Exxon Mobil Sued Over Climate Change Cover-Up | HuffPost

The lawsuit alleges the oil giant's terminal near Boston continues to pollute rivers and communities.

By

Senior Reporter, HuffPost

|

The environmental advocacy group Conservation Law Foundation has made good on its threat to sue Exxon Mobil Corp., filing what it says is the first U.S. legal action aimed at holding the oil giant accountable for its well-documented climate change cover-up.

The 70-page suit, filed Thursday in U.S. District Court in Boston, alleges Exxon Mobil’s bulk storage and distribution terminal in Everett, Massachusetts, near Boston Harbor, continues to pollute the Island End and Mystic rivers and threatens nearby communities. The complaint also accuses the company of failing to fortify the facility to withstand climate change, including extreme weather events and rising sea levels.

The lawsuit, which seeks unspecified civil penalties and injunctive relief, comes as Exxon Mobil faces numerous investigations into whether the company lied to investors and committed fraud by covering up the risks of climate change for decades. The attorneys general of New York and Massachusetts are probing the company, and the Securities and Exchange Commission has begun an investigation into how Exxon Mobil values future projects amid climate change and plunging oil prices.

“Communities were put in danger and remain in danger, all to cut costs for one of the most profitable corporations in the world,” Bradley Campbell, president of Boston-based Conservation Law Foundation, said in a statement. “It’s time to make Exxon answer for decades of false statements to the public and to regulators and ensure that its Everett facility meets its legal obligation to protect thousands of people and the Boston Harbor estuary from toxic water pollution.”

In 2009, a subsidiary of Exxon Mobil was ordered to pay more than $6.1 million for allowing 15,000 gallons of diesel fuel to spill into the Mystic River. The lawsuit alleges the company continues to violate the Clean Water Act and other federal laws by discharging toxic pollutants.

Chelsea oil tanks on the right, with ships on the docks in Everett, upper right. The Tobin Bridge spans the river and Charlestown, Massport on left.

Boston Globe via Getty Images

Exxon Mobil spokesman Todd Spitler said the lawsuit is “yet another attempt to use the courts to promote a political agenda.” He said the company will vigorously fight it.

“This lawsuit is based on discredited and inaccurate claims by activists about Exxon Mobil’s nearly 40-year history of support for climate research that was conducted publicly in conjunction with the Department of Energy, academics and the UN Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change,” Spitler told The Huffington Post in an email. “To suggest that we had reached definitive conclusions, decades before the world’s experts and while climate science was in an early stage of development, is not credible.”

Reports last year by InsideClimate News and the Los Angeles Times found Exxon executives were aware of the climate risks associated with carbon dioxide emissions in the 1980s, but funded research to cover up those risks and block solutions. In a more recent investigation, the Washington-based Center for International Environmental Law uncovered documents that show the oil industry, including Humble Oil (now Exxon Mobil), was on notice about the potential role of fossil fuels in CO2 emissions no later than 1957 and was “shaping science to shape public opinion” even earlier, in the 1940s.

Though the lawsuit accuses Exxon Mobil of failing to fortify its facility in Everett, oil companies, including Exxon Mobil, have redesigned oil and gas rigs in the face of climate change.

As early as the 1980s, oil companies were beginning to invest in taller oil rigs that could withstand rising sea levels and the impacts of hurricanes, documents uncovered in the Center for International Environmental Law investigation show. Carroll Muffett, the center’s president, called it “an example of the profound distinction of how these companies were protecting their own interests” and not the public’s.

The Conservation Law Foundation lawsuit says Exxon Mobil has been well aware of the impacts and risks of climate change.

“Despite knowing of the certainty of rising temperatures and rising sea levels since as early as the 1970s, Exxon Mobil did not use its findings to prepare its Everett Terminal for such risks,” the complaint says.

The lawsuit includes projections showing the Everett facility would be inundated with water in the event of a hurricane or climate-driven sea level rise. Either scenario, the suit says, could result in oil and other pollutants being discharged.

