Labor Department Proposes 'Life-Saving' Rule To Tighten Silica Standards On Worksites

How The White House 'Came To Its Senses' On Worker Safety
|
Open Image Modal
US President Barack Obama answers a question during a town hall meeting at Binghamton University, on August 23, 2013 in Binghamton, New York. Obama is on a two-day bus tour through New York and Pennsylvania to discuss his plan to make college more affordable, tackle rising costs, and improve value for students and their families. AFP Photo/Jewel Samad (Photo credit should read JEWEL SAMAD/AFP/Getty Images)

WASHINGTON -- After a long delay at the White House and heavy pressure from public health groups, the Labor Department proposed a new regulation on Friday that would tighten standards on silica dust on U.S. work sites, saving thousands of lives and curbing lung disease, according to occupational health experts.

Known as the silica rule, the regulation would cut the allowable amount of respirable silica dust in U.S. workplaces by at least half. Silica, considered a carcinogen by the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, has for years been known to lead to debilitating lung conditions, including lung cancer, in industries like coal mining and construction where workers breathe tiny particles of the dust.

As HuffPost previously reported, the White House sat on the safety proposal for more than two years amid pressure from industry groups, rankling worker advocates and labor unions who said the inaction was costing lives. After numerous closed-door meetings between stakeholders and administration officials, the release of the rule on Friday puts the proposal into the public record and opens up a period of public comment.

The announcement by the Labor Department on Friday doesn't guarantee that the rule will become law, and industry trade groups are expected to lobby hard to water down or scrap the rule. But safety advocates said the proposal marked a major step forward in a decades-long effort to protect vulnerable workers.

"This is one of the poster children of occupational health hazards," said Celeste Monforton, a work safety expert with George Washington University. "This has been something the public health community has known for thousands of years to be a problem. I'm glad to see that the White House finally came to their senses or recognized that the political climate was safe enough for them to allow [the Labor Department's Occupational Safety and Health Administration] to move forward with this."

Crystalline silica is commonly found in construction materials like sand and granite. Workers who breathe the dust, particularly in a line of work like sandblasting, can eventually suffer from the respiratory disease silicosis. According to the Labor Department, about 2.2 million U.S. workers are exposed to the dust, with 1.85 million of them in the construction industry.

Despite the mounting evidence of silica's dangers, businesses have told federal officials they're worried about the cost of stronger regulations. Groups that met with the White House over the rule included the National Association of Home Builders, the American Chemistry Council and the National Industrial Sand Association, as well as the AFL-CIO labor federation and non-profits dealing in workplace safety.

Dr. David Michaels, the Labor Department's assistant secretary of labor for occupational safety and health, told HuffPost that the rule would provide a critical update to regulations that haven't been adequately tightened since they were established in the early 1970s.

"We haven't made significant progress since 1971," Michaels said. "Subsequently, we've learned a great deal. The most important development since the early 1970s has been numerous studies showing that silica exposure increases the risk of lung cancer."

Current regulations allow for 100 micrograms of silica per cubic meter in most industries, and 250 in construction. The new rule would make the limit 50 micrograms per cubic meter across all industries. The rule would also provide medical exams and training to workers who are exposed to the dust. OSHA estimates that the rule would save 700 lives and head off 1,600 new silicosis cases each year.

Michaels said the rule allows for companies to take certain formal precautions on their worksites in order to be in compliance, rather than take on the cost of having the site measured for silica dust. He said that provision would help keep the rule's cost down for small construction businesses. According to OSHA, the average cost of the rule for the typical U.S. workplace will be $1,242 per year, and a more modest $550 for small workplaces of less than 20 employees.

In a statement on Friday, AFL-CIO President Richard Trumka praised the release of the proposal but warned that it was far from being officially on the books.

"This rule is long overdue," Trumka said. "But this rule is only a proposal -- workers exposed to silica dust will only be protected when a final rule is issued. Some industry groups are certain to attack the rule and try to stop it in its tracks."

Support HuffPost

At HuffPost, we believe that everyone needs high-quality journalism, but we understand that not everyone can afford to pay for expensive news subscriptions. That is why we are committed to providing deeply reported, carefully fact-checked news that is freely accessible to everyone.

