Simon Schama: Orthodox Jews Are 'In Denial' About Jewish History

Simon Schama: Orthodox Jews Are 'In Denial' About Jewish History
|

How can one man, or even one documentary, tell the entire story of a group of nearly 14 million people? For Simon Schama, whose new documentary 'The Story of the Jews' elaborates on the complicated history and culture of the Jewish people, it is a matter of looking at trends and misconceptions and using this to build toward a healthy future.

Jewish history has been co-opted in many ways, often relegated to the Holocaust-onward and mired in debates on Zionism and the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. But Schama is taking things back a few thousand years to look at some of the most fundamental trends in Jewish history.

As Schama told HuffPost Live host Josh Zepps in a recent interview, the history of the Jews is one of great diversity and adaptation.

"The Jewish story is the story of wandering," Schama says. "It is the story of extraordinary heterogenous complication."

The question of Israel as a Jewish state, contrary to the heterogenous nature of the Jewish past, Schama says, is an argument that goes on even within Israel.

"The argument between Tel Aviv and Jerusalem, the argument between those who want a peace with Palestinians, like me; who want side by side a Jewish state and a Palestinian state are those who feel that the story of the Jews is about finding a place to live with people who are not like you."

This long-standing value, Schama says, gets lost among Orthodox Jews, who the historian believes are "in denial about what the complicated reality of Judaism, as well as Jewish culture, has been."

Before You Go

Lost Synagogues Of Europe
Belz(01 of16)
Open Image Modal
Hassidic Synagogue and study center built in 1843. (credit:Andrea Strongwater)
Bochum(02 of16)
Open Image Modal
The main synagogue was destroyed during Kristallnacht, Nov. 9-10, 1938. (credit:Andrea Strongwater)
Karlovy Vary(03 of16)
Open Image Modal
Karlovy Vary Exterior -- A spa town. The synagogue was built in 1877 and hosted the 12th and 13th Zionist Congress. (credit:Andrea Strongwater)
Karlovy Vary(04 of16)
Open Image Modal
Karlovy Vary Interior -- the synagogue was built to accommodate 2,000 worshippers. (credit:Andrea Strongwater)
Tartu(05 of16)
Open Image Modal
A synagogue built in 190l in Estonia. (credit:Andrea Strongwater)
Leopoldstadtler Synagogue(06 of16)
Open Image Modal
Leopoldstadter Synagogue, Vienna, interior -- The largest synagogue in Vienna was built in 1858. (credit:Andrea Strongwater)
Warsaw(07 of16)
Open Image Modal
The Tlomackie Synagogue built in 1875-77. (credit:Andrea Strongwater)
Dortmund(08 of16)
Open Image Modal
A synagogue built in 1900 and destroyed as a test to gauge public opinion in September 1938. (credit:Andrea Strongwater)
Frankfurt(09 of16)
Open Image Modal
A synagogue complex built in 1904. (credit:Andrea Strongwater)
Livorno(10 of16)
Open Image Modal
The interior of a synagogue on a site that has housed a synagogue since the 1500s. (credit:Andrea Strongwater)
Luxembourg(11 of16)
Open Image Modal
The synagogue was built in 1894 (credit:Andrea Strongwater)
Przedborz(12 of16)
Open Image Modal
A wooden synagogue that dates from approximately 1760. (credit:Andrea Strongwater)
Seesen(13 of16)
Open Image Modal
The first synagogue built specifically for a Reform congregation in 1810. (credit:Andrea Strongwater)
Strasbourg(14 of16)
Open Image Modal
The synagogue on Quai Kleber inaugurated in 1898. (credit:Andrea Strongwater)
Torah Shield(15 of16)
Open Image Modal
Painted with reference to a Torah decoration from 18th century Poland. (credit:Andrea Strongwater)
Heitzing Synagogue(16 of16)
Open Image Modal
Heitzing Synagogue in Vienna, built in 1924. (credit:Andrea Strongwater)