Conservation Law Foundation’s trial team will include attorney Allan Kanner, whose firm represented plaintiffs in BP’s Deepwater Horizon spill in 2010.

Our 2024 Coverage Needs You

As Americans head to the polls in 2024, the very future of our country is at stake. At HuffPost, we believe that a free press is critical to creating well-informed voters. That's why our journalism is free for everyone, even though other newsrooms retreat behind expensive paywalls.

Our journalists will continue to cover the twists and turns during this historic presidential election. With your help, we'll bring you hard-hitting investigations, well-researched analysis and timely takes you can't find elsewhere. Reporting in this current political climate is a responsibility we do not take lightly, and we thank you for your support.

Contribute as little as $2 to keep our news free for all.

Can't afford to donate? Support HuffPost by creating a free account and log in while you read.

Support HuffPost

Before You Go

Recent Oil Spills

(01 of54)

Crews work to clean up the North Vancouver shoreline on April 12, 2015, four days after bunker fuel leaked into English Bay. (credit:Western Canada Marine Response Corporation)

(02 of54)

(credit:Western Canada Marine Response Corporation)

(03 of54)

(credit:Western Canada Marine Response Corporation)

(04 of54)

(credit:Western Canada Marine Response Corporation)

(05 of54)

(credit:Western Canada Marine Response Corporation)

(06 of54)

(credit:Western Canada Marine Response Corporation)

(07 of54)

(credit:Western Canada Marine Response Corporation)

(08 of54)

(credit:Western Canada Marine Response Corporation)

(09 of54)

(credit:Western Canada Marine Response Corporation)

(10 of54)

(credit:Western Canada Marine Response Corporation)

(11 of54)

Barnacles are covered in oil at Second Beach in Vancouver after an oil spill from a ship in English Bay. (credit:Vancouver Aquarium)

(12 of54)

Oil washed up on Ambleside beach in West Vancouver. (credit:Vancouver Aquarium)

(13 of54)

Bunker fuel residue washes up on the beach April 10, 2014 after an oil spill in Vancouver's English Bay. (credit:Vancouver Aquarium)

(14 of54)

The Canadian Coast Guard responds to a bunker fuel spill in Vancouver's English Bay on April 9, 2015. (credit:Darryl Dyck/Canadian Press)

(15 of54)

(credit:Darryl Dyck/Canadian Press)

(16 of54)

(credit:Darryl Dyck/Canadian Press)

(17 of54)

(credit:Darryl Dyck/Canadian Press)

(18 of54)

(credit:Darryl Dyck/Canadian Press)

(19 of54)

(credit:Darryl Dyck/Canadian Press)

(20 of54)

(credit:Darryl Dyck/Canadian Press)

(21 of54)

(credit:Darryl Dyck/Canadian Press)

(22 of54)

(credit:Darryl Dyck/Canadian Press)

(23 of54)

(credit:Ben West/Tanker Free BC)

(24 of54)

(credit:Ben West/Tanker Free BC)

(25 of54)

(credit:Ben West/Tanker Free BC)

(26 of54)

Water birds were reportedly spotted on the beach with oily feathers, but officials say they flew away before their health could be checked. (credit:Darryl Dyck/Canadian Press)

(27 of54)

(credit:Darryl Dyck/Canadian Press)

California Declares State Of Emergency As Oil Spill Harms Pristine Coastline(28 of54)

GOLETA, CA - MAY 22: A bird covered in oil spreads its wings as it sits on a rock near Refugio State Beach on May 22, 2015 in Goleta, California. California Gov. Jerry Brown declared a State of Emergency after over 100,000 gallons of oil spilled from an abandoned pipeline on the land near Refugio State Beach, spreading over about nine miles of beach within hours. The largest oil spill ever in U.S. waters at the time occurred in the same section of the coast in 1969 where numerous offshore oil platforms can be seen, giving birth to the modern American environmental movement. (Photo by Justin Sullivan/Getty Images) (credit:Justin Sullivan via Getty Images)

SeaWorld Cares For Oiled Sea Lion(29 of54)

