Larry Summers Opposition Grows As Name Mentioned As Possible Federal Reserve Chairman

Campaign Against Summers Gains Momentum
|
Open Image Modal
BOSTON - SEPTEMBER 12: Two well known Harvard economists, Lawrence 'Larry' Summers and Greg Mankiw, not pictured, took part in a forum held on the campus of Northeastern University, talking about their views on the recovery and tax policy. The event was moderated by former Massachusetts governor Michael S. Dukakis. (Photo by Jim Davis/The Boston Globe via Getty Images)

* Liberal Democrats push back, wary of Wall Street ties

* Group of Senate Democrats throws support to Yellen

* Sources see quiet proxy campaign on behalf of Summers

* Obama said to see Summers' Wall Street ties as a strength

By Pedro da Costa and Mark Felsenthal

WASHINGTON, July 25 (Reuters) - President Barack Obama could be months away from announcing his pick to replace Ben Bernanke at the Federal Reserve, yet critics are already making an unusual public effort to stop one contender in the race - former U.S. Treasury Secretary Lawrence Summers.

The outcry has come not from Republicans, but the left wing of the Democratic Party. Summers advised Obama, was treasury secretary under former President Bill Clinton, led Harvard University and was chief economist for the World Bank. He helped tame the Asian financial crisis that threatened to sweep the globe under Clinton.

But liberals blame him for spearheading financial deregulation that they charge helped create the financial crisis, and say his work at hedge fund D.E. Shaw makes him the epitome of a revolving door between Wall Street and government.

A representative for Summers, who writes an opinion column for Reuters, declined to comment for this article, as did the White House and the Fed.

Some powerful Democrats, including former Treasury Secretary and one-time Citigroup executive Robert Rubin, have been speaking up behind the scenes for Summers, according to multiple sources with close ties to the Fed or the White House.

If Obama tapped Summers, he would be picking him over the Fed's current vice chair, Janet Yellen, who is seen as the other main candidate for the job.

Both Yellen and Summers would be expected to hew fairly close to the policy course set by Bernanke.

Supporters of Summers argue he should have an edge given his crisis-management experience.

"When there is consensus, who the Fed chair is hardly matters, and the times when it matters are the times when you have to think outside the box, and then his strengths shine," said Brad DeLong, a professor at the University of California, Berkeley, who worked with Summers in the Clinton Treasury Department.

According to aides, Senate Democrats who oppose him have penned a letter urging Obama to choose Yellen, who has been a major force in the Fed's efforts to stimulate a sluggish U.S. recovery using unconventional monetary policies. Yellen would be the first woman to head the central bank.

Democratic Senator Sherrod Brown of Ohio was circulating the letter, the aides said. It was unclear how many senators had signed it, but several Democrats have already spoken out in favor of Yellen and against Summers.

"I am for Janet Yellen. I am taking that position," Democratic Senator Tom Harkin of Iowa told Reuters.

A spokeswoman for Brown did not respond to emails requesting comment, and a Fed spokeswoman said Yellen declined to comment.

Bernanke's second four-year term at the helm of the central bank expires on Jan. 31, 2014. While he has not discussed his plans, it is widely expected he will step down.

Some critics of Summers wonder why Obama might turn down a woman for a man who has been accused of sexism. As president of Harvard, Summers sparked a firestorm by suggesting intrinsic aptitude might explain why relatively fewer women reach top academic positions in math and science - comments for which he later apologized.

"The president's track record of appointing women is mediocre at best," Greg Valliere, chief political strategist at Potomac Research Group, said in a note to clients. "So there's a brilliant female candidate to replace Ben Bernanke; she's highly respected within the Fed - and Obama is going to appoint someone who will never live down his comments that women lack the qualifications for some university jobs?"

CONCERNS ON REGULATION

When he served as Treasury chief under Clinton, Summers helped clinch the law that revoked the Depression-era Glass-Steagall Act, which separated investment banking activities from those of commercial, deposit-taking institutions.

That opened the gate for commercial banks to get involved in riskier financial products, such as the credit default swaps that were at the heart of the 2007-2009 financial crisis.

Moveon.org, a liberal group that provided major support to both Obama presidential campaigns, is circulating a petition entitled: "Don't let Larry Summers head the Fed," which accuses him of laying the groundwork for the deep U.S. recession.

Senate Banking Committee member Jeff Merkley, a Democrat from Oregon, told Reuters he would find a nomination of Summers "disconcerting."