Whether you come to HuffPost for updates on the 2024 presidential race, hard-hitting investigations into critical issues facing our country today, or trending stories that make you laugh, we appreciate you. The truth is, news costs money to produce, and we are proud that we have never put our stories behind an expensive paywall.

Would you join us to help keep our stories free for all? Your will go a long way.

Support HuffPost

Before You Go

2014 Gubernatorial Candidates
Greg Abbott (R-Texas)(01 of95)
Open Image Modal
State Attorney General (2002-Present)State Supreme Court Justice (1995-2001) (credit:(AP Photo/Pat Sullivan))
Tom Pauken (R-Texas)(02 of95)
Open Image Modal
Texas Workforce Commissioner (2008-2013)Republican Party of Texas Chairman (1994-1997) (credit:(Source: Tompauken.com))
Gov. Pat Quinn (D-Ill.)(03 of95)
Open Image Modal
Incumbent41st Governor of Illinois (2009-Present)Lieutenant Governor of Illinois (2003-2009)State Treasurer (1991-1995) (credit:(AP Photo/Scott Eisen))
Bill Daley (D-Ill.)(04 of95)
Open Image Modal
White House Chief of Staff (2011-2012)U.S. Secretary of Commerce (1997-2000) (credit:(AP Photo/M. Spencer Green))
Bill Brady (R-Ill.)(05 of95)
Open Image Modal
GOP Nominee for Governor (2010)State Senator (2002-Present) (credit:(AP Photo/Scott Eisen))
Kirk Dillard (R-Ill.)(06 of95)
Open Image Modal
State Senator (1994-Present) (credit:(AP Photo/Seth Perlman, File))
Bruce Rauner (R-Ill.)(07 of95)
Open Image Modal
Venture Capitalist (credit:(AP Photo/M. Spencer Green))
Dan Rutherford (R-Ill.)(08 of95)
Open Image Modal
State Treasurer (2011-Present)State Senator (2003-2011)State Representative (1993-2003) (credit:(AP Photo/Seth Perlman))
Gov. John Kasich (R-Ohio)(09 of95)
Open Image Modal
Incumbent69th Governor of Ohio (2011-Present) (credit:(AP Photo/Tony Dejak, File))
Ed FitzGerald (D-Ohio)(10 of95)
Open Image Modal
First Cuyahoga County Executive (2011-Current)Mayor of Lakewood (2007-2011) (credit:(AP Photo/Mark Duncan))
Tom Carlson (R-Neb.)(11 of95)
Open Image Modal
State Senator (2007-Present) (credit:(Source: Wikipedia))
Charlie Janssen (R-Neb.)(12 of95)
Open Image Modal
State Senator (2009-Present) (credit:(Source: www.agingrebel.com))
Chuck Hassebrook (D-Neb.)(13 of95)
Open Image Modal
Executive Director, Center for Rural AffairsUniversity of Nebraska Regent (credit:(AP Photo/Grant Schulte))
Bill Halter (D-Ark.)(14 of95)
Open Image Modal
Arkansas Lieutenant Governor (2007-2011)Acting Social Security Commissioner (2001)Deputy Commissioner (1999-2001) (credit:(AP Photo/Brian Chilson))
Mike Ross (D-Ark.)(15 of95)
Open Image Modal
U.S. Representative (2001-2013) (credit:(Source: Wikipedia))
Curtis Coleman (R-Ark.)(16 of95)
Open Image Modal
Businessman, GOP Activist (credit:(AP Photo/Danny Johnston, File))
Debra Hobbs (R-Ark.)(17 of95)
Open Image Modal
State Representative (2008-Present) (credit:(Source: arkansashouse.org))
Asa Hutchinson (R-Ark.)(18 of95)
Open Image Modal
Administrator of Drug Enforcement Administration (2001-2003)U.S. Representative (1997-2001) (credit:(AP Photo/ Evan Vucci))
Gov. C.L. "Butch" Otter (R-Idaho)(19 of95)
Open Image Modal
Incumbent32nd Governor of Idaho (2007-Present)U.S. Representative (2001-2007)Lieutenant Governor of Idaho (1987-2001)State Representative (1973-1977) (credit:(AP Photo/Idaho Press-Tribune, Charlie Litchfield, File))