SAN DIEGO, CA - MAY 21: In this handout photo provided by SeaWorld San Diego, a young California sea lion is washed at SeaWorld San Diego's Oiled Wildlife Care Center May 21, 2015 in San Diego, California. The animal was brought to SeaWorld for rehabilitation after being affected by the oil spill in Santa Barbara. The animal's condition is guarded, as the team continues to keep him hydrated and wash all the oil off. (Photo by Mike Aguilera/SeaWorld San Diego via Getty Images) (credit:Handout via Getty Images)

Ruptured Pipeline Spills Oil Along Santa Barbara Coast(30 of54)

GOLETA, CALIFORNIA - MAY 20: An octopus lies dead on an oil-covered beach after an oil spill near Refugio State Beach on May 20, 2015 north of Goleta, California. About 21,000 gallons spilled from an abandoned pipeline on the land near Refugio State Beach, spreading over about four miles of beach within hours. The largest oil spill ever in U.S. waters at the time occurred in the same section of the coast where numerous offshore oil platforms can be seen, giving birth to the modern American environmental movement. (Photo by David McNew/Getty Images) (credit:David McNew via Getty Images)

Ruptured Pipeline Spills Oil Along Santa Barbara Coast(31 of54)

GOLETA, CALIFORNIA - MAY 20: A dead lobster lies on an oil-covered beach after an oil spill near Refugio State Beach on May 20, 2015 north of Goleta, California. About 21,000 gallons spilled from an abandoned pipeline on the land near Refugio State Beach, spreading over about four miles of beach within hours. The largest oil spill ever in U.S. waters at the time occurred in the same section of the coast where numerous offshore oil platforms can be seen, giving birth to the modern American environmental movement. (Photo by David McNew/Getty Images) (credit:David McNew via Getty Images)

US-OIL-POLLUTION(32 of54)

A bird covered in oil glides from rocks to the water at El Capitan State Beach in Goleta, California, May 22, 2015. The oil company behind a crude spill on the California coast vowed to do the 'right thing' to clear up the mess, even as reports emerged of past leaks involving its pipelines. Plains All American Pipeline made the pledge as it said nearly 8,000 gallons of oil had been scooped up, out of some 21,000 gallons believed to have flooded into the ocean near Santa Barbara, northwest of Los Angeles. AFP PHOTO/ MARK RALSTON (Photo credit should read MARK RALSTON/AFP/Getty Images) (credit:MARK RALSTON via Getty Images)

APTOPIX California Oil Spill(33 of54)

A bird covered in oil flaps its wings at Refugio State Beach, north of Goleta, Calif., Thursday, May 21, 2015. More than 7,700 gallons of oil has been raked, skimmed and vacuumed from a spill that stretched across 9 miles of California coast, just a fraction of the sticky, stinking goo that escaped from a broken pipeline, officials said. (AP Photo/Jae C. Hong) (credit:ASSOCIATED PRESS)

US-OIL-POLLUTION(34 of54)

Pelicans fly above the oil polluted water at Refugio State Beach in Goleta, California, May 22, 2015. The oil company behind a crude spill on the California coast vowed to do the 'right thing' to clear up the mess, even as reports emerged of past leaks involving its pipelines. Plains All American Pipeline made the pledge as it said nearly 8,000 gallons of oil had been scooped up, out of some 21,000 gallons believed to have flooded into the ocean near Santa Barbara, northwest of Los Angeles. AFP PHOTO/ MARK RALSTON (Photo credit should read MARK RALSTON/AFP/Getty Images) (credit:MARK RALSTON via Getty Images)

Ruptured Pipeline Spills Oil Along Santa Barbara Coast(35 of54)

GOLETA, CALIFORNIA - MAY 20: An oil-covered lobster lies dead on the beach after an oil spill near Refugio State Beach on May 20, 2015 north of Goleta, California. About 21,000 gallons spilled from an abandoned pipeline on the land near Refugio State Beach, spreading over about four miles of beach within hours. The largest oil spill ever in U.S. waters at the time occurred in the same section of the coast where numerous offshore oil platforms can be seen, giving birth to the modern American environmental movement. (Photo by David McNew/Getty Images) (credit:David McNew via Getty Images)

