Evidence For Universe Inflation Theory May Lurk In New Data From Planck Space Probe

Secrets Of Universe's Birth May Lurk In New Data
|
Open Image Modal

At first, there was nothing — complete and utter emptiness. Zero energy and zero matter.

And then, out of this nothingness, the universe was born. Tiny, but extremely dense and packed with energy. And then, within a miniscule fraction of a second, it rapidly grew in size — inflated — by at least a factor of 10raised to the 25th power.

This theory, known as inflation, is currently the dominant explanation for what happened after the Big Bang and for how the universe came to be the way it is today. But although many scientists now believe that inflation did indeed take place, they still don't know how or why it started, or how it stopped. And so far, there hasn't been any solid experimental evidence for this accelerated expansion. [8 Baffling Astronomy Mysteries]

Scientists hope that in just a few months they might start to unravel the riddle, when they examine the next set of data from the Planck satellite. Since 2009, this radio telescope, run by the European Space Agency (ESA), has been mapping the oldest light in the universe.

Known as the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB), this fossil light is often called the Big Bang's afterglow. It is thought to have appeared after the inflationary period, some 380,000 years after the universe was born, when neutral atoms started forming and space became transparent to light.

When the first set of Planck data was released in March 2013, both "inflationists" and "anti-inflationists" felt vindicated.


Incomprehensible as it sound, inflation poses that the universe initially expanded far faster than the speed of light and grew from a subatomic size to a golf-ball size almost instantaneously.

Supporters of the theory said the Planck results hinted perfectly at how inflation might have worked. Critics, however, argued that the inflation models were simply tweaked to fit the data, without really explaining it.

All Planck data suggests that the universe is "remarkably simple," said astrophysicst Anna Ijjas of Harvard University. The same data, however, only supports inflation models that are highly complicated and, she said, "only work for much more restricted initial conditions."

Tiny cause, big effect?

Scientists hope that the next set of Planck data may show whether inflation is a plausible explanation for the shape of today's universe. And supporters of the universe inflation theory say that it might prove that the seeds of today's universe can be found in quantum physics.

Scientists already know, both from Planck and earlier observations, that the CMB shows tiny density fluctuations, which then became huge over the next 13.7 billion years, as the universe expanded. [From the Big Bang to Today in 10 Easy Steps]

These classical density fluctuations probably originated in tiny, spontaneous quantum fluctuations in the spacetime metric immediately after the Big Bang, said theoretical physicist Daniel Baumann of Cambridge University. "We believe that inflation stretched these small quantum fluctuations into [the] classical density fluctuations observed in today's universe."

Since these classical fluctuations appeared right after inflation, that means they were already there when the CMB was created. And it's these density fluctuations that became the seeds of stars and galaxies.

In sync

The oscillations found in the CMB provide another pointer toward inflation. When the CMB began to "glow," the quantum fluctuations had already become classical density waves.

The first set of Planck spacecraft results not only confirmed these fluctuations, it also showed that they are correlated over huge distances: all waves with the same wavelength seem to be oscillating in sync with each other.

"This coherence is something that inflation explains very naturally," said Baumann."It is by far the most striking observation we have made. It's very tantalizing."

One of the most startling results of all CMB measurements, though, has been the uniformity of the fossil light's temperature, which varies by less than 0.0003 degrees Celsius.There are only two ways that the universe could have achieved such uniform temperatures, Baumann said.


This image unveiled March 21, 2013, shows the cosmic microwave background (CMB) as observed by the European Space Agency's Planck space observatory. The CMB is a snapshot of the oldest light in our Universe, imprinted on the sky when the Universe was just 380 000 years old. It shows tiny temperature fluctuations that correspond to regions of slightly different densities, representing the seeds of all future structure: the stars and galaxies of today.

In a non-inflationary model, there would have to be wild temperature differences between different parts of the universe, which then, over time, would have reached equilibrium, just like various objects in a house reach "room temperature."

However, the universe is too young to explain equilibrium over such large regions of space. Or to put it differently: The universe is larger than the maximal distance (called horizon) at which light or any disturbances in the Big Bang's primordial plasma could have affected each other. So, in a seeming paradox, distant parts of the universe have the same temperature and density, even though they cannot have "contacted" each other. [History and Structure of the Universe (Infographic Gallery)]

Inflation, says Baumann, offers a better solution: all matter initially had the same temperature and then was suddenly torn apart at an accelerated pace. So now there are tiny temperature variations among objects, because they all started out at the same place and with the same temperature.

"It is like finding two cups of coffee [very far away from each other] with exactly the same temperature," said Baumann. "If they have never been close enough to exchange heat, there is no reason for them to have the same temperature."

