Why Aren't We Talking About What This Study Discovered About NFL Violence?

Researchers have found that NFL players get arrested for violent crimes more often than 20- and 30-something men.
|

study recently published online in the Journal of Criminal Justice is being touted as proof that NFL players on the whole are better behaved than the media and public generally assume, but there's a finding within the numbers that's a bit more worrisome.

The researchers found that NFL players’ overall arrest rate was significantly lower than those of men age 20-39 in the general population, and media outlets including CNN, CBS, Sporting News and The Guardian have run with the study’s top-level finding.

Overall, it appears to be true that NFL players aren't arrested as much as their male peers. The researchers obtained the general population figures from the FBI Uniform Crime Reports and the NFL arrest numbers predominantly from The San Diego Union-Tribune Database and The USA Today Database, which both track arrests among players in the NFL. Twenty- and 30-something men were almost twice as likely as NFL players to be arrested between 2000 and 2013. 

Open Image Modal
utdallas.edu

“There’s a perception that the NFL has this huge crime problem and that it’s longstanding. That’s what everybody believes,” Alex Piquero, Ashbel Smith professor of criminology at University of Texas at Dallas and one of the study's authors, said in a release. “The data show that it’s not true.”

But the study also broke down the arrests into three groups -- violent crime, property crime and public order crime -- and something pops out once you look at those groupings separately: While NFL players are arrested for property crimes and public order crimes at rates far below the national average, they are often arrested for violent crimes at rates above them.

Open Image Modal
utdallas.edu

The researchers identified six years in which the rate of NFL players’ rates of violent crime was above the national average at a "statistically significant" level. In a number of other years, the rate was above the general male population as well, albeit less so. The combined measure of 2000 to 2013 found that NFL players have been arrested for violent crimes at a rate above 20- and 30-something men as a whole in the 21st century overall.

Violent crime, as categorized by the researchers, included things like murder, manslaughter, DUI manslaughter, robbery, aggravated assault, sexual assault, rape, battery, domestic violence, child abuse and kidnapping.

Property crimes included burglary, theft and failure to pay child support. Public order crimes included things like DUIs, prostitution, public intoxication, animal abuse and disorderly.

Deadspin published a story back in 2013 that found NFL players committed assault and battery at rates below those of men overall in 2010. But Piquero argued that his team's study is more comprehensive, as it looks at a longer time period on both sides, and many more crimes. “In one sense, this [study] may provide some support to those who are concerned about violence among NFL players," the authors wrote in their report. 

An NFL spokesman did not specifically respond to a request for comment about the NFL's violent arrest rate. But Charles Way, the NFL's Vice President of Player Engagement, did release this statement on the study:

We have long recognized that arrest rates of NFL players are far below the general population. NFL players are highly visible members of their community who are all expected to conduct themselves properly. Everyone in the league -- coaches, players and executives -- is held to higher standards of responsible conduct because of what it means to be associated with the NFL. We have longstanding policies and programs designed to encourage responsible behavior, and have evolved them to ensure that everyone meets that standard and embodies our values.

Piquero said in a conversation with The Huffington Post that it was “certainly” possible that the players’ high incomes provide intangible benefits that lead to lower arrest rates for property and public order crimes. But like the NFL's Way, he hoped the main takeaway is that the most NFL players aren't criminals. “In the majority of the cases, the players are really good people and they don’t commit crimes," he said. 

Geert Dhondt, an assistant economics professor at John Jay College of Criminal Justice, questioned the usefulness of comparing NFL arrest rates to such a broad swath of the male population, rather than, say, men of a certain income.

Dhondt also noted over the phone that it's possible the study underplays the overall criminality of NFL players. The researchers only consider the crimes NFL players commit during their careers -- which are on average only around six years, according to the league -- while the statistics for crimes committed by 20- and 30-something men in the general male population aren't limited to such parameters. Could the overall male arrest rate compare more favorably to NFL players' if the researchers looked at a different or more specific time period?

Piquero willingly admitted it was possible when asked, but said it was "equally plausible" that it could make NFL players look even better or roughly the same.

In an email, he wrote: 

Our rationale in using the 20-39 age span is because there are players who are between those ages. So, yes, we could do the analyses using a different age band (but those age bands could vary in many ways, right, one could do 20-23, 26-29, 30-33, etc., so which one is the *more* correct one, and there is no perfect or agreed-upon answer to that of course; as well, if the average age is, say 27-30, and it covers 75% of the players, what about the other 25% -- how would one handle that in any comparison?).

In the end, we wanted to be more complete in a comparison sense and not pose any undue restriction or assumptions on the comparisons across the two samples. So, that was our rationale.

