Turns Out, There Is A Better Way To Play With Your Dog

Scientists watched 187 videos of humans playing with canines. Here's what they found.

About 70 million people in the U.S. own a dog, but in between cuddle sessions, staring into each other's eyes or playing plain ol' fetch, we all tend to play with our dogs in different ways, according to new research.

Turns out, men play with dogs very differently than women do, and people who work with dogs professionally (such as veterinarians or dog groomers) have their own way of bonding over playtime.

But while we all have distinct styles of play, new research has found that we all speak to our dogs similarly.

In a study recently published in the journal Animal Cognition, scientists have identified the most common words we say to dogs as well as how to make the most of quality time with your pooch.

Open Image Modal
Arthur Tilley via Getty Images

To uncover the secret formula for the perfect dog-human playtime, Alexandra Horowitz and Julie Hecht, scientists with Barnard College's Dog Cognition lab, asked the public to send in short videos of them playing with their dogs.

Dog lovers worldwide jumped at the opportunity, and Horowitz and Hecht reviewed 187 videos from 19 different countries that showed people between the ages of 8 and 75 playing with their canine friends. 

Watching the videos frame-by-frame (which, by the way, is a scientifically-proven pick-me-up), the researchers observed 30 types of playing, including fetch, tug, chase, keep-away, various tricks and teasing. They also measured the face-to-face contact between owner and dog, level of activity, proximity to the dog, and physical contact during the playtime.

The researchers even transcribed every word the owner said to the dog and identified the 35 most used words (e.g., "good," "get/got," "come/c'mon," etc.).

While Horowitz and Hecht observed that the dogs' response to the playtime was "overwhelmingly positive," they found that the dog owners' emotional reactions depended on how they played with their dogs.

"I was surprised to see that different types of play (and different levels of activity and contact between person and dog) were correlated with different emotional experience for the persons," Horowitz told CBS News in an email. "They had very positive affect in games like tug or wrestling play; much more neutral affect in fetch."

Since most of the dogs were happy with the playtime, the researchers measured how much the owners smiled to determine how they were affected by these interactions. 

Here's what they they found:

People are happier when they are physically close to their dogs and active with them.

The researchers found that dog owners who touched their dogs more, stayed close and moved around a lot appeared to have more fun while playing with their dogs.

"In other words," the researchers explain in the study, "people smiled more in play when they were active and moving around, and when there was a lot of physical contact between them and their dogs." 

Open Image Modal
Dougal Waters via Getty Images

Women are more likely to touch their dogs during playtime.

The researchers found male dog owners engaged in less physical contact with their dogs than female owners. In fact, 50 percent of men had no contact with their dogs during the observed playtimes, while only 32 percent of women were hands off.

Open Image Modal
Peathegee Inc via Getty Images

Dog professionals stay closer to their dogs during playtime.

Of the 187 videos, 48 of them featured people who handle dogs professionally, including trainers, veterinarians, dog groomers, breeders, and shelter or doggy day care workers. Compared to the rest of the people in the videos, individuals who worked with dogs professionally spent significantly more time in close proximity to their dogs. They also engaged in higher levels of face-to-face contact with their dogs.

Open Image Modal
Jose Luis Pelaez Inc via Getty Images

The top three most common forms of play were fetch, tease and tug-of-war.

But tug-of-war and teasing (defined as play which provokes or bothers lightheartedly, such as pretending to toss a ball) yielded more positive emotions in humans than fetch, which yielded more neutral emotions.

Open Image Modal
Teresa Short via Getty Images

And in case you were wondering, here's the full list of the most common words we say to our dogs:

1. You

2. Good

3. It

4. Get/got

5. Go/gonna

6. Come/c’mon

7. (Dog’s name)

8. Girl

9. Yay/yeah!

10. That

11. Here

12. I

13. On

14. Oh

15. Are/aren't/'re

16. Ready

17. Boy

18. The

19. Give/gimme

20. Play

21. Okay

22. What/whatcha/what's

23. Me

24. To

25. Yes/yea

26. Do/does

27. Wanna/want

28. Where/where'd/where's

29. Your

30. Drop

31. Is

32. No

33. Ball/bally

34. Am/'m

35. This

 

Support HuffPost

At HuffPost, we believe that everyone needs high-quality journalism, but we understand that not everyone can afford to pay for expensive news subscriptions. That is why we are committed to providing deeply reported, carefully fact-checked news that is freely accessible to everyone.

Whether you come to HuffPost for updates on the 2024 presidential race, hard-hitting investigations into critical issues facing our country today, or trending stories that make you laugh, we appreciate you. The truth is, news costs money to produce, and we are proud that we have never put our stories behind an expensive paywall.

Would you join us to help keep our stories free for all? Your will go a long way.

Support HuffPost

Before You Go

These Dogs Getting Massages Are the Cutest Thing Ever
(01 of03)
Open Image Modal
A relaxing session with a client named Doug da Pug.

Massage therapist Rubi Sullivan never needs to ask her clients to disrobe. But otherwise, the dogs she treats have much in common with people getting a rubdown. "They respond a lot like we do," says Sullivan, a former preschool teacher and the owner of Heal Animal Massage in Portland, Oregon. "Some will relax, stretch out, take deep breaths. Others just yawn and fall asleep." While sessions don't involve candles and incense, Sullivan says a melodious soundtrack can come in handy: "Soft music helps nervous dogs calm down. I like playing piano and classical music for them—and Yo-Yo Ma."
(credit:Joanna Sooper)
(02 of03)
Open Image Modal
Sullivan works on Samson, a black Labrador.

Sullivan is trained in techniques like Swedish massage and soft tissue therapy, but her regulars aren't just pampered pups being overindulged. Most of them have osteoarthritis or joint inflammation, or are recovering from surgery. For senior pooches, the psychological rewards can outweigh the physical ones. Says Sullivan: "I worked with an older long-haired collie named Quincy, who had painful arthritis, for more than a year. The massage was great for his sticky joints, but the mental stimulation really perked him up."
(credit:Laurine Apollini of Apolloni Vineyards)
(03 of03)
Open Image Modal
Through her clients and volunteer work at shelters, Sullivan has helped care for at least 500 canines. But a special pair of pups stand out. "Sacha is my three-legged dog, mostly German shepherd, from the Galápagos Islands, and Thor is a 12-year-old Great Pyrenees I adopted ten years ago," she says. "They're not spoiled, but they definitely demand hands-on attention—and I'm happy to oblige!" (credit:Andie Petkus)