Gov. John Kitzhaber (D-Ore.)(20 of95)
Open Image Modal
Incumbent35th and 37th Governor of Oregon (1995-2003, 2011-Present)President of Oregon Senate (1985-1993) (credit:(AP Photo/Don Ryan, file))
Gov. Tom Corbett (R-Pa.) (21 of95)
Open Image Modal
Incumbent46th Governor of Pennsylvania (2011-Present)State Attorney General (2005-2011) (credit:(AP Photo/Manuel Balce Ceneta, File))
Kathleen McGinty (D-Pa.)(22 of95)
Open Image Modal
Secretary of Pennsylvania EPA (2003-2008)Chair of the Council on Environmental Quality (1995-1998) (credit:(Source: pennlive.com))
John Hanger (D-Pa.)(23 of95)
Open Image Modal
Pennsylvania Secretary of Environmental Protection (2008-2011) (credit:(Source: pennlive.com))
Rob McCord (D-Pa.)(24 of95)
Open Image Modal
State Treasurer (2009-Present) (credit:(AP Photo/ anonymous/Courtesy of McCord Campaign, File))
Allyson Schwartz (D-Pa.)(25 of95)
Open Image Modal
U.S. Representative (2005-Present)State Senator (1991-2005) (credit:(AP Photo/Charles Dharapak, File))
Gov. Robert Bentley (R-Ala.)(26 of95)
Open Image Modal
Incumbent53rd Governor of Alabama (2011-Present)State Representative (2003-2011) (credit:(AP Photo/Dave Martin))
Gov. Jerry Brown (D-Calif.)(27 of95)
Open Image Modal
Incumbent34th and 39th Governor of California (1975-1983, 2011-Present)State Attorney General (2007-2011)Mayor of Oakland (1999-2007)Democratic presidential candidate (1976, 1980 and 1992)California Secretary of State (1971-1975) (credit:(Photo/Rich Pedroncelli, file))
Tim Donnelly (R-Calif.)(28 of95)
Open Image Modal
State Assemblyman (2010-Present)(AP Photo/Rich Pedroncelli) (credit:AP)
Abel Maldonado (R-Calif.)(29 of95)
Open Image Modal
Lieutenant Governor of California (2010-2011)State Senator (2004-2010)State Assemblyman (1998-2004)Mayor of Santa Maria (1996-1998) (credit:(AP Photo/Paul Sakuma, File))
Gov. Terry Branstad (R-Iowa)(30 of95)
Open Image Modal
Incumbent39th and 42nd Governor of Iowa (1983-1999, 2011-Present)Lieutenant Governor of Iowa (1979-1983) (credit:(AP Photo/Charlie Neibergall))
Jack Hatch (D-Iowa)(31 of95)
Open Image Modal
State Senator (2003-Present)State Representative (1985-1993, 2001-2003) (credit:(Source: senate.iowa.gov))
Bob Krause (D-Iowa)(32 of95)
Open Image Modal
Candidate for U.S. Senate (2010)State Representative (1975-1977) (credit:(Source: Wikipedia))
Tyler Olson (D-Iowa)(33 of95)
Open Image Modal
Iowa Democratic Party Chairman (2013)State Representative (2007-Present) (credit:(AP Photo/Charlie Neibergall, File))
Gov. Dennis Daugaard (R-S.D.)(34 of95)
Open Image Modal
Incumbent32nd Governor of South Dakota (2011-Present)Lieutenant Governor of South Dakota (2003-2011) (credit:(AP Photo/Manuel Balce Ceneta))
Gov. Susana Martinez (R-N.M.)(35 of95)
Open Image Modal
Incumbent31st Governor of New Mexico (2011-Present) (credit:(AP Photo/J. Scott Applewhite, File))
Gary King (D-N.M.)(36 of95)
Open Image Modal
State Attorney General (2007-Present) (credit:(AP Photo/Susan Montoya Bryan,File))
Linda Lopez (D-N.M.)(37 of95)
Open Image Modal
State Senator (1997-Present) (credit:(Source: newmexico.watchdog.com))
Gov. Paul LePage (R-Maine)(38 of95)
Open Image Modal
Incumbent74th Governor of Maine (2011-Present)Mayor of Waterville (2003-2011) (credit:(AP Photo/Robert F. Bukaty))