Comparing NFL players' arrest rates to men in general is difficult work, especially considering it requires working with differing databases that often employ varying methodologies. But Piquero still hopes that "when you look at the forest and not the trees," you'll see the typical NFL player isn't much worse than the typical man.

When it comes to the NFL as a whole, however, the forest still looks rather violent. 

Also on HuffPost:

2015 NFL Breakout Stars
Brandin Cooks, WR, New Orleans(01 of25)
Open Image Modal

We pegged Cooks before his rookie year as a guy to watch, and, while shaky at times, he emerged as a real weapon for Drew Brees. A versatile wideout -- and now a healthy one -- who can line up all over the field, the dynamic Oregon State man and former Biletnikoff Award winner no longer has to share targets with the departed Jimmy Graham and Kenny Stills. He should eat.

(credit:Credit: Chris Graythen via Getty Images)
Carlos Hyde, RB, San Francisco(02 of25)
Open Image Modal

Longtime 49ers stalwart Frank Gore is in Indy, which means Hyde, the second-year man from Ohio State, is the unquestioned leader in the backfield. As a rookie, he gained 70.3 percent of his yards after contact -- the most of any running back in the NFL, according to Pro Football Focus. His bruising running style and nose for the goal line will be a welcome sight for Colin Kaepernick and this offense. Don't be surprised to see Hyde -- now in the zone-blocking scheme -- rack up 300 carries and over 1,500 total yards.

(credit:Credit: Michael Zagaris via Getty Images)
Allen Robinson, WR, Jacksonville(03 of25)
Open Image Modal

Forget about super-hyped free agent pickup Julius Thomas. Robinson was a revelation during his 10-game rookie campaign with the Jags, amassing 548 yards while becoming the go-to target for fellow rookie Blake Bortles. In year two, expect a healthy Robinson to take another step forward and build his rapport with Bortles by continuing to catch both the easy and tough balls.

(credit:Credit: Associated Press)
Jarvis Landry, WR, Miami(04 of25)
Open Image Modal

Fellow LSU receiving product Odell Beckham Jr. garnered most of the praise last year, but Landry quietly caught 84 balls, slotting him 17th in the league. With Mike Wallace departed to Minnesota, the 5-foot-11 Landry will become Ryan Tannehill's true No. 1 option. Expect to see both his touchdowns and yards per catch rise as a result.

(credit:Credit: Associated Press)
Joseph Randle, RB, Dallas(05 of25)
Open Image Modal

The truth is that Randle was supposed to play a bigger role last year, but then DeMarco Murray erupted and Randle couldn't stay out of trouble. Now, with Murray gone and little in the form of competition, he gets the opportunity to be the Cowboys' feature back behind the game's premier offensive line. Tony Romo excels running play-action, and the best way to set it up is by establishing Randle, who's probably more talented than he's given credit for.

(credit:Credit: Tom Pennington via Getty Images)
Davante Adams, WR, Green Bay(06 of25)
Open Image Modal

I loved Adams even before the devastating Jordy Nelson injury. He has all of the tools you covet in a young receiver: size, speed, route-running ability and consistent hands in cold weather. As a rookie, he single-handedly broke the game open against Dallas in the divisional round of last year's playoffs. And, despite being the fourth option in the Green Bay offense (behind Jordy Nelson, Randall Cobb and Eddie Lacy), Adams has earned the trust of Aaron Rodgers and the Green Bay staff. He won't see enough targets to amass the gaudy numbers of Jarvis Landry, say -- but to be sure, we can expect a bump in his production.

(credit:Credit: Al Bello via Getty Images)
Derek Carr, QB, Oakland(07 of25)
Open Image Modal

Carr had a solid rookie campaign, despite playing on a wretched football team with little help. The Raiders went out and got the best receiver in the draft in Alabama's Amari Cooper, whose tremendous route running and consistent hands will help Carr immensely. If he can stay upright, Carr --- who will also benefit from his new offensive coordinator, Bill Musgrave -- should enjoy a very productive second season in Oakland.

(credit:Credit: Steve Nehf via Getty Images)
Lamar Miller, RB, Miami(08 of25)
Open Image Modal

Miami wants to run the ball, and the diminutive Miller has the necessary speed and pass-catching ability to really help Ryan Tannehill out of the backfield. But he needs to stay on the field for three downs, and he needs to become a 20-touch guy. Coming off his most productive season as a pro, Miller -- who rushed for 1,099 yards and eight scores -- has the playmaking ability to take it to another level in 2015. Better yet, this is the all-important first contract year.

(credit:Credit: Chris Trotman via Getty Images)
Markus Wheaton, WR, Pittsburgh(09 of25)
Open Image Modal

Wheaton doesn't have the physical stature of teammate Martavis Bryant, but his lightning speed and ability to work the middle of the field will make him a favorite of Ben Roethlisberger. With Antonio Brown and even Bryant commanding top corners, Wheaton will benefit that much more. He could feasibly catch 70 balls and pass the 1K mark.

