'Girls' Season 2, Episode 5 Recap: 'One Man's Trash'

I dearly missed the presence of Marnie, Jessa and Soshanna on this week's episode of "Girls." This is partially due to the balance and wit their characters provide in the midst of sad and ridiculous plot lines, but also because Hannah has officially hit a big fat zero on the togetherness scale.
|
This post was published on the now-closed HuffPost Contributor platform. Contributors control their own work and posted freely to our site. If you need to flag this entry as abusive, send us an email.
Open Image Modal

Note: Do not read on if you have not yet seen Season 2, Episode 5 of HBO's "Girls" titled "One Man's Trash."

Let me start by saying that I dearly missed the presence of Marnie, Jessa and Soshanna in this week's episode of "Girls." This is partially due to the balance and wit their characters provide in the midst of sad and ridiculous storylines, but also because Hannah has officially hit a big fat zero on the togetherness scale.

Let's begin with the smaller problems that came up during "One Man's Trash."

She has a rebellious streak that has manifested itself in garbage.

In the same way teenagers sneak out of the house to defy their parents, Hannah gets a rush from throwing the Cafe Grumpy trash in a can that does not belong to the coffee shop. After the handsome man on the receiving end of her habit comes charging angrily into the coffee shop, Hannah is quick to tell him she's very sorry for what she's done, but that she thinks her rebellion "makes a lot of sense in a way." Does it?

She has no problem playing ping pong naked or passing out in a shower.

In case you hadn't figured it out from the previews, Hannah ends up hitting it off with the guy whose trash can she's filling with pastries and coffee grounds. Has name is Joshua (Patrick Wilson) -- not Josh -- and he's a 42-year-old, recently-separated doctor.

He invites her in to his very pretty, very adult brownstone, and they have sex almost immediately. Soon, they're playing ping pong naked. I'm not saying playing games naked is an entirely terrible thing, as a lot of people enjoy the occasional skinny dip. But ping pong? Really? It just seems (and looks) like a bad idea on a lot of levels.

Speaking of bad ideas, when Hannah discovers that Joshua has a very high-tech shower that can probably talk, she immediately turns up the heat and ends up fainting because of the amount of steam that accumulates. She is of course saved by Joshua, who is becoming something of a father figure at this point. But what if he hadn't been around?

And then there are her bigger problems ...

She thinks quitting her job isn't a big deal.

We all have moments that make us want to ditch the nine-to-five scene to travel the world, spend a year writing a book or just hide under our covers. But unless you have access to a trust fund, which Hannah does not, quitting your job because your boss was a jerk to a handsome guy isn't all that smart.

When you're paying your own rent and kicking out roommates every other month, a stable income is a necessity. Unfortunately for Hannah, being a free-spirited girl who stands up for herself only goes so far.

She completely trusts strangers.

It's universally known that taking candy from a stranger is a bad idea, but Hannah plucks them off the street and hangs out in their apartments for days. She attempted to do this with Adam back in Season 1, and succeeded in doing this with Joshua.

They had sex, played topless ping pong, ate good food, and read the paper. They talked about their feelings -- er, she talked about her feelings -- and other than a nervous comment about possibly getting herself into a Ted Bundy situation, Hannah didn't seem very concerned about the fact that she knew next to nothing about this older man. She's so comfortable, in fact, that she puts herself in the aforementioned compromising situation with a shower and assumes Joshua will come to her rescue if anything bad happens.

She has some hugely weird issues she hasn't addressed.

After Joshua saves Hannah from his high-tech shower, she feels the need to talk about her feelings a lot. While she brings up the standard #twentysomethingproblems like feeling lost, confused and lonely, she also admits some really horrific things.

"One time I asked someone to punch me in the chest and then come on that spot," she says.

"When I was three, I told my mom my babysitter had touched me on the vagina in the bath." She has no idea if it was true. She just told her mom that for the hell of it.

She isn't happy.

I know this should fall under "small problems," or maybe it shouldn't make the list at all, but although Hannah appears to be living out her twenties with the appropriate amount of angst and carelessness, her life is a rocky and unhappy one. She's hungry for the stability Joshua has and could provide for her: a sunlit apartment, enough money, and a caring relationship.

"Please don't tell anyone this," Hannah whispers as Joshua strokes her hair. "But I want to be happy."

It's unlikely that we'll ever see Joshua again, as Hannah found herself alone in his bed in the episode's final minutes. And although she hit zero in "One Man's Trash," Joshua provided Hannah with the small glimmer of hope that she could maybe, someday, get it kind of together.

"Girls" airs on Sundays at 9 p.m. EST on HBO.

