Eric Holder Tells Sam Brownback That Kansas' New Gun Law Is Unconstitutional

Kansas Vows To Fight Holder Claims
|

Kansas officials are vowing to fight United States Attorney General Eric Holder's claim that the state's new ban on federal gun laws is unconstitutional.

Holder wrote Kansas Gov. Sam Brownback (R) in late April that the new law which would prohibit the enforcement of federal gun laws on all guns that are made and stay in Kansas violates the U.S. Constitution's supremacy clause and that the federal government would be willing to take Kansas to court over the law, the Associated Press reported Thursday. In April, Brownback signed the law, which is being described as the most pro-Second Amendment measure in the country. It says that any federal agent who enforces a federal gun law on a "made-in-Kansas" gun would face felony charges.

"Kansas may not prevent federal employees and officials from carrying out their official responsibilities," Holder wrote to Brownback. "And a state certainly may not criminalize the exercise of federal responsibilities."

Brownback did not return messages left for comment by HuffPost.

State Rep. Brett Hildabrand (R-Shawnee), a co-sponsor of the law, told The Huffington Post that he stands behind it and that it does not violate the Constitution. Because the bill only covers guns that stay within the state, it is not subject to interstate commerce, said Hildabrand. His defense is in line with a statement released Thursday afternoon by Kansas Secretary of State Kris Kobach (R), who helped write the law.

Kobach, a constitutional law professor, also accused the federal government of engaging in unconstitutional actions in its Fast and Furious and amnesty cities programs, and questioned why Holder is targeting Kansas.

"The Obama administration has repeatedly violated the United States Constitution for the past four-and-a-half-years," Kobach said. "That abuse cannot continue. The state of Kansas is determined to restore the Constitution and to protect the right of its citizens to keep and bear arms."

Kobach vowed that the state would fight Holder in court, if he chooses to take legal action against Kansas. It is unclear whether Kobach, who oversees elections and record keeping, has the authority to enter the state into litigation.

Robert Cottrol, a law professor at George Washington University, told HuffPost last month that he believes the Kansas law is unconstitutional.

Hildabrand, who said the law is needed for the state's economy, deferred to Brownback on battling Holder in court.

The Kansas law has bipartisan support, including Democratic co-sponsors state Reps. Jan Pauls (Hutchison) and Brandon Whipple (Wichita), who did not return requests for comments. In February, Pauls, a former judge, told HuffPost that it would be up to the courts to determine constitutionality.

The Kansas battle comes as lawmakers in neighboring Missouri are considering similar legislation, which has passed the GOP-controlled state House. Missouri state Rep. Stacey Newman (D-St. Louis) said that Holder's action would not stop her state, but said she is glad he is taking action.

"I am really thankful and glad that the attorney general is being direct with Kansas and saying that this is blatantly unconstitutional," Newman told HuffPost. "You'd think our own legislators would be paying attention."

Our 2024 Coverage Needs You

As Americans head to the polls in 2024, the very future of our country is at stake. At HuffPost, we believe that a free press is critical to creating well-informed voters. That's why our journalism is free for everyone, even though other newsrooms retreat behind expensive paywalls.

Our journalists will continue to cover the twists and turns during this historic presidential election. With your help, we'll bring you hard-hitting investigations, well-researched analysis and timely takes you can't find elsewhere. Reporting in this current political climate is a responsibility we do not take lightly, and we thank you for your support.

to keep our news free for all.