Mike Michaud (D-Maine)(39 of95)
Open Image Modal
U.S. Congressman (2003-Present)State Senator (1994-2002)State Representative (1980-1994) (credit:(AP Photo/Robert F. Bukaty, file))
Eliot Cutler (Ind.-Maine)(40 of95)
Open Image Modal
Independent Candidate for Governor (2010)Lawyer (credit:(Source: onlinesentinel.com))
David Slagger (Green Ind.-Maine)(41 of95)
Open Image Modal
State Representative (Jan. 2012-Dec. 2012) (credit:(AP Photo/Glenn Adams))
Gov. Brian Sandoval (R-Nev.)(42 of95)
Open Image Modal
Incumbent29th Governor of Nevada (2011-Present)Federal District Court Judge (2005-2009)State Attorney General (2003-2005) (credit:(AP Photo/Kevin Clifford,File))
Gov. Nikki Haley (R-S.C.)(43 of95)
Open Image Modal
Incumbent116th Governor of South Carolina (2011-Present)State Representative (2005-2010) (credit:(AP Photo/Jeffrey Collins))
Vincent Sheheen (D-S.C.)(44 of95)
Open Image Modal
Democratic nominee for Governor (2010)State Senator (2004-Present)State Representative (2000-2004) (credit:(AP Photo/Bruce Smith))
Gov. John Hickenlooper (D-Colo.)(45 of95)
Open Image Modal
Incumbent42nd Governor of Colorado (2011-Present)Mayor of Denver (2003-2011) (credit:(AP Photo/Ed Andrieski))
Greg Brophy (R-Colo.)(46 of95)
Open Image Modal
State Senator (2005-Present)State Representative (2003-2005) (credit:(AP Photo/Brennan Linsley))
Scott Gessler (R-Colo.)(47 of95)
Open Image Modal
Colorado Secretary of State (2011-Present) (credit:(AP Photo/Ed Andrieski, file))
Tom Tancredo (R-Colo.)(48 of95)
Open Image Modal
U.S. Representative (1999-2009) (credit:(AP Photo/Ed Andrieski, File))
Anthony Brown (D-Md.)(49 of95)
Open Image Modal
Lieutenant Governor of Maryland (2007-Present)Maryland House of Delegates Member (1999-2007) (credit:(AP Photo/Jose Luis Magana))
Heather Mizeur (D-Md.)(50 of95)
Open Image Modal
Maryland House of Delegates Member (2007-Present) (credit:(Photo by Thos Robinson/Getty Images for Women's Campaign Fund))
Douglas Gansler (D-Md.)(51 of95)
Open Image Modal
Maryland Attorney General (2007-Present)State's Attorney for Montgomery County, Maryland (1999-2007) (credit:(Source: Wikipedia))
David Craig (R-Md.)(52 of95)
Open Image Modal
Harford County Executive (2005-Present)State Senator (1995-1999)State Delegate (1991-1994) (credit:(Source: Wikipedia))
Ron George (R-Md.)(53 of95)
Open Image Modal
State Delegate (2007-Present) (credit:(Source: Wikipedia))
Brian Murphy (R-Md.)(54 of95)
Open Image Modal
Republican Candidate for Governor (2010)Founder of Plimhimmon Group and Smith Island Baking Company (credit:(Source: catchthedogs.com))
Blaine Young (R-Md.)(55 of95)
Open Image Modal
President of the Frederick County Board of Commissioners (2010-Present) (credit:(Source: gazette.net))
Joe Avellone (D-Mass.)(56 of95)
Open Image Modal
Pharmaceutical Executive, Ex-Wellesley Selectman & Navy Veteran (credit:(AP Photo/Michael Dwyer))
Steven Grossman (D-Mass.)(57 of95)
Open Image Modal
Treasurer and Receiver-General of Massachusetts (2011-Present)DNC Chairperson (1997-1999)Massachusetts Democratic Party Chairperson (1991-1993) (credit:(Source: pembrokechamber.org))
Dan Wolf (D-Mass.)(58 of95)
Open Image Modal
State Senator (2011-Present) (credit:(Source: wickedlocal.com))