In an analogue to the inflation theory, both cups would be "produced by the same coffee machine at the same time, and inflation then takes the coffee cups and separates them faster than the speed of light."

Gravitational waves

Studying the CMB's extremely faint light has been tricky throughout, but also full of scientific promise. That's because the quantum fluctuations at the start of the universe should also have triggered gravitational waves, elusive and so far theoretical ripples in spacetime predicted by Einstein.

If they were to be found, and found to map to the CMB's fluctuations, they could provide extremely strong support of inflation. "Seeing gravitational waves would be a smoking gun" for the inflation model, said Baumann.

The proof is complex, but it depends on subtle variations in the polarization of the light waves from the CMB. There are two types of polarization variations, called E-mode and B-mode. The latter describe the rotation, or twist, of the polarization, and it is this variation that physicists hope will provide weighty evidence for inflation.

According to Einstein's general theory of relativity, the CMB would show B-mode polarization because of the huge energies involved in the stretching of spacetime during inflation, said Ijjas.

If the CMB's light is indeed twisted that way, inflation would provide an excellent explanation, because "such a high-energy mechanism would shake space-time in a dramatic way, so that we could determine its strength by measuring the amplitude of gravitational waves it produced," said Ijjas.

Baumann says that gravitational waves may even persuade scientists who are working on alternatives to inflation to accept the model.

"Seeing B-modes would give us a lot of confidence that inflation happened and that we all came from quantum fluctuations."

Ijjas agreed. "The main tendency has been [so far] to design complicated inflationary models with many parameters that match the Planck data," she said. "Detecting or not detecting the gravitational wave signal is a key test that can either improve or harm the case for inflation."

Follow Katia Moskvitch on Twitter @SciTech_Cat. Follow SPACE.com on Twitter @Spacedotcom. We're also on Facebook and Google+. Original article on SPACE.com.

Copyright 2014 SPACE.com, a TechMediaNetwork company. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Our 2024 Coverage Needs You

As Americans head to the polls in 2024, the very future of our country is at stake. At HuffPost, we believe that a free press is critical to creating well-informed voters. That's why our journalism is free for everyone, even though other newsrooms retreat behind expensive paywalls.

Our journalists will continue to cover the twists and turns during this historic presidential election. With your help, we'll bring you hard-hitting investigations, well-researched analysis and timely takes you can't find elsewhere. Reporting in this current political climate is a responsibility we do not take lightly, and we thank you for your support.

to keep our news free for all.

