Eric Holder: 9/11 Defendants 'Would Be On Death Row' If Case Proceeded In Federal Court Instead Of Gitmo

Eric Holder: 9/11 Defendants 'Would Be On Death Row' If Case Proceeded In Federal Court Instead Of Gitmo
|

WASHINGTON -- Defendants currently awaiting a military trial in Guantanamo Bay in connection with the Sept. 11 attacks "would be on death row as we speak" had their case proceeded in federal court, Attorney General Eric Holder said Monday.

Four years ago, in November 2009, Holder announced that Khalid Sheikh Mohammed and four alleged co-conspirators would face trial in New York City. The Justice Department reversed its decision a year and a half later, directing the case back to military court due to political opposition to the decision.

But as many critics of the military justice system suspected, the case has dragged on at Guantanamo, and the Sept. 11 case has been bogged down in pretrial hearings, with defense lawyers challenging the very legitimacy of the military tribunal system. When asked at a Monday Justice Department press conference if he stood by his original decision to hold the trial in New York, Holder said events have shown he was right.

"I think that what we have seen over these past four years, not to be egocentric about this, but that I was right," Holder said. "I had access to documents, files, recommendations by the military, U.S. attorneys offices in the Eastern District of Virginia as well as the Southern District of New York, and I think the decision that I announced that day was the right one. I think that the facts and events that have occurred since then demonstrate that."

"We unfortunately did not go down that road for reasons other than those connected to the litigation, I think reasons largely political, I think the opposition was largely political in nature," Holder said, "and I think this is an example of what happens when politics gets into matters that ought to be simply be decided by lawyers and by national security experts."

Our 2024 Coverage Needs You

As Americans head to the polls in 2024, the very future of our country is at stake. At HuffPost, we believe that a free press is critical to creating well-informed voters. That's why our journalism is free for everyone, even though other newsrooms retreat behind expensive paywalls.

Our journalists will continue to cover the twists and turns during this historic presidential election. With your help, we'll bring you hard-hitting investigations, well-researched analysis and timely takes you can't find elsewhere. Reporting in this current political climate is a responsibility we do not take lightly, and we thank you for your support.

to keep our news free for all.

Support HuffPost

Before You Go

Inside Guantanamo's Prison Facility
Guantanamo Guard Tower(01 of23)
Open Image Modal
Located between Guantanamo's Camp Five and Camp Six. (credit:Ryan J. Reilly / Huffington Post)
Guantanamo detainee received physical therapy(02 of23)
Open Image Modal
A skinny Guantanamo detainee receives physical therapy on Tuesday, April 16, 2013. (credit:Ryan J. Reilly / Huffington Post)
Empty cell block(03 of23)
Open Image Modal
A cell block at Guantanamo's Camp VI that had been occupied until a raid on April 13, 2013. One detainee had written "stop tortur us. stop desclate our relgion" on the wall of his cell. The officer in charge of the facility said that detainees had hoarded all types of materials in the communal area. (credit:Ryan J. Reilly / Huffington Post)
Guantanamo Camp VI video feeds(04 of23)
Open Image Modal
A Guantanamo guard looks over a video screen at Camp VI at Guantanamo in April. Detainees had blocked 147 of the prison's 160 cameras, according to a military official. (credit:Ryan J. Reilly / Huffington Post)
Weapons(05 of23)
Open Image Modal
Water bottles filled with gravel were amongst the weapons officials said they confiscated from detainees after the raid in April. (credit:Ryan J. Reilly / Huffington Post)
Weapons(06 of23)
Open Image Modal
Other weapons included broom sticks and shanks. (credit:Ryan J. Reilly / Huffington Post)
Occupied block(07 of23)
Open Image Modal
A guard checks on detainees in a sparsely populated block of Guantanamo's Camp Six in April. (credit:Ryan J. Reilly / Huffington Post)
Guantanamo Medical Facility(08 of23)
Open Image Modal
Military officials show journalists the room where some detainees were being force fed during the ongoing hunger strike at the facility. (credit:Ryan J. Reilly / Huffington Post)
Force Feeding chair(09 of23)
Open Image Modal
A restraining chair used to feed detainees at Guantanamo. (credit:Ryan J. Reilly / Huffington Post)
Cans of Ensure at Guantanamo(10 of23)
Open Image Modal
A guard displays cans of Ensure used to force feed detainees at Guantanamo. (credit:Ryan J. Reilly / Huffington Post)
Detainee handprint(11 of23)
Open Image Modal
A handprint is shown on a Camp VI cell block that was occupied by a detainee until a raid in mid-April. (credit:Ryan J. Reilly)
Detainee shoe(12 of23)
Open Image Modal
A shoe from a detainee left on the now-empty cell block. (credit:Ryan J. Reilly / Huffington Post)
Shower camera(13 of23)
Open Image Modal
Cameras are everywhere in Guantanamo's Camp VI, even inside the shower. (credit:Ryan J. Reilly / Huffington Post)
Cell block(14 of23)
Open Image Modal
The second level of an empty cell block in Camp VI as seen from below. (credit:Ryan J. Reilly)
Camp VI Sign(15 of23)
Open Image Modal
A sign outside Guantanamo's Camp VI. (credit:Ryan J. Reilly / Huffington Post)
Guantanamo Flag At Half Staff(16 of23)
Open Image Modal
A flag flying over Guantanamo's Camp Six flys at half staff in honor of victims of Boston Marathon massacre. (credit:Ryan J. Reilly / Huffington Post)
Camp Five Guards(17 of23)
Open Image Modal
Guards at Camp Five stand watch during morning prayers. (credit:Ryan J. Reilly / Huffington Post)
Camp Five Cell Block(18 of23)
Open Image Modal
An empty cell block in Guantanamo's Camp Five. (credit:Ryan J. Reilly / Huffington Post)
"Splash" Shields(19 of23)
Open Image Modal
Face shields intended to prevent guards from being hit in the face by "cocktails" of urine, feces and semen. (credit:Ryan J. Reilly / Huffington Post)
Water handoff(20 of23)
Open Image Modal
A guard hands water to a detainee on the Bravo block of Guantanamo's Camp Five. (credit:Ryan J. Reilly / Huffington Post)
Dead Banana Rat(21 of23)
Open Image Modal
A dead banana rat on the road to Guantanamo's prison facilities. (credit:Ryan J. Reilly / Huffington Post)
Sunrise By Guantanamo's Camp Five(22 of23)
Open Image Modal
(credit:Ryan J. Reilly / Huffington Post)
Obama, Hagel On Joint Detention Group Board(23 of23)
Open Image Modal
President Barack Obama and Secretary of Defense Chuck Hagel pictured at the headquarters of Joint Task Force Guantanamo's Joint Detention Group headquarters. (credit:Ryan J. Reilly / Huffington Post)