California Oil Spill(36 of54)

Staff members and volunteers work to clean oil off a brown pelican at the International Bird Rescue office in the San Pedro area of Los Angeles, on Friday, May 22, 2015. A broken onshore pipeline in Santa Barbara, Calif., spewed oil down a storm drain and into the ocean for several hours Tuesday before it was shut off. (AP Photo/Chris Carlson) (credit:ASSOCIATED PRESS)

SeaWorld Cares For Oiled Sea Lion(37 of54)

SAN DIEGO, CA - MAY 22: In this handout photo provided by SeaWorld San Diego, a California sea lion affected by the Santa Barbara oil spill is washed by members of SeaWorld's Rescue Team at SeaWorld San Diego's Oiled Wildlife Care Center May 22, 2015 in San Diego, California. Shown in the photo is the animal's back flipper. The animal's condition is guarded, as the team continues to keep him hydrated and wash all the oil off. (Photo by Mike Aguilera/SeaWorld San Diego via Getty Images) (credit:Handout via Getty Images)

US-OIL-POLLUTION(38 of54)

Volunteers and staff of the International Bird Rescue use a toothbrush and soap to clean oil off a brown pelican in the San Pedro area of Los Angeles, California on May 22, 2015, who was rescued after being covered in oil from the Refugio Oil Spill. Oil-covered pelicans, dead lobsters and other marine life have been recovered from the area, where a nine-mile (14-kilometer) long oil spill has closed two beaches normally crowded with tourists, officials said. Plains All American Pipeline made the pledge as it said nearly 8,000 gallons of oil had been scooped up, out of some 21,000 gallons believed to have flooded into the ocean near Santa Barbara, northwest of Los Angeles. AFP PHOTO/ ROBYN BECK (Photo credit should read ROBYN BECK/AFP/Getty Images) (credit:ROBYN BECK via Getty Images)

California Declares State Of Emergency As Oil Spill Harms Pristine Coastline(39 of54)

GOLETA, CA - MAY 22: Two birds covered in oil sit on a rock near Refugio State Beach on May 22, 2015 in Goleta, California. California Gov. Jerry Brown declared a State of Emergency after over 100,000 gallons of oil spilled from an abandoned pipeline on the land near Refugio State Beach, spreading over about nine miles of beach within hours. The largest oil spill ever in U.S. waters at the time occurred in the same section of the coast in 1969 where numerous offshore oil platforms can be seen, giving birth to the modern American environmental movement. (Photo by Justin Sullivan/Getty Images) (credit:Justin Sullivan via Getty Images)

SeaWorld Cares For Oiled Sea Lion(40 of54)

SAN DIEGO, CA - MAY 21: In this handout photo provided by SeaWorld San Diego, SeaWorld Animal Care Specialist Gareth Potter, Dr. Todd Schmitt and SeaWorld Animal Care Specialist Nick Northcraft wash a sea lion affected by the Santa Barbara oil spill, in the background is Kris Wiese, environmental scientist with California Fish and Game, at SeaWorld San Diego's Oiled Wildlife Care Center May 21, 2015 in San Diego, California. The animal's condition is guarded, as the team continues to keep him hydrated and wash all the oil off. (Photo by Mike Aguilera/SeaWorld San Diego via Getty Images) (credit:Handout via Getty Images)

Ruptured Pipeline Spills Oil Along Santa Barbara Coast(41 of54)

GOLETA, CALIFORNIA - MAY 20: A California brown pelican and California sea lion fish in oil-contaminated water from an inland oil spill near Refugio State Beach on May 20, 2015 north of Goleta, California. About 21,000 gallons spilled from an abandoned pipeline on the land near Refugio State Beach, spreading over about four miles of beach within hours. The largest oil spill ever in U.S. waters at the time occurred in the same section of the coast where numerous offshore oil platforms can be seen, giving birth to the modern American environmental movement. (Photo by David McNew/Getty Images) (credit:David McNew via Getty Images)