"Many questions need to be asked and answered related to his philosophy of regulation and deregulation," he said.

LEANING TOWARD SUMMERS?

A person with close ties to the Obama administration said he had reason to believe the president was closely considering Summers, and perhaps even leaning toward him. The source said Obama would likely view Summers' ties to Wall Street and crisis-management experience as important attributes.

At the same time, sources familiar with thinking inside the Fed say staff and some members of the central bank's board are concerned Summers' often blunt manner could be a detriment in shaping policy at the consensus-driven central bank.

Those sources requested anonymity given the sensitive nature of the personnel discussions.

Yellen has been the runaway favorite to replace Bernanke in media polls of financial market participants, but analysts say Summers has the advantage of a close relationship with Obama.

He also has powerful supporters.

"His allies have been ginning up support, making it clear that he's interested - and that's the kiss of death. If you want a major job in this town, you have to be coy," Valliere said.

A person familiar with the nomination process said Obama had yet to make a decision. An announcement is not expected until the autumn.

Our 2024 Coverage Needs You

As Americans head to the polls in 2024, the very future of our country is at stake. At HuffPost, we believe that a free press is critical to creating well-informed voters. That's why our journalism is free for everyone, even though other newsrooms retreat behind expensive paywalls.

Our journalists will continue to cover the twists and turns during this historic presidential election. With your help, we'll bring you hard-hitting investigations, well-researched analysis and timely takes you can't find elsewhere. Reporting in this current political climate is a responsibility we do not take lightly, and we thank you for your support.

to keep our news free for all.