Charlie Baker (R-Mass.)(59 of95)
Open Image Modal
GOP Nominee for Governor (2010)Massachusetts Secretary of Administration and Finance (1994-1998) (credit:(Source: Wikipedia))
Gov. Andrew Cuomo (D-N.Y.)(60 of95)
Open Image Modal
Incumbent56th Governor of New York (2011-Present)State Attorney General (2007-2010)U.S. Secretary of Housing and Urban Development (1997-2001)Assistant Secretary of Housing and Urban Development (1993-1997) (credit:(AP Photo/David Duprey))
Gov. Mary Fallin (R-Okla.)(61 of95)
Open Image Modal
Incumbent27th Governor of Oklahoma (2011-Present)U.S. Representative (2007-2011)Lieutenant Governor of Oklahoma (1995-2007)State Representative (1990-1995) (credit:(AP Photo/Sue Ogrocki))
Gov. Nathan Deal (R-Ga.)(62 of95)
Open Image Modal
Incumbent82nd Governor of Georgia (2011-Present)U.S. Representative (2003-2010)State Senator (1981-1993) (credit:(AP Photo/David Goldman, File))
David Pennington (R-Ga.)(63 of95)
Open Image Modal
Dalton Mayor & Businessman (credit:(AP Photo/Courtesy of David Pennington))
Gov. Neil Abercrombie (D-Hawaii)(64 of95)
Open Image Modal
Incumbent7th Governor of Hawaii (2010-Present)U.S. Representative (1991-2010) (credit:(AP Photo/Marco Garcia))
David Ige (D-Hawaii)(65 of95)
Open Image Modal
State Senator (1994-Present)State Representative (1986-1994) (credit:(AP Photo/Anita Hofschneider))
Gov. Sam Brownback (R-Kan.)(66 of95)
Open Image Modal
Incumbent46th Governor of Kansas (2011-Present)U.S. Senator (1996-2011)U.S. Representative (1995-1996) (credit:(AP Photo/John Milburn))
Gov. Rick Snyder (R-Mich.)(67 of95)
Open Image Modal
Incumbent48th Governor of Michigan (2011-Present) (credit:(AP Photo/Carlos Osorio))
Mark Schauer (D-Mich.)(68 of95)
Open Image Modal
U.S. Representative (2009-2011)State Senator (2003-2009)State Representative (1997-2002) (credit:(Source: Wikipedia))
Gov. Bill Haslam (R-Tenn.) (69 of95)
Open Image Modal
Incumbent49th Governor of Tennessee (2011-Present)Mayor of Knoxville (2003-2011) (credit:(AP Photo/Mark Humphrey, File))
Gov. Dan Malloy (D-Conn.)(70 of95)
Open Image Modal
Incumbent88th Governor of Connecticut (2011-Present)Mayor of Stamford (1995-2009)Kings County Assistant District Attorney (1980-1984) (credit:(AP Photo/Manuel Balce Ceneta))
Tom C. Foley (R-Conn.)(71 of95)
Open Image Modal
Republican nominee for Governor (2010)Ambassador to Ireland (2006-2009) (credit:(Source: blogs.rep-am.com))
John McKinney (R-Conn.)(72 of95)
Open Image Modal
State Senator (1999-Present) (credit:(AP Photo/Charles Krupa))
Gov. Rick Scott (R-Fla.)(73 of95)
Open Image Modal
Incumbent45th Governor of Florida (2011-Present) (credit:(AP Photo/J Pat Carter, File))
Elizabeth Cuevas-Neunder (R-Fla.)(74 of95)
Open Image Modal
Puerto Rican Chamber of Commerce of Florida President, Businesswoman (credit:(AP Photo/Matt Rourke))
Nan Rich (D-Fla.)(75 of95)
Open Image Modal
State Senator (2004-2012)State Representative (2000-2004) (credit:(AP Photo/Steve Cannon))
Charlie Crist (D-Fla.)(76 of95)
Open Image Modal
44th Governor of Florida (2007-2011) Florida Attorney General (2003-2007) Florida Commissioner of Education (2001-2003) State Senator (1993-1999)Former Republican (credit:(Source: Wikipedia))
Gov. Mark Dayton (DFL-Minn.)(77 of95)
Open Image Modal
