The Blog

A Brutally Honest <i>The Whale</i> at Victory Gardens

Brutal honesty. That's playwright Samuel D. Hunter's razor-sharp focus in his deeply significant play,.
This post was published on the now-closed HuffPost Contributor platform. Contributors control their own work and posted freely to our site. If you need to flag this entry as abusive, send us an email.

Brutal honesty. That's playwright Samuel D. Hunter's razor-sharp focus in his deeply significant play, The Whale. And through Charlie, a 600-pound gentle giant played by the superbly understated Dale Calandra in Victory Gardens' uncompromising production, we see brutal honesty: in the flesh.

At Monday's press opening, there were audible "tsks" and sighs of disapproval from the audience as the couch-ridden and morbidly obese Charlie reached for a non-diet 20 oz soda and tore into a tub of KFC provided by his well-intended but enabling caregiver Liz (Cheryl Graeff). But by this must-see production's powerful conclusion, the snap judgements are wiped clean and you're simply left devastated by Charlie's unrelenting honesty and humanity.

The brilliance of Hunter's work is that he's written a character who so desperately craves honesty and truth, he'll take it any way he can find it. Even if it means absorbing verbal abuse from his estranged 16 year-old daughter Ellie (a brooding Leah Karpel) or allowing a well-meaning Mormon (the tightly wound Will Allan) to enter his house and judge his downward-spiraling lifestyle.

Charlie, a part time online writing tutor, just wants people to speak from the heart -- even as his own diseased heart fails him. He's recently suffered a great loss -- his male partner -- and he's unable to reconcile his emotions. He's also been given the grave news that he has days to live. So now is not the time for half-hearted pleasantries.

Director Joanie Schultz does wonderful things with Hunter's potentially melodramatic script, but perhaps the wisest choice is casting Calandra as Charlie. The articulate, soft-spoken Calandra embodies the unassuming heart and soul in this heart-wrenching show. Through Calandra's deeply honest performance, we learn that it's never too late for second chances, as fleeting as they may be.

"The Whale" plays through May 5 at Victory Gardens Theater. More info here.