremy Renner (credit:Kevin Mazur via Getty Images)
(15 of83)
Open Image Modal
Viola Davis (credit:Jeff Kravitz via Getty Images)
(16 of83)
Open Image Modal
Alicia Vikander (credit:Kevin Mazur via Getty Images)
(17 of83)
Open Image Modal
Jeremy Renner (credit:Frazer Harrison via Getty Images)
(18 of83)
Open Image Modal
Jim Parsons (credit:Lester Cohen via Getty Images)
(19 of83)
Open Image Modal
Kate Arrington, and Michael Shannon (credit:Jeff Kravitz via Getty Images)
(20 of83)
Open Image Modal
Sara Bareilles (credit:Kevin Mazur via Getty Images)
(21 of83)
Open Image Modal
Nicole Kidman (credit:Frazer Harrison via Getty Images)
(22 of83)
Open Image Modal
Scarlett Johansson (credit:Frazer Harrison via Getty Images)
(23 of83)
Open Image Modal
Seth Rogen and Lauren Miller (credit:Jeff Kravitz via Getty Images)
(24 of83)
Open Image Modal
Halle Berry (credit:Steve Granitz via Getty Images)
(25 of83)
Open Image Modal
Michelle Williams (credit:Kevin Mazur via Getty Images)
(26 of83)
Open Image Modal
Casey Affleck (credit:Frazer Harrison via Getty Images)
(27 of83)
Open Image Modal
Laura Dern (credit:Steve Granitz via Getty Images)
(28 of83)
Open Image Modal
Janelle Monae (credit:Steve Granitz via Getty Images)
(29 of83)
Open Image Modal
Dakota Johnson (credit:VALERIE MACON via Getty Images)
(30 of83)
Open Image Modal
Mahershala Ali (credit:Steve Granitz via Getty Images)
(31 of83)
Open Image Modal
Michael J. Fox (credit:Frazer Harrison via Getty Images)
(32 of83)
Open Image Modal
Matt Damon and Luciana Barroso (credit:VALERIE MACON via Getty Images)
(33 of83)
Open Image Modal
Dev Patel (credit:Jeff Kravitz via Getty Images)
(34 of83)
Open Image Modal
David Oyelowo and producer Jessica Oyelowo (credit:Steve Granitz via Getty Images)
(35 of83)
Open Image Modal
Jessica Biel and Justin Timberlake (credit:Steve Granitz via Getty Images)
(36 of83)
Open Image Modal
Olivia Hamilton and director Damien Chazelle (credit:Jeff Kravitz via Getty Images)
(37 of83)
Open Image Modal
John Cho and Kerri Higuchi (credit:Frazer Harrison via Getty Images)
(38 of83)
Open Image Modal
Octavia Spencer (credit:Steve Granitz via Getty Images)
(39 of83)
Open Image Modal
Pharrell Williams (credit:Frazer Harrison via Getty Images)
(40 of83)
Open Image Modal
Director Ava DuVernay (credit:Frazer Harrison via Getty Images)
89th Annual Academy Awards - Arrivals(41 of83)
Open Image Modal
HOLLYWOOD, CA - FEBRUARY 26: Actor Kirsten Dunst attends the 89th Annual Academy Awards at Hollywood & Highland Center on February 26, 2017 in Hollywood, California. (Photo by Steve Granitz/WireImage) (credit:Steve Granitz via Getty Images)
(42 of83)
Open Image Modal
Trudie Styler and Sting (credit:Jeff Kravitz via Getty Images)
(43 of83)
Open Image Modal
Chrissy Teigen and John Legend (credit:Steve Granitz via Getty Images)
(44 of83)
Open Image Modal
Tracy Pollan (credit:Steve Granitz via Getty Images)
(45 of83)
Open Image Modal
Taraji P. Henson (credit:Frazer Harrison via Getty Images)
(46 of83)
Open Image Modal
Terrence Howard and Mira Pak (credit:Frazer Harrison via Getty Images)
(47 of83)
Open Image Modal
Tarell Alvin McCraney (credit:George Pimentel via Getty Images)
(48 of83)
Open Image Modal
Jharrel Jerome (credit:Frazer Harrison via Getty Images)
(49 of83)