Support HuffPost

Before You Go

United States Governors
Robert Bentley (R-Ala.)(01 of50)
Open Image Modal
Took office: Jan. 2011Term ends: Jan. 2015 (credit:AP)
Bill Walker (R-Alaska)(02 of50)
Open Image Modal
Took office: Dec. 2014Term ends: Jan. 2018 (credit:ASSOCIATED PRESS)
Doug Ducey (R-Ariz.)(03 of50)
Open Image Modal
Took office: Jan. 2015Term ends: Jan. 2019 (credit:ASSOCIATED PRESS)
Asa Hutchinson (R-Ark.)(04 of50)
Open Image Modal
Took office: Jan. 2015Term ends: Jan. 2019 (credit:ASSOCIATED PRESS)
Jerry Brown (D-Calif.)(05 of50)
Open Image Modal
Took office: Jan. 2011Term ends: Jan. 2019 (credit:AP)
John Hickenlooper (D-Colo.)(06 of50)
Open Image Modal
Took office: Jan. 2011Term ends: Jan. 2019 (credit:AP)
Dannel P. Malloy (D-Conn.)(07 of50)
Open Image Modal
Took office: Jan. 2011Term ends: Jan. 2019 (credit:AP)
Jack Markell (D-Del.)(08 of50)
Open Image Modal
Took office: Jan. 2009Term ends: Jan. 2017 (credit:AP)
Rick Scott (R-Fla.)(09 of50)
Open Image Modal
Took office: Jan. 2011Term ends: Jan. 2019 (credit:Getty Images)
Nathan Deal (R-Ga.)(10 of50)
Open Image Modal
Took office: Jan. 2011Term ends: Jan. 2019 (credit:AP)
David Ige (D-Hawaii)(11 of50)
Open Image Modal
Took office: Dec. 2014Term ends: Jan. 2018 (credit:ASSOCIATED PRESS)
Butch Otter (R-Idaho)(12 of50)
Open Image Modal
Took office: Jan. 2007Term ends: Jan. 2019 (credit:AP)
Bruce Rauner (R-Ill.)(13 of50)
Open Image Modal
Took office: Jan. 2015Term ends: Jan. 2019 (credit:ASSOCIATED PRESS)
Mike Pence (R-Ind.)(14 of50)
Open Image Modal
Took office: Jan. 2013Term ends: Jan. 2017 (credit:AP)
Terry Branstad (R-Iowa)(15 of50)
Open Image Modal
Took office: Jan. 2011Term ends: Jan. 2019 (credit:AP)
Sam Brownback (R-Kan.)(16 of50)
Open Image Modal
Took office: Jan. 2011Term ends: Jan. 2019 (credit:AP)
Steve Beshear (D-Ky.)(17 of50)
Open Image Modal
Took office: Dec. 2007Term ends: Dec. 2015 (credit:AP)
Bobby Jindal (R-La.)(18 of50)
Open Image Modal
Took office: Jan. 2008Term ends: Jan. 2016 (credit:AP)
Paul LePage (R-Maine)(19 of50)
Open Image Modal
Took office: Jan. 2011Term ends: Jan. 2019 (credit:AP)
Larry Hogan (R-Md.)(20 of50)
Open Image Modal
Took office: Jan. 2015Term ends: Jan. 2019 (credit:ASSOCIATED PRESS)
Charlie Baker (R-Mass.)(21 of50)
Open Image Modal
Took office: Jan. 2015Term ends: Jan. 2019 (credit:ASSOCIATED PRESS)
Rick Snyder (R-Mich.)(22 of50)
Open Image Modal
Took office: Jan. 2011Term ends: Jan. 2019 (credit:AP)
Mark Dayton (D-Minn.)(23 of50)
Open Image Modal
Took office: Jan. 2011Term ends: Jan. 2019 (credit:AP)
Phil Bryant (R-Miss.)(24 of50)
Open Image Modal
Took office: Jan. 2012Term ends: Jan. 2016 (credit:AP)
Jay Nixon (D-Mo.)(25 of50)
Open Image Modal