Support HuffPost

Before You Go

Economic Predictions That Were Blatantly Wrong (Or Have Blatantly Yet To Come True)
Paul Ryan: QE2 Risks Inflation(01 of12)
Open Image Modal
Back in 2010, Republican Vice Presidential candidate Paul Ryan explained that the Federal Reserves plan to purchase $600 billion worth of securities -- known as QE2 -- was little more than "sugar-high economics" that risked rising inflation and weakening the dollar. But instead the opposite took place. According to Bloomberg:
"Since that prediction by Ryan, who has been chosen by presumptive Republican presidential nominee Mitt Romney to be his running mate, the dollar has risen against major currencies and inflation has stayed below the Fed's goal of 2 percent."
(credit:AP)
Christina Romer: Unemployment Will Remain Below 8%(02 of12)
Open Image Modal
In early January of 2009, Christina Romer, economic adviser to then President-elect Barack Obama, made a prediction: massive government stimulus on the order that would eventually be passed by Congress would keep unemployment below 8 percent, reports The Washington Post. Without it, unemployment could reach as high as 9 percent.In July 2012, unemployment edged up to 8.3 percent. It has not gone below 8 percent since January 2009. (credit:AP)
Jim Cramer: Obamacare Will Topple The Stock Market(03 of12)
Open Image Modal
On March 18, 2010, Jim Kramer stated on Larry Kudlow's program that Obamacare would tank the stock market. The reform package was, in his words, "the single greatest impediment to the stock market going higher."On March 23 of that year, according to CBS News, President Obama signed health care reform into law. Following Yahoo's tracking of the Dow Jones, the market on April 1 2010 was at 10,927. On August 17, over two years later, the Dow Jones Industrial Average was pegged at 13,264. Granted, the market could still take a nose dive. But odds are it won't be because of health care reform. (credit:AP)
Michelle Bachmann: Obama Taking 'The Final Leap To Socialism'(04 of12)
Open Image Modal
In a radio interview Minnesota Congresswoman Michelle Bachmann gave with Bill Bennet in March of 2009, the Minnesotan claimed that Obama's policies were representing the "final leap into socialism," Think Progress reported.But alas, while Bachmann's sensational claim may have gotten her into the spotlight, the government has been engaged in selling its stake in the industries that it had to temporarily prop up.General Motors, an automaker that the U.S. government had to prop up with emergency capital, bought back all preferred shares held by the U.S. Treasury as of December 2010, reports The New York Times.Wall Street's largest banks that have frequently brought about wrath from liberals such as Paul Krugman, like Citi, Goldman Sachs and JP Morgan, are still privately run. (credit:AP)
Glenn Beck: U.S. Will Go Through 'Great Depression Times 100' (Or Hyperinflation)(05 of12)
Open Image Modal
In early 2010, then-Fox News commentator Glenn Beck said that the U.S. was likely in for a "Great Depression Times 100," reports Media Matters, going on to say that the country would experience a period of hyperinflation.Unemployment during the Great Depression peaked at around 25 percent, according to an article published by the Bureau of Labor Statistics. But even at the worst moments of the Great Recession, unemployment only reached slightly above 10 percent. Presently, it is at 8.3 percent, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics. With inflation estimated to remain stagnant at 1.5 percent through 2012, the nightmare warnings of hyperinflation expounded by Beck as well as by renowned "economist" Peter Schiff appears to be just that. A nightmare. (credit:AP)
Rick Santelli: 'Stagflation Is Almost A Certainty'(06 of12)
Open Image Modal
In October of 2009, CNBC analyst and Tea Party founder Rick Santelli told said on the show Fast Money that he believed "stagflation is almost a certainty." In other words Santelli was predicting that America would go through a period of high inflation and high unemployment. The only question he had was when.In November of that year, the Bureau of Labor Statistics revealed that between October 2008 and October 2009, prices rose by 1.7 percent not including food and gas. This made, at the time, Santelli's claim even bolder. Even though unemployment is still high -- almost three years later -- inflation has risen far below the Federal Reserves 2 percent annual target, Bloomberg reports. (credit:Getty Images)
Rush Limbaugh: Obamacare Will Leave 250 Million People Uninsured(07 of12)
Open Image Modal
Among the many predictions conservative radio host Rush Limbaugh has made over the years, the one he made on March 8, 2010 was not one of his best.On his daily radio show The Rush Limbaugh Show, Limbaugh announced to his listeners that healthcare reform, which would be signed into law later that month, would end up leaving 250 million Americans uninsured, Media Matters reported.As of June 2012, 49.9 million Americans do not have health insurance, CNN estimated. (credit:AP)
Mitt Romney: U.S. WIll Default If We Raise Debt Ceiling(08 of12)
Open Image Modal
In the June 13, 2011 Republican Presidential Debate, Mitt Romney, when asked about the consequences of not raising the debt limit answered the moderator's question with a question. "Well, what happens if we continue to spend time and time again, year and year again more money than we take in?"As Asher Smith pointed out on The Huffington Post, this can only mean that the U.S. will eventually be unable to pay off its obligations and, as a result, default.Bit as of August 2012, close to one year after the debt ceiling was raised, the U.S. still hasn't defaulted. (credit:AP)
Bill Gross: End Of QE2 Would Cause Bond Yields To Go 'Much Higher'(09 of12)
Open Image Modal
In March of 2011, PIMCO Co-Founder Bill Gross predicted an imminent spike in treasury bond yields following the end of the Federal Reserve's Quantitative Easing program, Fortune's Colin Barr reported.Bond yields, Gross told reporters, were likely to go "higher maybe even much higher" at the end of June 2011 when QE2 ended. The 10-year treasury bond yield has since fallen. Since the 2011, 10-year bond rates have hovered between 2.5 and 1.5 percent, according to Bloomberg.
Joe Biden: US Out Of Recession In 18 Months (Feb. '09)(10 of12)
Open Image Modal
In February of 2009, Vice President Joe Biden predicted that the federal stimulus package being implemented by Barack Obama's administration would "literally drop kick us out of this recession," The Hill reported. "This [stimulus] is about getting this out and spent in 18 months to create 3.5 million jobs."Technically, the recession ended during the third fiscal quarter of 2009, according to the Bureau of Economic Analysis. But with unemployment hovering around over 8 percent for the last three years, some economists are no longer talking about calling the current economic period a recovery. Brad DeLong, an economist with UC Berkley, told readers on his blog in 2011 that we're now in the midst of a "Little Depression" instead.
Peter Schiff: Inflation At 20 Percent By 2009(11 of12)
Open Image Modal
Economist Peter Schiff stated that the Federal Reserves monetary policies would lead to 20 percent inflation within one year. The statement, made in October 2008 on Glenn Beck's former CNN program, was proven wrong. During 2009, the U.S. actually experience deflation. (credit:AP)
Ron Paul: Beware Of Runaway Inflation(12 of12)
Open Image Modal
Congressman Ron Paul believed that runaway inflation was "just horrendous" in May 2011, he said during an appearance on Fox Business News. When Congressman Paul made that statement, inflation was pegged at 3.2 percent and, after peaking at 3.9 percent that October, inflation has steadily fallen to 1.4 percent in July 2012. (credit:AP)