(credit:Credit: Justin K. Aller via Getty Images)
Teddy Bridgewater, QB, Minnesota(10 of25)
Open Image Modal

Bridgewater was 6-6 as a starter sans Adrian Peterson, but his nearly 3,000 yards were more impressive. The Louisville product completed over 72 percent of his passes in December, and has drawn the praise of coaches and teammates in camp. Now, with Adrian Peterson back in the fold, along with rising receiver Charles Johnson and speedster Mike Wallace -- acquired via trade last March -- Bridgewater seems on the verge of stardom. Plus, he has Norv Turner to aid in his development.

(credit:Credit: Joel Auerbach via Getty Images)
Jordan Matthews, WR, Philadelphia(11 of25)
Open Image Modal

We know Chip Kelly wants to throw the ball, and we know he likes Matthews. That's all you really need, but here's the cherry on top: Matthews, at 6 feet 3 inches, is a big, rangy target who, by all accounts, is having a splendid training camp. New quarterback Sam Bradford will love his ability to stretch the field and, perhaps equally importantly, make plays in the slot. Moreover, the No. 1 receiving option in the Eagles' passing game has averaged 83.5 receptions for 1,325 yards and 9.5 touchdowns under Kelly, per SI.com. Plus, former Eagle Jeremy Maclin's 143 targets are up for grabs.

(credit:Credit: Al Bello via Getty Images)
Charles Johnson, WR, Minnesota(12 of25)
Open Image Modal

Johnson -- not the more-hyped Cordarrelle Patterson --is the one to watch for on the perimeter for the Vikings. A true downfield threat (sub-4.4 speed) with big, strong hands and a massive target range, the 6-foot-2 Johnson -- a Division II product out of Grand Valley State -- will expand his route tree in the always-pivotal third season for a wide receiver. Teddy Bridgewater will look his way a ton, and the result could be a 1,000-yard season.

(credit:Credit: Joe Robbins via Getty Images)
Latavius Murray, RB, Oakland(13 of25)
Open Image Modal

Murray flashed brilliance during his second year, highlighted by his 4-carry, 120-yard, 2-touchdown performance against Kansas City in Week 11. A monstrous runner with real speed at 6 feet 3 inches, Murray is also a capable receiving threat for Derek Carr out of the backfield. Basically, get this guy the ball any way you can, and he will take care of the rest.

(credit:Credit: Associated Press)
John Brown, WR, Arizona(14 of25)
Open Image Modal

Brown, a Division II Pittsburg State product, is the true No. 2 receiver in Arizona's offense, and with Michael Floyd's injury concerns, he may even be the No. 1 at times. An explosive, shifty wideout with breakaway speed, he also put on an extra 10 pounds of muscle during the offseason. Simply put, Carson Palmer will feed him a ton of targets this season, and Brown will capitalize.

(credit:Credit: Christian Petersen via Getty Images)
Travis Kelce, TE, Kansas City(15 of25)
Open Image Modal

"Gronk-lite," as I refer to Kelce, is a physical specimen with tremendous athletic ability and a receiving skill set we simply do not see that often. A 6-foot-5, 260 pound behemoth of a tight end who can really run, he should reach the 75-catch, 1,000-yard mark in his second pro season. Like Austin Seferian-Jenkins, Kelce is another second-year tight end with massive upside.

(credit:Credit: Jamie Squire via Getty Images)
Jonathan Stewart, RB, Carolina(16 of25)
Open Image Modal

Stewart, a 28-year-old veteran running back, doesn't really fit the "breakout" mold, but opportunity strikes. The brutally unsuccessful Thunder and Lightning combination he made with DeAngelo Williams is finally over. Assuming Stewart stays healthy (and durability has been an issue in the past), he will go over the 1,000-yard clip for the first time since 2009.

(credit:Credit: Associated Press)
Alfred Blue, RB, Houston(17 of25)
Open Image Modal

Arian Foster is out, which means Alfred Blue -- a rugged second-year back from LSU -- will have every opportunity to assume the role for Bill O'Brien's offense. The Texans may have trouble scoring, but their stout defense will keep them in games. Plus, no team runs the ball more. Blue, whom I had pegged as a potential fantasy sleeper before Foster's injury, is known for his vision and toughness -- two traits that will earn him carries ... and production.