Open Image Modal
Director Denis Villeneuve and Tanya Lapointe (credit:Jeff Kravitz via Getty Images)
(50 of83)
Open Image Modal
Trevante Rhodes, Alex R. Hibbert and Ashton Sanders (credit:Frazer Harrison via Getty Images)
(51 of83)
Open Image Modal
Andrew Garfield (credit:Frazer Harrison via Getty Images)
(52 of83)
Open Image Modal
Leslie Mann and filmmaker Judd Apatow (credit:Kevin Mazur via Getty Images)
(53 of83)
Open Image Modal
Andre Holland (credit:Jeff Kravitz via Getty Images)
(54 of83)
Open Image Modal
Riz Ahmed (credit:Frazer Harrison via Getty Images)
(55 of83)
Open Image Modal
Ginnifer Goodwin and Josh Dallas (credit:Frazer Harrison via Getty Images)
(56 of83)
Open Image Modal
Karlie Kloss (credit:Kevin Mazur via Getty Images)
(57 of83)
Open Image Modal
Emma Roberts (credit:Frazer Harrison via Getty Images)
(58 of83)
Open Image Modal
Lin-Manuel Miranda and Luz Towns-Miranda (credit:Kevin Mazur via Getty Images)
(59 of83)
Open Image Modal
Hailee Steinfeld (credit:Frazer Harrison via Getty Images)
(60 of83)
Open Image Modal
Jackie Chan (credit:Steve Granitz via Getty Images)
(61 of83)
Open Image Modal
Gael Garcia Bernal (credit:Kevin Mazur via Getty Images)
(62 of83)
Open Image Modal
Viggo Mortensen (credit:Kevin Mazur via Getty Images)
(63 of83)
Open Image Modal
Blanca Blanco (credit:Steve Granitz via Getty Images)
(64 of83)
Open Image Modal
Felicity Jones (credit:Kevin Mazur via Getty Images)
(65 of83)
Open Image Modal
Isabelle Huppert (credit:Kevin Mazur via Getty Images)
(66 of83)
Open Image Modal
Ruth Negga (credit:Frazer Harrison via Getty Images)
(67 of83)
Open Image Modal
Luke Bracey (credit:Kevin Mazur via Getty Images)
(68 of83)
Open Image Modal
Lucas Hedges (credit:Frazer Harrison via Getty Images)
(69 of83)
Open Image Modal
Vince Vaughn (credit:Jeff Kravitz via Getty Images)
(70 of83)
Open Image Modal
Sunny Pawar (credit:Steve Granitz via Getty Images)
(71 of83)
Open Image Modal
Aldis Hodge (credit:Frazer Harrison via Getty Images)
(72 of83)
Open Image Modal
Auli'i Cravalho (credit:Kevin Mazur via Getty Images)
(73 of83)
Open Image Modal
Jerry O'Connell (credit:Kevork Djansezian via Getty Images)
(74 of83)
Open Image Modal
Sofia Boutella (credit:Jeff Kravitz via Getty Images)
(75 of83)
Open Image Modal
Cynthia Erivo (credit:Steve Granitz via Getty Images)
(76 of83)
Open Image Modal
Sofia Carson (credit:Kevork Djansezian via Getty Images)
(77 of83)
Open Image Modal
Shohreh Aghdashloo (credit:Frazer Harrison via Getty Images)
(78 of83)
Open Image Modal
Glen Powell (credit:Steve Granitz via Getty Images)
Olivia Culpo(79 of83)
Open Image Modal
Olivia Culpo (credit:Steve Granitz via Getty Images)
(80 of83)
Open Image Modal
Brianna Perez (credit:Frazer Harrison via Getty Images)
(81 of83)
Open Image Modal
Teresa Palmer (credit:Frazer Harrison via Getty Images)
(82 of83)
Open Image Modal
John Savage (credit:Kevin Mazur via Getty Images)
(83 of83)
Open Image Modal
Darby Stanchfield (credit:Kevin Mazur via Getty Images)

Related

bombay high courtnewsrape
Suggest a correction
-- This article exists as part of the online archive for HuffPost India, which closed in 2020. Some features are no longer enabled. If you have questions or concerns about this article, please contact indiasupport@huffpost.com.