Support HuffPost

Before You Go

Best Of European Space Agency Photos
Herchel's Image Of Andromeda Galaxy(01 of43)
Open Image Modal
The European Space Agency's Herschel Space Observatory took this infrared image of the Andromeda Galaxy, showing rings of dust that trace gaseous reservoirs where new stars are forming. (credit:ESA/Herschel/PACS/SPIRE/J.Fritz, U.Gent/XMM-Newton/EPIC/W. Pietsch, MPE)
ISS And Docked Endeavour(02 of43)
Open Image Modal
This image shows the International Space Station and the docked space shuttle Endeavour, flying at an altitude of approximately 350 km. (credit:ESA/NASA)
Over France, Looking South(03 of43)
Open Image Modal
France as seen from the International Space Station. (credit:ESA/NASA)
Christer Fuglesang During Spacewalk(04 of43)
Open Image Modal
Swedish astronaut Christer Fuglesang doing construction and maintenance on the International Space Station during a seven-hour spacewalk in 2009. (credit:NASA)
Baby Stars In Rosette cloud(05 of43)
Open Image Modal
This image from ESA's Herschel Observatory reveals the formation of previously unseen large stars, each one up to ten times the mass of our Sun. (credit:ESA/PACS/SPIRE Consortium/HOBYS Key Programme Consortia)
The 'Hourglass' Nebula(06 of43)
Open Image Modal
A Hubble Space Telescope image of the ‘Hourglass’ Nebula taken in 1996. According to one theory, the hourglass shape is produced by the expansion of a fast stellar wind within a slowly expanding cloud, which is denser near its equator than near its poles. (credit:JPL/NASA/ESA)
Shuttle Launch With Node-3 And Cupola(07 of43)
Open Image Modal
The Space Shuttle Endeavour was launched in February 2010, to head for the International Space Station. (credit:NASA)
Volcano In Onekotan Island, Russia(08 of43)
Open Image Modal
Last picture from @Astro_Paolo, astronaut Paolo Nespoli's Twitter handle, before leaving the International Space Station at the end of a 6-month mission. (credit:ESA/NASA)
Supermoon Rise From ISS(09 of43)
Open Image Modal
Supermoon rise as seen from International Space Station on 20 March 2011. (credit:ESA/NASA)
Aurora Australis(10 of43)
Open Image Modal
Aurora Australis (also known as the southern lights) is featured in this image photographed by a crew member on the International Space Station during a geomagnetic storm in May 2010. (credit:NASA)
Earth From Space: Yukon Delta(11 of43)
Open Image Modal
Envisat, an inoperative Earth-observing satellite still in orbit, took this image featuring Alaska’s Yukon Delta, where the Yukon River fans out into a labyrinth of tributaries before emptying into the Bering Sea. (credit:ESA)
Cuba(12 of43)
Open Image Modal
Cuba as seen from the International Space Station, a habitable artificial satellite in low orbit over the Earth. (credit:ESA/NASA)
Installing Columbus Laboratory(13 of43)
Open Image Modal
The European Columbus laboratory was installed on International Space Station in February 2008. NASA astronauts Stanley Love and Rex Walheim spent nearly eight hours outside their spacecraft. (credit:NASA)
The Microwave Sky As Seen By Planck(14 of43)
Open Image Modal
This multi-frequency mage of the microwave sky has been composed using data from Planck, an ESA space observatory designed to observe microwaves. (credit:ESA/ LFI & HFI Consortia)
The Eagle Nebula(15 of43)
Open Image Modal
This composite of far-infrared and X-ray images shows how hot young stars in the Eagle Nebula are interacting with the surrounding ultra-cool gas and dust. (credit:far-infrared: ESA/Herschel/PACS/SPIRE/Hill, Motte, HOBYS Key Programme Consortium; X-ray: ESA/XMM-Newton/EPIC/XMM-Newton-SOC/Boulanger)
Heart Of Central Asia(16 of43)
Open Image Modal
This satellite image features the heart-shaped Small Aral Sea, the former northern basin of the Aral Sea that once supported a vibrant economy in Central Asia. The whitish area surrounding the lakebed is a vast salt plain, now called the Aralkum Desert, left behind by the evaporating sea. (credit:USGS)
Siberian 'Gecko'(17 of43)
Open Image Modal
The gecko-shaped body of water featured in this ESA satellite radar image was formed by the Bratsk Reservoir in southeastern Siberia, Russia. The reservoir was formed in the 1960s by damming the Angara River to provide hydroelectric power. (credit:ESA)
Northern Canada(18 of43)
Open Image Modal
Stunning icy landscape in northern Canada as seen from International Space Station 230 miles away. (credit:ESA/NASA)
Great Britain And Ireland(19 of43)
Open Image Modal
The varied landscapes of the island nations of Great Britain (right) and Ireland (left) are seen by ESA's Envisat satellite in October 2010. (credit:ESA)
Ariane 5 Lifts Off With Herschel And Planck(20 of43)
Open Image Modal
The dual launch of ESA’s far infrared space telescope Herschel and the cosmic background mapper Planck lifted off on an Ariane 5 launcher in French Guiana on May 14, 2009. (credit:ESA/S. Corvaja)
Montana(21 of43)
Open Image Modal
Mountain range in Montana, USA, as seen from the International Space Station. (credit:ESA/NASA)
Ice Lake Found On Mars(22 of43)
Open Image Modal
This is a giant patch of frozen water inside an unnamed impact crater on Mars. The existence of this water-ice patch on Mars raises the prospect that past or present life will one day be detected. (credit:ESA/DLR/FU Berlin (G. Neukum))
Alexander Gerst Inside Module Mockup(23 of43)
Open Image Modal
