The Women Those 'Evolution Of Beauty' Videos Leave Out

The contrast between the reality and the ideal is stark.
|

With videos like "100 Years of Lingerie in 3 Minutes" or "100 Years of Beauty: Germany," the Internet has been treated to gorgeous viral videos that show the glamorous side of women's lives throughout history, but according to Polish costume blogger Karolina Zebrowska these videos are leaving out reality. 

"As a person interested in the history of fashion and beauty it really bugged me how inaccurate some of these [videos] are. The beauty standards they show are almost always our contemporary stereotypes of the past decades," Zebrowska said on her blog

Stereotypes, as Zebrowska's video demonstrates, that often ignore the reality of women's lives throughout the 20th century. We prefer to remember women of the past as glamorous fashion ideals rather than real and, often, struggling people.

So Zebrowska made her own "Beauty Through the Decades" video, this time accurately reflecting the fashion demanded of women at different times of economic stress.

"To be frank, it was supposed to be just another 'Beauty Through The Decades' video. I saw lots of them already, but they all have seemed to show beauty standards in a very stereotypical and pop culture way, so I wanted to do a more historically accurate one," Zebrowska said in a caption accompanying her video. "As I was doing some research, I became more and more aware that beautiful faces and fashion we see on the photos, ads and fashion plates are just an idealistic version of reality. So here's to reality."

Though Zebrowka's video only covers 1900-1940 and specifically considers white women living in the West, the imagery is a powerful commentary both on how we view the past and who we think the women of the past were.

For instance, when we look at the lovely Gibson Girl of the 1900s we see the feminine ideal at the time.

Open Image Modal
Karolina Zebrowska

But women of the time were more likely to be physical laborers in factories than high-fashion socialites. In the United Kingdom, as much as 40 percent of those working in factories were women. 

Open Image Modal
Karolina Zebrowska

We remember the flappers and silver screen sirens of the "Roaring '20s" with fondness.

Open Image Modal
Karolina Zebrowska

In Russia, though, 1 in 9 women were domestic workers like maids and nannies.

Open Image Modal
Karolina Zebrowska

The contrast between the reality and the ideal is stark.

Other beauty videos have considered historical exigencies of the time, including Cut Video's "100 Years of Beauty," which depicts cultural and political shifts as they relate to fashion, notably the division between North and South Korea in "100 Years of Beauty: Korea."  

Zebrowska's video adds another layer of commentary to how we interpret history and see women of the past. We're here for the reality.

Also on HuffPost:

18 Books Every Young Woman Should Read
(01 of18)
Open Image Modal
As any book lover knows, reading provides an ability to escape. Whether it's for a few minutes before bed, on the hour-long bus ride to work or even a full day under the sun -- books and the stories they hold are a driving force for creativity, growth and (almost always) relaxation.Novels allow us to visit places, time periods and states of mind we never thought possible. Often these stories and their characters change how we see ourselves and put us on a completely new path.It's no surprise that women are big readers, contributing to 64 percent of book sales. With these statistics in mind (and our own healthy addiction to reading), we asked the HuffPost editors and our Facebook audience which books shaped the way they thought about themselves as young women. And while we couldn't fit all of the amazing books on this list, we've rounded up 18 that have made life-changing impressions on our community.In the name of written words that have left a permanent mark on us, here are 18 books that changed the way many young women felt about themselves:
1. The Bluest Eye(02 of18)
Open Image Modal
"The Bluest Eye helped me to realize that I was truly beautiful -- both inside and out -- in spite of society's standards." - Dana Oliver, Senior Beauty Editor"[This book] definitely changed the way I felt about myself as a young, black woman -- especially after growing up in predominantly white areas/schools. I used to adhere to these sort of beauty ideals that all of my friends wanted for themselves, and similar to one of the main characters Pecola... It wasn't until I read this book for a 1960s literature class that it really hit me that I should enhance and embrace my own beauty, instead of morphing myself into somebody else." - Chanel Parks, Style Fellow
2. The Bell Jar by Sylvia Plath(03 of18)
Open Image Modal
"Some of The Bell Jar reads like Austen -- a literary vestige of times gone by. But reading Plath's 'fig tree' metaphor for the lack of dimension often demanded of women's lives, in which Esther Greenwood finds herself 'starving to death' when she is unable to choose which metaphorical 'fig' to reach for (career, love, ambition, children), was the first time the perennial paradox of womanhood was elucidated so clearly for me." - Amanda Duberman, News Editor HuffPost Women"I strongly believe every woman, young and old, should read it a few times throughout their lives as it will strike different chords at different times but it is so wonderful no matter the relevance at the time." - Jaecie Butler, via Facebook
3. How Should A Person Be? by Sheila Heti(04 of18)
Open Image Modal
"[Heti] found a way to articulate the messy mix of ambition, self-doubt and complicated feelings about success that many young women -- particularly those of a creative persuasion -- experience... It also depicts the intimacy and difficulty and kindness of female friendships in a way that I'd never seen before in print." - Meredith Melnick, Editorial Director Healthy Living
5. White Oleander by Janet Fitch(05 of18)
Open Image Modal
"I felt the power of all women after reading that. It's never far from my heart, literally." - Candace Alyshia, via Facebook"[It] taught me about how unfair the world can be to certain people but you should always fight for what's right." - Kerri Padilla, via Facebook
6. To Kill A Mockingbird by Harper Lee(06 of18)
Open Image Modal
"I still read it once a year. It's super grounding. It reminds me to actively practice empathy and patience toward others." - Ley Allen, via Facebook
7. A Wrinkle In Time by Madeleine L'Engle(07 of18)
Open Image Modal
"Life lesson: Nerdy girls are awesome too." - Emma Gray, Senior Editor HuffPost Women
8. The Poetry Of Emily Dickinson by Emily Dickinson(08 of18)
Open Image Modal
"We were assigned boy-centric classics growing up (Hemingway, Fitzgerald, etc), which today I realize was really problematic. I'd begun to think that literature could only be associated with things like men fighting wars, and didn't realize that subtle, emotional observations can be as weighty and important as so-called 'masculine' subjects. In eighth grade I found The Poetry of Emily Dickinson lying around my house, and reading it did away with that mindset completely. I've been in love with language, and female writers who tell bold, quiet stories, ever since." - Maddie Crum, Editor HuffPost Books
9. The Diary Of Anaïs Nin by Anaïs Nin(09 of18)
Open Image Modal
"Nin challenged, in her writings and life, the conventions of writing, art, love, sexuality, feminism, eroticism, morality, marriage, monogamy, law, etc. While I disagree with some of her life choices, her writings, as a young woman, gave me the courage to challenge the status quo. " - Kimiki Wolf, via Facebook
10. The Secret Life Of Bees by Sue Monk Kidd(10 of18)
Open Image Modal
"[This book] taught me about the importance of strong female relationships in a woman's life, that you're much stronger than you think you are and sometimes the best kind of family is the one you choose for yourself." - Holly Chapman, via Facebook.
11. Little Women by Louisa May Alcott(11 of18)
Open Image Modal
"It made me feel strong, independent and that I wanted to be a writer, which I am today. I am a working print journalist. I identified greatly with Jo." Nancy MacPhee, via Facebook
12. The Women's Room by Marilyn French(12 of18)
Open Image Modal
" [It] made me appreciate the women's rights activists that came before me, how far we've come and how much further we have yet to go.Every woman, young or old should read it." - Ivana Batkovic, via Facebook.
13. Dealing With Dragons by Patricia C. Wrede(13 of18)
Open Image Modal
"I used to carry a copy [of the book] around with me everywhere as a little girl, I think because it was proof that my two secret life aspirations weren't abnormal: 1. to never, ever find a husband, and 2. to acquire a pet dragon as soon as possible so we could go on nature-related adventures together." - Elizabeth Perle, Senior Editor HuffPost Teen
14. The Red Tent by Anita Diamant(14 of18)
Open Image Modal
"It inspired me to become a midwife and to be what I want to be as a woman because I want it, not because of what others dictate." - Emma McNulty, via Facebook"It reminded me of the sisterhood I was a part of, and how uniquely we must view our places in the world." - Anjelica Guevara, via Facebook
15.Jane Eyre by Charlotte Brontë(15 of18)
Open Image Modal
" Jane Eyre taught me that anyone with the will to do so can rise above his/her circumstances and lead a life that counts for something." - Beth Elizabeth, via Facebook
16. Tori Amos: Piece By Piece by Tori Amos and Ann Powers(16 of18)
Open Image Modal
"One statement from Tori Amos: Piece by Piece by Tori Amos and Ann Powers: 'I was born a feminist.' That statement really helped define who I am; I have always followed my own path, always trying to resist letting others define my personal brand of femininity and womanhood." - Anne Bettina Pedersen, via Facebook
17. Our Bodies, Ourselves produced by the Boston Women's Health Book Collective(17 of18)
Open Image Modal
"Not a novel, but it is literally the bible when it comes to female body image, sexuality and how our bodies actually work. It's everything your mother wanted to tell you, but probably couldn't." - Emma Gray, Senior Editor HuffPost Women
18. Ella Enchanted by Gail Carson Levine(18 of18)
Open Image Modal
"[Ella] was her own hero. No prince needed. She overcame a problem that should have seemed hopeless." - Krystal DeLatte, via Facebook

Our 2024 Coverage Needs You

As Americans head to the polls in 2024, the very future of our country is at stake. At HuffPost, we believe that a free press is critical to creating well-informed voters. That's why our journalism is free for everyone, even though other newsrooms retreat behind expensive paywalls.

Our journalists will continue to cover the twists and turns during this historic presidential election. With your help, we'll bring you hard-hitting investigations, well-researched analysis and timely takes you can't find elsewhere. Reporting in this current political climate is a responsibility we do not take lightly, and we thank you for your support.

to keep our news free for all.

Support HuffPost