Ruptured Pipeline Spills Oil Along Santa Barbara Coast(42 of54)

GOLETA, CALIFORNIA - MAY 20: California brown pelicans and gulls fish in oil-contaminated water from an inland oil spill near Refugio State Beach on May 20, 2015 north of Goleta, California. About 21,000 gallons spilled from an abandoned pipeline on the land near Refugio State Beach, spreading over about four miles of beach within hours. The largest oil spill ever in U.S. waters at the time occurred in the same section of the coast where numerous offshore oil platforms can be seen, giving birth to the modern American environmental movement. (Photo by David McNew/Getty Images) (credit:David McNew via Getty Images)

Ruptured Pipeline Spills Oil Along Santa Barbara Coast(43 of54)

GOLETA, CALIFORNIA - MAY 20: An oil-covered crab stopped dead in mid-track on the beach near Refugio State Beach on May 20, 2015 north of Goleta, California. About 21,000 gallons spilled from an abandoned pipeline on the land near Refugio State Beach, spreading over about four miles of beach within hours. The largest oil spill ever in U.S. waters at the time occurred in the same section of the coast where numerous offshore oil platforms can be seen, giving birth to the modern American environmental movement. (Photo by David McNew/Getty Images) (credit:David McNew via Getty Images)

Ruptured Pipeline Spills Oil Along Santa Barbara Coast(44 of54)

GOLETA, CALIFORNIA - MAY 20: An crab lies dead on an oil-covered beach after an oil spill near Refugio State Beach on May 20, 2015 north of Goleta, California. About 21,000 gallons spilled from an abandoned pipeline on the land near Refugio State Beach, spreading over about four miles of beach within hours. The largest oil spill ever in U.S. waters at the time occurred in the same section of the coast where numerous offshore oil platforms can be seen, giving birth to the modern American environmental movement. (Photo by David McNew/Getty Images) (credit:David McNew via Getty Images)

Ruptured Pipeline Spills Oil Along Santa Barbara Coast(45 of54)

GOLETA, CALIFORNIA - MAY 20: An oil-covered lobster lies dead on the beach after an oil spill near Refugio State Beach on May 20, 2015 north of Goleta, California. About 21,000 gallons spilled from an abandoned pipeline on the land near Refugio State Beach, spreading over about four miles of beach within hours. The largest oil spill ever in U.S. waters at the time occurred in the same section of the coast where numerous offshore oil platforms can be seen, giving birth to the modern American environmental movement. (Photo by David McNew/Getty Images) (credit:David McNew via Getty Images)

(46 of54)

(credit:Darryl Dyck/Canadian Press)

Niger Delta ExxonMobil Spill, Nigeria - May 2010(47 of54)

In Nigeria's Akwa Ibom State, an ExxonMobil pipeline ruptured on May 1 and spilled over a million gallons of oil, reported the Guardian. The leak continued for seven days before it was stopped.HuffPost blogger Omoyele Sowore explained in July 2010 that an oil spill from ExxonMobil operations was nothing new to the country. He wrote that an "environmental catastrophe [had] been going on since December 2009." He described the toll on Nigeria: "There's oil on the surface of the ocean, wildlife coated in crude, fishermen losing their businesses."In 2011, the Nigerian government said there had been more than 7,000 oil spills in the country between 1970 and 2000 that could take up to 30 years and $1 billion to clean up. (credit:Getty)

Trans-Alaska Pipeline Spill - May 2010(48 of54)

In May 2010, several thousand barrels of oil spilled from the Trans-Alaska pipeline "during a scheduled pipeline shutdown at a pump station near Fort Greely," explained AP.No injuries were reported and officials said the spill was likely "limited to the gravel on top of the containment area's line." (credit:Alamy)

Red Butte Creek Spill, Utah - June 2010(49 of54)

In June 2010, a Chevron pipeline ruptured and spilled oil into a creek near Salt Lake City, Utah.It was first estimated that over 17,000 to 21,000 gallons spilled into the creek, which leads into the Great Salt Lake, reported AP. Around 150 birds were "identified for rehabilitation." The oil did not reach the Great Salt Lake, however.Chevron was later cited for the spill, which released an estimated 33,000 gallons in total.In March 2012, a group of 66 residents of a Salt Lake City neighborhood sued Chevron for damage caused by the Red Butte Creek spill and a smaller spill in December 2011.