'Girls' Season 2 Photos
"Girls" Season 2(01 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 10 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(02 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 10 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(03 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 10 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(04 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 10 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(05 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 10
"Girls" Season 2(06 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 10 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(07 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 9 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(08 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 9 (credit:HBO)
'Girls' Season 2(09 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 9 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(10 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 9 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(11 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 9 (credit:HBO)
'Girls' Season 2(12 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 9 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(13 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 8 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(14 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 8 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(15 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 8 (credit:13)
"Girls" Season 2(16 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 8 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(17 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 8 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(18 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 8 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(19 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 8 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(20 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 8 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(21 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 8 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(22 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 8 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(23 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 7 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(24 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 7 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(25 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 7 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(26 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 7 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(27 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 7 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(28 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 7 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(29 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 7 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(30 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 7 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(31 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 6 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(32 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 6 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(33 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 6 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(34 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 6 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(35 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 6 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(36 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 6 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(37 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 6 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(38 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 6 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(39 of111)
Open Image Modal
"Girls" Season 2(40 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 5 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(41 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 5 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(42 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 5 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(43 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 5 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2 (44 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 5 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(45 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 5 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(46 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 4 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(47 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 4 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(48 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 4 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(49 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 4 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(50 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 4 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(51 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 4 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(52 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 4 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(53 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 4 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(54 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 4 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(55 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 4 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(56 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 3 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(57 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 3 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Seaosn 2(58 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 3 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(59 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 3 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(60 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 3 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(61 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 3 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(62 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 3 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(63 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 3 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(64 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 3 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(65 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 3 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(66 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 3 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(67 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 3 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2 (68 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 2 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(69 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 2 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(70 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 2 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(71 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 2 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(72 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 2 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(73 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 2 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(74 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 1 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(75 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 1 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(76 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 1 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(77 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 1 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(78 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 1 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(79 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 1 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 1(80 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 1 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(81 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 1 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(82 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 1 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(83 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 1 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(84 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 1 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2(85 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 1 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2 (86 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 1 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2 (87 of111)
Open Image Modal
Episode 1 (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2 Key Art(88 of111)
Open Image Modal
Lena Dunham as Hannah Horvath (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2 Key Art(89 of111)
Open Image Modal
Jemima Kirke as Jessa Johansson (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2 Key Art(90 of111)
Open Image Modal
Allison Williams as Marnie Michaels (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2 Key Art(91 of111)
Open Image Modal
Zosia Mamet as Shoshanna Shapiro (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2 Key Art(92 of111)
Open Image Modal
Adam Driver as Adam Sackler (credit:HBO)
"Girls" Season 2 Key Art(93 of111)
Open Image Modal
Alex Karpovsky as Ray Ploshansky (credit:HBO)
'Girls' Season 1(94 of111)
Open Image Modal
(credit:HBO)
'Girls' Season 1(95 of111)
Open Image Modal
(credit:HBO)
'Girls' Season 1(96 of111)
Open Image Modal
(credit:HBO)
'Girls' Season 1(97 of111)
Open Image Modal
(credit:HBO)
'Girls' Season 1(98 of111)
Open Image Modal
(credit:HBO)
'Girls' Season 1(99 of111)
Open Image Modal
(credit:HBO)
'Girls' Season 1(100 of111)
Open Image Modal
(credit:HBO)
'Girls' Season 1(101 of111)
Open Image Modal
(credit:HBO)
'Girls' Season 1(102 of111)
Open Image Modal
(credit:HBO)
'Girls' Season 1(103 of111)
Open Image Modal
(credit:HBO)
'Girls' Season 1(104 of111)
Open Image Modal
(credit:HBO)
'Girls' Season 1(105 of111)
Open Image Modal
(credit:HBO)
'Girls' Season 1(106 of111)
Open Image Modal
(credit:HBO)
'Girls' Season 1(107 of111)
Open Image Modal
(credit:HBO)
'Girls' Season 1(108 of111)
Open Image Modal
(credit:HBO)
'Girls' Season 1(109 of111)
Open Image Modal
(credit:HBO)
'Girls' Season 1(110 of111)
Open Image Modal
(credit:HBO)
'Girls' Season 1(111 of111)
Open Image Modal
(credit:HBO)

Our 2024 Coverage Needs You

As Americans head to the polls in 2024, the very future of our country is at stake. At HuffPost, we believe that a free press is critical to creating well-informed voters. That's why our journalism is free for everyone, even though other newsrooms retreat behind expensive paywalls.

Our journalists will continue to cover the twists and turns during this historic presidential election. With your help, we'll bring you hard-hitting investigations, well-researched analysis and timely takes you can't find elsewhere. Reporting in this current political climate is a responsibility we do not take lightly, and we thank you for your support.

to keep our news free for all.

Support HuffPost