(credit:Credit: Gregory Shamus via Getty Images)
Tyler Eifert, TE, Cincinnati(18 of25)
Open Image Modal

I liked Philly's Zach Ertz here, too, but Eifert is more important to his offense -- an instrumental component to Andy Dalton's success. The third-year man from Notre Dame is finally healthy, after essentially missing all of 2014-15. At 6 feet 6 inches, he provides a massive target range for Dalton, especially inside the 20s, where he can win jump-balls. Eifert is a robust talent whose consistent hands should lend themselves to plenty of targets while amassing at least 65 catches. Plus, because Eifert is a capable blocker and because Jermaine Gresham is gone, he will also take the lion's share of snaps.

(credit:Credit: Peter Aiken via Getty Images)
C.J. Anderson, RB, Denver(19 of25)
Open Image Modal

Anderson burst onto the scene later in the season with his nasty running style and consistent play. Further, because he can catch the ball (34 receptions), he's an ideal fit for Peyton Manning and Denver. He also tied for second in the ESPN good blocking yards per attempt (GBYPA) metric, which gauges a ball carrier's productivity on plays with good blocking. Expect more of the same from Anderson, with an expanded role from Week 1.

(credit:Credit: Colorado Springs Gazette via Getty Images)
Jeremy Hill RB, Cincinnati(20 of25)
Open Image Modal

Year two for Jeremy Hill means he can show why -- during the second half of last year -- only Marshawn Lynch and Eddie Lacy had more yards after contact. Marvin Lewis loves to run the ball, and with Hill, he has one of the game's truly elite young backs: a physical, and yet very dynamic, runner. Don't be too worried about Giovani Bernard stealing reps. Instead, expect a monstrous season for the former LSU standout.

(credit:Credit: Associated Press)
Martavis Bryant, WR, Pittsburgh(21 of25)
Open Image Modal

Bryant joins C.J. Spiller, DeAndre Hopkins and Sammy Watkins as another one of Clemson's skill position dynamos. Expectations are tempered with the 4-game suspension, but even still, Bryant should put up big numbers. The 6-foot-5 receiver can beat you with speed (4.4 40) and size, not to mention a consistent set of hands rare for a 23-year-old. We know Big Ben loves to throw the deep ball, an area in which few were better than Bryant last season, including both Calvin Johnson and A.J. Green, per ESPN.com.

(credit:Credit: Justin K. Aller via Getty Images)
Doug Martin, RB, Tampa Bay(22 of25)
Open Image Modal

Remember this guy? After taking the league by storm and rushing for nearly 1,500 yards as a rookie -- one of my few accurate predictions -- Martin has posted back-to-back sub-500-yard seasons with putrid yards per carry averages. The Bucs, meanwhile, have revamped a bad offensive line, and Martin has reportedly lost a ton of weight as well. He will provide a boost to Jameis Winston and regain the form he had three years ago.

(credit:Credit: Joe Robbins via Getty Images)
Chris Ivory, RB, New York Jets(23 of25)
Open Image Modal

The 27-year-old Ivory is hardly the sexiest name on this list, but he is a proven in-between-the-tackles runner who will be on the field for three downs and earn goal line carries. The Jets -- even without Geno Smith under center -- want to control the clock and let their defense win games. Ivory, who will earn plenty of yards after contact and won't cough it up, should be in line for his best year yet.

(credit:Credit: Associated Press)
Eddie Royal, WR, Chicago(24 of25)
Open Image Modal

I had the former Virginia Tech standout in this group even before the Kevin White injury news. Royal is as steady as he is stealthy, consistently under the radar despite catching 109 balls and scoring 15 touchdowns over the past two years. Now, the 29-year-old vet heads to Chicago, where he will reunite with Jay Cutler. In 2008, as a rookie with Denver, Royal caught 91 balls from Cutler, working primarily in the slot. He will once again assume that role in 2015, this time opposite Alshon Jeffery, who's sure to command plenty of attention.

(credit:Credit: Jonathan Daniel via Getty Images)
DeAndre Hopkins, WR, Houston(25 of25)
Open Image Modal

DeAndre Hopkins has the look and feel of a guy about to bust out for a massive, All-Pro type of year. Plus, we know that the crucial step for wide receivers comes in year three. The Texans' quarterback issues are a concern, but Hopkins is a true burner who can flat-out catch the football. Expect the third year wideout to improve on his 1,200-yard, 6-touchdown effort.

(credit:Credit: Associated Press)

Support HuffPost

At HuffPost, we believe that everyone needs high-quality journalism, but we understand that not everyone can afford to pay for expensive news subscriptions. That is why we are committed to providing deeply reported, carefully fact-checked news that is freely accessible to everyone.

Whether you come to HuffPost for updates on the 2024 presidential race, hard-hitting investigations into critical issues facing our country today, or trending stories that make you laugh, we appreciate you. The truth is, news costs money to produce, and we are proud that we have never put our stories behind an expensive paywall.

Would you join us to help keep our stories free for all? Your will go a long way.

Support HuffPost