Kalamazoo River Spill, Michigan - July 2010(50 of54)

In late July 2010, an Enbridge pipeline in southwestern Michigan sprung a leak and spilled over 800,000 gallons of oil into a creek which flows into the Kalamazoo River.By August, a regional EPA administrator said that significant progress had been made at the site, but "the agency cautioned that it will take months to complete the cleanup," reported AP.By the end of September, the pipeline -- which travels from Ontario to Indiana -- was back in operation.The EPA later reported that about 1.1 million gallons of oil were recovered, but pipeline operator Enbridge said that it would stick with previous estimates that only about 843,000 gallons were spilled. (credit:Getty)

Xingag Harbor Spill, Dailan, China - July 2010(51 of54)

In July 2010, China experienced what was reported as the "country's largest reported oil spill" after a pipeline rupture near the northeastern port city of Dailan.Several days after the spill, cleanup efforts were underway over a 165 square mile (430 square kilometer) area of the Yellow Sea.The Chinese government reported that about 1,500 tons or 461,790 gallons of oil had spilled, but experts contended that the spill could have been "dozens of times larger," reported AP. (credit:Getty)

North Sea Spill, United Kingdom - Aug. 2011(52 of54)

In August 2011, an oil rig off the eastern coast of Scotland began leaking oil into the North Sea. Royal Dutch Shell, which operates the Gannet Alpha oil rig, initially reported that 54,600 gallons of oil were spilled.A second leak soon occurred, turning the spill into the worst in the North Sea in a decade, reported AP.Several days later, Shell announced that it had "closed a valve from which oil was spilling into the North Sea," according to AP. The spill released about 1,300 barrels of oil, which spread out over a 2.5 square mile (6.7 square kilometer) area. (credit:Alamy)

Rena Spill, New Zealand - Oct. 2011(53 of54)

In October 2011, a Liberian-flagged cargo ship ran aground on a reef in Northern New Zealand and began leaking oil.With oil washing up on shore, a government minister deemed it the country's largest maritime environmental disaster a week later.Although over 2,000 sea birds were killed by the spill that spilled about 400 tons of fuel oil, 343 little blue penguins were rescued and cleaned of oil. [Watch video of the penguins' release into the wild here.]In January, half of the stricken Rena began sinking into the sea after breaking apart and spilling over 100 cargo containers. (credit:Getty)

Mayflower, Arkansas Pipeline Rupture - March 2013(54 of54)

In late March 2013, ExxonMobil's Pegasus pipeline ruptured and spilled about 5,000 barrels (210,000 gallons) of Canadian heavy crude oil into a residential area in Mayflower, Arkansas. Exxon later removed a damaged 52-foot section of the pipeline.The company's cleanup efforts -- which reportedly included using paper towels -- were criticized in the media.Local residents began reporting health issues not long after the spill. Arkansas Attorney General Dustin McDaniel has also expressed his concern for the health of Mayflower residents, reported The Huffington Post's Lynne Peeples.One month after the spill, the same pipeline leaked one barrel of oil into a residential yard in Missouri. (credit:EPA)

Suggest a correction

|

From Our Partner

HuffPost Shopping's
Best Finds

This Affordable Drugstore Cream Might Be The Closest Thing To The Famous La Mer

This Palestinian Olive Oil Soap Is The Best I’ve Ever Used

12 Cute And Comfortable Garden Clogs That Aren’t Crocs

The 'Unsexy' Beauty Products That My Algorithm Keeps Suggesting Are Actually Pretty Great

37 Ways To Make Your Backyard Look Like An 'After' Shot On HGTV