Took office: Jan. 2009Term ends: Jan. 2017 (credit:AP)
Steve Bullock (D-Mont.)(26 of50)
Open Image Modal
Took office: Jan. 2013Term ends: Jan. 2017 (credit:AP)
Pete Ricketts (R-Neb.)(27 of50)
Open Image Modal
Took office: Jan. 2015Term ends: Jan. 2019 (credit:ASSOCIATED PRESS)
Brian Sandoval (R-Nev.)(28 of50)
Open Image Modal
Took office: Jan. 2011Term ends: Jan. 2019 (credit:AP)
Maggie Hassan (D-N.H.)(29 of50)
Open Image Modal
Took office: Jan. 2013Term ends: Jan. 2017 (credit:AP)
Chris Christie (R-N.J.)(30 of50)
Open Image Modal
Took office: Jan. 2010Term ends: Jan. 2018 (credit:AP)
Susana Martinez (R-N.M.)(31 of50)
Open Image Modal
Took office: Jan. 2011Term ends: Jan. 2019 (credit:AP)
Andrew Cuomo (D-N.Y.)(32 of50)
Open Image Modal
Took office: Jan. 2011Term ends: Jan. 2019 (credit:AP)
Pat McCrory (R-N.C.)(33 of50)
Open Image Modal
Took office: Jan. 2013Term ends: Jan. 2017 (credit:AP)
Jack Dalrymple (R-N.D.)(34 of50)
Open Image Modal
Took office: Dec. 2010Term ends: Dec. 2016 (credit:AP)
John Kasich (R-Ohio)(35 of50)
Open Image Modal
Took office: Jan. 2011Term ends: Jan. 2019 (credit:AP)
Mary Fallin (R-Okla.)(36 of50)
Open Image Modal
Took office: Jan. 2011Term ends: Jan. 2019 (credit:AP)
Kate Brown (D-Ore.)(37 of50)
Open Image Modal
Took office: Jan. 2015Term ends: Jan. 2019 (credit:ASSOCIATED PRESS)
Tom Wolf (D-Pa.)(38 of50)
Open Image Modal
Took office: Jan. 2015Term ends: Jan. 2019 (credit:ASSOCIATED PRESS)
Gina Raimondo (D-R.I.)(39 of50)
Open Image Modal
Took office: Jan. 2015Term ends: Jan. 2019 (credit:ASSOCIATED PRESS)
Nikki Haley (R-S.C.)(40 of50)
Open Image Modal
Took office: Jan. 2011Term ends: Jan. 2019 (credit:AP)
Dennis Daugaard (R-S.D.)(41 of50)
Open Image Modal
Took office: Jan. 2011Term ends: Jan. 2019 (credit:AP)
Bill Haslam (R-Tenn.)(42 of50)
Open Image Modal
Took office: Jan. 2011Term ends: Jan. 2019 (credit:AP)
Greg Abbott (R-Texas)(43 of50)
Open Image Modal
Took office: Jan. 2015Term ends: Jan. 2019 (credit:Chip Somodevilla via Getty Images)
Gary Herbert (R-Utah)(44 of50)
Open Image Modal
Took office: Aug. 2009Term ends: Jan. 2017 (credit:Getty Images)
Peter Shumlin (D-Vt.)(45 of50)
Open Image Modal
Took office: Jan. 2011Term ends: Jan. 2017 (credit:AP)
Terry McAuliffe (D-Va.)(46 of50)
Open Image Modal
Took office: Jan. 2014Term ends: Jan. 2018 (credit:AP)
Jay Inslee (D-Wash.)(47 of50)
Open Image Modal
Took office: Jan. 2013Term ends: Jan. 2017 (credit:Getty Images)
Earl Ray Tomblin (D-W.Va.)(48 of50)
Open Image Modal
Took office: Nov. 2010Term ends: Jan. 2017 (credit:AP)
Scott Walker (R-Wis.)(49 of50)
Open Image Modal
Took office: Jan. 2011Term ends: Jan. 2019 (credit:AP)
Matt Mead (R-Wyo.)(50 of50)
Open Image Modal
Took office: Jan. 2011Term ends: Jan. 2019 (credit:AP)