German ESA astronaut Alexander Gerst during training at ESA's Neutral Buoyancy Facility in Cologne, Germany, on June 8, 2010. (credit:ESA - H. Rueb, 2010)
Nose Of Space Shuttle Discovery(24 of43)
Open Image Modal
A striking view of Space Shuttle Discovery from July 2006, taken by the crew of the International Space Station, during the Shuttle's 'rendezvous pitch maneuver' (performed by the Shuttle prior to docking to allow for inspection of its underside). (credit:NASA)
Ion Thruster In ESTEC's Propulsion Laboratory(25 of43)
Open Image Modal
Prince Willem Alexander of the Netherlands is seen here observing an operating 'Hall effect' thruster during the opening ceremony of ESA's Propulsion Laboratory at Noordwijk, the Netherlands in April 2008. (credit:ESA)
Our Neighbor Venus(26 of43)
Open Image Modal
ESA's Venus Express mission, launched to Venus in 2005, took this false-colour ultraviolet image with its Venus Monitoring Camera in July 2007 from a distance of 35 000 km. (credit:ESA/MPS/DLR-PF/IDA)
Astronaut Frank De Winne In Training(27 of43)
Open Image Modal
ESA astronaut Frank De Winne is seen here in a Soyuz spacecraft simulator during training in Star City near Moscow. This photo was taken in early 2009 while De Winne was preparing for his six-month stay on the International Space Station. (credit:NASA (JSC-2009-E-120674))
Phobos Seen By Mars Express(28 of43)
Open Image Modal
This image, taken by the High Resolution Stereo Camera on board ESA’s Mars Express spacecraft, is one of the highest-resolution pictures so far of the Martian moon Phobos. (credit:NASA)
Ariane 5 ECA Lift-Off From Kourou(29 of43)
Open Image Modal
This view of an Ariane 5 rocket launch at Kourou in French Guiana was taken on the evening of 7 July 2008. (credit:ESA/CNES/Arianespace/Service Optique Video du CSG)
Herschel Telescope Mirror(30 of43)
Open Image Modal
Herschel's Observatory telescope, seen here during testing in the Netherlands, has a 3.5-m primary mirror—the largest ever launched into space. (credit:ESA)
Panorama Of The Carina Nebula(31 of43)
Open Image Modal
This Hubble Space Telescope image shows the central region of the Carina Nebula where star birth – and death – is taking place. The Carina Nebula is about 7500 light-years away in the southern constellation Carina. (credit:NASA/ESA/N. Smith (Univ. Calif., Berkeley)/STScI/AURA)
Planck Inspection(32 of43)
Open Image Modal
ESA's Planck satellite’s surface was inspected under ultraviolet light to detect dust particles that fluoresce in the ultraviolet. (credit:ESA)
First Spacewalk By ESA Astronaut(33 of43)
Open Image Modal
German astronaut Thomas Reiter performed the first spacewalk by an ESA astronaut during a mission to the Mir space station in 1995. (credit:ESA)
Meteosat-2 View Of Earth(34 of43)
Open Image Modal
Using Meteosat geostationary meteorological satellites, images of the planet from space have become very useful in monitoring the Earth. (credit:ESA)
Descent Of Soyuz TM-32 Reentry Module(35 of43)
Open Image Modal
This return module, carrying ESA astronaut Claudie Haigneré, seen minutes before landing near the city of Dzhezkazgan in Kazakhstan, on 31 October, 2001, concluded a 10-day mission to the International Space Station. (credit:CNES/ESA/S. Corvaja)
Through A Water Drop(36 of43)
Open Image Modal
ESA astronaut Pedro Duque watches a water bubble float between him and the camera, showing his image refracted, on the International Space Station during a mission in 2003. (credit:NASA (ISS007-E-17973))
ESA's SpaceHouse(37 of43)
Open Image Modal
ESA’s SpaceHouse is a concept design for a new type of habitation on Earth based on a series of innovative space technologies. It is designed to cope with high wind speeds, flooding, earthquakes, subsidence, severe hail and exceptionally heavy rain, and even fires. (credit:ESA)
Largest Volcano In Our Solar System(38 of43)
Open Image Modal
This view, taken in January 2004, looks vertically down into the caldera at the summit of Olympus Mons on Mars, the highest volcano in our Solar System. Olympus Mons has an average elevation of 22 km. (credit:ESA/DLR/FU Berlin (G. Neukum))
Staring At The Sun(39 of43)
Open Image Modal
This image was taken by SOHO, the Solar and Heliospheric Observatory is stationed 1.5 million kilometres away from Earth. There, it constantly watches the Sun, returning spectacular pictures and data of the storms that rage across its surface. (credit:ESA/NASA)
Titan, Epimetheus And Saturn's Rings(40 of43)
Open Image Modal
The Cassini spacecraft delivered this stunning image showing the small moon Epimetheus and murky atmosphere of Titan in the background, with Saturn's A and F rings stretching across the scene. (credit:NASA/JPL/Space Science Institute (PIA08391))
Blue Lagoon(41 of43)
Open Image Modal
The Niau atoll, in the central South Pacific Ocean, is seen in this image taken on October 6, 2005. Niau is one of nearly 80 coral reef atolls that form the Tuamotu Archipelago in French Polynesia. (credit:ESA)
Recovering An Ariane Booster At Sea(42 of43)
Open Image Modal
Since it became operational in 1999, ESA’s Ariane 5 rockets have launched satellites for communications, Earth observation and scientific research. (credit:ESA/CNES/Arianespace)
Ariane 5 Lift-Off(43 of43)
Open Image Modal
On March 11, 2007, an ESA rocket launched in French Guiana on its mission to place two satellites into geostationary transfer orbits. (credit:ESA/CNES/Arianespace-Service Optique CSG)