Incumbent40th Governor of Minnesota (2011-Present)U.S. Senator (2001-2007)State Auditor (1991-1995) (credit:(AP Photo/The Star Tribune, Jeff Wheeler))
Dave Thompson (R-Minn.)(78 of95)
Open Image Modal
State Senator (2011-Present) (credit:(Source: Wikipedia))
Kurt Zellers (R-Minn.)(79 of95)
Open Image Modal
Speaker of the Minnesota House of Representatives (2011-2013)Minority Leader, Minnesota House of Representatives (2009-2011)State Representative (2003-2013) (credit:(AP Photo/Stacy Bengs, file))
Gov. Scott Walker (R-Wis.)(80 of95)
Open Image Modal
Incumbent45th Governor of Wisconsin (2011-Present)Milwaukee County Executive (2002-2010)Member of Wisconsin State Assembly (1993-2002) (credit:(AP Photo/Scott Bauer, File))
Gov. Matt Mead (R-Wyo.) (81 of95)
Open Image Modal
Incumbent32nd Governor of Wyoming (2011-Present)U.S. Attorney for District of Wyoming (2001-2007) (credit:(AP Photo/Casper Star-Tribune, Alan Rogers))
Cindy Hill (R-Wyo.) (82 of95)
Open Image Modal
State Superintendent of Public Instruction (2011-Present)EducatorTea Party Activist (credit:(AP Photo/Bob Moen))
Gov. Sean Parnell (R-Alaska)(83 of95)
Open Image Modal
Incumbent10th Governor of Alaska (2009-Present)Lieutenant Governor of Alaska (2006-2009)State Senator (1997-2001)State Representative (1993-1997) (credit:(AP Photo/Chris Miller))
Gov. Jan Brewer (R-Ariz.)(84 of95)
Open Image Modal
Incumbent22nd Governor of Arizona (2009-Present)Arizona Secretary of State (2003-2009)Maricopa County Board of Supervisors Member (1997-2003)State Senator (1987-1997)State Representative (1983-1987) (credit:(AP Photo/Matt York))
Ken Bennett (R-Ariz.)(85 of95)
Open Image Modal
Arizona Secretary of State (2009-Present)President of Arizona Senate (2003-2007) (credit:(Photo by Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images))
Al Melvin (R-Ariz.)(86 of95)
Open Image Modal
State Senator (2008-Present) (credit:(Source: azsenaterepublicans.com))
Hugh Hallman (R-Ariz.)(87 of95)
Open Image Modal
Mayor of Tempe (2004-2012)Tempe Councilman (1998-2002) (credit:(Source: Wikipedia))
Andrew Thomas (R-Ariz.)(88 of95)
Open Image Modal
Maricopa County Attorney (2005-2010) (credit:(AP Photo/Ross D. Franklin, File))
Chad Campbell (D-Ariz.)(89 of95)
Open Image Modal
State House Minority Leader (2011-present)State Representative (2007-Present) (credit:(Source: azcapitoltimes.com))
Fred DuVal (D-Ariz.)(90 of95)
Open Image Modal
Treasurer of Democratic Governors Association (2008-2010)Democratic National Committee Member (1989-1993, 2009-2011) (credit:(Source: Wikipedia))
Gov. Peter Shumlin (D-Vt.)(91 of95)
Open Image Modal
Incumbent81st Governor of Vermont (2011-Present) (credit:(AP Photo/Toby Talbot))
Gov. Maggie Hassan (D-N.H.)(92 of95)
Open Image Modal
Incumbent81st Governor of New Hampshire (2013-Present)State Senate Majority Leader (2008-2010)State Senator (2005-2010) (credit:(AP Photo/Jim Cole, File))
Andy Sanborn (R-N.H.) (93 of95)
Open Image Modal
State Senator (2011-2012, 2013-Present) (credit:(Source: twitter))
Gov. Lincoln Chafee (D-R.I.)(94 of95)
Open Image Modal
Incumbent74th Governor of Rhode Island (2011-Present)U.S. Senator (1999-2007)Mayor of Warwick (1992-1999) (credit:(AP Photo/J. Scott Applewhite, File))
Gina Raimondo (D-R.I.)(95 of95)
Open Image Modal
State General Treasurer (2011-Present) (credit:Source: Wikipedia))